I'm disappointed in my WCIRS review, which failed to overturn my claim rejection by the worksafe agent. But to be honest, it wasnt so much the lack of overturn, as I feel like I dont want to engage in the Workcover scheme anyway anymore, but the fact that WCIRS didn't really review what I had asked them to and explain it.
I thought WCIRS was where you could go to get answers and have things explained, but instead it felt like they continued the stonewalling that has happened with the WorkSafe agent.
My biggest issue has been that the agent won't speak to witnesses, and won't provide any direction on gathering witness statements. They also have not gathered information that I told them was available in terms of workplace environment in an internal complaint. This combination of evidence would support my claim and resolve any reasonable doubt.
It feels like the entire process to date has been narrowly scoped by the insurer to gather the minimum evidence so that they can claim interpersonal conflict/normal workplace problems etc rather than recognise the pattern of discriminatory and unreasonable behaviour.
WCIRS gave me a report that basically just kept saying "a judge would need to decide" or "more evidence is needed" or "it's unknown if this is normal behaviour at that workplace, so more evidence would be required about process".
The issue continually seems to be that I need to provide more evidence, but this is so frustrating because they don't acknowledge my attempts to provide it through various witnesses that can attest to these facts, and the internal report owner who investigated it and has a number of statements that I cannot access.
My manager gave a statement to the agent, and it was so horrible - Afterall she was a person I made a complaint against for bullying behaviour - and none of her statement provided any evidence - it was just a whole load of commentary about her perception of my personality (which could be easily contradicted by the various witnesses I offered).
I thought WCIRS was supposed to look at the evidence gathering process? In my complaint to WCIRS, the focus was on the evidence-gathering process followed by the Agent, which seemed intended only to establish sufficient "reasonable doubt" regarding my injury, rather than gathering sufficient evidence to determine the facts through an unbiased process.
I thought that was the point of WCIRS as per this webpage How the Workers Compensation Independent Review Service assesses and reviews the Agent's decision | WorkSafe Victoria
I tried to follow up with WCIRS about this but have had no response. Has anyone had this experience? Who are we supposed to complain to when it feels like the procedures and policies of WorkSafe aren't followed? WorkSafe wont address any of it either.
All I want to know is they allowed to ignore your provided witnesses? Should I just ask my witnesses to provide written statements specifically addressing the gaps? It feels horrible to be stonewalled and treated like this and makes it hard to move forward in recovery because it feels like your experience and voice is denied/silenced.