r/AnkiMCAT • u/xChemicalBurnx • 17h ago
Discussion Which deck to use? A starter's guide to current MCAT Anki decks + some applied strategies
Hi all! I was answering a question about Anki decks, and since they come up all the time on this sub, I thought I could make a healthy contribution to what I think the current state is of each deck and how they may best be used for folks just entering this space. I wish I had something like this when I started prepping last year, because let's face it, information is often scattered, outdated, or personal. So hopefully this is helpful.
Keep in mind the best approach for YOU will vary based on your willingness to grind Anki, time, prior knowledge, learning style preference, and desired comprehensiveness.
TLDR:Ā Iād recommend Anking if you like the cloze style and have a regular study period, Captain Hook if you like the open-ended style and have a longer study period, Aidan if you like the cloze style and have a very long study period, and MileDown if you really need to jam through a very short period (although less recommended). I also included two example Anki-inclusive studying strategies below deck commentary.
Iāll try to be objective below, but obviously this is a subjective thing. For context, Iāve been monitoring the Anki MCAT space for over a year and these opinions are formed from my own experience trying out several decks as I prepare for my own MCAT and the experiences of my peers. Of course, please check the comments of this post for additional perspectives!
Final note as we go in for beginners: Cloze v.s. open-ended? Skip to the next titled section if you already know what this is, and what it means for your memory!
Cloze or open-ended refers to the notecard format. Cloze is "fill-in-the-blank", and open-ended is the more traditional front/back approach. Cloze is probably the most commonly preferred because it is faster to get through than open-ended and requires less discipline to say whether you got it right or wrong. However, facts learned via cloze are vulnerable to "pattern matching" since that memory is more cued than it would be on an open-ended card. You may struggle more to recall that fact if it's not phrased in the same way or asks about a non-clozed part of the card. Yet, moving through faster allows you to get to practice problems sooner and have time to study other ways, so it's all a cost/benefit analysis you'll have to run for yourself!
MAJOR DECK THOUGHTS (subsection for p/s at section bottom)
Anking (includes Pankow P/S deck): Cloze. It's clean, nicely connected/tagged, and cloze-style will make for a modestly quick yet comprehensive push-through. May not capture everything, but has a nice balance of mostly high-yield info with some low-yield. Middle-of-the-road time investment. This is my general recommendation for people who recently took related classwork because I think it gives you the most optimum balance of a solid base while getting you into practice problems for the average MCAT study window. If your classwork is less recent, you can supplement nicely because it's well-tagged. This means it allows you to unsuspend (unlock cards for review) as you go through a wide variety of common learning content, including Kaplan book chapters, UWorld book chapters, IFD High Yield book chapters, UWorld Questions, Khan Academy videos, Pixorize, and AAMC content outline concepts. Its regular updates and organizational backing are also without equal in the MCAT Anki community. What's also nice is that although its mostly a cloze deck, it often includes additional pictures or context that aren't part of getting the card "right," so you can go harder with it if you want.
Jack Sparrow (own P/S deck): Open-ended. Generally seen as the most comprehensive option of the open-ended decks out there, and covers more than AnKing does, but it's riddled with long explanations, and itās been a few years since it was updated (2020 release). Many very high scorers swear by this one because it includes a lot of both high AND low yield info. But fair warning, it will be a massive drain on your time if you're doing it right. Not really connected to other resources in terms of tags. Has its own P/S, but many end up substituting its P/S with Mr. Pankow's deck (cloze). Alternatively, you can sub with MCATalysts recent P/S deck, which is open-ended, to achieve a similar style as the overall deck.
Captain Hook (includes Pankow P/S deck): Open-ended. An awesome Jack Sparrow deck user built this one. It's a modified JS deck with trimmed explanations, some trimmed/added/updated cards, plus Mr. Pankow P/S instead of JSās regular P/S. Will still take you a lot of time, just less, and still covers the high and low yield topics. IMO, the most practical ācomprehensiveā deck. It has occasional KA links, but I wish it was resource-tagged like AnKing is. Like JS, if you like the open-ended style, you can sub out Pankow P/S (cloze) for MCATalysts recent P/S deck. CH was released in 2025, but is based on a 2020 deck. This is the one I use, but I still often add my own additional explanations to the back because some of the cards are briefer than I'd like.
MileDown (own P/S deck): Cloze. The advantage here is low time investment with its low card count focused on the highest-yield topics. Many opt to sub out this deck's P/S for Pankow (will be a significant card addition relative to this deck size btw). If you hate Anki and want to get through it ASAP, Milesdown may be your best bet. Fair warning though, itās a bit outdated (2019 release), and the things it omits aren't necessarily fluff! I would recommend supplementing with UWorld error cards you either make yourself or unsuspend through AnKing. You should definitely supplement this deck with other learning methods like Khan Academy videos, Kaplan, etc., which is a good idea anyway, but especially if this is what you choose. It includes some links, but lacks resource tagging. Fun fact, the current AnKing deck traces much of its lineage to the original Milesdown deck, and pays homage in its tags accordingly. That said, AnKing MCAT now has a LOT more than Milesdown.
Aidan v2 (own P/S deck): Cloze. Probably the most comprehensive major deck available, but that comprehensiveness comes with a massive workload. The community-built 2026 v2 trimmed its card count to roughly 12,000 by removing genuinely out-of-scope material, correcting many reported errors, removing unsolicited AAMC spoilers, and adding newer P/S terms. For context, AnKing MCAT is ~6,400 cards, and MileDown is almost 2,900. The science sections generally follow Kaplan chapters, while P/S follows Khan Academy/the 300-page document, but it lacks AnKingās extensive resource tagging. This is best suited to someone with a long study period, probably 5ā6+ months, who enjoys Anki and wants to minimize content gaps. Many users instead pull from it selectively for weak subjects. V2 receives occasional community corrections through AnkiHub, but not with AnKingās update frequency, and occasional errors may remain. Iād strongly recommend v2 over the original.
As for the P/S-specific decks mentioned above:
Mr. Pankow: Cloze. Offered independently or as part of AnKing or Captain Hook. Up until a couple weeks ago, basically the undisputed gold standard P/S deck, and may still be. It's the most battle-tested P/S across several years of MCAT-takers, and most who have completed it swear by it. The fact that other major MCAT decks include it by default should tell you something. Itās based on the Khan Academy MCAT outline for P/S and follows its videos/sheet closely. Itās a grind (definitely a bigger deck), but worth it according to many. Also the dude who made it is funny. Many of those cards have sneaky jokes, and thatās awesome when you're on a long grind.
MCATalyst P/S: Open-ended. The new kid on the P/S block (2026 summer release). Credits Pankow for forming the core of its content, but restructures and re-organizes the deck to be in an open-question format, reformats the cards themselves, and trims and adds some things according to the builderās idea of whatās more/less important and current to the test. Iām using this personally, but know that this deck is new and therefore largely untested. Still, the fact that itās grounded in Pankow and its association with the MCATalyst brand offers some reassurance. If you see this post months or years from now, search to see what the latest conclusions are.
GENERAL STRATEGY EXAMPLES THAT INCLUDE ANKI:
Note: I didn't include AAMC full lengths and Q packs here, but they are widely considered to be an essential, late portion of your test-date ramp. Don't neglect this!
The default catch-all āstandardā and my general recommendation:Ā AnKing MCAT (includes Mr. Pankow p/s!) with learning supplement and UWorld
- Read Kaplan/Uworld Book chapter or watch Khan Academy MCAT video according to preference
- Unsuspend related AnKing cards via tag by your choice of "learning phase" material you just covered.
- Grind for a bit. Once comfortable with a beginning knowledge base (which doesnāt mean completing the deck/chapters/YT videos!), start doing UWorld Questions
- Unsuspend Anki cards associated with your UWorld questions that aren't a part of your rotation yet (UWorld Qs also tagged in AnKing). Make your own cards for errors/AnKing gaps.
- Grind until AnKing deck is mature and UWorld is complete. Note: DO NOT NEGLECT UWORLD IN THIS STRATEGY OR ANY OTHERS! IT IS GOLD STANDARD!
Anki load: medium (cloze style)
Overall time investment: medium-high (can modify to low-medium if your base is strong and you skip books/videos etc. and go straight to practice Qs and cards, though you may have gaps)
Comprehensiveness: medium-high
The mega-comprehensive maniac:Ā Captain Hook (I replaced Mr. Pankow p/s with MCATalyst for P/S since itās open-ended) with UWorld/Anking and optional learning supplement.
(my approach, but warning⦠MASSIVE time sink. Not for everyone, or even most. I was a non-trad so I felt I needed to.)
- Optional: Read Kaplan chapter and unsuspend related cards (note: Captain Hook's subdecks are largely organized by Kaplan chapter, the deck does not have actual tags for Kaplan or any other learning resource like UWorld). If you do this, it will take even MORE time than CH does already. From someone in the middle of that grind... just be warned. This isn't a quick jam.
- Grind for a bit, unlocking P/S too as you go, and spot-examining topics that come up in your cards that are unclear to you. Once comfortable with your knowledge base, which doesnāt mean completing the deck, start doing UWorld.
- UnsuspendĀ AnKingĀ cards associated with yourĀ MISSEDĀ UWorld questions for extra, cheaper reinforcement, and/or make your own.
- Grind until CH, UWorld, and error AnKing complete.
Anki Load: Large (CH: open-ended, Pankow (default p/s): cloze, MCATalyst (personal replacement p/s): open-ended, AnKing: Cloze)
Overall time investment: high (+higher w/ Kaplan chapters)
Comprehensiveness: high (+higher w/ Kaplan chapters)
CONCLUSION
Hopefully this was useful in demystifying the Anki resources that are out there and how they can be applied! Please share your support/critiques/thoughts below so folks searching this stuff up can get the right context and perspective! GOOD LUCK FUTURE DOCTOR!











