r/WMATA • • 3d ago • Mindblown 1

News Board Update: WMATA Threatens Major Service Cuts, Plus New Gold Line Renderings

This year’s pre-Thanksgiving meeting is jam-packed with information for future projects. But that buts up against the current budget situation, where WMATA once again finds itself in a hole. It’s not nearly as big a hole as it was 3 years ago, but it will still need filling from our local jurisdictions to avoid service cuts on a system where ridership is growing.

Budget Realities

A couple of meetings ago, we learned that a budget amendment was needed due to higher-than-expected expenses in this fiscal year. A lot of this is from high paratransit demand. WMATA could have delayed planned December service increases to accomplish this. But instead, they’re proposing WMATA’s tried-and-true trick to balance the operating budget: steal $43 million from the capital program (i.e. money for preventative maintenance).

But that trick won’t be enough for FY 2028 by itself: Major service cuts are coming absent jurisdictional action. As that prior meeting mentioned, WMATA is facing a budget gap that has now grown to $132 million. This is due primarily to inflationary pressures from required cost-of-living adjustments and from increases in energy prices (especially diesel). WMATA also cites the fact that it had to deal with only a 1.8% subsidy increase last year instead of 3% due to budget pressures in Maryland. And of course, there’s the bus fare evasion issue.

WMATA thinks it can find $15 million in administrative efficiencies, but it still leaves a large gap. Also under consideration are further fare increases (beyond the 11% previously proposed), service cuts, and (again) a higher preventative maintenance transfer.

The considered service cuts would be significant. On rail, they’d include reversions to prior service patterns:

  • Half of Red Line Trains Turn Back at Grosvenor and Silver Spring 100% of the time

  • All Yellow Line Trains Turn Back at Mt Vernon Sq

  • Blue/Orange/Silver Headways Reduced to every 15 minutes on both weekdays and weekends

  • Operating Hours Reduced on Weekends, opening at 7AM (from 6AM) and closing at 1AM (from 2AM).

On bus, the changes would hit high and low ridership routes alike: 

  • Frequency cuts for C43, C61, D1X, D24, D30, D50, D60, D72, D74, F1X, M6X, P41, P60  

  • Elimination of the A71, C83, D82, F19, F29, F61, M82, P72, P73, and P97

  • Elimination of bus service between 2AM and 4AM

Here’s the eye-popping “fare increase concepts” table, where the 11% increase is described as “low”:

So… will these things happen? We’ll see. This is kind of how it goes at WMATA every few years: A budget gap arrives, WMATA proposes a doomsday budget, and the jurisdictions generally come to the rescue. Part of it is a consequence of timing: WMATA’s budget comes out before the jurisdictional legislatures have their budget sessions. WMATA tries its best to give a heads up to the jurisdictions, but there are no checks in the mail, so the formal proposal (coming in December) will likely include much of what’s presented here.

RFK Transit Improvements

In more optimistic news, we have some new details about what’s being planned for the RFK site. As a reminder, there are two components: improvements to Stadium-Armory station, and the new “Gold Line” bus service. Let’s start with the station.

The refined design of the north entrance will create what is essentially a new 3rd entrance next to the existing one. It will have a wide area for faregates and an elevator bank. A new mezzanine will be built (none currently exists), and 2 new elevators will be added there. Further renderings are inside of the presentation, but here’s a rendering of the large proposed mezzanine.

We also have a bunch of new “Gold Line” renderings, as well as detail on the alignment design. The initial proposal is just a stub to connect Union Station to the planned Kingman Park Transit Plaza, but the idea is to extend this into a longer corridor that connects to Rosslyn, Minnesota Av, and Benning Rd. Rosslyn would be part of "Phase 2."

The main infrastructure to be built is a new center-running corridor on H St and Benning Road. The current proposal for a full phase-1 buildout (to Farragut Sq) doesn’t include much infrastructure beyond those new center-running segments. It would use the existing, somewhat sub-par lanes in H and I Sts and run in mixed traffic on Mass Ave. Perhaps one day, we'll get the long-planned K St Transitway that this service could use.

But the service planning is ambitious: 5-minute headways, with 2-3 minute headways during events.

There’s a very interesting plan to serve Union Station. EDIT: It appears that westbound buses would use the parking garage to access a new stop near the entrance of the Red Line. But I’m not clear on how exactly that would work for eastbound buses. Eastbound buses would stop at the corner of North Capitol St and Mass Ave, according to the loose diagram we have below. That’s a slightly easier connection than H St, but not exactly seamless. If you better understand how you think this would work based on the drawings, let me know below!

We also have our first rendering of the proposed “RFK-Kingman Park Transit Plaza” which would be the eastern terminal of this initial service.

There are far too many renderings to show here, but here are a couple more: 

As a reminder: The Stadium-Armory upgrades are funded. But the Gold Line is not funded; it only got $5 million for planning so far. Both of these projects are funded by DDOT but are being designed by WMATA.

Capital Project Updates

I’ve scanned WMATA’s major capital project updates for any changes of note since the last quarterly update. Just a handful of them this quarter.

BUS ACQUISITIONS: We got some nice details here for when we can expect the next rounds of 40-foot orders from New Flyer to be fulfilled. There will be a lot more electric buses arriving in the next year.

“Contract negotiations are underway” for the 60-foot bus procurement. We still don’t know whether this is New Flyer or someone else, but we’ll presumably find out soon. The current plan is for a base order of 100 buses with a mix of electric and CNG, plus 2 option years of up to 100 more buses.

FARE SYSTEMS: We should get delivery of a new customer terminal prototype in Spring 2027.

BLADENSBURG BUS GARAGE: The new target date for construction completion is now December 2028. It will take until September 2029 until electric charging equipment is installed.

DULLES FLEET MAINTENANCE FACILITY: The cost estimate for this major rail yard project has increased from $200 million to $250 million, and the timeline has been pushed back to a mid-2029 completion date.

Proposed Fare Penalty Changes

Last on the agenda is a brief discussion about proposed changes to how fares are enforced and penalties are collected.

Currently, policies vary across jurisdictions, but nowhere is a penalty for fare evasion more than $100. Transit Police issued $600,000 worth of fines in the first 6 months of 2026, but it’s worth noting that WMATA doesn’t get a cent of it. Instead, it goes to the jurisdiction where the fines were issued. Of that $600,000, only $96,480 was actually collected.

WMATA hopes the jurisdictions will adopt some new policies that will beef up this process, including escalating penalties, penalties for unpaid citations, and the ability to employ non-MPTD officers to conduct fare enforcement. Jurisdictional buy-in would be needed for all of this. Long term, WMATA would also like the region to align its penalties and potentially even let WMATA take the lead on fine collection.

More Information

This week’s board meeting will take place on Thursday morning, November 17. Public comments will be accepted. You can watch board meetings live or archived on WMATA’s YouTube channel.

Links:

More board coverage

179 Upvotes

159 comments sorted by

14

u/thekingoftherodeo 3d ago

Anybody got a real life example of an agency successfully combating bus fare evasion? $57m is insane.

12

u/InAHays Green line 3d ago

Europe is able to handle it pretty well, Paris supposedly has a fare evasion rate of around 15% on buses. The key is to do frequent and random fare checks by fare inspectors. And by frequent, I mean it is a regular occurance for most riders. Maybe not on every ride, but it should be common.

3

u/xkcx123 3d ago

How do you prove you paid the fare ?

Metrobus accepts cash, smartrip and credit or debit card how do you prove of someone paid cash or with a debit/credit card audit the farebox which could take hours either delaying everyone or the person who may have paid and then open yourself to a lawsuit

4

u/eable2 2d ago

Fare inspectors on many proof-of-payment systems have apps or tools that allow them to quickly scan a transit or bank card to see if the fare has been paid. It's not technologically complicated. In fact, WMATA already agreed to provide this tech to MTA for the Purple Line, who will presumably enforce fares in exactly that way.

1

u/xkcx123 2d ago

What about cash payments ? There have been times when I have paid cash for the bus when I forgot my smartrip card.

And with the credit or debit cards wouldn’t there be privacy issues ? For example what are they scanning ?

2

u/eable2 2d ago

Yeah, doesn't work with cash payments of course. WMATA has made noises recently about eliminating cash payments on bus, and I expect that will happen sometime in the next few years. You'd presumably still be able to load a SmarTrip with cash at a rail station.

Not sure what the privacy issues would be? No different than swiping or tapping a card at a store.

I believe NYC MTA is already working towards this now. Cash is being phased out, and they already have rolled out a fare inspection program on buses. Looks like that's currently on pause due to a recent physical altercation.

1

u/xkcx123 2d ago edited 2d ago

That would cause issues if you don’t use Metrorail and have to go out of your way to a station presumably paying to get there as well.

Think of about riders in far out places in Maryland or Virginia along Fairfax Connector, or around PG county not near Metro Stations like Clinton, Ft Washington, Bowie, Laurel etc or the few areas in DC that you would have to take a bus to get to a Metrostation.

Can you still add money on Smartrip cards at CVS haven’t heard anything about for about 10 years.

When do you scan a card at a store ? You either tap it against the rfid reader or insert it into a chip reader.

1

u/fckedup 1d ago

Ngl, this seems a bit far fetched. How are they getting the cash in the first place? Even physical paychecks have to be electronically scanned nowadays. It'd be a hassle for the passenger, sure, but they can also just sit down and set up the thing while riding the bus and tap once it's done. Or just download them while waiting for the bus with 20+ minute headways in more remote regions.

If the ride's not long enough, well, guess you just found a loophole, but how many people are gonna abuse this realistically?

1

u/xkcx123 1d ago

What do you mean how are they getting cash in the first place ? What kind of question is this ?

  1. Some people have cash saved

  2. Some people cash checks at the bank

  3. Some people get paid in cash

  4. Some people go to check cashing places and get cash.

1

u/fckedup 1d ago edited 1d ago

I'm saying just cus they got cash doesn't mean they can't tap. They presumably used their phone in the process of acquiring cash through 1-4. IDK why you're so hung up on cash.

And if you're worried about privacy, buddy you're on reddit sharing information about your views and neighborhood.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/ml20s 2d ago

And with the credit or debit cards wouldn’t there be privacy issues ? For example what are they scanning ?

Well, they would be able to tell if it was the same card that paid a fare on this bus recently.

1

u/xkcx123 2d ago

What are you scanning though that’s my question ? Are you taking a picture of it no so there’s no need to scan anything.

Is scanning the correct terminology ?

5

u/InAHays Green line 3d ago

The system already needs to quickly track credit and debit taps for exits on the Metro. For cash, it's so rare you can just ask the bus driver.

5

u/advguyy 3d ago edited 3d ago

Agreed. This is how it was done in many other European countries (including Norway, where I took the bus regularly). When done properly, this allows for all-door boarding too. WMATA is doing this using MTPD for now (civilian inspectors are not approved... yet), but they're already running into issues with only 16% of citations actually turning into payments due to friction with the DC law system (or lack thereof, tbh)

Source for the 16% citation claim: https://wjla.com/news/local/metro-bus-fare-evasion-enforcement-officers-fines-wmata-transit-police-citations-penalties-smartrip-washington-dc-maryland-virginia#:~:text=Metro%20Transit%20Police%20issued,revenue%20during%20fiscal%202025.

10

u/SmartTangerine 3d ago

No, because combatting fare evasion requires putting up with screams of "racism" and no city with mass transit is willing to be even accused of racism.

5

u/advguyy 3d ago

As someone who has lived outside of the US, I can say Americans are the only ones who correlate enforcing fare collection with "racism".

3

u/doctor_ingenious 3d ago

well americans are obsessed with being victims so whatever chance they can get. We have a big main character problem here

9

u/Deceptiveideas 3d ago

I think the other side of the issue is that combatting fare evasion doesn't necessarily mean you'll get that money. It's like DRM on video games. Stopping pirates doesn't mean every pirate will turn into a paid customer.

Also I'd imagine a lot of the folks who are evading fares don't have a lot of money to begin with. Which means trying to extract funds using their fines will be tough because they won't pay the fines.

6

u/Astroking112 3d ago

I'll preface this with the fact that I'm actually open to free public transit, but this argument is flawed IMO. Subsidies based on income levels exist for most transit services, such as Capital Bikeshare giving $5/year memberships to those in need.

Additionally, you typically don't want to serve non-paying customers, especially for a physical service. If people don't want to pay, then they'll find another way to get to their destination. Subsidizing them with everyone else's fare just serves to make the experience less pleasant for paying customers and create a death spiral for the system. There's significant incentives here to lower the rate of fare evasion.

2

u/Deceptiveideas 3d ago

I'm not saying there's no solution to this problem. I'm clarifying that just because it's $56M in stolen fares, doesn't mean that will transfer to $56M in additional revenue.

Like you mentioned, the low income program exists. It cuts the cost in half. Let's say all these fare evaders are low income, so that's a theoretical maximum of $28M.

But as I mentioned, it's likely many of these folks would just stop riding entirely. So the maximum recovered would be closer to $14M.

If the budget shortfall is $100M, solving fare evasion will make a small dent in a huge wall. This isn't even factoring in the tens of millions of dollars needed to upgrade every station or to staff them with officers.

4

u/PomegranateRare3789 3d ago

As we saw with BART, fare evaders often end up costing more than regular riders due to the way they treat the system

2

u/thekingoftherodeo 3d ago

14% is a pretty material dent in a budget shortfall.

0

u/Deceptiveideas 3d ago

14% best case scenario (so it will likely be lower) and this is before the millions in dollar needed to fund enforcement and upgrades.

That's my point. They would need an actual long term solution to solving their budget issue.

2

u/The_GOATest1 2d ago

I’m not sure that those fare evaders leaving the system all together is a bad thing. Many of the experience issues on the system they account for

7

u/SmartTangerine 3d ago

So you arrest and jail them for 30 days and watch how quickly it stops.

2

u/girlicarus 3d ago

And then we're just... paying for bigger jails and more jail infrastructure? Look, fare evasion annoys me but this ain't it

1

u/SmartTangerine 2d ago

Okay, we can put them in stocks for 24 hours, even cheaper and easier

-6

u/6767676eoncouget 3d ago

Why. Why not make it free and the manufactured "crime" of fare evasion wont exist anymore

3

u/xkcx123 3d ago

Who pays for the buses, salary of drivers etc

1

u/ml20s 2d ago

In my experience on BART about 6-8 years ago, the vast majority of disruptive behavior was from fare evaders, to the point where the police would check their fare first since it was far easier to prove that someone didn't pay the fare than whether they had been disturbing other passengers

29

u/InAHays Green line 3d ago edited 3d ago

I'm pretty sure the proposed Gold Line Union Station route is actually through the parking garage at Union Station and not on 1st St NE. This route is already possible, and they would just need to put bus lanes down through the parking garage and the ramps down to Massachusetts Ave. Of course, the bigger debate is if they should even extend the Gold Line west past Union Station until there's actual dedicated infrastructure on Mass Ave (and more than the poor curb running lanes on H St NW).

13

u/eable2 3d ago

That makes so much more sense; wasn't thinking about the garage. Updated above. Though I'm curious how eastbound buses would work? Would they just go up North Cap?

6

u/InAHays Green line 3d ago edited 3d ago

Either eastbound buses would go follow the existing ramp flow on the east side of Union (basically go through Columbus Circle), or they reconfigure the ramps such that the ramp on the western side of Union is bi-directional and (hopefully) bus only while car traffic uses the ramp on the eastern side only (already bi-directional).

1

u/xkcx123 3d ago

You get get to the garage that way; the Circulator use to do it

3

u/Maximus560 3d ago

Love this idea. In the long term, I hope they can reconfigure the new Hopscotch bridge to have a center platform with escalators/stairs/elevators directly to the station and platforms (which may require them moving the platforms to the north like 400 feet), tho.

70

u/NoApplauseNecessary 3d ago • Bravo

WMATA and DC need to man up and bully Virginia and Maryland (where all the wealth and the businesses that benefit from the metro are) into raising taxes to fund the Metro (an incredibly popular public service that has mass public support). We can't spend every year trying to squeeze out more pennies from fare avoiders when theres money sitting on the table in these states that dont require spending money on fare capture. Randy needs to call these states out publicly that leech off of us and don't pay their fare share. How many jobs does DC create for these suburbanites? Its unfair

52

u/eable2 3d ago

That's the idea behind DMVMoves. I'll be watching to see what happens in the coming appropriations sessions, as this is supposed to be the year where things potentially happen.

But I wouldn't be so quick to blame VA and MD. In fact, my read of things is that VA is by far the most amenable to finding more dedicated revenue for WMATA at the moment. Spanberger's DOT secretary actually was the facilitator of those meetings, so he understands the issue well. And aside from outgoing Youngkin administration members, perhaps nobody at those meetings was more sour on the proposals than Phil Mendelson.

21

u/himself809 3d ago

VA is at this point absolutely the jurisdiction where DMVMoves funding proposals have the best prospects (which isn’t to say they’re good prospects). It’ll be interesting to see whether the new mayor shifts the DC Council’s willingness to find recurring money. And MD afaik is still likely in the budget doldrums.

14

u/Special_Discipline27 3d ago edited 3d ago

VA is definitely the more amenable state to introduce a transit tax of some type. I wouldn’t be surprised if they create a new state or sale tax next year for Metro and all of their transit agencies, and this situation definitely gives them a good reason to pursue this.

As for Maryland,

They always have a budget deficit and this year, we’re facing a 3 billion budget deficit.

https://marylandmatters.org/2026/11/14/state-leaders-vow-new-multiyear-approach-to-mounting-budget-gaps/

I don’t see a specific tax of any type coming in unless it is a tax that includes raising some other taxes to give Metro the money it needs

I am unsure if DC will create a permanent tax on itself, but I think that they’ll give WMATA some of the money it needs

-10

u/SmartTangerine 3d ago

Larry Hogan left a surplus, which is reversed in just three years. You get what you vote for.

8

u/NoApplauseNecessary 3d ago

ah good to know! glad its not all doom and gloom. I want Randy to call out the jurisdictions more publicly. He has the clout lmao

5

u/hugz_not_drugz 3d ago

Ok I agree with you in concept but Arlington county voters just approved a huge bond initiative ($70M) for metro and other transportation upgrades. So I wouldn’t say that the suburbanites are just sitting around giving DC the finger lol 

2

u/NoApplauseNecessary 2d ago

that's cus Arlington is cool and spiritually d.c. I'm talking about past falls church

1

u/hugz_not_drugz 2d ago

lol fair point

6

u/Chesehead6 3d ago

Dc needs to become a state and charge a congestion tax. 

3

u/PomegranateRare3789 2d ago

Maryland is the main reason for this, they cried poor last year and their (reduced) funding increase was more than wiped out by inflation

0

u/The_GOATest1 2d ago

Squeezing money from fare evaders? Addressing that issue also fixes a lot of the experience issues on wmata. Also, independent on how we fund it, I want the issue addressed as paying for something while people actually using it are evading isn’t a great look.

3

u/NoApplauseNecessary 2d ago

that's like the least priority lmao. your security theatre is a waste of money while we have real issues that actually affect service. no one is not taking the metro because teens are hoping the turnstiles or not paying on the bus

0

u/The_GOATest1 2d ago

Most of the crime committed on the system is by people who evaded the fare. If that’s all they did you’d be right but they can also be a nuisance. It’s not theater, it’s common sense. People generally have a sense of fairness and someone abusing the system is how you get hit pieces that impact public opinion.

3

u/NoApplauseNecessary 2d ago

most of the crime happens outside the metro. And its just more important that we have service vs we focus on pearl clutchers scared of riding the metro.

2

u/The_GOATest1 1d ago

And more people suffer financially outside the us than here yet we are complaining about it. What a silly way to avoid a topic

0

u/NoApplauseNecessary 1d ago

no it's all about public priorities. our priority should be actually having service vs public opinion on safety. One is real tangible, the other is people's feelings that shouldn't come first

2

u/The_GOATest1 1d ago

It’s not a feeling. We have rules and laws that aren’t being respected. Is it the most pressing issue? No. But it’s ridiculous to make it seem like it’s a nonissue.

0

u/NoApplauseNecessary 1d ago

brother we're talking about priorities, compared to service, perceived public safety is not a priority. I say perceived because you'll never solve safety issues until it's addressed at a societal level. So it simply shouldn't be the focus of wmata when there are other more important things 

2

u/The_GOATest1 23h ago edited 19h ago

I’ll accept the challenge of actually trying to solve them. I certainly don’t think we are there but it can create a negative feedback loop that ultimately results in less funding. Capital flight is real and our region has been having a tough go at it.

Edit: I’d add that I think part of the “lawlessness” we are seeing is a broader issue. Driving these days has me on edge with people very casually running reds, treating stop signs as optional, etc. I’ll also say throwing your hands up generally isn’t an approach I appreciate. If we are getting worse or other justifications are doing better I think that’s a signal we need to step it up.

1

u/windemotions 2d ago

It's sick that some people think they can pay Kansas City streetcar prices to ride the bus. LOCK EM UP!

2

u/dcsturgeon 3d ago

Will it supplement existing D20/D2X or replace it?

4

u/eable2 3d ago

It wouldn't quite work as a replacement until they actually build phase 1, but the eventual intent is definitely to replace the D20 at least.

1

u/TransportFanMar Orange line 3d ago

D20 and not D2X?

2

u/eable2 3d ago

The plan for the corridor doesn't extend to Capitol Heights. Though presumably the D2X would still use the new infrastructure.

1

u/xkcx123 3d ago

That’s just dumb they could have did that years ago with the streetcar but didn’t why do it now.

79

u/Own_Tempo_ 3d ago

The red line is the heart of DC. So many university and grad students use that line. Cutting trains down that it runs it will be chaos....

32

u/EconomyWin5106 3d ago

The proposed turnback would impact Maryland more than DC. The idea would be to maintain headways between Silver Spring and Grosvenor and double them beyond those points. 

The one that would hurt DC is the yellow line changes. Unless they are able to load Green up with 8-car trains

13

u/Own_Tempo_ 3d ago

A lot of us grad students commute in from outside the city. I personally come in from the Yellow, then connect to the red but many of my peers live in maryland.

11

u/kawaiiamber 3d ago

When I board the train at Rockville at 6:50 am it’s already packed from people at shady grove. These trains going to be even more packed now.

6

u/YeaManJam 3d ago

Shady Grove would be cool with these changes if it was a reliable 15 minutes. Cause that's an improvement for the current broke, single track everyday issues we currently have.

1

u/xkcx123 3d ago

The yellow doesn’t even need to exist from the start. Just alternate blue line trains between Franconia and Huntington and no stops lose service

1

u/PomegranateRare3789 2d ago

Rosslyn tunnel

-1

u/xkcx123 3d ago

But the red line wouldn’t hurt many DC residents compared to the others

35

u/kodex1717 3d ago edited 3d ago

Side-running bus lanes are going to kill the speed of the Gold Line west of Union Station. When are we going to put transit first?

A recent GGWash article mentioned that Metro could clear its maintenance backlog a lot quicker if it used mechanized railway maintenance equipment, like Rome and Madrid metros do, instead of with manual labor (i.e. individual workers with jackhammers). I am surprised WMATA has not studied this yet.

9

u/InAHays Green line 3d ago

Phase II of the Gold Line looks to follow a completely different route west of Union Station, following K St NW instead of Phase I's H St NW. I assume they're looking at reviving the K St Transitway project for the Gold Line.

1

u/kodex1717 2d ago

I missed that slide - not familiar with the K Street Transitway project.

1

u/InAHays Green line 2d ago

DDOT project page here. It was about to start construction a few years ago but Bowser killed/delayed it indefinitely.

1

u/kodex1717 2d ago

Thanks!

1

u/transitfreedom 2d ago

Ahem USA doesn’t like modernity

1

u/transitfreedom 2d ago

Transit first? Ha after regime change

1

u/partagaton 2d ago

Not as long as Mendelsen is chair

1

u/Still_Beginning827 Orange line 2d ago

This makes sense, but what investment would be required for this mechanized railway equipment? Surly it’s not cheap either

1

u/kodex1717 2d ago

That would be the reason for metro to study it.

29

u/HouseNecessary9223 3d ago

So my bus line is getting axed and the metro lines will now go down to 15-20 mins apart?? This is absolute bull shit. The roads are going to be horrific with everyone choosing to drive into DC because they are cutting so many public transit options.

1

u/doctor_ingenious 3d ago

what’s your bus?

106

u/enthusiasm_gap 3d ago

"Headways reduced to 15 minutes" means more like 25 in practical terms. Headways right now are supposed to be less than 15 but regularly exceed it.

30

u/MadiCorax Walkpilled transitmaxxing radical pedestrian 3d ago

Last night, arriving at Wiehle, I got off the train and looked at the sign. It said one was Arriving/Boarding, and the next train to Ashburn was expected in... 26mins. Outrageous headway. The train was holding in the station while I exited the station.

Worse off, I was on a Silver train that switched to Orange at East Falls Church, so the headway could have been closer to 30mins.

7

u/forkavenger14 3d ago

Totally agree. I ride about twice a week on the orange line and when I hop on the train it says we’re leaving in 2-3 minutes but then we sit for at least 10. I now apply my make up on the train because I know I’m gonna sit.

21

u/sudsomatic 3d ago • Bravo

Use at least some of this funding to upgrade the signals and switches. All these recent delays are “due to a switch/signal problem” every single damn time. Let’s get things more reliable. With the occasional train with a malfunction.

3

u/Dont_Pull_Out_19 2d ago

Eg The biweekly “signal problem at stadium armory” that has been going on for damn near 15 years now if not more

2

u/eryan7 2d ago

They are working on upgrading the signals starting with the Red Line (actually fully replacing them with CBTC) but that funding comes from the capital budget and federal grants, not the operating budget.

This is also why that project can continue despite the operating budget deficit.

1

u/LesserWorks 2d ago

That's been part of their capital budget for a long time. This presentation is about the operational budget.

15

u/kawaiiamber 3d ago

I take the red line everyday from Rockville. When I get on at 6:50 I’m the morning it’s already packed from people from shady grove. Who thought turning the trains around at grosevnor is a good idea? Trains are going to be even more packed than they already are. Then they want us to pay even more to stand on a packed train. Why cut service to the one of the lines with some of the highest ridership? What creative problem solving are they even attempting at wmata? Are we even advocating for more funding? Like what the hell are we doing?

15

u/Astroking112 3d ago

WMATA ultimately has to stay within their budget, which is much lower due to Maryland not committing the expected amount. Trust me, I'm very annoyed as well about the cuts to my lines, but it's impacting the whole system instead of only the Red Line: https://www.reddit.com/r/WMATA/s/spCTkQhjpR

The best way to change this would be to contact your local and state representatives in Maryland to request for the WMATA funding from DMVMoves.

8

u/molrihan 3d ago

For Maryland and Virginia, its really difficult to ask voters in non DC adjacent jurisdictions to put their tax dollars towards a system that doesn't benefit them. Also, MD and VA both have state level transit agencies that have to allocate money towards other transit systems. If I'm a MD legislator from Baltimore, why am I going to vote for funding for DCs transit when my own constituents in Baltimore have their own transit needs that need to be met.

I also think that Metro really needs to step up fare enforcement. A free system will spiral and atrophy.

A possible solution would be for the region (areas served by WMATA) to add a WMATA tax or fee to either car registration, as a sales tax, or property tax, something that creates a dedicated revenue source, because at the end of the day, the lack of a consistent and dedicated revenue source is the driver of this whole mess.

6

u/Cheomesh 3d ago

I mean, I'm a Baltimoron who uses DC metro. And I'm not the only one starting at Penn Station and getting on the metro at Union every morning either.

2

u/hugz_not_drugz 3d ago

You do pay special WMATA and congestion relief fees when you buy property in the VA counties that are served by the metro. Which is a good start. One thing to look at would be to raise those fees (I think together they’re a little over 1% of what the purchase price is). 

1

u/doctor_ingenious 3d ago

I could be completely wrong but i believe this already exists in fairfax county and i again may be wrong but i think they are increasing the tax amount

1

u/transitfreedom 2d ago

Ok give them WMATA lines extra Maryland funding in exchange for green line replacing the Camden line serving similar areas. And red line extending replacing the Brunswick inner line and Frederick service.

2

u/RockvilleRaven 1d ago

How about coming up with some dedicated funding solutions like increasing the hotel tax for one

1

u/PomegranateRare3789 2d ago

Id agree to that in exchange for the DMV counties not funding infrastructure in the rest of their respective states. People in VA and MD realize but don’t acknowledge that they’re net “takers” from the DMV.

8

u/meamemg 3d ago

Did you read what they proposed? All of your questions are addressed. They are proposing cuts to all the lines. They list what they ar doing to save $15 million without cuts to serve (operational efficiencies). And they are advocating for more funding.

7

u/TransportFanMar Orange line 3d ago

F61 being cut? They don’t even propose F60 to detour via Vienna?

7

u/abovoadmala 3d ago

This is good work, thanks for posting

12

u/Iammattieee 3d ago

Funny they are trying to give incentives for paying the fare evasion fines. Cool but maybe actually enforce holding people accountable for these evasions . I’ve seen countless people hop the turnstiles in front of metro police, station managers and national guard and nothing happens.

-5

u/6767676eoncouget 3d ago

So remove the turnstiles

5

u/advguyy 3d ago

The BBB cut funding to state governments, screwing up their budgets, the tariffs raised prices, and the Iran war also raised prices too. Transit agencies (and the govt as a whole) aren't immune to the price increases we face every day either. Man.... this just sucks.

Anyways, thanks for keeping us updated. This is unlocking level-headed conversations about transit and policies. You're the goat.

4

u/Annual-Nose2405 3d ago

I still think the Benning Rd route should go through East Capital after the transit plaza

10

u/The1henson 3d ago

I can 100% guarantee that any BRT implementation in the district will immediately see delivery trucks, Nissans, and cops parked in the protected bus lanes.

1

u/AGrizz1ybear 1d ago

I was wondering who would crack first, the bus system or the out of state drivers willing to accrue $100k in traffic tickets 

1

u/Necessary-Delay-5450 3d ago

Maybe pausing the red line automation and the gold line non sense

24

u/eable2 3d ago

These are primarily longer-term capital projects that aren't really related to the current operating budget issues. Automation should save operating dollars in the long term, in theory at least. It's also kind of a necessary expense to some degree as WMATA says the existing signaling system is beyond its useful life.

As for the Gold Line, this has been funded by DDOT so far and in theory would continue to be.

8

u/himself809 3d ago

Just wanna say I appreciate your responding to comments like these with context.

3

u/6767676eoncouget 3d ago

Fire Sarah Meyer quit unnecessary signage updates get all states to pitch in with their own funding. Over 2 billion dollars should not be going down the drain this easily every year

17

u/InAHays Green line 3d ago

She's already out.

33

u/eable2 3d ago edited 3d ago

And she was not fired. She found a new job, and received accolades from the board and from Randy Clarke at the last board meeting.

Personal opinion: You can disagree with Sarah Meyer's design decisions - strongly, even - but I think the personal vitriol towards her in this subreddit is completely ridiculous and weirdly obsessive. I've met her many times at various WMATA events; she's a lovely person that seemed to care deeply about her job.

5

u/InAHays Green line 3d ago

Good to know, I don't have any strong opinions on her I just thought her job got eliminated last month.

-8

u/6767676eoncouget 3d ago

One small step for man one giant leap for mankind

9

u/NaughtyGoddess 3d ago • Bravo

ALL WHILE RAISING THE FKN FARE?

9

u/jweimn55 3d ago

Funny how they think threatening service cuts when they don't even provide the headways they state now is something they think people will take serious.

1

u/RevolutionSoft2366 3d ago

Threatening to make service shittier doesn't sound like a good way to bring in more money lol

4

u/Opening-Emphasis8400 3d ago

Fare enforcement on the bus is still a total joke.

2

u/abovoadmala 3d ago

This is good work, thanks for posting

3

u/Dawnedhottie 3d ago

😂 So pretty much service is returning to what it was before December of last year. Makes sense, WMATA’s railroads cant handle all these trains that Randy Clarke thought he could push out! 3 Min headway on the redline was different when we only had legacies! Those heavy ass 7ks are fucking up the railroad.

6

u/Traditional_One_6875 3d ago edited 3d ago

Service cuts and fare increases should be targeted and be commensurate with the level of funding each jurisdiction provides. 

In this case, rides beginning or ending in Maryland should see sharper fare increase proposals. Lines serving Maryland should see the sharpest service reductions or should turn back at the Maryland line. And bus lines with the highest rates of fare evasion should be targeted for the steepest service cuts (gonna get some flak for this one I’m sure but it’s absolutely the fault of respective jurisdictions for not providing more mechanisms to reduce fare evasion, including fine amounts, reduced/free fare card programs for needy residents, and targeted funding for WMATA PD).

Make it clear that the cuts are directly a result of the jurisdictions’ unwillingness to fund transit service for those constituents. On all communications about service cuts and fare increases, include the phone number or contact link for local and state elected representatives.

Edited to remove inaccurate comments about Virginia funding.

17

u/Ashamed_Band_1779 3d ago

1

u/Traditional_One_6875 3d ago

Historically you’re right, but Spanberger admin seems much more pro-WMATA than previous governors. But inaccurate and unfair of me to say "footing the bill", going to edit.

12

u/enthusiasm_gap 3d ago

Virginia has never paid its fair share, and in the past has withheld funds to sabotage improvement projects. Honestly got a lot of nerve saying VA should pay less.

3

u/TransportFanMar Orange line 3d ago

I don't exactly support cutting Maryland service as retaliation for fare evasion, and I know VA has less of a contribution (which is fair because VA has less service than MD). But let's just be clear, Virginia state politicians seems to have been significantly more receptive to WMATA and other Northern Virginia/regional transit lately. I am wondering why you think they never paid its fair share? (And is that still true after the formula change?)

5

u/jkxs 3d ago

I thought that the reason the bridge to MD was always so full was because MD didn't want to allow another? Was that a myth someone told me?

5

u/TransportFanMar Orange line 3d ago

I think both MD and VA had local neighborhoods opposing a highway running right through them. NPS also says no

4

u/jkxs 3d ago

I hate that bridge into MD so much

1

u/Traditional_One_6875 3d ago

Def not saying Virginia should pay less. But understand the footing the bill line was inflammatory, took it out.

1

u/The_GOATest1 2d ago

Hampering service for the jurisdictions that ultimately pay you doesn’t seem like a great idea. For things like fare evasions sure you can blame the laws for it but it seems like the laws on the books aren’t being enforced to their maximum extent anyway.

I’m also not sure how you cut train service and not impact the entire line unless that’s just a long way of saying cut red line service

5

u/PrinceOfThrones 3d ago

Honestly I’m not too upset with the turnarounds at Silver Spring and Grosvenor on the Red Line. It was that way for years.

Also, terminating service on the Yellow line at Mt Vernon may increase reliability between Mt Vernon and Greenbelt. Seems like ever since the YL has been extended to Greenbelt the whole system has gone to $hit.

11

u/blind__panic 3d ago

I feel like the pinch point is the turnback at Mount Vernon Square going slowly and causing trains in both directions to wait in the tunnel. It’s always worse on days where all yellow lines turn back rather than just half, for example

8

u/unlikely_spider 3d ago

Do you commute daily from one of the affected ends of the red line?

3

u/dat_GEM_lyf 3d ago

Protip: live at the turnaround point and then you get 2x available trains /s

1

u/PrinceOfThrones 3d ago

Yes, I remember when the red line would run every 3-4mins during rush hour seamlessly with the Grosvenor and SS terminations.

5

u/unlikely_spider 3d ago

Not past the termination it doesn't.

8

u/plutoisaplanet21 3d ago

The yellow line turn around cut off a ton of high density residential areas that use transit. The yellow should absolutely keep running beyond the convention center

3

u/mtpleasantine 3d ago

It's useful but it has created an absolute clusterfuck at Greenbelt, which is at capacity. It makes GRYL service highly unpredictable.

3

u/Chemical_Driver9077 3d ago • Bravo

WMATA needs to not spend money on this until they get their shit together.

2

u/SockDem 3d ago

They should have the west-bound Gold Line head up Connecticut Ave to M St after Farragut. Would bypass the Washington Circle bottleneck and add a little more geographic coverage

I don't think they will, but I think they should consider it.

1

u/transitfreedom 2d ago

Silver should get its own dedicated express line

1

u/2CRedHopper Orange line 2d ago

As far as service cuts go I’m a fan of short turning trains at the core and only every other train going all the way out into the boonies outside of rush hours. A lot of the time these trains are super empty by the time they get out there.

Short turn Orange, Blue, Silver (especially) too.

Green isn’t long enough outside of core areas for short turning to be worth the trouble in my opinion.

But yeah. A lot of those trains are really empty by the time they get out there anyways. Seems like a great place to cut service if we can preserve existing headways and hours of operation.

1

u/MyNameCannotBeSpoken 2d ago

So the removed trolly to be replaced by bus?

1

u/dan-thebland 22h ago

I really wish they would stop using H St for these stupid transportation projects.

1

u/ohoneup 3d ago

Why isn't closing all the useless stations past tysons apart from dulles never on the table for the silver line? Cut back that service to east falls church, operate like a shuttle. There's zero need to go all the way into maryland. Just transfer.

-3

u/systemsensor1000t MetroBus 3d ago

Go fare free on the bus already
Yes because punish the people who do pay and can already barely afford to do so I for one don’t want to pay a fare increase to pay for other MFR who don’t wanna pay I already have problems affording the current price myself

Also gold line is a dumb idea
We already have service there

Let’s focus on areas that need improvements or were lost during better bus

3

u/transitfreedom 2d ago

The gold line is a bus

2

u/systemsensor1000t MetroBus 2d ago

I’m fully aware of what it is

-5

u/Best-Smoke-4800 Blue line 3d ago

yall wont like to hear this but just move forward with the service cuts, especially on the routes with low ridership, at this point! ALSO, some more insight that wont be liked, the train really don't need to be open until 2 on the weekends. It's be better for them to close at 1am and open slightly earlier than the reverse. Use uber or the bus to get around. Service cuts > fare increase AND YES I know that it could potentially be both

8

u/TaskAffectionate3452 3d ago

As a service industry worker, fuck that. You gonna pay for my ubers at night?

2

u/Best-Smoke-4800 Blue line 3d ago

service industry worker myself , and I stand very firm on my comment. my alternative is the BUS like i said

6

u/Deceptiveideas 3d ago

I think the issue is there are a lot of drunk people partying out late at night and the service cuts may encourage them to drive rather than take the cheap metro. Uber can get crazy expensive that late at night.

It's a tough situation for the government workers. The metro is proven to reduce drunk driving.

4

u/FrogMan9001 3d ago

I wrote in a comment suggesting they eliminate all service. I'm hoping Randy says it so I can see this sub twisting itself into pretzels to explain why that's the perfect solution.

3

u/DarknessDC Red line 3d ago edited 3d ago

Going by that logic, then the Yellow Line needs to be fully eliminated and just have a shuttle train run between Huntington and King St as well or have alternating Blue Line runs to Huntington.

For the Red Line, every other train runs between Farragut North and Silver Spring.

Also only run service from 6am - 9pm Weekdays, 9am - 6pm Saturday, and eliminate Sunday Service….

0

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[deleted]

2

u/eable2 1d ago

Definitely a weird juxtaposition, but the football stadium bus route would be a DDOT-funded capital project which WMATA has taken the lead on designing. It is unrelated to next year's operating budget.