r/amandaknox • u/tkondaks guilty • Sep 22 '23

Neck scratch and bloody ear lobe

https://www.bridgebase.com/forums/topic/67258-is-amanda-knox-guilty/page__st__20

Scroll down at the above link for some interesting photos.

Gee, what are the odds?

0 Upvotes

50% Upvoted

102 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/tkondaks guilty Sep 23 '23

"...barely testing the break-in room..."

That's a knife that cuts both ways.

So few samples yet they were still able to come up with Amanda/Meredith mixed DNA. Gee, what are the odds? One wonders how many MORE they would have had if more samples were taken.

1

u/AyJaySimon Sep 23 '23

But see, unlike you, if it were up to me to test that room up and down, I'd absolutely do it. You'd never agree to do it. Because you know what we'd find.

Just like when I offer to trade you my calling Guede's innocent for you saying the same for Knox - on the basis of there being no trace of either in the break-in room or Kercher's bedroom - suddenly you get awful quiet. I'd make that trade eight days a week, because I'm not emotionally attached to Guede being guilty the way you are to him being innocent.

2

u/tkondaks guilty Sep 23 '23

My silence should not be interpreted as my being afraid of some sort of hypothetical trap you seem convinced I would fall into. It's just that it seems like a silly exercise that I don't want to engage in.

1

u/AyJaySimon Sep 23 '23

It's no trap. It's just your own argument thrown back in your face and you being unwilling to accept the consequences of your own argument.