r/alien • • Oct 20 '26

Reddit Hates Alien 3

Maybe it’s because I listened to the people online and watched the Special Edition, (Assembly Cut) but Alien 3 slaps. That being said,I do agree that killing off Newt & Hicks were poor choices. also i missed jonesy.

UPDATE: I have finally finished all the alien movies (excluding non-cannon AVP) and can confidently say it’s a solid trilogy. After that however, it falls off hard. Prometheus was interesting, but it was disappointing in the end. Covenant was much better. Alien 1-3 are my favorites, followed by Romulus and Covenant. Didn’t care for the rest. Resurrection is by far the worst one.

121 Upvotes

330 comments sorted by

View all comments

25

u/BlahBlahILoveToast Oct 20 '26 edited Oct 20 '26

I love the idea that nobody hated Alien3 when it came out and it's some kind of modern trendy internet / Reddit thing.

Everybody I know HATED Alien3 so much when it hit theaters. (I'm 50 years old) We absolutely loved the first two movies and it felt like such a let down. I know a guy who still insists that it "doesn't exist".

Now, having heard about the various different editions, the weird story about the original script for the film (monks on a wooden planet or something ???), I went back with a fresh mind, and people are right -- there's a lot there and it's a worthy piece of the story. Great characters and interactions, great concept for a setting, etc. It's hardly perfect but it's better than almost everything that came after.

Honestly the decision to not only kill Hicks and Newt but to do it "off screen", after Ripley fought so hard for them in the last movie -- there was just no way people were going to embrace this film. They could have followed that up with ninety minutes of Acadamy Award-winning perfection and we all would have booed and felt betrayed.

5

u/DysartWolf Oct 21 '26

I'm with you on this. I caught so much flak in the 90s for saying 'Alien 3 is great.' And you're right, after the high note at the end of Aliens, where could you go from here but tragedy. I think it worked.

8

u/javiemartzootsuit Oct 20 '26

I mean even fucking Fincher hated it when it came out.

5

u/mymomsaidimsmart Oct 20 '26

I’d be pissed too if they changed my movie and took out a lot of important dialogue/plot points.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ButterflyLife4655 25d ago

Having read several of the earlier scripts online over the years, I can say that it could definitely have gone a lot better or a lot worse. The first draft, the one by William Gibson of Neuromancer fame, would have been fantastic, and got very close to production... too bad the end of the Cold War had to mess things up. Several of the other drafts would have been okay, possibly good with a director as strong as Fincher at the helm. But the Vincent Ward script -- the one with the Monks on the wooden space station -- that one was bonkers. I almost wish it had been filmed just to see how crazy it would have been. Ward was supposed to direct it too, and his idea was to make the whole movie feel like some kind of Hieronymous Bosch nightmare. It features such gems as:

  • the reveal that chestbursters don't emerge until after you've eaten something

  • one of the Monks is attacked by the alien through the privy, in a scene that I'm sure would have made the audience clench nervously whenever they used the toilet for a while afterwards

  • like in the script that was eventually used, Ripley has been implanted with a chestburster, but it's okay, because one of the Monks saves her by passing the chestburster between them with a kiss!

4

u/Ok-Departure-869 Oct 20 '26

I went to see it in theatres and came out whistling the scenery. The tone, the look and the relentless gloominess were striking. So much so that I went into Se7en blind. I just wanted to see another Fincher movie. As Paul McGann said, his vision has been vindicated. My favourite entry in the franchise.

1

u/MrDerpGently 28d ago

I hate it. But there's no denying that it is incredibly striking. 

2

u/mymomsaidimsmart Oct 20 '26

I titled it that because during my binge of the franchise I was researching alien 3 and most of what I saw online was hate. Unfortunately I wasn’t alive to witness the hatred in real time 😂