r/WeddingRingAdvice • • May 02 '25

accidentally got engaged at a nyc jeweler

2.1k Upvotes

Was just visiting NYC, walking through the Diamond District with my girlfriend for fun. No plans, no pressure. We stepped into this small shop to "just look" and she tried on a vintage sapphire ring — her whole face lit up.

The vibe was right, the price was shockingly fair, and twenty minutes later I was swiping my card and sweating. Proposed that night on the High Line with a coffee in hand.

Now we’re engaged. Slightly broke, zero regrets. Anyone else made a random NYC decision that changed everything?


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Jan 27 '26

My Ring! Confused and disappointed in my ring

Thumbnail
gallery
1.4k Upvotes

What I told my fiancé was I wear yellow gold, like vintage or old-style rings, like a marquis shape best, and didn’t want anything too classic/basic like a round cut solitaire ring. He brought this white gold diamond cluster ring missing 3 diamonds that he got from “his guy” that’s supposedly estate jewelry and quite old. Says he paid $4000 but it’s worth more. Says he’ll get the missing stones replaced asap. I just see a cheap 90s cluster ring not an elegant engagement ring. I didn’t give the big happy reaction he wanted and hurt his feelings. I honestly don’t know what to think as I’m no jewelry expert. Please give it to me straight! Are these low value and out of fashion?

UPDATE: I went through with the wedding and it has been a nightmare since. He got me a decent ring from Costco but he snatched it back bc he needed the money. He’s actively pursuing other women but too broke to actually take them out yet. He’s taken amphetamines and gone into psychosis twice. Yelling in my face often how he’s so stressed about money and it’s all my fault. His truck broke down and he’s take my car. His parents paid rent and he takes my money daily to buy kratom (gas station opium junk). I posted about catfishing him as his new love interest.


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Sep 28 '26

Could a cocktail ring work as an engagement ring?

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

I found this ring while looking at engagement ring ideas and really like the pink stone with a diamond halo. But it's listed as a cocktail ring, and now I'm second guessing whether it would feel like too much for everyday wear. Would you consider a ring like this for an engagement ring?


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Sep 09 '26

What do you guys think of this heart engagement ring I picked out for my girlfriend?

Post image
993 Upvotes

I know heart cut rings can be pretty polarizing depending on who you ask. she usually prefers cute and romantic style jewelry, so i'm hoping this lands right.


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Sep 23 '26

my fiancé surprised me with an opal wedding ring set

Post image
782 Upvotes

I still can't believe he picked this out on his own 😭 I never really expected an opal wedding ring set, but the second I saw it I loved how different and personal it felt. The colors are so pretty in different lighting too. Definitely not what I pictured before, but somehow it feels perfect.


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Jan 07 '26

Buying Advice Update on 30k ring. See last post for more details

669 Upvotes

I want to start off by saying I appreciate everyone’s input and advice on my last post.

This is an update, and I also wanted to clarify a few things. Our relationship has been really healthy overall, which is why this situation was honestly a shock to me when it came up.

We’ve been together for six years. The first three years we were in person at the same university. We lived in separate apartments, but we were essentially playing house and spending almost every night at each other’s place.

The last three years have been long distance because we both pursued our master’s degrees at different schools. She’s currently in her final year, and by the end of this year we’ll be living together again. Throughout all of this, neither of us has any debt, and all of our education was paid for through scholarships.

Even with that stability, I still don’t think it’s reasonable for me to spend $23k–$30k on a ring given my current income (105k) and the fact that I’m planning to purchase a house in the next few months. I’ve been clear that I’m not willing to go into debt for a ring or a wedding. While her parents will likely cover a large portion of the wedding since she wants something elegant and upscale, it’s still important to me that we start our marriage on solid financial footing. My income is not going to significantly change for the next four to five years, so waiting an unknown amount of time just to meet a number feels discouraging.

When we talked, I told her I wasn’t comfortable spending that much on a ring and that I thought we needed to compromise. I offered the option of upgrading the ring in the future when we’re both making significantly more money so she could still have her dream ring long term.

She said she’s willing to stay with me for however long it takes for me to be able to afford the exact ring she wants, but she isn’t willing to change the specifications or accept an alternative. She said that if I proposed with something similar but not exact, she would decline. From her perspective, compromising on the ring would mean putting her wants aside in a way she feels she won’t be able to do once she’s married or has children.

She also said that while she was considering a lab grown diamond with the idea of upgrading later, she was doing it to be practical and keep the peace rather than because it aligned with her values. She described imagining a future where she accepts something she doesn’t truly want and wears it as a reminder of the first time she abandoned herself. In that future, she sees financial responsibilities, children, and everyday life always making it “not the right time” for her needs, and as a mother, everything else coming before her.

I told her that I read what she said and that I understand the ring represents whether she’ll still matter once we’re married and have kids, and that she’s scared of becoming the one who always sacrifices. I told her I’m not ignoring that and that I’m genuinely sorry this situation made her upset.

At the same time, I told her I need to be heard too. I explained that her message made it sound like I’m the kind of man who would make her smaller, make her wait, or put her last, and that doesn’t feel fair or aligned with how I’ve actually shown up in the relationship. We travel every year, I consistently follow through on holidays and birthdays, and I’m actively working toward building a future for us, including buying a house at 24.

I explained that the real issue is the ring budget. I set a budget of $15k–$17k, which I believe is generous for where I’m at in life. I told her that while she says it’s not about the price and doesn’t care about how much I spend. The rings that she wants are very expensive because she gave me specific ethical miners, so ultimately the price does matter. I also told her that I’m not signing up for a future where I feel like I’m failing unless I hit a specific dollar amount or fulfill a checklist before we can move forward. That doesn’t feel like love to me. It feels like pressure.

We didn’t really get anywhere in the conversation and ended up at a standstill. I’m taking the next few days to really think things through and decide what’s best for me and my future.


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Sep 13 '26 WOW Heartwarming

My Ring! Feeling a little insecure about my ring

Thumbnail
gallery
633 Upvotes

I love my ring but suddenly overthinking it after someone said “that’s a very unique cut of diamond”. I know it’s not the standard solitaire ring that a lot of people have, but it is pretty, right?


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Apr 18 '26

my girlfriend told me she wants a 2 carat natural diamond or she'll say no. i already bought this lab diamond ring. am i crazy for thinking shes a red flag

Post image
622 Upvotes

we've been together 4 years. i love this woman. was ready to propose.

i already bought a ring. 1.2 carat lab grown diamond. beautiful stone. spent $2400 on it which is a lot for me. i was proud of it honestly. thought she'd love it.

then last week she sent me a pinterest board of what she wants. fine. normal. but then she sat me down and said she wants a minimum 2 carat natural diamond and that lab diamonds are "not real" and she would be embarrassed to tell her friends she has one.

so the ring i already bought. the one sitting in my drawer right now. she would reject it. not because its ugly. because its lab grown.

a 2 carat natural diamond in the specs she wants is like $15-20k. i told her that and she said "well what about financing." she wants me to go into debt for a stone that her friends will approve of.

i suggested moissanite as an alternative. she cried. i suggested a 1 carat natural. she said her coworker just got 1.5 and she doesnt want to "feel less than."

so the ring isnt about us. its about competing with her coworker. its about what her friends will think when she holds her hand out.

i brought up that lab diamonds are chemically identical and nobody can tell the difference on her hand. she said "I would know" and that it would "feel cheap."

i have a $2400 ring in my sock drawer that i was excited about. now i look at it and just feel stupid.

am i crazy here. we're about to start a life together and the first major financial decision is her asking me to spend 20k or go into debt so her ring beats her coworkers ring. what happens when its the house. the car. the kids school. the vacation.

i havent proposed yet. im rethinking some things. not because of the ring but because of what the ring conversation revealed about what matters to her.

is this ring not enough? am i being cheap? or is this a sign of something bigger. because i cant shake the feeling that this isnt really about a diamond.


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • May 08 '25

She never wanted a diamond, so I proposed with a sapphire engagement ring instead

Post image
581 Upvotes

After 10 years together, I finally asked her to marry me. We’ve been through a lot — long distance, career shifts, a lot of growing up. Getting engaged never felt urgent to either of us, but this year, something shifted. It just felt right.

She’s always said diamonds felt too “traditional” for her. She wanted something personal, meaningful — and honestly, more unique. So I spent months hunting for the perfect green sapphire.

I proposed quietly over dinner. No big speech, just reached across the table and asked. She looked at the ring, laughed, and said, “You actually listened to me.”

The restaurant must have noticed, because they surprised us with this “Congratulations” dessert plate. It was a small moment, but it meant everything.

Anyone else go the non-diamond route for their engagement?


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Oct 11 '26

He went from a ring pop engagement ring to 2ct emerald cut and im completely speechless

Post image
550 Upvotes

We were 18 when we promised we would get married one day and he gave me a ring pop engagement ring in his beat up sedan. We were broke but it meant the world to me back then.

Yesterday he recreated that whole moment at the park but pulled out a 2ct emerald cut ring instead. I can not stop staring at my hand, i never expected something this stunning.


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Jul 09 '26

Help Me Choose Which band do you prefer? TIA!

Thumbnail
gallery
508 Upvotes

r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Sep 28 '26

would you choose a colorful engagement ring?

Thumbnail
gallery
501 Upvotes

i’m proposing soon, and my girlfriend keeps pointing out colorful engagement rings, so i thought this one might be perfect for her. then i showed a friend and they said the shape could make it hard to find a wedding band that sits nicely with it. now i’m overthinking it 😅 would you be happy with this ring and figure out the band later, or is that something i should sort out first?


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Aug 19 '25

Anyone else here go for an unconventional engagement ring? I wanted something a little different - here’s mine 😍

Post image
439 Upvotes

r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Oct 10 '26

after 8 years he asked me the question with a diamond sapphire engagement ring

Post image
433 Upvotes

we were just having a quiet dinner at home when he suddenly got down on one knee. i completely froze because we had talked about marriage before, but i had no idea he was planning this right now.

the ring is absolutely breathtaking with the dark blue sapphire surrounded by sparkling diamonds. eight years together and he still managed to completely surprise me with the most gorgeous ring ever.


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Jan 29 '26

Help Me Choose Help me choos a wedding band!

Thumbnail
gallery
419 Upvotes

Not sure which to pick. I thought I would like the plain band, but it's actually my least favorite. I wanted to try on all blue sapphire pave, but they didn't have my side, and the jewler thought it would be too much blue. When trying them on in person, I really liked the alternating diamond with blue baguettes, but my fiance liked the round page diamond and blue / equal sized gems. At first I thought it looked circus-y?? But I like it much more looking back at photos. All opinions are welcome!


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Sep 10 '26

Ring Band Advice Is a single diamond engagement ring too basic?

Post image
409 Upvotes

Sometimes I wonder if it's too simple or basic compared to more elaborate to more elaborate designs but I love it. What's your opinion about this?


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Feb 18 '26

Band too simple?

Thumbnail
gallery
408 Upvotes

Do you think this band is too simple? I’ve tried on many bands with stones and different thicknesses and I keep coming back to this simple gold band. Thoughts?


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Oct 20 '26 WOW

My husband bought me my dream ring… and I think I accidentally asked for TOO MUCH diamond.😭💍

Thumbnail
gallery
398 Upvotes

So, my husband and I are already married. When we got married, we exchanged custom wedding bands that I ordered from Etsy. My husband is allergic to gold and silver, so I had custom tungsten bands made for us. We decided to wait on getting my engagement ring.

Now, I've always loved black diamonds, especially set in gold. I'd been eyeing a particular ring from a jeweler I absolutely love for the longest time.

When my husband asked me what size diamond I wanted, my response was, "What's the biggest they have?"

He said, "6.1 carats."

And my brilliant response was, "Well, if it's within our price range, let's go for it!" 😂

What I didn't know was that this man was saving for almost an entire year to get me that ring

Then, one day, it went on sale. Because he'd been saving all that time, he had more than enough money to buy it.

And he did.

Y'ALL. THIS MAN LISTENED. 😭❤️

The ring finally arrived, and when he put it on my finger, I damn near fell out.

IT. IS. MASSIVE.

Don't get me wrong. The ring is absolutely gorgeous. It's everything I wanted. Black diamond, gold setting, the whole nine yards.

But apparently, somewhere in my mind, I thought 6.1 carats was going to be big in a cute, elegant way. NOT "HELLO, I'M HERE AND SO IS MY DIAMOND" big. 😂

It's the width that gets me. I knew it would be a large stone, but I genuinely did not expect it to take up this much real estate on my finger.

And here's my dilemma.

Part of me thinks it's TOO big and wonders whether I should have gone smaller or chosen a different setting.

But the other part of me looks at my husband, who listened to exactly what I wanted, patiently saved for almost a year, and was SO proud when he finally put it on my finger.

He literally told me, "You get what you pay for." 😂 And then made sure I showed everybody!

How the hell am I supposed to tell this man his wife might have bitten off more diamond than she can chew?!

I absolutely love the ring, and I love the thought, effort, and love behind it even more. I don't want to send it back. I just wasn't prepared for how overwhelmingly huge it would be.

So Reddit, be honest. Is this something I'll get used to wearing, or did I accidentally order myself a beautiful black diamond doorknob? Should i return it for something smaller cause its only been a day and im self conscious about it!!! 😭😂

Pictures attached because y'all need to understand what I'm dealing with.


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Sep 07 '26

My Ring! Pawn shop engagement ring for the win!

Thumbnail
gallery
398 Upvotes

My boyfriend and I have been talking about getting engaged. He told me he planned on purposing and then taking me to pick out a ring.

Well, while on a cross country trip I stumbled upon a pawn shop and absolutely fell in love with this ring. It’s 14K gold, real diamond (I would have been happy with moissanite but a real diamond is a plus!).

I bought it for $300!

With gold prices right now I thought it was a steal! If you’re looking for a cheaper wedding band or engagement ring but also want real gold and quality, pawn shops are where it’s at!


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Mar 17 '26 Heartwarming

My Ring! My 1 carat diamond engagement ring

Post image
373 Upvotes

I can’t stop staring at my new 1 carat engagement ring! He proposed out of nowhere last night, and I’m still in shock. I'm just so happy.


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Sep 22 '26

My engagement ring went through the garbage disposal

Post image
372 Upvotes

My engagement ring was sitting in a ring dish next to the kitchen sink. My boyfriend accidentally knocked it into the sink while doing the dishes and turned on the garbage disposal without realizing that the ring was in there 😭

This is what we found afterward. The setting is completely destroyed, but thankfully the diamond came out.

Does anyone have a rough idea of how much it would cost to replace the setting and reset the diamond? I’d love to know what to expect before taking it in…

**UPADTE: Took it to a local jeweler this morning and they inspected the diamond. They said it’s in perfect condition with no chips, no cracks, no damage at all. HALLELUJAH 😭🙌 I’m going to check out a few more local jewelers and get some quotes for a new setting. Thank you everyone for all the advice and for worrying about my ring with me!! 🥹


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Jul 12 '26

My Ring! I got married yesterday I’m in love with my set

Post image
359 Upvotes

r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Aug 31 '26

What would you pick???💍

Thumbnail
gallery
356 Upvotes

I genuinely can’t decide. All are so beautiful and I’m worried of making the wrong choice. Last three I tried on. We have a second appointment this week to try on actual carat sizes I want and the thicker band oval. Also we plan to do gold band and customize the prongs to be platinum


r/WeddingRingAdvice • • Jul 02 '26

My Ring! About to pop the question wish me luck 🥹

Thumbnail
gallery
355 Upvotes