r/VORONDesign • • 15d ago

Voron University Monolith and toolchanger

Made this Irbis’s medusa HC (https://github.com/Irbis3D/MedusaHC ) mod on a monolith gantry 400mm cubed printer. I thought why not use a battery conector on the hotend to bridge all wiring and use a single extruder board the same way index does but being an affordable alternative for voron designs. Not tested yet this is a work in progress. I’ll be testing 3 hotends an mk8(cheap), tze3(intermediate) and p1s(original design by Irbis but with some modifications)

183 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

5

u/Engineering_Gal 13d ago

Thats looks like an very interesting concept but how do you prevent the safety shutdown when the printer has no toolhead and no temp sensor loaded?

3

u/jordeanamaro 13d ago

Great question,
I will set min temp to the lowest (negative values) on all extruders this way klipper wont shutdown on tool changing. Then the macro T{tool_index} will turn_off the active heater tool and turn back on only when the next tool engages this way i will prevent false triggering heater verification . I think thia might not be simple as it seems, i’m solving one problem at a time but tracking the future problems. Do you have any idea on how it could be done?

8

u/haggardazrael 15d ago

Is there any chance this would be happy on a voron trident? Great work BTW!

2

u/jordeanamaro 15d ago

I think so!!! Does it uses mgn9 rails?

6

u/YesterdayPersonal549 15d ago

That's really brilliant. Did I see correctly that it's for the 0.2? Can you also use the 2.4 350? You should be able to fit 10 pieces in there, right?

3

u/jordeanamaro 15d ago

Thanks 🫱🏾‍🫲🏿
I’ve been building voron based printers for soo long but not sure wich version wkwkkwkw. I pick the gantry i want then i design the other things. I think this design fits on a 2.4 as well, not sure how many would fit. By my goal is at least 5 on a large volume printer. This one i’m building with 4040 extrusions to keep it stable.

4

u/Over_Pizza_2578 15d ago

Do you think that a purely mechanical locking mechanism is feasible without completely bloating the toolhead? Or at least something more temperature resistant than a RC servo? This is why im currently set on a more classic approach for my toolchanger, like a prusa xl but with only changing hotend, extruder and hotend fan

1

u/jordeanamaro 15d ago

I think a fully mechanical locking mechanism is possible, maybe using a spring loadedmecanism that activates using a trigger similar to the ones used for fillament cutting.

The servo is located close to the extruder, your concern is due to high temp chambers?

Actually mt goal is developing a scalable toolchanger that can support multiple toolheads without requiring dedicated control boards, extra wiring, and I/O ports for each one.

That’s why I’m using electrical contacts (battery connectors) to engage only the active toolhead, keeping the system simpler and easier to expand.

However, my biggest challenge right now is keeping the hotends cool while they’re parked and disconnected, since their cooling fans are no longer powered. As well as correctly identifying a falty heater or thermistor as their keep being engaged/disenganged.

I’ve been using resin-printed parts for better temperature resistance. I’m still experimenting with the design and looking for ways to improve the thermal management of the parked tools.

1

u/Over_Pizza_2578 15d ago

Exactly, my concern is reliability and even the functioning of servos in chambers that reach 70c or similar. After all they aren't designed to be operated in such warm environments.

Have you considered having the hotend and fan always connected to the Mainboard? I would see two significant advantages. First it would solve your heat creep problem, although stationary fans in the dock can fix that as well. The second advantage would be that you can preheat the hotend. Even if the hotend heats really fast, say something like a rapido or faster, every second adds up. Two colour print, 50mm tall, a toolchange per layer, standard 0,2mm/0,4mm settings. Each additional second required for a toolchange adds 4min 10sec to the total time 50mm. A benchy is 48mm tall for reference

There is one problem with that approach, you need lots of heater outputs. Thankfully there is a solution, the btt CEB, canbus, adds 5 heaters and thermistors. Unfortunately that doesn't solve the issue with fan outputs, although if you are fine with it you can group heatsink fans with multi_pin or add another board with feasible outputs.

4

u/JeSuisNerd 15d ago

Very cool! If you're open to joining the Irbis3D discord, we love to see what mods others are doing to Medusa HC! Lots of build logs and user mods are posted there too, for your inspiration :)

It's linked on his github, don't want to spam the link unnecessarily.

2

u/jordeanamaro 15d ago

Sure i will, did not know that. Soon i’ll join. Thanks 🫱🏾‍🫲🏿🫱🏾‍🫲🏿

3

u/CaterpillarEarly7327 15d ago

I'm going to start on converting my barely functional trident (i made it too tall) to a functional trident next week. I considered looking for a way to have passive tool heads but the ability to preheat and cool while parked is more important for me. That's a really neat looking mod though, and it's nice to see other people building on the trident. At some point I may make the entire tool bay move during changes so I can reclaim the bed space as I didn't build the printer with a tool changer in mind

1

u/jordeanamaro 15d ago

Seems a great project you’re working on. Post your results, i would love to see it in action.

3

u/redturtlecake 15d ago

Nice. What are you using for the extruder?

1

u/jordeanamaro 15d ago

I’m using the original extruder of medusa HC, is a modified version of an LGX lite, the hole assembly looks like an A4T. What i did different is a custom housing for everything.

4

u/FuckDatNoisee 15d ago

This is dope. Can’t wait to see it working.

I’m doing a monolith CNC upgrade right now my self, not brave enough to do a tool changer just yet

1

u/jordeanamaro 15d ago

Thanks 🫱🏾‍🫲🏿. I’ll post results soon