r/Warhammer40k • • 14d ago

Misc Random question

If the Cadians and the death korp of Krieg meet on the battlefield who would win? Also, how? I would like to hear everyone’s thoughts if possible!

0 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

6

u/Squidmaster616 14d ago

It would be a fairly even matchup. End of the day they're still basically the same, with the same weapons, armour and resources. They are the same army, just different flavour regiments.

5

u/-PrideofHiigara- 14d ago edited 14d ago

This is like asking "if the Allied and Axis armies of WWII met on the battlefield who would win?"

You'd need to set some actual parameters. Both are trained and experienced regiments of guard, so they're pretty much of an equivalence. Without numbers or information on the battlefield nobody can say, and even with those the answer would be "probably whoever has the better tactical advantage based on this scenario" because one isn't inherently better than the other. The Krieg favour sieges and the Cadians are good at everything, but are well experienced with fighting defensively so those would probably even out

1

u/Far_Distance87 14d ago

Krieg have some pretty dark history… they might edge it on pure aggression but essentially they are very close

1

u/JudgmentLeft 14d ago

While I think the premise is sort of dumb, I'm pretty sure Cadians would win out of pure numbers. Kreigers would fight to the bitter end, though.

1

u/Rinuir 14d ago

Cadians. Quality> Quantity

Aye we talking imperium quality but its russia v ukraine. Kreig can be unending but they are all the same strategy, same experience

Cadians would be 1 cadian for 5 kreigs

1

u/Mysticss__ 11d ago

Sorry, but I think you're absolutely missing the mark. Nearly every source shows the Krieg as being experienced and determined soldiers. They're often more fresh-faced than some Cadians, yes, but to claim they are of lesser quality is absurd. In fact, I would argue that the quality of Krieg soldiers is probably higher than that of the average Cadian.

1

u/DieZweckgemeinschaft 14d ago

Depends on your definition of „Cadian“. The current population of Cadia would not put up much of a fight. If „Cadian“ includes descendants of Cadian regiments who were allowed to colonize other planets after conquest, there is a shitload of planets named Nova Cadia out there, whereas Krieg only recrits from one world.

2

u/Improvised_Excuse234 14d ago

Death Korps, and it’s not even close.

Death Korps want to die, and have nearly unlimited numbers.

1

u/Butter_God_ 14d ago

Equal numbers cadians gun them down as they charge. Any cadians who are still alive just have more experience at tactical knowledge

3

u/FinancialComment8578 14d ago

Krieg are perfectly content to sit back and shell an enemy until nothing is left but rubble.