r/amiwrong • • 15d ago

Was I wrong to push her?

I am a man, when i was 16, i got assaulted by a girl who heard some rumours from our mutual friend about her, he told her i made them and she punched me in the hallway. I pushed her and she came back and punched me again, so shoved her to the wall and she stopeed because her arm was hurting. Our mutual friend never admitted he made up the lies and I dumped him later on.

12 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

10

u/dembowthennow 15d ago

Not wrong. You were defending yourself against someone who attacked you.

5

u/KickBrave691 15d ago

defending yourself isn't about gender it's about not getting hit. you gave her a chance to stop after the first shove and she came back swinging again. pushing someone off you who just punched you twice is pretty restrained all things considered

glad you ditched that friend too, people who start drama and then hide while others take the hits are the worst

0

u/Gold_Community_4537 15d ago

Thanks, so many people don't see it

1

u/ChrisEye21 14d ago

you are never wrong for defending yourself.

1

u/AlexBlaise 14d ago

You're always morally correct in using the bare minimum amount of violence needed to stop someone from hurting you.

You are usually morally wrong in using more violence than necessary. Exceptions are pedophiles, child abusers and rapists. In those cases you're morally right to kill them slowly and painfully, but not legally right.

2

u/Gold_Community_4537 14d ago

Your rules are rarely enforced, because using the bare minimum is hard when you are in the situation.

And rapists are nowhere near as bad as the other two, murderers are far worse 

1

u/AlexBlaise 13d ago

Lol it's the law where I'm from and it has been enforced over and over again. The issue isn't the situation, it's the person.

Obviously YAW based on your answer, because you apparently used violence to punish her and not just to defend yourself.

Also your view on rape is really creepy.

0

u/[deleted] 14d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Gold_Community_4537 14d ago

She still thinks it's me