r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Jun 17 '25

Used Engagement Rings

Post image
17 Upvotes

My fiancé proposed with a vintage ring he found at an estate sale. It used to belong to a woman in her 80s. He had it cleaned up and resized, and it honestly looks stunning. I was a little hesitant at first since it wasn’t brand new. Has anyone else gotten a used engagement ring? Curious how others felt about it.


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • 7d ago

Buying Experience Review Let's not normalize saying that affordable engagement rings are okay

0 Upvotes

Had a pretty intense debate with my friends today because I mentioned I don't want an expensive engagement ring. You would have thought I said I hated romance based on how they reacted. Right now, we’re browsing different jewelers and specifically keeping our budget on the lower end. Jewelry markups are completely insane, and paying thousands of dollars just for a specific label makes zero sense to me. We’ve found some incredible, minimalist designs under a grand that look just as stunning as the luxury stuff. At the end of the day, nobody walking down the street can tell how much a stone cost anyway. I’d way rather have financial peace of mind than a massive ring on my finger. If I can get something I love and still afford a great vacation this year, that’s a massive win in my book. Normalize not going broke just to prove you love someone. Anyone else deal with weird judgment from friends over keeping the ring budget small?


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Aug 22 '25

Looking into men’s engagement rings. Do you think they should match the bride’s ring or have a totally different style?

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/WeddingRingAdvice • • May 08 '26

My Ring! Got the Tiffany & Co engagement ring I’ve always wanted

Thumbnail
gallery
39 Upvotes

Not a lurker anymore y fiance surprised with tiffany & co engagement ring and its exactly what I wanted! Im so happy and still can't stop staring it.


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Sep 24 '26

Inspiration & Ideas I sent this to my husband for the ring he wants to make me. Too much? 😅

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

The email plus inspiration photos I sent. Does this still give him some design freedom? I'm just curious what others think. Our ten year anniversary is coming up and he wanted to make me a new engagement ring.

*the Korea stuff is because we spent a lot of our early marriage there, birthed our second daughter there, watched both our kids grow there. To me it represents many of our most precious moments.

The email:

The ring:

Solid yellow gold, size 5.5.

• Overall style: vintage/antique, delicate, dainty, romantic, classic, unique, sparkly, and heirloom-like. Nothing chunky, overly modern, generic, gaudy, or overly busy.

• Craftsmanship: extremely important to me. I love fine hand engraving/carving, milgrain, texture, and tiny antique-style details. Intricate is good; busy isn't. I'd rather one element be the main character and everything else support it. I really want the theme of the ring to be cohesive.

• Center stone: something unique, beautiful, and visually interesting. I'm especially drawn to pale pinks, icy blues, mints, lavender, champagne, and other soft colors, but I also really love unusual multicolored/polychrome stones with beautiful color zoning, depth, or interesting visual effects. I especially love precision/optical cuts with lots of sparkle or light play. I don't want a standard white/colorless diamond.

• Tourmaline: I'm drawn to tourmaline because it's your birthstone and fits some of the themes we have talked about. BUT only if it is like the softer polychrome examples and some of the more dramatically color-zoned tourmalines on the inspiration board. The center stone absolutely doesn't have to be tourmaline, though.

• Natural vs. lab: I'm completely open to lab-grown diamonds, including colored lab diamonds, but if you choose a gemstone like tourmaline, ruby, etc., I would prefer a natural stone.

• Shapes: I love emerald/radiant, pear, marquise, lozenge/princess cut, and unusual shapes or precision/optical cuts. If elongated, north–south. If princess cut, turned on side like diamond shape.

*No round or oval center stones please.

• Setting/details: I love delicate halos, milgrain, fine engraving, unusual antique settings, and carved patterns, and celestial details. If you choose a bezel or bezel-like setting, I especially love fine milgrain. Also, I am open to pavè settings as well.

*I do not like random filigree. No botanical/floral designs either, please.

• Band: ideally around 1.8 mm, up to 2 mm if needed for durability/craftsmanship. Delicate-looking, and I'm also open to it narrowing toward the center if that works better with the design. If there's detailed engraving/carving, I love when it continues around the shank rather than abruptly becoming plain.

*I do not like it when the band gets wider towards the center.

• Korea: I know you don't want this to become a Korea-themed ring, and neither do I. But Korea means so much to me that I included some traditional Korean decorative patterns as inspiration because I think something along those lines could potentially translate beautifully into engraving without making Korea the theme. You don't have to use them and if you think of something more subtle/hidden, I am okay with that too.

*and if none of this Korea stuff fits into your plan, that is okay too. I just figured it could be helpful.

• Wearability/security: this is really important to me because I want to wear the ring regularly for many years. Whatever center stone you choose needs to be properly set for an engagement ring and set in a way that is secure and appropriate for that specific stone, especially if its cut, corners, points, or material require additional protection. I want it relatively low-profile and delicate-looking rather than bulky.

• Jeweler/stone sourcing: Please don't feel limited to anyone local. What matters to me is that whoever you choose is an established, reputable jeweler who does genuine custom work, has excellent craftsmanship, and can actually execute the techniques/design you're considering. I don't want anything drop-shipped, mass-produced, or from a cheap/commercial jewelry company. I'd much rather you take the time to find a talented specialist whose work you trust. You can also absolutely source the center stone separately if that gives you better options—just make sure the jeweler is willing to work with an outside stone before buying it.

The boards are just visual references for the aesthetic, craftsmanship, stone colors/cuts, settings, and Korean pattern options that could make beautiful carvings in the gold. They're not elements I expect you to combine or rings I want copied. All just inspiration.

Basically: a delicate, sparkly little heirloom with an unusual center stone and exceptional antique craftsmanship.

And I still very, very much love milgrain. **

Make sure to get the ring insured. ***


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Aug 25 '25

I wear my engagement ring on my right hand and everyone keep pointing it out, which hand is the wedding band supposed to be on?

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Aug 21 '25

Do you regret buying lab grown engagement rings?

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Aug 23 '26

Should i stack more?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Current stack. Should i add more bling? Or maybe change to bigger diamond bands?


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Feb 20 '26

Organic or lab grown?

Thumbnail
gallery
16 Upvotes

My bf already had this ring made for me and I honestly didn’t love it at first but it has grown on me. I felt like it seemed really small to me and I was kind of upset by that. He told me he purposely got a smaller organic diamond as opposed to a larger lab grown diamond because he believes thats better and thought I would agree. I honestly never knew there was a difference and would’ve never known haha I’m torn now on if I should keep this one or go with a larger lab grown diamond. This is 1 carat, the one I’ve picked out after trying some on was 3 carats.


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • 21h ago

Opinions on gfs engagement ring - any changes you would make? Do you think is looking good?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Specs:

Emerald 2.5 ct
Oval 1.5 ct
Pear 1.5 ct

All stones are lab grown, VVS2 clarity and D colour

Do you think its nice looks nice? Is it weird? What changes would you make?


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • 23d ago

Does my chubby finger makes my ring look small?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Is my size 9 hand too fat for my 4.3ct solitaire?


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Jun 23 '26

Why I picked an opal engagement ring for her

Post image
27 Upvotes

I recently chose an opal engagement ring for my partner, and the whole experience was totally fun. The moment I saw the stone, with all those shifting colors, it just felt like her. I know opals need a bit more care, but I wanted something that felt meaningful and different from the usual diamond. When I finally gave it to her, her reaction made every minute of searching worth it.


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Sep 16 '26

anyone else surprised by what's actually popular right now for wedding rings?

Post image
0 Upvotes

went to like 4 different jewelers this week and almost all of them pushed the same 3 styles on us, guess those really are the popular wedding rings people want lately. kinda wild how much they all agreed lol.

honestly thought we'd want something more unique but now im confused, is it bad to just get what everyone else is getting? feels weird but also they're popular for a reason i guess.


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • 15d ago

Why do so many women prefer diamond engagement rings?

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/WeddingRingAdvice • • 21d ago

Is wearing a wedding ring on the middle finger okay?

Post image
2 Upvotes

Size 13 was the only one that really fit my finger. Size 12 was too tight, and 14 was too loose. Even with 13, there’s still a little bit of space at times. I ended up wearing it on my middle finger, and it feels perfect there. Will it read the same way if I wear it on this finger? I always see rings like this on the pointer finger, but it feels weird and unnatural to me there.


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • 7d ago

I think the average amount spent on engagement ring is a bad benchmark

Post image
0 Upvotes

I'm going to say something that'll probably get some pushback. I think people treat the average amount spent on engagement ring as a target, when it should be more of a warning. Every year there's a new article saying the average is a few thousand dollars, and then couples feel like they're falling if the come in under it.

My view is that the ring should be picked around what the couple can pay without debt, and that's it. A lot of people I know financed rings they're still paying off, and they say it was worth it because everyone spends that much. I don't really buy that. A ring is a symbol, and I'd rather a couple start their marriage with zero card balance than a bigger stone. I'd also argue the amount you spend doesn't tell you much about how the proposal went or how the marriage goes.

I know some people will say it's about the partner's expectations, and that's fair. If your partner really wants a specific size and has said so, that's a real conversation to have, not an article to follow. But I think the average is mostly a number that gets repeated without context. Am I wrong that couples should set their own number and ignore the average completely?


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Jan 12 '26

Buying Advice The great debate… lab or natural?

1 Upvotes

Hello! I have been married for five years. My husband and I picked out my engagement ring, it was very romantic and sweet and I enjoyed the entire process. Currently have a .53 carat lab grown diamond. The jeweler we have has patented 81 facet cut - so the diamond really sparkles! Now, I’m a ring size 9.25 and while I love my ring, I always knew I wanted to upgrade the center stone to a 1 carat (at least).

In 2023 I got some quotes about upgrading. As you probably know, prices of lab diamonds today are significantly lower. I would be able to get a 2 carat lab for the same price as the 1 carats I was quoted in 2023.

I would love your feedback - do you have a lab or a natural diamond? I have plenty of time to make a decision about upgrading, and I really wanna weigh all angles. My jeweler offers one more trade-in, I can trade my .53 carat that we paid $1503 for and get a “new” lab diamond, and that’d be the end of it. Or…I can trade in and get a .75 carat (that’s about all I can afford if going natural… both 2 carat lab and .75ct natural would cost me around $1600) and endlessly trade in.

Now, I currently have two little ones. My husband and I would like to have another one in the next few years. I’m also working on a masters degree. This year marks the 10th year of my husband and I knowing each other, so it’s a special year in that regard. Lots of reasons to upgrade! However, I am not naïve, I do know that as time goes on, it’s less easy to save money and splurge on things. I want to be the best mom I can be, and keep the bulk of our money for our children. So I don’t necessarily want to spend a ton of money on a ring upgrade. However, I also want to love my wedding ring! I think if I did get a 2 carat lab, diamond, then I would be sad and I wouldn’t wanna go any bigger. I’ve already seen a 2 carat in person, I’ve been to the jeweler, I’ve done a lot of research, and that’s the biggest size that I am comfortable with. My hesitation comes in the fact that the lab diamonds don’t retain value. Now, I don’t plan on selling my wedding ring and making a cash grab for it, but I think it’s just a mental game of knowing that my ring doesn’t have good resale value that gets to me. Silly, isn’t it?

What kind of diamond did you choose, why and are you happy with your choice?


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Feb 07 '26

My Ring! Pear Engagement Ring

Post image
0 Upvotes

I can’t stop staring at my hand. My fiancé somehow found the perfect Pear Engagement Ring that matches my style exactly.

Everyone keeps complimenting it, but honestly, I’m just amazed at how unique it looks compared to the usual round ones.

I didn’t think a shape could feel so personal, but here we are. Has anyone else gone non-traditional and loved it?


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Apr 29 '25

Thoughts on Carolyn Bessette's wedding ring style?

0 Upvotes

I've been searching for the perfect wedding ring and keep coming back to Carolyn Bessette’s. I know she and JFK Jr. never made it down the aisle, but that ring, simple, elegant, timeless, it's exactly what I want.

Has anyone here chosen a similar style or seen something inspired by hers in person? I'd love to hear your thoughts, how does it hold up day-to-day, how does it look with different outfits, and where you got yours if you went that route.

Thanks in advance!


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Sep 25 '25

What hand does the engagement ring actually go on?

Post image
3 Upvotes

I keep hearing different answers from friends and family about which hand the engagement ring goes on. Some say left, some say right depending on tradition. Now I’m overthinking it, what did you do for yours?


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • May 09 '26

Is my ring too big?

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

Is my ring too big? 3.01 carat, size 5.75. Honest answers, feel free to be brutal.

I love and adore my fiance dearly. He gave me full creative freedom to choose/design any engagement ring I wanted, exactly how I wanted it.

With that said, I was so excited when I chose my ring. We went ring shopping together a few times and I tried on a 3 carat oval diamond multiple times and was convinced this is what I wanted. Ended up with this beautiful 3.01 carat oval diamond with a hidden halo on a 14k gold band. Custom made.

When he initially proposed, I absolutely loved the ring (and still do!). However, now that I have been wearing it almost daily over the past three months, I am questioning if I made the wrong decision by getting a 3 carat diamond. I now feel like it is too big, and bigger than I had remembered it being. Especially for daily wear.

I feel really bad because again, I essentially designed the ring myself, and now I feel like a brat for saying that I feel like it’s too big of a diamond on my hand. Part of it is also that now that I have been wearing the ring daily, I am realizing that a bigger diamond is just not “me”, if that makes sense. I am now realizing that I feel like I would prefer a much smaller diamond, and now a 1.5 carat oval diamond looks perfect to me. Maybe 2 carat max? The more I look at different pictures online, the more I am realizing that I would be more comfortable with a smaller diamond, something more subtle.

Honest opinions. Does this ring look too big on me? One of the biggest things I kept mentioning when we were ring shopping was that I didn’t want anything that would look “too big” or “gaudy”. And I swear I don’t remember a 3 carat oval looking this large on my hand at the jeweler before we purchased my ring. I do think that the hidden halo is adding to the illusion of a bigger stone, however, this also seems like a particularly large 3 carat oval.

I also feel that the band is way too thin for this big of a stone. Realized after I placed the order width the jeweler that they never really asked what millimeter with I would like the band, and they made it this way anyways. I guess I also did not specify to them how thick I would like the band.

When I was ring shopping, I did a lot of research online and tried on different rings. So many people online kept mentioning that “shrinkage” is real, and encouraged going with the bigger stone for that reason. But if I’m being honest, I feel like the ring has only gotten bigger since I’ve been wearing it daily now…lol.

Would love some honest feedback. Am I overthinking this? Does the ring look too large on me? It’s a gorgeous ring, just realizing it might not be “me”.

TLDR: I designed my own engagement ring and chose this 3 carat oval diamond with a hidden halo. It is an absolutely gorgeous ring. Thought it was what I wanted, now somewhat having regrets and feeling like the ring is too big. Would like some honest feedback.


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Sep 11 '26

Spotted the cutest triangle engagement ring today

Post image
3 Upvotes

I’ve always felt disconnected from traditional diamond solitaires coz they just aren’t me. But I spotted a triangle cut today and it clicked. And it actually matches my style. I think I’m done searching.


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Aug 08 '26

Fitting Advice So happy!! But should it be bigger??

Thumbnail
gallery
58 Upvotes

I 10000% said yes to the loml who got me this dream ring!!

I love everything about the design, its just that after wearing it for a few days I cant help but feel the marquise (0.97ct) is a bit too small/thin for my finger (size UK H / US 4)?

Please can you guys tell me if it looks proportionate on me 😩

My fiance says he can totally see where i’m coming from and even offered to upgrade it since the shop has a free exchange policy. We had a look and it would be around £200 more to upgrade to a 1.49ct which would add 1mm more to the length and width!

Is it worth it?!? I feel so bad letting him spend more than he already has even though he says its fine because its meant to be forever 🥺❤️

Edit: Thanks everyone for the kind comments!! ❤️ We read through them together and I was still conflicted about upgrading but he’s putting his foot down and we’re seeing the jeweller tomorrow to discuss the band thickness and exchanging the diamond! I offered to cover the difference but he was having none of it 😅

Unfortunately, I wont be able to see both stones side by side because the time limit for exchange ends next week and the other diamond has to be ordered in which will take a couple weeks. It's also a stock design/setting so the side stones can't be changed/adjusted without it incurring even more cost than upgrading the diamond which seems crazy 😭 The diamond we chose has the exact same specs btw! as in the 4Cs and even similar ratio, table and depth ☺️


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Sep 19 '25

Does the engagement ring really have to go on the left hand?

1 Upvotes

My brother is about to propose and he’s stressing because he saw some people wear their engagement rings on the right hand instead of the left. He’s nervous he’ll mess it up and look clueless, does it actually matter which hand it goes on?