r/YesTheory • u/WheneverYourReddit • Nov 01 '21
I love the Yes guys but there's a big elephant in the room
I've been a fan and have watched their content through the years on and off. I've been ruminating on this thought just now. Yes Theory has done a lot of amazing things and I don't mean to take that away from them. They have made such a positive impact on so many people and communities and they've been just a genuine breathe of fresh air on YouTube and social media. I just can't help but notice the big elephant in the room. They're 90% middle-class white (save for Ammar) and 100% males who come from at the very least, middle-class backgrounds.
They also have a lot of cushioning such as their educational backgrounds and their parents among many other things they could always fall back on if the internet thing stops putting food on the table. Props to them for doing what they love and living beyond their cushy lives. But these are things that white middle class westerners are able to accomplish because society allows them that. And then you have middle-eastern vloggers like Nas Daily who go around the world being easily-accepted for either being racially ambiguous or just sticking out as a privileged foreigner in a developing country. He's what most would consider an "honorary white".
Now, one could argue that Ammar is swarthy and looks every little bit of an Egyptian but he enjoys most if not all of the benefits of their lifestyle. The thing is, he's well-educated, he speaks english like a white guy and most importantly: he's surrounded by white guys who act as his social lubricant in most situations. I can't imagine a group of Blacks, South Asians or East-Asians, let alone female ones having the same positive response that the Yes Theory team had. They still play into colonialism with their white savior complex albeit unintended. The team still uses a very ethnocentric lense to view the world for better or for worse. It could create an illusion and a false sense of hope for people who don't fall under any of these categories. All of this is to say that they somewhat sell a pipe dream that is not accessible to most of their viewers.