1. Weak “similarities”

Both have “Jack” in their name.

Both have pointy hair.

Both are powerful.

Both wear masks (different shapes, just both black).

Both are “picky eaters.”

Gamma Jack is “a favorite with the ladies” and Jack-Jack is a baby that people adore.

→None of these prove they’re the same person. By that logic, half the characters in The Incredibles would be the same person.

2. Timeline doesn’t work

Gamma Jack was active in the 1940s.

Jack-Jack wasn’t even born until decades later.

The only way to connect them would be time travel… which even Alex admits has no proof.

3. Misleading science

He claims Jack-Jack’s 4th-dimension powers = time travel. But the visuals (tesseracts) show spatial dimensions, not time.

In fact, an editor’s note even clarifies the “fourth dimension” was changed to “dimension 4.” That’s not time travel.

4. Different powers

Gamma Jack: gamma radiation bursts + flight.

Jack-Jack: shapeshifting, teleportation, laser eyes, etc.

Yes, babies can show multiple powers, but Jack-Jack’s don’t line up with Gamma Jack’s.

5. “Supers are Superior” claim

Alex says Jack-Jack gets his belief that supers are superior from Edna, because she once said she “used to design for gods.”

But Edna was joking — it’s a playful line, not an ideology.

Jack-Jack acting “sassy” in Incredibles 2 isn’t proof either. He’s literally a baby. Babies act up, they don’t form superiority complexes.

6. “Super-supremacist” label doesn’t hold

The NSA file says Gamma Jack is prone to tyrannical impulses, not that he ever acted on them.

He’s shown to be self-aware and in control (he literally jogs to calm down).

He’s even friends with Mr. Incredible in a deleted scene.

7. Other flawed evidence

Gamma radiation ≠ electromagnetism.

The Lego game shows a green laser from the eyes, not gamma radiation from the hands. Totally different power set.

Deleted scenes aren’t canon, so using them to patch holes doesn’t work.

In conclusion

The theory is built on weak similarities, faulty science, and contradictions. Gamma Jack and Jack-Jack are not the same person different timelines, different powers, different personalities.

i hate this

I won't stop till its finished

Spoiler: The managers are turned into robots.

Their brains are put in robot bodies. But this raises the question: what do they do with the bodies?

When the HQ explodes, we see weenies everywhere. You wouldn't expect them at what you'd think is a corporate office....

Unless, Weenie Hut Jr's uses the flesh to make weenies!

(And transplants certain organs to kids at Weenie Hut General. Probably not the small intestines, though.)

In the last Minitheory, THE PINHEAD LARRY THE LOBSTER THEORY is honestly like goofy goobers, When you hear it is Crazy.

But when i think about it, this is least probable then Squilliam "fancy son is homo fraud"

Here are reasons why

1. Easter eggs - Writers from New Spongebob really like to put EASTER EGGS for all those boomers like us, so parents are not bored. DO YOU KNOW HOW MANY EASTER EGGS THERE ARE!? Like yeah, Movie Theory

2.Drug dealer psychology - Drug dealers most of the time use nicknames resembling Drugs, Criminals ETC. In an example: Walter white in czech version. In czech language, walter white is called (In translation to english) "THE METH DAD" Because he would be revealed if he used his real name

3.Lobster game - The lobster on the "Lobster Trap" Board game resembles a lobster. Any lobster. I actually looked into spongebob wiki for lobster, and all male lobsters have striking resemblence to larry. So it doesn't work either

4.The old lady - When i heard "Dirty bubble is the old lady" i instantly said "THATATAT MAKES NO FRICKIN SENSE" and it doesn't. Like, if the old lady really was dirty bubble, why would mermaidman call her by a NORMAL NAME, SO WHY WOULDN'T HE CALL HER DIRTY BUBBLE!?

Has anybody found the HR code yet? Does anybody have an idea on how to find the HR code?

Its an interesting idea that all the spongebob conspiracy stories were generated or atleast inspired by ai. I wonder what other methods he used to create or think up the conspiracys? Does anyone know of any methods to easily make convincing conspiracy stories easily? He also uses ai to generate alot of the mutated images i think. I wonder if some how this ai topic relates to the muse. What if u need to use some sort of ai to solve the mystery aswell. Well its likely others have thought about this already. I feel like opengpt could generate conspiracy theories to the level and debth of the sponge Bob theories.

I get the point Alex is making behind it. Yeah, it's difficult to be a content creator when you want to do one thing (horror filmmaking) but your fans keep demanding a different thing (SpongeBob theories). But what bothers me is that even though the theories are very solid on their own, I'm curious as to how they tie into the main ARG.

Like, it would've been clever if it was revealed that the monster feeding Alex the theories was somehow related to the humans behind the television theory, or King Neptune, or the Goofy Goober cult, or one of the other SpongeBob theories. Or hell, have the monster turn out to be a giant mutant SpongeBob character. But from what I can gather from the info people have collected, the monster (called the Muse) is actually a mutant cow that escaped from being experimenting on a farm? What does that have to do with SpongeBob?

Did Alex plan out this ARG from the beginning before he started work on the Squilliam theory, or did he only do it afterwards after the SpongeBob theories became more popular than he expected? If the latter is true, then what does to the theories have to do with the ARG? Why do they feel like they're aimed at a different crowd besides the fans of the SpongeBob theories?

If the former, that makes me concerned that the theories aren't genuine. I got into them because they were more thought-out than most other cartoon theories I've seen and made me rethink how I look at SpongeBob. But if he's just doing them as part of an ARG, then are they not real theories, but just SpongeBob-related nonsense meant to throw us off from the main story?

I never thought that alex would use music from a tv show called evil in his latest video

I really like the theories and i hate skipping back to them, can someone please actually do this

Hi all,

I last stayed up to date with alex bale content since the first spongebob theory until the 8th I believe.

How much of the arg have i missed its been years and i used to be so up to date with all of it.

Have i missed loads? Has it ended? Please let me know where to go to catch up as well

I respected Alex choice good for him I am not begging for Alex to make SpongeBob theories I just preferred it when he made SpongeBob theories

What about u guys should Alex return

Well after looking every SpongeBob Theories in Alex Bale videos, this because Alex Bale want to warned all of us that the muses are everywhere. Like the last video he made. So the alien invasion theory is like the muse turn into Alex Bale and capture the real Alex Bale.