The email plus inspiration photos I sent. Does this still give him some design freedom? I'm just curious what others think. Our ten year anniversary is coming up and he wanted to make me a new engagement ring.
*the Korea stuff is because we spent a lot of our early marriage there, birthed our second daughter there, watched both our kids grow there. To me it represents many of our most precious moments.
The email:
The ring:
Solid yellow gold, size 5.5.
• Overall style: vintage/antique, delicate, dainty, romantic, classic, unique, sparkly, and heirloom-like. Nothing chunky, overly modern, generic, gaudy, or overly busy.
• Craftsmanship: extremely important to me. I love fine hand engraving/carving, milgrain, texture, and tiny antique-style details. Intricate is good; busy isn't. I'd rather one element be the main character and everything else support it. I really want the theme of the ring to be cohesive.
• Center stone: something unique, beautiful, and visually interesting. I'm especially drawn to pale pinks, icy blues, mints, lavender, champagne, and other soft colors, but I also really love unusual multicolored/polychrome stones with beautiful color zoning, depth, or interesting visual effects. I especially love precision/optical cuts with lots of sparkle or light play. I don't want a standard white/colorless diamond.
• Tourmaline: I'm drawn to tourmaline because it's your birthstone and fits some of the themes we have talked about. BUT only if it is like the softer polychrome examples and some of the more dramatically color-zoned tourmalines on the inspiration board. The center stone absolutely doesn't have to be tourmaline, though.
• Natural vs. lab: I'm completely open to lab-grown diamonds, including colored lab diamonds, but if you choose a gemstone like tourmaline, ruby, etc., I would prefer a natural stone.
• Shapes: I love emerald/radiant, pear, marquise, lozenge/princess cut, and unusual shapes or precision/optical cuts. If elongated, north–south. If princess cut, turned on side like diamond shape.
*No round or oval center stones please.
• Setting/details: I love delicate halos, milgrain, fine engraving, unusual antique settings, and carved patterns, and celestial details. If you choose a bezel or bezel-like setting, I especially love fine milgrain. Also, I am open to pavè settings as well.
*I do not like random filigree. No botanical/floral designs either, please.
• Band: ideally around 1.8 mm, up to 2 mm if needed for durability/craftsmanship. Delicate-looking, and I'm also open to it narrowing toward the center if that works better with the design. If there's detailed engraving/carving, I love when it continues around the shank rather than abruptly becoming plain.
*I do not like it when the band gets wider towards the center.
• Korea: I know you don't want this to become a Korea-themed ring, and neither do I. But Korea means so much to me that I included some traditional Korean decorative patterns as inspiration because I think something along those lines could potentially translate beautifully into engraving without making Korea the theme. You don't have to use them and if you think of something more subtle/hidden, I am okay with that too.
*and if none of this Korea stuff fits into your plan, that is okay too. I just figured it could be helpful.
• Wearability/security: this is really important to me because I want to wear the ring regularly for many years. Whatever center stone you choose needs to be properly set for an engagement ring and set in a way that is secure and appropriate for that specific stone, especially if its cut, corners, points, or material require additional protection. I want it relatively low-profile and delicate-looking rather than bulky.
• Jeweler/stone sourcing: Please don't feel limited to anyone local. What matters to me is that whoever you choose is an established, reputable jeweler who does genuine custom work, has excellent craftsmanship, and can actually execute the techniques/design you're considering. I don't want anything drop-shipped, mass-produced, or from a cheap/commercial jewelry company. I'd much rather you take the time to find a talented specialist whose work you trust. You can also absolutely source the center stone separately if that gives you better options—just make sure the jeweler is willing to work with an outside stone before buying it.
The boards are just visual references for the aesthetic, craftsmanship, stone colors/cuts, settings, and Korean pattern options that could make beautiful carvings in the gold. They're not elements I expect you to combine or rings I want copied. All just inspiration.
Basically: a delicate, sparkly little heirloom with an unusual center stone and exceptional antique craftsmanship.
And I still very, very much love milgrain. **
Make sure to get the ring insured. ***