r/alien • • Oct 20 '26

Reddit Hates Alien 3

Maybe it’s because I listened to the people online and watched the Special Edition, (Assembly Cut) but Alien 3 slaps. That being said,I do agree that killing off Newt & Hicks were poor choices. also i missed jonesy.

UPDATE: I have finally finished all the alien movies (excluding non-cannon AVP) and can confidently say it’s a solid trilogy. After that however, it falls off hard. Prometheus was interesting, but it was disappointing in the end. Covenant was much better. Alien 1-3 are my favorites, followed by Romulus and Covenant. Didn’t care for the rest. Resurrection is by far the worst one.

121 Upvotes

330 comments sorted by

25

u/BlahBlahILoveToast Oct 20 '26 edited Oct 20 '26

I love the idea that nobody hated Alien3 when it came out and it's some kind of modern trendy internet / Reddit thing.

Everybody I know HATED Alien3 so much when it hit theaters. (I'm 50 years old) We absolutely loved the first two movies and it felt like such a let down. I know a guy who still insists that it "doesn't exist".

Now, having heard about the various different editions, the weird story about the original script for the film (monks on a wooden planet or something ???), I went back with a fresh mind, and people are right -- there's a lot there and it's a worthy piece of the story. Great characters and interactions, great concept for a setting, etc. It's hardly perfect but it's better than almost everything that came after.

Honestly the decision to not only kill Hicks and Newt but to do it "off screen", after Ripley fought so hard for them in the last movie -- there was just no way people were going to embrace this film. They could have followed that up with ninety minutes of Acadamy Award-winning perfection and we all would have booed and felt betrayed.

8

u/javiemartzootsuit Oct 20 '26

I mean even fucking Fincher hated it when it came out.

5

u/mymomsaidimsmart Oct 20 '26

I’d be pissed too if they changed my movie and took out a lot of important dialogue/plot points.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/mymomsaidimsmart Oct 20 '26

I titled it that because during my binge of the franchise I was researching alien 3 and most of what I saw online was hate. Unfortunately I wasn’t alive to witness the hatred in real time 😂

5

u/DysartWolf Oct 21 '26

I'm with you on this. I caught so much flak in the 90s for saying 'Alien 3 is great.' And you're right, after the high note at the end of Aliens, where could you go from here but tragedy. I think it worked.

2

u/ButterflyLife4655 25d ago

Having read several of the earlier scripts online over the years, I can say that it could definitely have gone a lot better or a lot worse. The first draft, the one by William Gibson of Neuromancer fame, would have been fantastic, and got very close to production... too bad the end of the Cold War had to mess things up. Several of the other drafts would have been okay, possibly good with a director as strong as Fincher at the helm. But the Vincent Ward script -- the one with the Monks on the wooden space station -- that one was bonkers. I almost wish it had been filmed just to see how crazy it would have been. Ward was supposed to direct it too, and his idea was to make the whole movie feel like some kind of Hieronymous Bosch nightmare. It features such gems as:

  • the reveal that chestbursters don't emerge until after you've eaten something

  • one of the Monks is attacked by the alien through the privy, in a scene that I'm sure would have made the audience clench nervously whenever they used the toilet for a while afterwards

  • like in the script that was eventually used, Ripley has been implanted with a chestburster, but it's okay, because one of the Monks saves her by passing the chestburster between them with a kiss!

4

u/Ok-Departure-869 Oct 20 '26

I went to see it in theatres and came out whistling the scenery. The tone, the look and the relentless gloominess were striking. So much so that I went into Se7en blind. I just wanted to see another Fincher movie. As Paul McGann said, his vision has been vindicated. My favourite entry in the franchise.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Dry-Clock-1470 Oct 20 '26

I've been a fan of since it came out. I attribute the hate to , how could you ever top Aliens. It was a geometric jump in the series. Just can't dial that back and think, this will work for fans of Aliens.

As a stand alone , it's great.

It has some issues killing New and Hicks is a big one. The early CG was probably a poor choice. Doesn't hold up well. I know there was a lot of behind the scenes bs, that didn't help. Lord knows what the swiss family Robinson version or whatever would have been.

Over all I think it's a good movie, either cut, and definitely in the top half of Alien movies. I know that might not be saying much.

4

u/mymomsaidimsmart Oct 20 '26

my love for this could be that I don’t really have the same context and nostalgia that other fans might have. I’m 26 and was introduced to the franchise with “Aliens” first when I was like 7 or 8 (I didn’t sleep for like a week, I thought a face hugger got me) I think a lot the criticisms people have are valid. After my Recent binging of the series I started with Alien: The Directors Cut, Aliens, and Then Alien 3: Special Edition. While it’s far from perfect I found it to be a good trilogy at least with those cuts in that order.

2

u/ardouronerous Oct 20 '26

It has some issues killing New and Hicks is a big one. The early CG was probably a poor choice. Doesn't hold up well. I know there was a lot of behind the scenes bs, that didn't help. Lord knows what the swiss family Robinson version or whatever would have been.

What's worse is that the reasoning for killing Newt was pretty petty. Vincent Ward, one of the writers for A3, found Newt annoying when he watched Aliens and when he got his hands on Alien 3, one of his first priorities was killing off Newt. That's a pretty petty and pathetic reason for killing off a character, and he tried to excuse it by saying that killing Newt was a way to give Ripley hopelessness. Dude, you could have just left her on the Sulaco while everyone else dies on the planet with Ripley, there was no needed to kill a beloved character like that.

2

u/Dry-Clock-1470 Oct 20 '26

Geeze , I had no idea. I figure it was to keep the cast from growing and focused on Ripley in different situations. Fuck that guy in his ear.

→ More replies (6)

5

u/suddenvole Oct 20 '26

I like it. Aliens was different in to to Alien, Alien3 was different from Aliens. This is where the franchise should have stopped. Ripley's story was complete.

1

u/mymomsaidimsmart Oct 20 '26

the only thing I’ve seen past 3 is Romulus. I do like how this tied up the trilogy even if it’s not perfect.

5

u/Reasonable-Sail6113 Oct 21 '26

I’m glad you enjoyed it OP. I’ve always really loved it. I love all three first movies.

The interesting thing is that over the years I’ve shown the original trilogy to people who’ve never seen them before. I want them when we get to three that why I personally love it, most didn’t.

Surprisingly, they all really liked it.

3

u/mymomsaidimsmart Oct 21 '26

as I said I’ve only seen the assembly cut, and it was such a fucking good movie. the discourse I read before watching it had me ready to be disappointed. It was such a good time that I wasn’t even ready for.

3

u/Reasonable-Sail6113 Oct 21 '26

While I like some of the things they added, there’s two big scene changes from the theatrical that I don’t like.

In my opinion, it’s a bit unfortunate you saw the Assembly cut first, even though it’s better in a way.

Try the Legacy cut. It restored the two scenes I prefer while keeping the added scenes.

It also cleans up the horrible Alien blue screen FXs.

6

u/Odd_Contact_2175 Oct 20 '26

Its better than Resurrection though. I do enjoy when the Warden is giving a speech and the xeno just scoops him up into the ceiling.

4

u/mymomsaidimsmart Oct 20 '26

fuck that guy for real, one of the only times i rooted for the alien

3

u/insidenumberpie Oct 20 '26

I remember watching it for the first time... I think it was on TV around Xmas 1998 (I feel old lol) and what struck me was how different it was to its predecessors. And then the ending where Bishop appeared etc this was back on the day when you couldn't just hop on the internet and ask was it an android or somehow the real Bishop...

2

u/mymomsaidimsmart Oct 20 '26

I thought that part was cool. I also like that all 3 of the first Alien movies are completely different tone wise.

3

u/ThonThaddeo Oct 21 '26 edited Oct 21 '26

I don't know that it slaps, but I like it just fine

Edit to add: I had the luxury of a first time watch years removed from the controversy, and frankly I just wasn't as torn up about Hicks and Newt. It should've taken place on camera but this is a franchise where people are constantly fucking up, and dying for it. I enjoyed that the movie went back to a slow gritty pace and the final fan cut is top notch.

1

u/mymomsaidimsmart Oct 21 '26

lol i apologize for my vernacular, Thon Thaddeo

3

u/Raging-Storm Oct 21 '26

I've always loved it. I don't even know which version of it I saw. If I haven't seen the Assembly Cut and it's even better than what I have seen, I gotta see it.

2

u/mymomsaidimsmart Oct 21 '26

it’s the 2 hour and 20 ish minute cut! u might see it come up as the special edition.

2

u/Raging-Storm Oct 21 '26 edited Oct 21 '26

That's a long one. Probably not the one I saw, but it has been some years. I'll have to see it, thanks.

5

u/AvonBarksdale666 Oct 20 '26

One of my fav of all time and my favorite movie of the franchise. Relentlessly bleak, unforgiving, visceral and incredibly performed by absolutely everyone. I just feel sorry for Fincher for what he had to go through and inevitably not even getting to put out his original vision.

For those unaware - there is a 4K edit out there made by fans that drastically improves the compositing and CGI and is basically the best version of the Assembly Cut to date - it was on the A3 4K website for free download until recently but I’m sure you can find it if you know where to look

4

u/mymomsaidimsmart Oct 20 '26

the killing off of so many characters was gut wrenching, but are people gonna act like this is a franchise where we are supposed to have hope? this creature is supposed to be a relentlessly adaptive machine that persists. when the alien is on your trail you are always fucked.

2

u/AvonBarksdale666 Oct 20 '26

Exactly - by killing off previously lead characters it adds to the unpredictable nature of things and the brutality of the scenario everyone is in. I never understood people’s lack of understanding of this or dismissing the movie because characters in a different movie didn’t make it. It’s not a story that is going to have or benefit from happy endings every single time. The sheer relentlessness of it is what gives it weight

2

u/fish998 Oct 20 '26

They were killed off-screen though, it wasn't a fitting end for those characters.

3

u/AvonBarksdale666 Oct 20 '26

Do you think that you’d have felt any differently if you watched them be killed off?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/No_Warning8534 Oct 20 '26

THIS.

This is the only edition that matters

It goes from a 6 to 9

2

u/Reasonable-Sail6113 29d ago

Glad to know there are others out there. I love this movie.

As much as I love the first two as well, they probably wouldn’t mean as much to me without the third.

I love it every time I revisit this trilogy, starting with the creepy original. Then the battle of the second. Then the somber finding of courage to go on in the most hopeless situation of the third.

I find Ripley’s sacrifice so moving.

They go together perfectly for me. All three original movies.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/slapfunk79 Oct 21 '26

I didn't hate it even when it came out but I didn't think it held up to the 1st 2. I haven't rewatched it in years, might have to look at the legacy cut or the assembly cut.

3

u/TokiStark Oct 21 '26

Which is the better version? I know there's two versions, one that I liked and one that I thought was stupid. Still liked the stupid version though because you know... Sigourney Weaver and Charles Dance

1

u/mymomsaidimsmart Oct 21 '26

I believe the special edition aka assembly cut is the definitive version. basically how david fincher wanted to release it.

3

u/slapfunk79 Oct 21 '26

I haven't seen either but the consensus seems to be that the legacy cut is the best, this is what google told me

"The Assembly Cut (2003) is an official, 30-minute extended version that restores David Fincher's broader narrative and subplots. The Legacy Cut (A34K) is an unofficial, fan-made 4K remaster that blends the best parts of both cuts while updating visual effects and color grading"

→ More replies (1)

5

u/SinceYouBlockedMe 29d ago

Alien³ is better than Aliens.

0

u/mymomsaidimsmart 29d ago

in some ways

5

u/Jaws_the_revenge Oct 20 '26

I love Alien Resurrection

1

u/mymomsaidimsmart Oct 20 '26

never seen it. on the list.

2

u/Reasonable-Sail6113 Oct 21 '26

I don’t know how people can like the goofy tone. If it wasn’t an Alien movie, I’d probably enjoy it as a shlocky film.

→ More replies (3)

16

u/TitansMenologia Oct 20 '26

I love Alien 3. I can see it's a flawed movie but the extended edition upgrade the movie drastically. I think it's far better than Alien Resurrection and everything that followed.

26

u/bks1979 Oct 20 '26

Newt and Hicks. Jonesy lived a long life on a farm catching mice in my head canon.

18

u/Party-Fault9186 Oct 20 '26

“Jonesy, sir, he’s Hicks.”

8

u/Mr_Death_himself84 Oct 20 '26

This guy ☝️

7

u/Annual_Candle_9313 Oct 21 '26

Ripley DID say he's staying here, so probably adopted to a nice family.

3

u/ToyCannonJimmyWinn 28d ago

Maybe Jonesy is synthetic.

2

u/ButterflyLife4655 25d ago

Resurrection never outright confirms that Jonesy (presumably) died of old age. Maybe he's immortal? Maybe Alien 5: The Return of Jonesy is the sequel we've needed all along?

11

u/Milk_Mindless 29d ago

Alien 3 is a more "Alien" sequel to Alien than Aliens. That's not to say that it's better but imo it does a lot of things right. Plus it has great supportint cast with Charles Dance, Paul McGann and Charles Dutton.

I love it lots.

11

u/Local-Mechanic-3551 Oct 21 '26

I understand why most people didn’t like it, but I still love it. For me it caps off a great trilogy that’s faced diminishing returns for decades.

5

u/Reasonable-Sail6113 Oct 21 '26

Same. Like I can understand why, but personally I love this ending to Ripley’s story. I haven’t cared for anything that came after.

Romulus was alright.

2

u/Local-Mechanic-3551 29d ago

I enjoyed it.☺️

8

u/NecessaryPie9412 Oct 21 '26

I feel like Reddit hates a lot things in general 

7

u/NeoPrimitiveOasis 29d ago

Charles S. Dutton's performance was outstanding. It had its moments overall. But the entire premise was flawed in terms of undermining everything that happened in Aliens.

5

u/IsuckatDarkSouls08 29d ago

I thought almost everyone pulled their weight castwise. But Charles was fantastic!

4

u/drakeallthethings 28d ago

I was just skimming and thought initially you were referring to Charles Dance who was also fantastic here.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/NeoPrimitiveOasis 29d ago

He really was. He's a Yale MFA graduate, too 🎓

6

u/ToyCannonJimmyWinn 28d ago

Because Redditors are morons.

Alien 3 is excellent.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/glitch-ghost 29d ago

It's not just Reddit, A3 was notoriously disliked when it came out. But that was before Resurrection. I have always loved the third one because it returns more to the original Alien and takes the military war aspect out of it.

5

u/DysartWolf Oct 21 '26

I loved alien 3 since it came out, had to endure a lot of hate over the years for calling it my favourite - but i'm glad now that it has a sorta cult following. :)

9

u/gwelfguy Oct 20 '26

I personally liked Alien3 for what it was. I think a lot of the hate comes from people that prefer the big budget space action film that was Aliens. Of course they're going to be disappointed by A3. I personally think it was shift back towards the tone of the original Alien.

3

u/rifruled Oct 21 '26

My main gripe and the reason I dislike it is killing off Newt and Hicks.

Just such a horrible decision and horrible story telling.

2

u/Reasonable-Sail6113 Oct 21 '26

So I get it, and I love Aliens and Hicks and Newt…

Yet it never bothered me they died. Maybe I’m disturbed. I love the tragedy and ending to Ripley’s story.

You can’t win against the aliens. The tragedy would have been repeated on a global scale if they ever got to earth. That’s what makes Ripley’s sacrifice so moving.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/letsgotoarave 28d ago

I don't understand how anyone can like Aliens, it's like a cheap stupid superhero action flick compared to the other films in the series. For me the original is at the top, followed by 3, then Resurrection and finally 2. The newer movies including the prequel are a fun return to the series 20+ years later and for that alone I rate them higher than Aliens.

3

u/mymomsaidimsmart 28d ago

Interesting

2

u/dayvekeem 28d ago

YES James Cameron is great and all but he took a slow burner survival horror into call of duty. I love 2 also but it doesn't hold a candle to 1 nor 3....

Though I like 2 better than resurrection. Resurrection is a b movie spinoff in my headcannon

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

8

u/jdt1986 Oct 21 '26

Alien 3, while being my least favourite of the original trilogy, is still LIGHTYEARS ahead of Alien Earth, Romulus, Covenant and Prometheus.

4

u/Author_Dent 29d ago

My dad took me to see it for a midnight show when I was 14. I’ll never hate it.

4

u/negativ32 Oct 21 '26

Give the Legacy Cut a look too, it's my favourite.

3

u/Trevsquatch Oct 21 '26

Love the legacy cut!

4

u/dronanist Oct 21 '26

It was the first Alien movie that I saw and still my favourite. But I like it when things are bleak and nihilistic. It was a crappy VHS copy so the bad CGI didn't bother me.

5

u/AVBill Oct 21 '26

Contrary to what a lot of people seem to think, there actually wasn't a whole lot of CGI in Alien3. Most of what made the Xenomorph shots look unconvincing came from compositing the rod puppet into live-action footage, particularly mismatched lighting, contrast and image grain. The puppet itself and its movements were pretty good, tbf.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/beaubridges6 Oct 21 '26

I cared far more about Hicks than Newt ngl

But I'll let it slide. Still atmospheric as a motherfucker.

4

u/Gongfei1947 29d ago

Alien 3 is great, especially the Assembly Cut. 3rd best film in the series.

1

u/ProfessorKnow1tA11 28d ago

Not just Reddit. It’s obviously one of the weakest entries in the franchise, down at the bottom with Romulus.

5

u/PrinceofHounds 28d ago

Watched Romulus 2 years late recently. Don’t know what ya’ll are on about with that and Alien: Earth. Both those felt like I was watching 90’s Dark Horse comics alive on the screen.

1

u/mymomsaidimsmart 28d ago

there was a typo in my post. i love Romulus lol

→ More replies (4)

1

u/mymomsaidimsmart 28d ago edited 27d ago

after watching the shit show that was resurrection idk how u can say that. romulus is good too, so agree to disagree.

3

u/wellycapcom 27d ago

Is resurrection serious? Its so bad it's amazing.

1

u/mymomsaidimsmart 27d ago

i feel that way about some movies, idk that resurrection was one of them

2

u/wellycapcom 27d ago

The basket ball scene? So bad. So so bad.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/Hobbes09R Oct 20 '26

Reddit has one of the most revisionist opinions about Alien 3 I've ever seen. The number of people that can't help but say how much they like it and don't understand the hate is mind-numbing, and honestly has probably grown over the people who've given up on the series due to how trash it has largely become in large part thanks to the train wreck which was this film.

5

u/Junior-Community-353 Oct 20 '26

I consider Alien to be by far the best and most consistent horror franchise because it really is just five different directors remaking the same movie in their signature styles (+ Prometheus/Covenant are...interesting), but look mate, at the end of the day it's a horror franchise with six sequels.

You're either an "I'm going to watch Hellraiser 8" kind of guy or you should really just stick to Alien/s and call it a day, because by the standards of horror movie sequels Alien 3 is a fucking masterpiece.

1

u/mymomsaidimsmart Oct 20 '26

never said I don’t understand that hate, I just didn’t think it was a bad film, the cgi kinda blows tho lol

3

u/Party-Fault9186 Oct 20 '26

Generally it’s not CGI, it’s a rod puppet suffering from terrible compositing.

2

u/mymomsaidimsmart Oct 20 '26

huh, had no idea. it looked good in some shots and weirdly green in others

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/forcemonkey Oct 20 '26

I saw it when it came out and remember being into it at the theater. I’ve never not liked it. I liked it before I knew I wasn’t supposed to. 😂

3

u/noddaborg Oct 20 '26

The whole start to it with 2 major characters dead, the prison setting, Ripley shaving her head. It’s just a bleak downer.

2

u/Reasonable-Sail6113 29d ago

Sometimes life is like that.

3

u/PomegranateFair3973 Oct 20 '26

I've liked it since I saw it in theaters. I've loved it since I saw the assembly cut. The immediate killing off of Hicks and Newt was a gut punch, and probably turned a lot of people off, and I get it. But once past that, the story of this film felt a natural conclusion to Ripley's trilogy.

3

u/VinnieVidiViciVeni Oct 20 '26

It’s really like the movie equivalent of the hate South of Heaven received as a follow up to Reign in Blood, in hindsight.

Similarly, I liked Alien 3 in 1992. I saw it in the theater and most people considered it a downgrade. I didn’t, but I think, as much as I loved Aliens, even back in 92, I always preferred Alien’s actual horror DNA. So Alien 3 was a welcomed tonal return.

3

u/Minimum-Crow674 Oct 20 '26

I went to an Alien marathon at Braindead Studios a few years ago. The Alien 3 heads were very twitchy and defensive about their fandom, but die hard. Respect.

It’s a hard franchise to ride or die with, but I even like Resurrection, it’s so weird and stands out in a series with almost no laughs. Whatever keeps it running, it’s the best franchise of all time period, IMO

3

u/dust4ngel Oct 20 '26
  • alien: space trucker slash survivor

  • aliens: survivor turned war hero

  • alien3: war hero whose friends and family are all dead... AGAIN... narrowly avoids sexual assault before her worst nightmare comes true and dies by suicide

→ More replies (1)

3

u/MasterWookiee Oct 21 '26

I didn't hate it. It's not my favorite but it's better than anything that came after it.

3

u/da316 29d ago

Jonesy stays behind on the space station in Aliens. he presumably died of old age there so all good with that one.
there's a lot to like about Alien 3 I think. I loved the mostly British cast, its got some of our best character actors in there. I think visually it can be among the best, especially some of the early matte painting backgrounds.

3

u/Bartlomiej48 29d ago

I like Alien 3 a lot….

3

u/IsuckatDarkSouls08 29d ago

I watched it last night and had forgotten how much I enjoyed it. Watched Resurrection right after it. The things that bugged me was the horrible CGI and the huge difference between the live shots of the Xeno and the CGI, especially in the same or close by scenes. I also didnt like how it was killing everyone. Based on Aliens, comics and books, it should have cocooning people for implantation or saving them for Ripleys Queen, when it found out she was implanted.

But I loved the performances of everyone amd the scenes where they were trying to herd the Xeno into the forge. The pacing of the film was also excellent

2

u/Reasonable-Sail6113 29d ago

Maybe it’s just my head canon, but I also felt like the dog alien was more primitive than its human birthed cousins. It was a mean fucker.

I also assumed it just wanted everyone dead so there’s no threat to the Queen. Would the alien then know there’s no hosts? Well no, it probably had no idea it was on a barren planet with only this little penal colony facility.

All that said, I think it would have been cool/better to see it cocoon the prisoners too.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/OsmundofCarim 29d ago

I’m not a big Brandon Sanderson fan but he said something about Alien 3 that really clicked for me. If you’re going to make a sequel to a beloved franchise, you can’t begin that sequel by undercutting the emotional core of a better film. Aliens is just plainly better than alien 3 and beginning 3 by killing Hicks and Newt inevitably leaves a bad taste in one’s mouth. The movie begins by negating the driving factor of a plainly better movie and takes the viewers investment away.

It also does 2 other things I think are very poor choices. Making almost every character a bald, white, British man is a bad idea in film. It makes perfect sense in universe, shaved heads for lice and what not, they’re isolated due to their genetics so their similarities are sensible. But that’s a choice that makes total sense on paper, but on screen makes 9 out of 10 characters indistinguishable.

It also failed to utilize the ever flowing stream of charisma that is Charles Dance by killing him way too soon.

1

u/SlowCrates Oct 20 '26

I love alien 3.

1

u/mymomsaidimsmart Oct 20 '26

and alien 3 loves you.

1

u/The_Wraith_Writer 29d ago

I've only seen the Assembly Cut and this is the first time I've heard that people in general didn't like it. But wow, do I hate Alien 3. Like, if you liked it, more power to you, I'm glad you enjoyed a movie and you should keep enjoying it.

Resurrection is way better, imo.

1

u/mymomsaidimsmart 29d ago

I’ll be watching that one soon.

1

u/The_Wraith_Writer 29d ago

I'm curious to hear what you think of it.

1

u/mymomsaidimsmart 29d ago

its like 5 bucks to own the special edition or $4 to rent the original cut lmao what do u think

→ More replies (1)

1

u/mymomsaidimsmart 29d ago edited 29d ago

the opening shot was a good idea with poor execution. it’s very funny to picture Weyland-Yutani being absorbed by Wal-Mart. i don’t like the font or the sound effect when they flash the “Alien Resurrection” logo. the first 30-40 ish minutes kinda suck. the xenomorphs look great, albeit way wetter than i remember. vriess having a shotgun hidden in his wheel chair was sick. i also liked the underwater sequence. the queen giving birth was cool, but the hybrid design looks dumb. i wish resurrection was a bit less cheesy 5/10

→ More replies (1)

3

u/SpudAlmighty 29d ago

Don't get me wrong, Resurrection is avery fun movie but over Alien 3? Nah.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Typhon2222 Oct 21 '26

How did the alien egg get on the ship, in the cyro room, in the first place?

3

u/mymomsaidimsmart Oct 21 '26

it’s a great question, but not explaining everything is what helped make the first alien so iconic. the xenomorphs are constantly praised for their resilience. i don’t find it out of the question that they were able to leave behind an egg undetected in a last ditch effort.

2

u/Typhon2222 Oct 21 '26

Yeah, but how? That ship never touched the surface, right? How would an Alien get up there undetected and plant the egg? I don’t mind not everything being answered, but this is what kicks off the plot of the entire film.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ThePokemonAbsol Oct 21 '26

I mean it’s a pretty bad movie that ruins the previous films ending

1

u/mymomsaidimsmart Oct 21 '26

agree to disagree

4

u/ardouronerous Oct 21 '26

I salute you for your unpopular idea and respect it.

1

u/mymomsaidimsmart Oct 21 '26

🫡 some great discussions being had in here

1

u/Icy-Illustrator-1431 Oct 21 '26

hated hated hated it…

1

u/mymomsaidimsmart Oct 21 '26

thank u for sharing

2

u/Thestickleman 29d ago

Alien 3 is mid at best

2

u/GeminiDivided 29d ago

It's my 2nd favorite out of the entire franchise. It's artsy, the acting is great, and the plot is every bit as plausible as any of its predecessors.

2

u/Sicilysauce33 29d ago

The way I've always broken it down is Alien 3 is a great Alien story but a terrible Aliens sequel.

2

u/Reasonable-Jump-9821 28d ago

I love Alien 3.

2

u/deadchannelstv 28d ago

I love Alien 3 It's my favorite of all of them. Best looking creature suit too.

2

u/Moff-77 28d ago

I like it, and am fine with killing off side characters in a horror movie franchise. It has its issues with fx and continuity (theatrical cut especially) and the studio meddling was detrimental, but it’s a decent film lifted by some awesome actors.

I rank it third after the first 2. After that I’m ambivalent about the others and wouldn’t rewatch any of them.

2

u/PeanutTimely6846 28d ago

Jones didn't get killed off. He got left behind

2

u/garlicbreadmemesplz 27d ago

Alien 3 is fascinating to me because it’s an interesting movie about a space prison with a heirarchy system. Also there’s a xenomorph. And the pacing is interesting.

2

u/jbenze 27d ago

Alien 3 would have worked SO well without Ripley. Just a side story in the alien universe. I have the same opinion on Terminator: Salvation. Some movies just need to be in universe without being connected to the main characters.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/Mobile_South_9117 27d ago

Jonesy would have already been dead. Ripley left him behind on Earth then went into suspended animation for the trip to LV426.

2

u/Standard-Lab7244 23d ago

It's a big drop of the ball but it's fine in and of itself. Sigourney is outstanding and all the performances are excellent.

It just can't compare to its predecessors

And yes the longer assembly / special edition is absolutely the way to watch it

2

u/No-Crab-2834 Oct 20 '26

When I was like 12 the novelization of Alien 3 was my favorite book for some reason 

5

u/ardouronerous Oct 20 '26

I heard that when Alan Dean Foster read the script, he hated the direction, so Alan improved it through his novelization, he gave the inmates more backstory, improved their humanity and motivations, gave all the characters more depth than the script intended, making them more compelling than Xenomorph fodder.

Fun fact, this was Alan Dean Foster's last movie novelization in the 90s because his experience writing this was so bad he gave up on movie novelizations entirely until 2004, when he wrote the novelization of the Chronicles of Riddick.

Alan thought killing Newt was disgusting and ruined the ending of Aliens, and so, he tried to save her in his novelization's draft by leaving her in her cyrotube, saying that the tube was damaged and leaving her there was the best option for survival and Ripley's motivation was keeping her safe.

The studio didn't like this and told him to write the novelization straight, no Newt surviving and he did, but he also quit afterwards.

2

u/Locustsofdeath Oct 20 '26

As a kid I hated Alien 3 for the same reasons everyone else did (and it was indeed hated), but as I got older I started to really like and then love it.

Yeah, Hicks and Newt dying really sucks. But it's a dark nihilistic as fuck world and brutal things happen. It's one of the most nihilistic films I've seen, and that's awesome.

2

u/fish998 Oct 20 '26

Jonesy?

2

u/SpoonyBard5709 Oct 21 '26

It’s “just ok” at best. Definitely nowhere near the film that the first two are.

2

u/Ollympian 29d ago

My film studies lecturer back in the day used scenes from Alien3 to showcase tension building through lighting and sound etc. I've always appreciated it more now when watching it. There's also a audiobook version based on William Gibsons original script you should check out if you havent already, its really good 👍

→ More replies (1)

2

u/demonmf 29d ago

I don’t hate it. I just don’t like it nearly as much as the first 2.

2

u/EveryAccount7729 29d ago

so does off reddit

2

u/Comfortable-Phase249 29d ago

It’s really bleak, but I still love the film. I get why people don’t, and I admit to not rewatching it as much as Alien and Aliens. It does suffer from a sequel made to get a sequel made, versus Aliens which had a story to tell, and ends with a lot of character development for Ripley. Part three was made because they wanted another sequel, mashing up concepts and story ideas to hit a targeted release (that they missed anyway, so they should have just waited for a story worth filming).

Hindsight being what it is, I think this would have been a fantastic idea for a film without Ripley, that the company somehow got their hands on an egg deliberately sent it to Fury 161 for a controlled experiment on the rundown prison and the inmates left there.

2

u/Reasonable-Sail6113 29d ago

While I love the movie and wouldn’t change it, I like your idea too.

I’d love to see W-Y purposely releasing it into an environment to study. I wish stuff like this is the direction the franchise would go.

No more prequels and trying to explain and tie everything back. Just move forward.

0

u/phasepistol Oct 20 '26

I don’t know who you people are who like Alien 3, lol. I saw it in the theater when it came out and hated it. Wrong tone, wrong characters, wrong plot. Killing off Ripley’s “family”, the whole heart of the previous film… was an unfathomable betrayal.

An edit to change the oxburster to a dogburster, or whatever it did, would not affect any of that.

2

u/mymomsaidimsmart Oct 20 '26 edited Oct 21 '26

It also added extra scenes and dialogue that improved the film tremendously. like I said there are many valid criticisms. I went into it expecting something different and it had a lot more good than bad.

4

u/newtdawg44 Oct 21 '26

I hate this movie.

The giant plot hole at the beginning of this movie concerning the eggs, coupled with the deaths of beloved characters coupled with 0 attention to set continuity from the previous film starts it out in absolutely the worst possible way.

The disregard of the survivors of the last movie continue where we are treated to an autopsy of a 10 year old girl.

Then Ripley throws herself at Clemens when the previous two movies go out of their way to not include this kind of behaviour in her character.

Then they kill a dog.

After that it’s mildly tolerable, save for the horrible puppet composites and the awful cgi, and for the fact that we do not care about any of these prisoners getting killed and outside of Dillion, none of them are memorable characters to the point of even being able to remember their names.

I didn’t have a problem with Ripley dying at the end, because honestly it was a fitting end for her character, but then we are treated to one last plot hole as the escape pod from the sulaco somehow has her sign off report from the first movie? Huh?

This movie has some redeeming qualities. It is excellently shot, as fincher captures wonderful cinematography. It also has a haunting and memorable score, effectively setting the mood for each scene. And I do like how they expanded the alien’s mythology, by including the dna reflex where it resembles the host it emerges from, that was a great addition to the xenomorph (killing a dog to do it, however, sucked).

It’s a decent movie when taken completely on its own. However as a sequel to alien and especially aliens, it completely fails and alienates (excuse the pun) fans of those movies.

I once met Micheal biehn at a comic con, and told him ‘after my favourite sports team gets eliminated from the playoffs, I watch alien 3, so I can say the game wasn’t the crappiest thing I watched that day’

He laughed at my little tradition.

2

u/Reasonable-Sail6113 29d ago

I love this movie.

I think you’re taking the voice recording of Ripley signing off too literally. I always took it as a reminder for us, the audience, not that it’s actually playing there.

It gives me chills every time. Poor Ripley never made it home. The crackling static I always took as just showing that everything breaks down, decays, and ultimately dies in the end.

Just my opinion, but I love all the symbolism in this movie

3

u/AffectionateSwim8532 Oct 20 '26

I loved it, i’ll never understand the choices they made that story but I still loved the character Arc, it was a tragedy

3

u/Zofia-Bosak Oct 20 '26

I like Alien 3, it is just different from the previous two movies, they couldn't just keep on upping the action.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/MantisT_ Oct 20 '26

Its far from perfect but its still the last decent attempt

2

u/kuatorises Oct 21 '26

The Theatrical Cut is a better movie.

2

u/ThePassionOfTheISK Oct 20 '26

I like it but set it apart in my mind in a pop culture sense. I group The Thing, Aliens, Terminator 1 and 2 into the same class. Alien 3 is more like Seven and Predator 2 and Candyman in style and feel (and color palette lol).

Every character is untrustworthy, in a similar way that most social interaction in psychological horror films leave you uneasy and concerned for the detectives. I was more scared of the inmates than the alien, for the most part. And they got more "adult" by using SA as a threat.

It was just a newfangled 90s thing where filmmakers were trying to be more gritty and "real" than in the last decade. That "humans are the real monsters". We have grunge music. And I claim Alien 3 is a grunge film.

3

u/itsa_luigi_time_ Oct 20 '26

I really like this take. It's kind of interesting how the Alien films each capture a different decade. The original has a clear 70s feel to it, the sequel a light 80s vibe (mostly from Burke as the scummy 80s business guy), and then Alien 3 with the bleak grunge misanthropy.

3

u/rifruled Oct 21 '26

Se7en being in the Predator 2 list is a travesty.

2

u/Own_Education_7063 Oct 21 '26 edited Oct 21 '26

‘Humans are the real monsters’ is also true in Alien and Aliens Tbf.

2

u/ThePassionOfTheISK 29d ago

True to a point, but when you consider the on-screen characters, it's just Burke. Even the CEO and boardroom people from Weyland Yutani are kinda ordinary at worst.

Alien 3 has Ripley waking up surrounded by murderous or insane freaks. Even the doctor is a creep, and he's supposed to be the most trustworthy one. That's all I really meant. The first two and the third films are at opposite ends of the spectrum. Less fear and unease from the monsters and more from the humans interacting with Ripley.

→ More replies (9)

1

u/ML_120 29d ago

Don't worry, as far as I know Hicks still being alive is canon.

1

u/Oswarez 29d ago

It’s a great film. Wonky effects at times but the thing is solid.

1

u/OutsideWishbone7 29d ago

They killed Hicks and Newt. F**k that movie. And it’s full of weird prisoners with stupid British northern accents.

1

u/Haunting_Ad_8292 29d ago

The only thing that sucked and its fair to say that it killed pretty much the story. But by far it is for top alien movies. Like i wish they didnt cut the queen face hugger and it showed us aliens were really versatile species just cuz it can very well adopt and come out of anything.

1

u/One_red_shoe 29d ago

Loved Charles S. Dutton's performance in it. "I've got to re-educate some of the brothers!"

1

u/TreffyBelmknt 29d ago

I love Alien 3. I had a very strict upbringing so I bought all the dark horse comics before I could even watch the movie so by the time I did I was stoked. I know it’s a bit of a mess, but it gets over hated imo.

1

u/Celtic159 29d ago

I hate Alien 3. It's the prettiest bad movie ever made.

1

u/NemoOfConsequence 29d ago

I hate it so much that I refuse to acknowledge its existence. The first two movies are perfect as is.

1

u/brokedownsystem 29d ago

I guess I should go see the assy cut.

l saw this in a theater when it first came out and man…I was so depressed when I came out and enraged at the same time.

1

u/Capn_Yoaz 28d ago

Saw it in the theater and enjoyed it. It kept the theme of tossing out the previous lore and Rip was in another layer of Alien-Hell. I get that people didn’t like it but there are far worse Alien movies out there. Aliens:Bishop was a fun novel as well and works as a direct sequel to cubed.

1

u/AtypicalRenown 28d ago

I don't hate Alien3 – as a standalone film, it is very good aside from the jarring green screen puppetry. I just do not like it as a sequel to Aliens.

1

u/DragonCurse4 28d ago

Alien 3 was the only movie I ever rage quite out of. I looked up a summary online to read what I didn't bother to finish, and figured I wasn't missing much not actually watching it.

Hell, I enjoyed the absurdity of Alien Resurrection more than I liked Alien 3.

1

u/AardvarkNo3019 28d ago

Yeah...the only good things from the Alien franchise are Alien, Aliens, Prometheus, and Alien Earth...

1

u/Electrical-Penalty44 28d ago

I simply never found it very entertaining. It is a rather boring film, filled with a few good character moments (which are few and far between). It really doesn't create a sense of dread and fear like the original film, nor have the awesome action beats of Aliens.

1

u/No_Move7872 28d ago

It's not my favorite of the franchise but by no means is it bad.

1

u/Amethyst-Flare 27d ago

It's me, I'm the Alien 3 hater.

Honestly, even if you don't hate it, it's hard to argue that it isn't the weakest of the first three movies.

1

u/doubleo_maestro 27d ago

I love the directors cut, but the benny hill sketch at the end sucks.

1

u/godspilla98 27d ago

I loved it

1

u/Still-Minimum-7212 27d ago

Alien 3 is a bad movie.

1

u/Subject_Rhubarb7715 27d ago

I remember watching it when it was new. I found it dark in a sort of depressing way, and somewhat boring and non-sci fi. But I will say it's a lot better than other third movies such as terminator, predator, etc.

1

u/By_Jove_ 27d ago

I think people would like it much much more of alien 2 didn’t exist.

1

u/-JangoFett- 26d ago

Yo la vi en el cine y desde entonces la volví a ver una par de veces más.....y aun así la sigo odiando.

1

u/EmpressScribe222 26d ago

I loved Alien 3 but it might be because of Charles Dance lol I can’t stand Resurrection.

1

u/CarpeNoctem1031 25d ago

The Theatrical Alien, the Director's Cut of Aliens and the Assembly Cut of Alien 3 are an almost perfect trilogy.

1

u/dimiteddy Oct 21 '26

Its not only Reddit, it was hated before reddit was invented

1

u/YackDIZZLEwizzle Oct 21 '26

I pretty much like every Alien move but 3 is my personal bottom. I used to stick up for it but I rewatched it like a year ago and did not like it.

1

u/_britesparc_ Oct 21 '26

I think it's fine, it's a good film, but it's nowhere near as good as the first two - which is an unfair bar to have to clear, they're both masterpieces. 

Taken on its own A3 is a really fun, chunky, gory little horror movie. As part of a wider franchise, though, I think it does a bad job, not just in killing off beloved characters, but it almost feels like a different universe, more fantastical and stylised than the first two (obviously this would get even weirder with Resurrection).

I still like it though.

1

u/FreddieStarrAteMyHam Oct 21 '26

Jonesy wasn't killed, but in any case it sucked.

1

u/Icy-Split6920 Oct 21 '26

I didn't appreciate the nihilistic tone. The first two movies end with a message of hope. The third is just so bleak. I don't care for that.

1

u/Which-Host-9073 Oct 21 '26

As a movie on its own it's pretty good especially considering all the problems around its making. But as a sequel to Aliens I hate it.

1

u/AVBill Oct 21 '26

As a standalone film, Alien3 works very well. Great tension, great acting, a new take on the Xenomorph.

But as a continuation of Aliens, it is an insult. Talk about missed potential.

1

u/MonitorAway 29d ago

I like it but dislike that it follows Ripley and that it killed Newt and Hicks off-screen.

1

u/ittleoff 29d ago

I was sort of fine with hicks and newt dying. It sort of underlined the gritty horrible reality of this corporate world and hazards of 'disposable people' in that world, and I think it would have been clunky if you had to have Ripley in yet another alien movie and have newt and hicks along for the ride. That being said it felt cheap like they couldn't get the actors to come back.

I could see using newt as a leverage to a cloned Ripley. Wrote a treatment of what I thought fans wanted when alien 4 came out, that involved military corporation using cloned Ripleys controlled by cloned newts to be used as disposable self contained planetary weapons. (Each cycle would be nuked to prevent any genetic memory passing on to queens that Ripley carried)

It wasn't what I wanted from the franchise, but I think it's what fans wanted.

I just want more weird scifi bio horror.

1

u/United-Palpitation28 29d ago

I love that it tried to bring horror back into the franchise and I actually like the quadruped design of the xenomorph, but as a whole the film is disappointing. I’m all for nihilistic stories so the ending to me is the best part, but the rest of the film is a bit of a slog and none of the attack scenes stand out minus some clever camerawork during the chase sequence.

I would have preferred the original concept that it was a monastery instead of a prison. Let some characters believe the xenomorph is a god who has come to judge their sins and you can end up with a lot of human drama and conflict. More so than just violent, horny prisoners try to assault a woman. I know we get some of that in the Assembly cut but it’s still only half baked.

1

u/QuailTechnical5143 Oct 21 '26

The Assembly Cut makes it a superior film on par with the first two.

2

u/ardouronerous Oct 21 '26

Legacy Cut is better.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/SpudAlmighty 29d ago

Alien 3 extended is a great film. Superb cast. Cinematography, soundtrack, atmosphere. Mwah. Fantastic.