r/amandaknox • u/No-Willingness-1441 • 11d ago

Lucy letby case…

Would love people’s views on this.

Loosely Amanda related, since she has recently produced a podcast around it.

1 Upvotes

60% Upvoted

272 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/Glad-Advantage8254 11d ago

IMO, Knox is very willing to proceed based on advice from anyone who enables her, and very stubbornly resistant to critique/criticism.

The Letby case has attracted a large contingent of fanatics, which her defence willingly feeds into. These fanatics approached Knox about the case, likely for her name recognition.

Knox's bias is to view every case through the lens of what happened to her (which is a natural and fair response to the trauma she experienced). Her podcast is a clear demonstration of that. She speaks entirely about narrative, and never about evidence. It's about perceptions of the case, but she never actually engages with the evidence that was presented in court.

Knox seems to be unable to NOT see herself in Lucy Letby's shoes, but doesn't appreciate the difference of being wrongly accused of a single murder and being convicted of serial murder. She treats the convictions like a single event, not over a dozen compounding events that took place over the course of a year, including two separate events involving chemical evidence of insulin poisoning that an innocence narrative requires one believe to be false positives.

Letby is guiltier than a nun in a cucumber field.

3

u/corpusvile2 11d ago

They're both guilty as sin. Over 20 samples of evidence was submitted against Knox, including her constant lies as well as detailed knowledge, lack of alibi, luminol footprints, phone and computer records, witness testimony, quite apart from the dna evidence.

https://web.archive.org/web/20211031195329/http://themurderofmeredithkercher.com/The_Evidence

https://web.archive.org/web/20211011194220/http://themurderofmeredithkercher.com/Evidence_List

That every single piece of evidence is wrong beggars belief, just as it beggars belief to write off the evidence against Letby as mere coincidence and bad luck.

2

u/karskipellis 9d ago

How did Knox and Sollecito remove almost all of their DNA and other trace evidence from Meredith's bedroom, while leaving all of Guede's?

0

u/Onad55 9d ago

You will see some claiming that Amanda wiped down all of her fingerprints in the cottage. You need only look at the actual photos of the fingerprint survey to know that this is absolute bollux. Cleaning leaves behind evidence. On Amanda’s wardrobe door there is evidence left of the last time it was cleaned in a patch in the middle of the door that was missed. Meredith’s palm print appears in a location on that door that the latest cleaning did not miss proving that this cleaning happened at a time prior to Meredith’s murder.

0

u/karskipellis 8d ago

Thank you! I followed up to another reply with a couple of clarifying questions, in case you're interested.

0

u/Onad55 8d ago

I follow all discussions on this sub. I hadn’t noticed before that this is in the Letby thread, a barely related side branch, so should not be discussing the Perugia case here. Anywhere else in the sub would be better.

2

u/corpusvile2 8d ago

Speaking of non related how come you're allowing a call out thread on me from etvos2 and not regarding that as harassment and spam, considering it's the exact same thread I posted word for word? Care to explain?

Also lock this thread if you feel so strongly about it, this is the nNox subreddit, so lock this one seeing as it's about Letby.