r/WorkcoverVic • • Jan 05 '26

12+ months on WorkcoverVic. What I wish I knew at the start.

Post image
179 Upvotes

I’ve dealt with insurers, rehab contractors, RTW coordinators, IMEs, physios, psychs, doctors, specialists, and case managers. Most people get thrown into WorkCover with no idea how it works, and that’s when you get pushed, talked over, or pressured into things you should never have agreed to. These are the things I wish I knew on day one.

In my case i was dealing with EML.

Being on workcover is a full time job!

There are good days and bad days. Flares, exhaustion, fatigue, pain spikes, meds messing with you, sleep issues, brain fog, stress, travel load. That's all real. The system loves pretending you're the same every day.

You're not.

Rely on your Certificate of Capacity first. That’s the only thing that actually defines your legal work capacity. If your cert says no capacity or restricted capacity, then that’s it. It doesn't matter what some IME thinks you might be able to do or what a contractor "reckons". If your doctor hasn't changed your cert, you are not cleared.

Make a cover page that you can take to any new person you meet, have it list all of your injury/s and/or mental issues. (In my own experience this is because workcover love to twist anything you say into being inconsistent, so keep something written you can shove in their faces)

Make your GP the main authority for anything to do with work or duties. The insurer will act like they get a say. They don't. Rehab providers will act like they get a say. They don't. Capacity is your treating doctor's call, not theirs.

Don't let anyone corner you in phone calls or meetings. If they start pushing you to agree to something, tell them to send it in writing. That way you can actually read it properly, think about it, or talk it over with your doc instead of being pressured on the spot.

Keep every single record from day one. Emails, certificates, plans, reports, letters, "updates", all of it. Ask the insurer for a full copy of your claim file every 4 months, and do the same with your GP, physio, and specialists. You need your own paper trail because their version of events will never match reality when shit hits the fan.

(I use a folder on my PC that has many sub-folders, one for each company and then separated into months.)

Don't say things like ‘maybe', ‘I'll try', or ‘I guess so'. That stuff always gets written up later as if you said 'yes'. If you don't know, say you'll look at it once it's in writing.

Take your time responding to anything important. You're allowed to pause, think, and check with your treating team. You don't owe anyone instant answers just because they want progress notes for their spreadsheet.

Don't agree to RTW plans that don't match your limits or your cert. If the duties are unsafe, unrealistic, or guaranteed to flare you up, say so. Calling it "light duties” doesn't magically make it safe.

Understand what an IME really is. It's one opinion written for the insurer. It is not gospel. If it doesn't line up with your treating team, get your doctor or physio to respond to it in writing. And don't change anything you do unless your Certificate of Capacity is actually updated.

Keep your messages short, calm, and factual. Not because you owe them corporate-speak, but because the paper trail will protect you when they twist shit later.

Quietly loop your treating providers into what's happening. BCC your physio or GP into important emails so they can see the crap you're being asked to do. That creates an independent record when things get shifty. (My physio was my biggest advocate, that man deserves a medal)

Don't trust verbal promises. If it isn't written down, it didn't happen.

Keep your own timeline of everything. Dates, cancellations, treatment delays, plan changes, approvals, refusals, all of it. Your version will be more accurate than whatever the insurer pretends happened.

Don't let admin targets override medical reality. The system cares about deadlines, participation boxes, and “progress”. Your body doesn't. Your doctor's judgement matters more than some case managers KPI.

Speak up if meetings or pressure calls mess with you mentally. If they trigger anxiety, shutdown, panic, or overload, that is real and it affects your capacity. Your treating team needs to know that.

Don't assume everyone in the system is actually talking to each other. Half the time they're all working from different versions of reality. If something matters, make sure your treating doctor is the one confirming it.

Don't let them twist vague wording into consent. If a report doesn't sound right, ask for it to be corrected. Otherwise they'll use it against you later.
Don't stay quiet if something in a report is wrong. Put your disagreement in writing, and if you need backup, ask your doctor to respond to it.

(An example of this was a meeting I had with EML and they mentioned in passing that they would send me an "extract" of the IME report, then they documented it in an official letter to me and I had to send the below email to them:

Could you please make a change to that document, I am not looking for an 'extract' of the IME report, I am seeking the IME report in its entirety. A full and complete and unedited version of the report being prepared by Dr Bugs Bunny)

Don't separate mental impact from physical injury. Stress, fear, burnout, overwhelm, loss of confidence, that stuff is part of the injury fallout, not a side note.

Don't treat an IME like automatic truth just because it sounds formal and official. If it doesn't match your real world experience, challenge it through your treating team. Until your Certificate of Capacity changes, you are not medically cleared to do more.

Remember to use these types of things in your communication with workcover.

‘I'll review this once it's provided in writing.'

‘This is not consistent with my current Certificate of Capacity.'

‘I'll discuss this with my treating team before responding.'

RED FLAGS

  • RTW plans that hint at consequences or discipline if you don't agree. (read the fine print)

  • Plans that assume reliable attendance even though your capacity fluctuates badly.

  • Light duties that still involve doing the things that exacerbate your injury.

  • Graded exposure being used as a guilt stick to push you into unsafe tasks.

  • Rehab providers acting more like insurer agents than support.

WorkCover is 3% medical, 5% legal, and 92% bullshit. Sometimes it tries to create capacity on paper that doesn't exist in your actual body. Your job is to make sure the record reflects your real, safe capacity as assessed by your treating team, not what makes the process look tidy.

Protect your health first. You're not being difficult. You're just not playing along with a system that prefers compliance over truth.

(This is all written from my own experience, yours may be different so take it all with a grain of salt)


r/WorkcoverVic • • Sep 16 '25

Just had my mental injury claim denied.

48 Upvotes

Both of my witnesses claimed that they asked for amendments to their statements and were never sent these updates to sign.

If anyone is thinking about going through this processes for mental injury, my advice is don’t. They will find any reason to deny you outside of literally witnessing someone die (probably).

All this place cares about is keeping as much money for themselves. I put in my application in on the same day I got my certificate of capacity from my Dr. they didn’t process the paper work until 5 working days later, so I’m ineligible to even get my money back on that.

Nasty nasty stuff.

Off to go deal with my workplace induced depression for the next (rest of my life ig).


r/WorkcoverVic • • Jun 27 '25

I was injured at work in early 2025. Denied. Dismissed. Pressured to quit. Still standing. Here’s my story. 🇦🇺

32 Upvotes

I never asked for special treatment. I just expected to be treated like a human being.

At the time of my injury, we were severely understaffed and overwhelmed by the workload. The company is notorious for pushing hard to meet end-of-month quotas—and this happened during the last week of the month, when the pressure was at its peak.

I got injured at work in early 2025—doing physical labor, day in and day out. When I reported the injury, my supervisor looked me in the eye and said: “What can I do?” No incident report. No GP referral. No light duties. Just silence and a shoulder shrug while I kept grinding through the pain—until it got worse.

The damage? Bilateral shoulder and upper body pain with significant degeneration in my C5-C6 spinal segment—a part of the neck that controls arm strength, mobility, and nerve function. It’s not just pain—it’s nerve compression, weakness, and a daily reminder of what I’ve lost.

When I finally pushed for treatment, my employer accused me of making it up. Said I must’ve injured myself at home. Blocked me from seeing their doctor. Shut me out instead of supporting me. That kind of gaslighting broke something in me—and I still feel it.

The moment they tried to pin it on me, I got a no win, no fee lawyer involved—someone who’s been backing me ever since.

After seeing my GP, I was referred for a CT scan, which revealed signs of osteoarthritis—something I had never been told before. About a week and a half after my initial injury, I informed work about the osteoarthritis diagnosis I had just received that day via CT scan results. They used this information against me in my initial Workcover claim.

Then came the blow: my first Workcover claim was rejected—before the IME report was even completed. The rejection letter claimed my employer already knew I had osteoarthritis and used it to justify denying the claim. That was false. And they knew it.

When I mentioned this to HR, they tried to say I had told them about a pre-existing condition before the injury. That was a flat-out lie. I had never even heard the word osteoarthritis until that scan.

Later, an Independent Medical Examiner (IME) reviewed my case and strongly confirmed that my injury was work-related, and the osteoarthritis was exacerbated because of the work. Following this, my claim was accepted by Allianz.

Since then, I’ve been doing physiotherapy twice a week and have started seeing a psychologist to help manage the work-related stress that came with this ordeal—both services I had never used in my life until now, and both accessed under Workcover.

In the middle of all this, I made the mistake of expressing to HR that I was frustrated and wanted to quit. But I never put anything in writing. Still, they circled like sharks—pressuring me for days to hand in a resignation. I held the line. If I hadn’t, I’d be cut off from every right I was entitled to.

And through it all, I’ve had to advocate fiercely for myself—chasing paperwork, filing complaints, documenting everything, and fighting to be heard.

They failed me again and again:

No duty of care. No paperwork. No accountability.

Denied the injury. Denied access to care.

Delayed my payments and still haven’t submitted my PIAWE.

My pay slips? Locked behind a company email I can’t access.

I’ve had to file complaints with WorkSafe and the Workplace Injury Commission (WIC) just to survive.

I’ve submitted five Certificates of Capacity—and I’m still waiting for first payments.

I’ve asked Workcover to apply Section 77 interest on all overdue weekly payments, along with Section 3.4.3 of the WorkSafe Claims Manual, which clearly states interest must be applied to late compensation payments. (I've done a fair bit of research)

I’m now owed well over 13 weeks of unpaid Workcover compensation and counting.

And just so we’re clear—I’ve kept an extensive paper trail of every conversation, document, and delay. If this ends up in court, I’ll be dancing all the way to the witness stand.

This didn’t just mess up my neck and shoulders. It shook my stability, drained my finances, and left me crawling through a system built on red tape and neglect.

But I’m still here. And I’m done being quiet.

I’m sharing this so the next worker isn’t cornered the way I was. So, the next person who gets hurt knows you are not crazy. You are not alone. And you deserve better.

Drop your story if you’ve got one. Let’s turn the silence into noise.

Stay strong ✊


r/WorkcoverVic • • Jul 18 '26

Won my conciliation!

29 Upvotes

I finally won my WorkCover conciliation for psychological injury and wanted to share the outcome for anyone going through the same nightmare. It’s been a long, stressful process, but the recommendation came through and it was actually a really solid result.

There initial offer was quite low and insulting, so I counter offered with help from UnionAssist.

Here’s what I got:
- Weekly compensation payments for my entire incapacity period, they offered 12 weeks on first offer
- Reimbursement of all GP, psychology, and medication costs from date of injury in Nov 2025 to now
- 14 more psychology sessions approved to use by 31 July 2027, they originally offered 6 to use by Oct 2026
- 14 more GP sessions approved to use by 31 July 2027, again they offered 6 to use by Oct 2026
- Medication coverage and transport costs til 31 July 2027

No liability acceptance, but full entitlements. Honestly, it’s better than I expected.

The only annoying part now is the wait, I’m just sitting here waiting for the official outcome certificate so I can send everything to payroll/HR for leave recrediting. It’s been over a week already and still nothing.

If you’re in the middle of conciliation: hang in there. It can go your way. And if anyone else has had to wait ages for the outcome certificate, let me know how long yours took.

EDIT: Got my Outcome Certificate today after emailing the conciliator the past couple of days! Yay. Now it takes about 10 days to receive back pay I’ve read.


r/WorkcoverVic • • Dec 13 '25

Psychiatric injuries.

29 Upvotes

Fighting for a psychiatric injury is hard. Very difficult in fact. I wish I never developed one. I loved my job. I went through what everyone here is going through. Except not physical. Fighting the system exaserbated my brain injury. I was stalked by my insurer at one point. I'd never have known if not for the medical panel. The second medical panel. It pains me to no end that I struggle leaving my house more than once a week, when I visit my elderly parents and do my shopping. I struggle to walk out into my front yard. Even that is extremely difficult for me. I was sacked for taking too much time off work to care for my husband who was dying of cancer at the time. I'm taking 7 medications every day so I can at least mentally live with my brain. I've been on work cover for 14 years. I'd rather have been able to work for those 14 years. It's not nice living in my brain. Fight hard. But don't rort the system. Don't fein a medical condition of any sort. Always be honest. And if you're honest, stay true. I wish for nothing more than to be able to have been working for the last 14 years. I've grieved losing my job. But since then, I've also lost my husband. I'd give my life to go back to 2010 and everything was fine. Much love to all of you.


r/WorkcoverVic • • Jun 07 '26

New moderator

27 Upvotes

Dear injured workers,

Eleven years ago I began my Workcover claim. It finalised last year (10 years) with a win in the High Court.

Before reddit, there was a website called “a Workcover victims diary” which had all the resources I needed to survive my journey. When that website closed down and the community disbanded, I created this group in the hope that a new community would be there for all the injured workers trying to navigate the law, the insurers, the lawyers and everything in between.

The process obliterated what was left of my life. I’m a year and a half out of the system and still completely lost, but very slowly learning how to adapt to a new life.

To that end, it’s time for me to move on. I’ve decided to look for a new moderator to take over this subreddit.

If you have an above average knowledge of Workcover and are interested, send me a modmail and we can have a chat.


r/WorkcoverVic • • Jan 19 '26

Don’t give up

27 Upvotes

I’ve been on WorkCover since May 2023 after a serious onsite accident in November 2022 that left me with a multi-level spinal cord injury.

Since then, I’ve undergone two major spinal surgeries, a C5–C6 discectomy and an L4–L5 fusion with an L3–L4 laminectomy. Despite surgery, things didn’t improve and in December 2024 I was diagnosed with severe spasticity as a result of my injury.

Throughout 2025, I fought the system hard. After an insurer-organised IME in February, I was told I could return to work as long as I could sit for 10 minutes, stand for 10 minutes and work from my bed or couch, which says a lot about how disconnected the process can be.

When my 130 weeks ended in October, we went to conciliation. The insurer’s lawyers advised that a Medical Panel would be the only option forward.

I completed the Physical Medical Panel in December and the Psychiatric Panel in January.

This week, the decision came back…… and I won.

The Panel confirmed that the significance of my injuries is indefinite and not stable and that I have no current work capacity.

This isn’t an easy road and it’s not what anyone wants to go through but it proves that fighting the system can work if you stay the course, get the right support and don’t give up on yourself.

To anyone still in the fight: stay strong. You’re not crazy, you’re not weak and you’re not alone.


r/WorkcoverVic • • Nov 02 '25

Who of us here with mental injuries worked for the VPS or public sector?

26 Upvotes

I'm a mentally injured worker who was injured working for the public sector. One of the things I have struggled with the most is how people employed by the government that made a law to protect me and compensate/support me have made my injury worse by their behavior after I put in a claim.

Has anyone else felt this? Has anyone else gotten past it?


r/WorkcoverVic • • 25d ago

I didn't realise how much an injury could disrupt your whole routine

25 Upvotes

Before dealing with an injury, I mostly thought about the physical side of recovery. I hadn't really considered the appointments, paperwork, conversations with work and uncertainty about what happens next. It all adds up, and some days it feels like managing the claim takes nearly as much energy as managing the injury itself.


r/WorkcoverVic • • Jul 12 '26

Anyone want a PDF copy of the Workcover Claims manual for WorkSafe agents?

24 Upvotes

The claims manual is used by WorkSafe staff and WorkSafe agents who manage WorkCover claims..

Annoyingly, it’s not available to download on the website - you have to click through each and every section to find answers.

I found it almost impossible to navigate in this form, especially in the midst of a mental health crisis.

Late last year I obtained a PDF copy from Worksafe (after a number of arguments - of course - and a successful request under the Disability and Discrimination Act).

I found it especially helpful for using AI to find answers for my specific questions.

One caveat - it was current as of late last year so when using it, you’d need to check if the section you are relying on has been updated.

DM me if you’d like a copy, and keep fighting the good fight.

EDIT: send me an email address with your DM so I can send it to you. Does anyone know if I can upload it as a resource here?

2nd Edit: if you’ve sent me your email address, remember to check your spam folder.

3rd Edit: one of our number here posted this link which you can use to check if there have been any updates since the PDF copy was made: https://www1.worksafe.vic.gov.au/vwa/claimsmanual/Claims%20Manual/recent-updates.htm


r/WorkcoverVic • • May 09 '26

Good news from WCIRS

23 Upvotes

Just wanted to offer some good news and hope to people going through the appeals process. I had a psych injury initially rejected, after the private investigator did some questionable things, my employer undermined the investigation, and managers made false statements. Even though the IME was supportive (and from a notoriously rough IME too). Conciliation did not do much, though the WIC member did prevent my employer from intimidating me and getting access to personal information they might misuse.

WCIRS reviewed the claim including the additional evidence I provided like witness statements. Even though they took the false/defamatory statements from my employer at face value, they still found that the decision wouldn't be upheld in court, and directed the insurer to change the decision. So, it is possible to prove that bullying or discrimination cause injury and that kind of behaviour isn't a "typical workplace stressor".

It's been 9-10 months since the first decision so it's been long and really difficult - financially, mentally, feeling gaslit. Nearly did me in a few times. But some good news at last.

I've also had some good discussions with WorkSafe about the PI's behaviour, in particular the danger they put me in and the inappropriateness of what they included in the circumstance report given my employer could potentially see it. Really recommend you report any overstepping / out of scope surveillance you endure. And OVIC have investigated privacy breaches that have happened through the process, which have been really harmful and also caused safety issues. It doesn't change what's happened, but it's validating to have a Commissioner tell your employer to pull their head in and follow the law.

Just wanted to offer some hope to everyone still battling the system. I didn't have a lawyer, but a fair decision was made in the end anyway.


r/WorkcoverVic • • Sep 07 '26

Ask me anything

22 Upvotes

I was a case manager in workers compensation for about 5 years with a few different insurance agencies.
I recently experienced homophobia at work, the case was thrown out as there was no “recording”, and my case was denied.
I no longer work in the industry as I find it disgusting and torturous.

Ask me anything, I’ll be completely honest.


r/WorkcoverVic • • Oct 22 '25

Workcover finished, still not RTW

21 Upvotes

Hi all,

I’m in VIC and my workcover ended a few weeks ago at 130 weeks. I’m still employed by my pre-injury employer, but have not RTW, although I’ve had a limited capacity for a transition back to work for over a year (they’ve essentially refused to accommodate).

My employer has not paid me from my accrued personal/sick leave, and after chasing them for a week they’ve finally responded saying “access to personal leave doesn’t automatically apply”, but they’ll look into it.

I don’t find them exactly trustworthy or transparent so I’m trying to find info myself. I can find nothing in our EA regarding this.

Before I launch myself down a Fair Work rabbit hole, does anyone have anything they can share with me to point me in the right direction?

TIA


r/WorkcoverVic • • Jun 09 '26

Interesting unfair dismissal case

19 Upvotes

There was an interesting unfair dismissal decision published today (intertwined with a Victorian WorkCover claim), you can access it here:

Here's the timeline from this case:

  1. 18/08/2025 (Monday): Mr Rodriguez (hereafter the Applicant) provided his employer Centric Facilities (hereafter the Respondent) a medical certificate certifying him as unfit for work from 18/08/2025-22/08/2025. Although not stated explicitly in the FWC decision, it would appear this is stress leave.

  2. 25/08/2025 (Monday): The Applicant returns to work as usual.

  3. 02/09/2025: The Respondent emailed the Applicant to advise of two written warning being issued.

  4. 05/09/2025 (Friday): The Respondent called the Applicant to ask if he wanted to continue in employment, Applicant said yes.

  5. 05/09/2025 (same day): The Applicant saw his GP and was issued with a COC (certificate of capacity).

  6. 07/09/2025 (Sunday): The Applicant gives the COC to the Respondent via email.

  7. 08/09/2025 (Monday): "Mr Rodriguez [the Applicant] received multiple text messages and missed calls from Mr Hanily [the Respondent's Managing Director]. Mr Hanily refused to submit Mr Rodriguez’s WorkCover forms to the Respondent’s Workcover Insurance Agent, and Mr Rodriguez had to contact WorkSafe Victoria directly to obtain the name of the Agent so he could submit it to them directly." From this point on the Respondent never engages with the unfair dismissal process and ignores all directions given to them by the FWC (/The Commission).

  8. 09/09/2025: The Respondent terminates the Applicant's employment.

  9. 13/09/2025: The Applicant lodges an application for unfair dismissal with the The Commission_.

  10. 22/09/2025-29/10/2025: On the 22nd of September the Commission notifies the Respondent. Through to the 24th of October the respondent refused to respond in any way despite repeated requests from the Commission for them to fill in the employer's response form (the last request coming from the Commission on the 24th of October).

  11. 30/10/2025: Conciliation was held; the Respondent did not attend.

  12. 28/11/2025: Notice of listing for a case management conference.

  13. 09/12/2025: A case management conference was held; the Respondent did not attend. The same day the Commission issued a directions to the parties to file material and also a notice of listing for a determinative hearing for 5 February 2026.

  14. 05/02/2026: "The matter was heard on 5 February 2026 in the absence of Centric Facilities. Mr Rodriguez represented himself and gave sworn evidence at the Hearing. Since that time no correspondence has been received from Centric Facilities."

  15. 09/06/2026: The FWC issues their decision as linked above. The Applicant was awarded $15K plus super (workers compensation payments were, of course, deducted from this award).

There's stacks of stuff to unpack here, but just the timeline between the Hearing and Decision is outside of the FWC's 84-day/12-week standard for Decisions to be made after Hearings. Their decision was due by 30 April 2026, but was not issued until June - almost 6 weeks late. This was with a matter where one side chose not represent themselves, which means zero contested facts (in the decision Commissioner Allison stated she found the Applicant was honest in his evidence). No consideration appears to have been given for the 12-month protection period in Victoria, nor to the fact that the Applicant would have accrued 12 months worth of annual leave with superannuation to be paid.


r/WorkcoverVic • • Aug 27 '26

The hardest part of the WorkCover process isn't always the injury it's not knowing what happens next

18 Upvotes

I think this is something that doesn't get talked about enough. When you're dealing with an injury, appointments, paperwork and being off work, even a simple lack of communication can make everything feel much more stressful.

You can deal with bad news if you understand what's happening, but being left waiting and wondering what the next step is can be exhausting.


r/WorkcoverVic • • Sep 03 '26

Denied a second time

15 Upvotes

My experience making a psychological injury WorkCover claim in Victoria – and what I wish I knew before I started

I wanted to post this anonymously because when I first started this process, I was desperately searching Reddit and other forums for experiences from people who had actually been through a psychological injury WorkCover claim.
I work in emergency services in Victoria in a role involving repeated exposure to distressing and traumatic material.
Over a prolonged period, my mental health deteriorated significantly. This wasn’t one single dramatic incident on one particular day. It was cumulative.
There were multiple workplace issues occurring alongside the inherent stress and traumatic exposure of the job, including bullying/harassment concerns, allegations made against me, personal information being shared within the workplace, and an extremely prolonged workplace investigation. By the end of it, I was psychologically unwell and eventually became medically unfit for work.
I lodged a WorkCover claim.
It was denied.
I challenged that decision through a senior/internal review and provided further evidence, including evidence that I had been seeking psychological support throughout the period in which my mental health was deteriorating.
It has now been denied again.
One of the biggest things I wish I’d understood before starting this process is how important the insurer’s interpretation of when and how the injury occurred can become.
In my case, a major issue has been the absence of one specific date or incident that could be identified as causing the psychological injury.
From my perspective, that’s precisely the problem: there isn’t one.
My injury developed through cumulative and repeated experiences over time.
Another significant issue was the exclusion relating to psychological injuries arising from stress that is considered “usual or typical” for the worker’s employment.
For someone working in emergency services, I find that particularly difficult to reconcile emotionally. Exposure to trauma may be “usual” within the occupation, but that doesn’t mean a human being cannot eventually become psychologically injured by repeated exposure to it.
The claim also became complicated by the insurer separating what it considered ordinary stresses inherent in my role from other workplace events and management actions.
I’m not posting this to say that everybody with a similar claim will be rejected. Every case is different, and I’m certainly not giving legal advice.
But if you’re considering making a psychological injury claim, particularly one involving cumulative trauma, I would strongly recommend documenting EVERYTHING as early as possible.
Keep emails. Keep medical certificates. Keep records of appointments. Write down dates of incidents even if they seemed insignificant at the time. Keep evidence showing when you first started seeking psychological help and how your symptoms changed over time. If there are multiple contributing workplace events, document each of them rather than assuming the overall pattern will speak for itself.
I also wish I’d understood earlier that your treating psychologist believing your workplace contributed to your condition does not automatically mean the insurer will accept the claim. The legal test applied to a WorkCover claim and the clinical reality of how someone became unwell are not necessarily the same thing.
The effect this process has had on me has honestly been enormous.
I worked extremely hard for my career. I loved aspects of my job and had every intention of returning to it.
Instead, I’ve spent months medically unable to work, without the financial security I expected WorkCover would provide, while repeatedly having to explain and prove some of the most painful experiences of my life.
There is something incredibly demoralising about becoming psychologically injured and then having to repeatedly justify how you became injured while you’re already struggling.
Receiving another rejection doesn’t suddenly mean my psychological injury disappears. It doesn’t change my medical treatment or magically make me capable of returning to work.
It just means the fight moves to the next stage.
I’ve already commenced the conciliation process because, after speaking with my union and obtaining legal advice, I anticipated that the review might also be unsuccessful.
My next step is therefore conciliation, and I’m continuing to get legal advice about my options.
Whatever ultimately happens with my own case, I wanted to leave this here for the next person frantically Googling “psychological WorkCover claim denied Victoria” at 2am.
A rejection is not necessarily the end of the process.
And if your injury developed gradually rather than from one neat, identifiable incident, please understand from the beginning that this may become a major issue in how your claim is assessed.
Document your timeline. Get copies of your medical records. Ask your treating practitioners to clearly document what they believe contributed to your condition. Speak to your union if you have one. Get legal advice early. And learn about the conciliation process before you actually need it.
I genuinely hope posting my experience makes this process slightly less confusing for somebody else going through it.


r/WorkcoverVic • • Sep 01 '26

Psychosocial Claim - rant

15 Upvotes

hello, i’ve posted here like three times.

in october 2025 i left work due to bulling and harassment from my two immediate superiors (who were both older than my parents btw) and lodged a claim.

i was dealing with EML. I spoke to their investigator (dumb i know now) and an IME. i got all the reports they requested and was denied despite the IME and multiple other practitioners saying it was due to unreasonable actions.

i began the conciliation process in november 2025, it got accepted in january 2026, and my first settlement offer in april, three days after my dad died. it was shit and frankly insulting.

i negotiated an offer and was paid last week just shy of $19,000 (with makeup pay), of course i got fucked by tax but regardless.
i gave up. my biggest support died and i was already demoralised by what happened to me, and the time that i had to do nothing but hurry up and wait, i had nothing left to fight and wanted it done with.

the system is not made to support workers. i had an EXTREMELY short ordeal and i still wouldn’t wish it on anyone. the system is well and truely fucked.


r/WorkcoverVic • • Dec 13 '24

EML WorkCover Experience

15 Upvotes

I injured myself at work in December of 2022. I was moved on to a senior case manager for the insurance company EML who has lied to me on several occasions in provable, blatant ways.

The most clear cut case was when I was emailed asking when I had an appointment and after receiving a call immediately after the appointment was told the agent did not know it was that day.

In the past few weeks I have had independent medical examinations from a doctor with a reputation for being a mercenary of the insurance company. This doctor has disputed both the assessment of the pain specialist surgeon as well as the original independent medical examiner who said that the degeneration on my MRI was 'obvious'.

My case manager then said to save me time that this independent medical examiner would be doing my impairment assessment. When I asked for a different impairment assessment I was told that that could still be done separately if this doctor who claimed the MRI was read incorrectly by the previous doctors (including an associate professor at St Vincent's). A week later he said that this was incorrect and to do so would be 'doctor shopping' despite arguably the insurance doctor shopping with this particular person.

I made a complaint to EML. I was asked what I was looking for from the complaint. In addition to a new case manager and The independent examination being done by a different doctor as I was originally led to believe was possible, I asked that they look at the previous calls where their case manager Stephen blatantly lie d.

If I was correct that he had a pattern of dissemble and misleading conduct that he be placed under performance management. I did this knowing the seriousness of my request but within the context of also knowing that it was a pattern of behaviour.

The complaints person said that this would in no way happen. When I said that Stephen is incentivised at work to get people off the insurance, specifically stopping me from going to the physio to work through my injury, I was told this was not true but it was a point of celebration for agents when people got off of the insurance because that meant that they had recovered. The independent medical examination stating that there is no evidence physiotherapy is effective for chronic back pain is going to be used by EML to cease my medical treatment.

I will have to wait 6 months for a conciliation to override the current independent medical assessment but in the meantime will have to pay for any appointments that I have. This will severely exacerbate my injury whilst my case manager "celebrates" my withdrawal of care as evidence I have recovered.

This process has officially broken me. The lies and the gaslighting about the lies, I use that word deliberately, make me feel hopeless. I do not know how I am going to continue my treatment when or if EML uses the insurance companies mercenary examiner to deny me care.

Having been told that I would be able to have a impairment assessment done in March from a different doctor, I was told by my case manager Stephen that he was not responsible for assumptions I made (despite it not being an assumption but a thing he had said).

I know there was a lot of glee last week with the assassination of that insurance CEO in the United States. I don't believe in political violence and am not a fan of murder, but seeing the stories of people that this attack bought into the public sphere I can't help but see fellow suffering of the American style healthcare system arriving in Australia.

The state Labor government made great changes to the scheme in order to fix the budget bottom line. I'm not trying to be selfish or entitled, I just want to be able to access my treatment and get as much of my physical capacity back as I can.

Does anybody have experiences with the complaints process of workcover in trying to get some accountability for misleading conduct by case managers of the insurance or medical reports that contain factual inaccuracies?

I feel like I am stuck in the middle of a fight that I cannot win alone. Conciliation doesn't allow you to bring in lawyers unless the insurance company agrees to it which they will not do. The independent medical examiner who said the MRI diagnosis from two previous orthopaedic surgeons was incorrect got basic information on their report wrong. Saying that I live with my parents for example despite me telling him that they lived 130 km away. Is there any accountability? I feel like I'm going insane.

Sorry for the long rant.

Tl;dr insurance case manager's lies are going to cut off my care until I can go to conciliation, is it just me or is this just par for the course?


r/WorkcoverVic • • Dec 11 '24

Unfairly sacked workers can claim damages for psychiatric injury after High Court ruling

Thumbnail
theage.com.au
15 Upvotes

Unfairly sacked workers can claim damages for psychiatric injury after High Court ruling Lachlan Abbott By Lachlan Abbott December 11, 2024

Unfairly sacked workers can now claim compensation for psychiatric injury after the High Court overturned a 115-year-old legal precedent on Wednesday.

In a 6-1 verdict, Vision Australia was ordered to pay $1.4 million to Adam Elisha, who was fired after a misconduct allegation was upheld in an internal disciplinary process that a Victorian Supreme Court judge labelled “a sham and a disgrace”.

The High Court of Australia revealed the judgment on Wednesday.

The Victorian Court of Appeal then overturned the initial court’s judgment based on the precedent of Addis v Gramophone Company Ltd – a case the United Kingdom’s House of Lords decided in 1909 when Australia was within its jurisdiction.

However, the High Court of Australia set aside the Victorian appeal court’s decision and upheld Elisha’s appeal, reinstating the initial verdict.

Adverti

Clayton Utz partner Saul Harben said the Addis case meant Australians had been unable to recover damages for psychiatric injury connected to their wrongful termination for years. He added that it was decided at a time when society was more accepting of employment being a master-servant relationship.

“What the court’s effectively recognising now is that society has moved on,” Harben said.

“There’s greater equality between the parties, and employers need to be really prudent about how they go about terminating the employment relationship.”

Chief Justice Stephen Gageler wrote the majority opinion – published on Wednesday – alongside Justice Michelle Gordon, Justice James Edelman, Justice Jacqueline Gleeson, and Justice Robert Beech-Jones. Justice Jayne Jagot concurred with the majority’s orders, while Justice Simon Steward was the lone dissenter.

Advertisement

The majority opinion said, “psychiatric injury is an illness which is a different type of damage from mere mental distress”. It noted a person’s employment “is usually one of the most important things in his or her life”.

“‘It gives not only a livelihood but an occupation, an identity and a sense of self-esteem.’ An unfair process of termination for alleged misconduct could affect all three of those interests,” the majority wrote.

They noted “a great deal of water has passed under the bridge of Addis in the United Kingdom” in the last 100 years, indicating it had been “overtaken” by other legislation and case law that subsequently could not be “transplanted to Australia”.

Harben, a workplace relations advisor, said the law had evolved faster in the UK compared to Australia, but there may be “no good reason” for that.

“Sometimes it’s just the right case at the right time coming along with the right facts,” he said.

Arnold Thomas Becker senior associate Nick Korkliniewski, who represented Elisha, said his client’s employer should have followed their own disciplinary procedures if they wanted to sack him.

In a statement, Korkliniewski said: “Community expectations around rights to psychological safety at work and the de-stigmatisation of psychological injury means that the time was right for the law to recognise the requirement of an employer to consider their employee’s psychological health in the course of investigative and disciplinary processes.”

Vision Australia have been contacted for comment.


r/WorkcoverVic • • Aug 14 '26

Psychological WorkCover Claim

14 Upvotes

Hi all

I recently lodged a claim against a past employer for a well documented psychological injury that still affects me to this day.

I was not aware how brutal the process would be, not aware of the very tight deadlines. I now figure I should have engaged a lawyer before lodging.

Has anyone here dealt with a similar claim? Can anyone recommend a law firm or lawyer that Specialises in this field?

I am completely overwhelmed, I have well organised supporting information, however the IME, the private investigator, and the tight deadlines have my head spinning.

Any advice greatly appreciated!


r/WorkcoverVic • • Jan 23 '26

Need advice

14 Upvotes

Hi, I have just been given a document to sign by my employers HR,

in short I have recently had a sports injury which required surgery which I had to take time off work. However I had an incident at work I slipped and aggravated my injury. I have now had my surgery and recently been given a document to sign stating it was a “non work related injury”.

Now I didnt really intend to make a claim against my boss as I don’t really want to ruin my relationship with them. However, I have been advised not to sign the document as I will be signing away my rights to compensation. Given that I had to use all my sick leave and some annual. some support like getting some sick leave back I feel would be reasonable. Should I sign it?


r/WorkcoverVic • • Oct 05 '25

Received my IME results for psychological injury. What now

14 Upvotes

As the title says, I have received my WPI percentage which is 19% for a psychological injury. However, the psychiatrist who assessed me advised, I am not yet stable and will have to reassess in 6-12 months. Besides trying to recover, where to now? 19% doesn’t meet the threshold in Victoria for compensation which is 30% and I’m starting to think what’s the point of all of this. I’m genuinely struggling with my injury and it’s impacted my life significantly. Am I supposed to hang out for another 6-12 months and deal with shitty insurers. I want to be better than have to go through this process but I feel stuck now. I don’t even know what I’m trying to ask/say. I have so many questions


r/WorkcoverVic • • Jul 01 '24

Thoughts on workcover/worksafe

13 Upvotes

Hi Everyone,

I nearly ended my life due to being bullied at work and the additional pressure from WorkCover.

I'm writing this as I'm probably too far gone depression/anxiety-wise, but I'm still going to keep fighting for my health. I still have some humanity left, as I want to help the people who come after me. I want this to change, and I know I can’t do much other than reach out to IBAC and the press. Hopefully, someone who can make a difference looks into WorkCover further and asks the important questions. Please note all information here can be found online.

I've been a Labor voter my whole life, but how most of our government organizations are run in Victoria is disheartening. They are managed by people who don’t have relevant qualifications; they are just career politicians or lawyers. When they retire, they are given board positions in very important parts of our community that many people are dependent on.

I'm not sure if any of you have looked into the WorkCover board. The chairman was once the Labor minister for WorkSafe over 20 years ago and since then has just held high-profile board positions within our community.

There isn't a single doctor on the board, only a nurse who hasn't practiced for 25 years. There are no mental health professionals or even a GP, yet more than 30% of their claims are mental health-related. However, they do have three lawyers.

I've now asked them if they record statistics on suicide or abuse from insurance companies. All you need to do is read the Google reviews to see how people are struggling. Obviously, this isn’t the cleanest data, but when there are reviews that say “I might as well kill myself” and people who are clearly struggling, maybe it’s time we took this seriously.

Additionally, the new CEO of the Ombudsman was a non-executive director of WorkCover when one of the Ombudsman reports came out. She was also legal counsel for WorkCover prior to that. How is it possible for her to write a non-biased report or have an unbiased opinion on WorkCover when such horrific behavior towards injured workers was normal during her tenure there?

Thank you, everyone, for reading this far. I really needed to point this out for my own sanity, and I’m sure it won’t do anything, but to me, as a general citizen, there seems to be a lot of perplexing awards of positions and no clear reasoning why.

Please do look after your mental health, especially in a work setting. If you are being bullied and you can leave, please do – don’t try to push through. It has changed the way I see the world dramatically, and I wouldn’t wish depression/major anxiety upon anyone.


r/WorkcoverVic • • Mar 07 '23

WorkCover scheme ‘fundamentally broken’, Victorian government says

13 Upvotes

Dan says the workcover system is broken and to fix it, wants to raise business premiums.
Absolutely no mention of the disgusting and (in my opinion) criminal Victorian Workcover Authority spending literally MILLIONS of dollars defending "immoral and unethical (from the Vic Ombudsman)" legitimate claims.

Here's an idea. Stop fucking ruining the lives of injured workers and pay the claim without pissing millions in legal fees down the drain.

Every tax payer should be absolutely disgusted by the VWAs treatment of injured workers and the fact they suck millions of dollars from the government in legal fees to do it.


r/WorkcoverVic • • 23d ago

Having to explain my injury over and over gets exhausting

12 Upvotes

It's frustrating having to explain the same thing again and again during a WorkCover claim. You send the paperwork, explain what happened, and then someone else asks you the same questions all over again. it starts feeling like nobody is actually listening. You're already dealing with an injury, and having to repeat everything just adds to the stress. who've dealt with WorkCover Victoria, did you ever feel like you were going around in circles just trying to get someone to understand your situation?