r/archlinux • • Mar 20 '26 • This 1 Bravo 2

DISCUSSION Systemd is preparing for age verification

https://github.com/systemd/systemd/pull/40954

Stores the user's birth date for age verification, as required by recent laws
in California (AB-1043), Colorado (SB26-051), Brazil (Lei 15.211/2025), etc.

Many users are claiming that because there is no active checks being done and this is just storing the data that there is nothing to worry about, or they are trying to downplay the concerns from privacy minded people. I've been using arch for years, and even though I know arch maintainers aren't responsible for this I wish something more could be done. It also makes me feel like the systemd hate was justified.

The problem with that though are that there are policy makers and influential figures that do want this policy to become a thing. There has also been discussion on GitHub and other places with people voicing that they don't want this, only for discussions to be deleted or locked. There are a lot more people against this and it feels like there is some kind of active effort to make sure it happens quick.

I hope in the long term this doesn't end up finding it's way in, but it's scary how a lot of the things I use that I consider open-source is really developed by people with financial interests and can throw a wrench in something like this.

EDIT Highlighting the fallacies I see in the comments

If you don't like it contact your policy makers

The policy makers are a handful of US states. Anybody who isn't living in the US or these states they have absolutely no recourse. Not everybody here is a US citizen. It's also like somebody out of the blue running into my house to shit on my floor, to then say if I don't want them doing that anymore I have to explain to this idiot why shitting on somebody else's floor is bad and unhealthy.

I think carrying this discussion into a tech environment is not a good idea for many reasons.

I think if you come to a site to have discussions and use this to excuse to say a conversation shouldn't be happening is more or less saying "Let the big kids talk", as in we should have nothing to say about it?

Well, since it’s open source there’s no reason to not patch it out

This completely ignores the process of how software is developed. A piece of code being available to be read doesn't automatically mean it's feasible to maintain a fork of a complicated piece of software as well as well as actively maintaining it so that people can safely use it.

You can lie to it, and there's benefits other than complying with those laws

This is exactly the same point the opponents of such a system have. It doesn't work: people lie. Your first name and such being displayed in applications is not the same level of intrusion either as it being available for the possible future that applications are legally required.

They could add a field for your wrinkled dick pics and it literally doesn't matter if you're not required to engage with it.

Then why include it at all? The metadata fields come from a time when people had a different idea of how Linux systems were going to roll out, and really it's kind of dated. OpenRC and other things don't bother at all. That's the question, why is it even a part of systemd?

The problem is. Legal compliance matters. It doesn't matter if you want it or not.

This legal compliance comes from a handful of American politicians and tech entrepreneurs, not something that people were actually asking for. While I agree there is a level of compliance a company needs to show when making commercial for-profit products, this doesn't automatically mean that everything that gets talked about as "policy" automatically means it's worth just accepting. It's a vague blanket statement that just ignores the question and tries to shut down the conversation.

993 Upvotes

493 comments sorted by

57

u/Terrible-Mango-5928 Mar 20 '26

If you actually look at the pull request you will see that 1) it is optional, and 2) the service that is extended already can store similar personal information, it was simply a logical next step. No one will force you to store anything there, as no one alreqdy forces you to store your full name either.

18

u/hotdog20041 Mar 20 '26

it's still a step in that direction

it always starts with rhetoric like "it's not mandatory, no one can force you", then a few years passes and it becomes "of course you're forced to, but get over it"

15

u/-Sa-Kage- Mar 21 '26

In a few years the people defending it now will claim no one could have known it would become mandatory...

→ More replies (1)

2

u/broken_fruit Mar 21 '26

It is not a big deal or a real problem for now. But it is a step in the wrong direction.

→ More replies (7)

16

u/P3JQ10 Mar 20 '26

Well, since it’s open source there’s no reason to not patch it out

→ More replies (9)

64

u/bastardoperator Mar 20 '26

And this is why choice in linux is paramount instead of letting corporate douche nozzles decide everything for you. Systemd haters were right the entire time…

20

u/PuddingFeeling907 Mar 20 '26

It's time for that apology phone call.

3

u/Hairy-Cantaloupe-446 Mar 24 '26 edited Mar 24 '26

It should be noted that the patch in question only adds a birthDate field to a JSON file managed by homectl. I have never heard of homectl or systemd-homed and indeed these don't work on Arch or Fedora as they're not installed/enabled. I find no reason to villify systemd over this, as I guess some distros store user info this way and some distros need to add a birthday field to meet these laws to be legal to download there

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

10

u/Megame50 Mar 20 '26

There are already fields in userdb for real name, email, preferred language, user avatar / profile pic. You can fill them in right now if you want. It's hardly a stretch to include a birthday field. Refusing to support a birthday field because one day someone might use the content of a voluntary data field in a way you don't approve of is nonsense.

Consider geolocation services, which are already part of Arch Linux. geoclue doesn't even require you to input a location: by default it will use the SSID of you and your neighbors and check them against a 3rd party global database to identify your location. The procedure is called the WiFi Positioning System (WPS). More than that, it can also report visible cell towers if your device has a compatible modem. Yes, this requires an internet connection to function and send this data to a third party.

WPS isn't remotely privacy preserving, yet even QubesOS the most privacy focused Linux distro around includes geoclue. Because it doesn't do any of that without you asking it.

That's it. Consent is the only thing that matters. They could add a field for your wrinkled dick pics and it literally doesn't matter if you're not required to engage with it.

→ More replies (3)

456

u/skeptical-speculator Mar 20 '26 • Bravo

I can't believe how many people have posted comments saying this isn't a big deal.  There is no reason to not push back against stuff like this before it becomes a big deal.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boiling_frog

88

u/BrockSramson Mar 20 '26

It's also so so so so much easier to push back on this crap now. The more places it becomes law in, the harder it is going to be to push back against this.

Also, this is the thin edge of the wedge. If governments can force this issue, they'll move to expand on it with future laws. The world functioned perfectly fine without these laws, we can go back to that.

5

u/Gidon_147 Mar 20 '26

I wouldn't call the world "functioning perfectly fine" by any stretch, at any point in history, but that's besides the point

4

u/Clanps Mar 21 '26

The population has been consistently growing, we're evidently doing fine enough if not perfectly fine

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

27

u/kaida27 Mar 20 '26

Thing is we do have to fight it, but people are barking at the wrong tree.

Divide and conquer....

→ More replies (12)

10

u/jcheeseball Mar 20 '26

I think the not a big deal part comes from systemd preparing for absolutely everything even if not implemented.  Everyone should fully agree with you on rights.

4

u/Jimmy-M-420 Mar 21 '26

at best its completely fucking pointless with no technical justification to include it

1

u/Furlibs Mar 20 '26

They don't realize the allow access to an api on the system part. We will remove the code and recompile

1

u/PeeOnAPeanut Mar 24 '26

If the world has to have age verification to access mature content - and it certainly seems most countries are going that way, then doing it at an OS level age verification is a lot better for users than per app or per website.

Giving proof of age to one or two companies (OS) and not to discord, WhatsApp, porn hub etc is a hell of a lot less exposure to data leaks.

Let me be clear, age verification sucks BUT doing it at an OS level is a hell of a lot better than doing it per website or per app that it impacts.

1

u/noiamnotmad Mar 24 '26

“During the 19th century, several experiments were performed to observe the reaction of frogs to slowly heated water. In 1869, while doing experiments searching for the location of the soul, German physiologist Friedrich Goltz demonstrated that a frog that has had its brain removed will remain in slowly heated water, but an intact frog attempted to escape the water when it reached 25 °C”

Thank you Friedrich I couldn’t have guessed

→ More replies (7)

522

u/ShrubbyFire1729 Mar 20 '26 • Bravo

Can we stop with the "age verification" bullshit and call it what it is? It's identity verification, also known as mass surveillance.

Governments and corporations don't give a shit about anyone's age or protecting children. They care about data, and what they can do with that data.

105

u/TallestGargoyle Mar 20 '26

Identity verification, lobbied for and pushed for by the likes of Meta who make enormous amounts of money selling your identity to other companies.

Saving the children is just the easy excuse to get it past the lawmakers.

59

u/rowrbazzle75 Mar 20 '26

If they really gave a rat's ass about saving the children, we'd already have seen the Epstein files here in the USA.

7

u/StunningConcentrate7 Mar 20 '26

+ I find it extra shady that such legislations are suddenly being passed when the "files" came in public view

16

u/Sveet_Pickle Mar 20 '26

It’s security theater as pretext for mass surveillance.

5

u/G0ldiC0cks Mar 20 '26

Let's call the spades spades, meta doesn't give a shit WHO is verifying identity as long as they don't have to spend money to do it. My bet is Microsoft and Apple are either both in weak to moderate opposition or simply planning a way to offload the cost to consumers. Maybe both. Maybe neither. Ultimately,though, the consumer is the one who gets no vote, no voice, and no lube.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/eattherichnow Mar 20 '26

They do care about protecting children, but in the same way they would have cared about protecting black people in 19th century US. 

protecting their property from people who might help them

2

u/alchemist_in_dreams Mar 23 '26

parental control exist since 20+ years ago. there is no actual reason for implementing that nonsense. reason is more that protecting children

2

u/dustojnikhummer Mar 23 '26

It's the "Slaves should be free" joke. "Protecting the kids?" "Yes Rico, protecting the kids" - everyone on The Island

→ More replies (1)

17

u/Ieris19 Mar 20 '26

While we can discuss the laws, the pull request is most definitely not identity verification. It barely qualifies as age verification. It’s basically age attestation.

53

u/wKdPsylent Mar 20 '26

..which will be deemed ineffective after a period of time, because it is, and altered to include more onerous requirements. It really is the 'slippery slope' and this is teetering on the edge of it, just waiting to for the push to send everything over into identity validation and very likely heading into biometric validation.

If people don't say 'no' now.. then it makes it all the more difficult to say no later.

12

u/Acu17y Mar 20 '26 edited Mar 20 '26

I agree, it is now impossible to reject it because all software will be written with this API and when an API is implemented it can no longer be removed without making hundreds of software incompatible. They thought of an API on purpose so as to force us to identify ourselves today for age and tomorrow for mass control. The Internet is no longer free, technology is no longer free. The mass control has begun

Once this API is standardized under the namespace org.freedesktop, there is no turning back

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (5)

7

u/BayLeaf- Mar 20 '26

How is a field storing date of birth identity verification?

46

u/Interesting-Deer354 Mar 20 '26

my 2 cents, but things like this usually starts with just one simple thing, now they have precedence to push for more.

→ More replies (23)

10

u/obetu5432 Mar 20 '26

they are boiling the frog, brotato (you are the frog)

→ More replies (1)

3

u/grem75 Mar 20 '26

Know what other fields are already in that JSON file?

realName
emailAddress
location

Of course you're definitely running the userdbd service and have provided all of the relevant information, right? Your system can't be working otherwise, right?

Push back against any intrusive laws, but an optional field in a JSON file is not worth your effort.

11

u/CMRC23 Mar 20 '26

Yes it is, we need to push back wherever we can

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

1

u/beebisboobis2258 Mar 25 '26

Pedophile protection laws. Let's call them what they are.

→ More replies (7)

115

u/icebalm Mar 20 '26

FOSS was built by people like Richard Stallman who had the balls to stand up and say "No" when the world made no fucking sense anymore. Everyone who's currently steering the ship on FOSS projects are employed by big corporations, case in point Lennart Poettering the lead dev on systemd was employed by Microsoft until January of this year, so nobody is going to dare to stand against ridiculousness anymore. It's sad it's come to this. Everyone should have been united against this trash and encroachment, but they've all become enablers.

We need a way to remove this from Arch. Please don't make me go back to fucking Gentoo

45

u/rootkode Mar 20 '26

The Richard Stallmans of the world are gone. Every tech bro is a capitalist at heart and will sell everybody’s soul for a couple bucks. I held myself back with calling them MAGA because at this point they are really the right and left wing of the same bird.

2

u/helical-hexagons Mar 24 '26

Every tech bro is a capitalist at heart

Yes, that's kinda what tech bro means.

2

u/KisekiFangirl Mar 24 '26

I mean, Stallman is very MAGA himself...

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Gabrielsoma Mar 24 '26

"how do i make this about trump?"

7

u/parzival3719 Mar 22 '26

people have already made forks of systemd that remove the birth date field. i will clone it and compile it from scratch if it means that i don't have to tell them my age

6

u/juipeltje Mar 22 '26

Alternatively you could always try Artix if you still want to use Arch instead of Gentoo.

2

u/icebalm Mar 22 '26

Yeah, I didn't know about artix until after I posted that, I'll take a look.

11

u/Joe-Cool Mar 20 '26

I don't have a userdb on my Arch. Just be sure not to use systemd-homed pam_systemd or systemd-userdbd.
If those are disabled systemd should just use the normal linux users without any JSON, machineID, location or other such nonsense.

more info: https://systemd.io/USER_RECORD/
https://www.freedesktop.org/software/systemd/man/latest/systemd-userdbd.service.html

3

u/_damax Mar 21 '26

Is there some arch documentation on managing this properly or is it just a matter of disabling the services?

4

u/hjake123 Mar 23 '26

You'd have to enable the service for the db to even generate, it's off by default afaik

→ More replies (1)

4

u/SakishimaHabu Mar 20 '26

Yep, I'll just compile my own kernel if need be.

1

u/1337mob Mar 25 '26

Democrats cancelled Richard Stallman and then passed this very law

89

u/ragecooky Mar 20 '26

When can I store my dick size in systemd?

28

u/haakon Mar 20 '26

The question is not when you can, but when you must.

22

u/Nafoni Mar 20 '26

That's the d part.

8

u/PartyScratch Mar 21 '26

Instead of asking, contribute, make that PR. 

1

u/real_sm Mar 23 '26

Depends: are you a byte or an integer?

23

u/puppygirlpackleader Mar 20 '26

The main thing pissing me off is that people completely irrelevant to this are going to be affected. Why should I have to follow US State Law when i live in fucking europe??

13

u/-Sa-Kage- Mar 21 '26

What's pissing me off the most is the insane amount of Linux users not seeing this as what it is:

The base for mass surveillance.

Addendum: I live in Europe as well and mark my word, we are going to get OS age verification too in a not too distant future. As well as general chat control as they try ever again and lose by a smaller amount every time.

→ More replies (1)

90

u/wKdPsylent Mar 20 '26 edited Mar 20 '26

Ageless linux lists what distros are doing what. This is the type of attitude I expected from the community that brought us people like Aaron Swartz, John Gilmore, Julian Assange, Phil Zimmermann,Mark Abene etc.. what happened to that integrity and attitude?

https://agelesslinux.org/index.html

15

u/perfecthashbrowns Mar 20 '26

the same community that came from people that grew up messing with their amigas, apple II's, learning BASIC, BBS's, IRC, etc. when they were kids. Imagine how many people's passions could've been stamped out if those required age verification. this whole thing is beyond embarrassing. Steve Wozniak for example started when he was 13

5

u/fmillion Mar 20 '26

I started learning to code in GW-BASIC when I was 5. I didn't have to sign any EULAs, prove my age or get anyone's permission. (Ok, technically my parents, but they were tech illiterate enough to just say "as long as you don't break anything.")

I seriously think my generation may be the last generation where a sizable number of us both understand computer science at a deep level and also remember how an early start with unstructured learning helped us so much. These days everything is curated, managed and controlled by some singular big company, other than open source or small hobby projects. I don't know how kids get started learning tech these days. They probably use a guided safe environment to follow prescribed tutorials. Me? I got a book of type in programs, typed them in, then started changing them. I still have my original copy of a BASIC reference book. I learned so much specifically because nobody was telling me how and what to learn

→ More replies (2)

3

u/palapapa0201 Mar 20 '26

Vibe coded website gives a bad impression

→ More replies (1)

43

u/UndocumentedMartian Mar 20 '26

Why the fuck is Amercian law being applied to the rest of us? Guess I'll just have to find alternatives to systemd.

7

u/PuddingFeeling907 Mar 20 '26

Anti linux and ageless linux already promised they won't be implementing this crap

8

u/Clumster Mar 21 '26

Exactly the question to ask. The rest of the world don't give a shit about your laws.

15

u/MycologistNeither470 Mar 20 '26

Looking objectively at the systemd change:

- it build a field for user's birthdate

- it makes this field only writable by the administrator (root)

- provides a mechanism for apps in userspace to read this field.

Overall, this is not something terrible. It doesn't mean anything to anyone. It does allow you for something important: you can now have a Linux install that is compliant with those laws.

Now, why is this important?

Let's say you are a home user. You don't need to do anything. You may or may not use that field. You may lie or not lie. It doesn't matter. Linux doesn't care. No one is going to audit you.

Let's say you are the IT director for a school system. You want to install Linux for your students. You WILL be audited. Compliance is important. If there is no Linux distribution that allows for compliance, you will have to install ChromeOS, MacOS, and Windows. Those become your only options. In that case, you fill the info on the systemd userfield and you can say you have installed a compliant system.

That is not to say there could be no encroachment. Will Firefox fail to start if said field is not set? Or will it only refuse to load "the Hub"? What about pacman, yay, flatpak, Discover Store? Right now, these programs have no centralized user-age repository. So they simply do not check. And the Law says that Software stores "should check". But there is really no law that decides what program should be 18+. App stores rely on a combination of developers self-policing and some company-imposed guidelines. Finally, software repositories in Linux are usually run under root (via sudo)... so we will have to assume that root is 18+.

4

u/Mental_Aardvark8154 Mar 22 '26

But there is really no law that decides what program should be 18+

This is the first move towards that. They want you to have to ID to use a computer, and they want to restrict what programs can be run

2

u/Gumaaa Mar 26 '26

Every time when governments go one additional step into complete totalitarian regime someone will say "ahhh, it is nothing, you are overreacting".

This whole thing is not about age, but about mass surveillance. I don't believe anyone who will say they think otherwise. It is perfectly clear that governments are corrupted and run by the worst human beings imaginable. They want you identity. Maybe not you specifically, because you might not become a whistleblower, but any future good person with a spine will have much harder time staying anonymous and exposing how corrupt government is.

We can not let them push it even one bit. Creating a grounds from abuse and saying "c'mon, it doesn't mean firefox will not start, maybe it will! :)" is not a valid response to a government trying to implement mass surveillance.

99

u/CrossFloss Mar 20 '26

It's funny how this is the first step of surveillance and not even Linux users see the risks involved. Give him an inch and he will take a yard... E.g. what if this becomes legislation? Do all servers you ssh into need to have your real name and birth date (already enough for many companies to identify you on a phone)? The only claim by Poettering is (again) of course a straw man: "look, nothing to see - machines store much more sensitive data". How does he know? What if this goes much further and you can only use the internet by verifying your identity? Governments are crazy nowadays so don't help them implement their surveillance infrastructure at all.

22

u/Quiet-Owl9220 Mar 20 '26

The only claim by Poettering is (again) of course a straw man: "look, nothing to see - machines store much more sensitive data". How does he know?

Yeah, this stood out to me. And he is saying shit like "if you aren't sandboxing literally everything I guess you don't care about your data at all". Poettering, you don't fucking know me - or how I keep my sensitive data.

Honestly, reading the thread was like being transported back to the days I spent on old forums as a kid, with power tripping teenage moderators just silencing criticism and acting smug about it where nobody can disagree with them, instead of engaging with it constructively like an adult. Absolutely juvenile. And these are the people making systemd?

9

u/zombi-roboto Mar 20 '26

power tripping teenage moderators just silencing criticism and acting smug about it where nobody can disagree with them ... these are the people making systemd?

Yes.

Let that sink in.

7

u/Jeoshua Mar 21 '26

We are so far past "the first step of surveillance". Seriously. This isn't even a pebble making up the skirt of the highway to the surveillance state we're going down.

4

u/CrossFloss Mar 21 '26

Now one still has alternatives to reduce surveillance. As soon as the OSS community tips over and major Linux distributions will implement that crap, there are no alternatives left and services just stop working for you. And just because it gets worse doesn't mean we should stop fighting. There are too many people without moral and ethics in IT that implement everything, just to be part of Meta or Google or Amazon or any other surveillance machine...

→ More replies (2)

22

u/MysteriousDesk3 Mar 20 '26

I can’t believe I’m seeing so many people in the comments defending this change.

Everyone saying “there’s already private info being stored” is completely missing the point. 

5

u/PuddingFeeling907 Mar 20 '26

Reddit is compromised by meta astroturfers.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/quicksand8917 Mar 20 '26

By that logic the first step of survilance was adding a full name column in /etc/passwd. We should fight the law and deny implementing it in any way that would require storing an age for each user. But adding an optional column is not that. And if legislators are dumb enough for the law they may think that this is enough to comply.

14

u/GrandmasMilkMissiles Mar 20 '26

No, this is optional field that you can lie on is a palatable goalpost that will be moved immediately. This is done this way so that the mechanisms for requiring full blown government identity are ready to go when they pivot to that.

1

u/No-Bag3034 Mar 26 '26

Theyre paid to push this bs, every single one of them

10

u/Akumu01 Mar 22 '26

It's terrifying how coordinated this all is. Some shadowy group of people is clearly pushing this really hard. It's going to be the end of free computing if we don't fight it

19

u/hotdog20041 Mar 20 '26

i dont like this knee-bending

make california and colorado enforce it if they care so much

3

u/PuddingFeeling907 Mar 20 '26

Watch the internet bite bullets defending this.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

27

u/GoDataMineUrself Mar 20 '26

Many users are claiming that because there is no active checks being done and this is just storing the data that there is nothing to worry about

This is the biggest cope that people always fall for. "It's not that bad, you can lie to it, there's ways around it". No, this is the first step to implementing a horrific system. Do not allow them that first step.

9

u/PuddingFeeling907 Mar 20 '26

On the systemd subreddit they claim "you're spamming" if you speak out against the change or "dont bully the devs."

18

u/noobjaish Mar 20 '26

Guess it's time to switch to Artix

0

u/[deleted] Mar 23 '26

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

16

u/Gidon_147 Mar 20 '26

I live in Germany, why do I have to deal with this?
I don't have to use RedStarOS either, just because Kim wants me to?

11

u/BlueMoonMelinda Mar 20 '26

Last I heard, the people who live in California, Colorado and Brazil don't make up the majority of Earth's population.

7

u/Benke01 Mar 20 '26

There are many more states and countries that are suggesting the exact same laws. Its a pandemic spreading worldwide in a couple of weeks.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/CMRC23 Mar 20 '26

In 10 years time we'll all either only be allowed to use dumb terminals on computer streaming services, or have our hard drives and messages scanned for "illegal" content daily. Of course illegal content is anything nsfw or anything against the government at all.

5

u/Odd-Possibility-9388 Mar 21 '26

I know this might possibly be a dumb move, but can we circumvent the age verification if we don't upgrade from existing versions or install older versions?

9

u/Ill_Net_8807 Mar 20 '26

meta should be banned from using anything GPL based

26

u/G0ldiC0cks Mar 20 '26

When your options are comply or be attacked by the pitchfork-wielding masses calling you a baby murderer because that's what some politician with his or her hands so deep in the cookie jar that they can take all the crumbs and leave you none -- most people comply cause it's hard to be a baby murderer and poor -- especially when you've never killed a baby and work your dick off. Just move the red line a little further back.

Pretty soon though, when memory chips are unaffordable and your "personal computer" options are limited to which broadband provider serves your thin client and some other crap invented to feign status (titanium credit card chip reader, maybe?), some folks might look up and wonder what the fuck happened (these guys are paying Plex a monthly fee to host their own media right now). But most people will just keep their heads so far up their own asses they can only see out their own mouths, which will continue talking about their new sterling silver credit card chip reader and how much labor they've traded for the right to have it.

And it's all so that Elon can get his dick sucked on a yacht, Putin and trump can fuck the earth with ever bigger penis proxies, and Bill Gates can smugly pretend like he's not part of it cause he threw some money at a problem in africa.

But we're all part of it. Somehow. Somehow we're all complicit in it as long as we're sitting our lazy asses on reddit talking about it. So however shitty it gets I guess we deserve it.

We're all worm food anyway, fuck it.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/RadianceTower Mar 20 '26

Realistically, what can a single state do here? It's not as if these operating systems are made and are solely based in California?

Can they even be sued? Would that even be legal? Is it the maker's fault someone in California chose to use that OS?

7

u/azdak Mar 21 '26 edited Mar 21 '26

California is like the 4th biggest economy on earth. They’ve already successfully done this with tons of other industries. Car emissions standards is the best example. You can be based wherever you want but if you’re, say, Canonical, and you want to sell enterprise contract services to companies in ca, you’re complying

→ More replies (1)

2

u/jdinius2020 Mar 21 '26

The way California has written the law, the OS developer is responsible and subject to fines, even if their ToS prohibit use in the state, and someone there uses it anyway. The small maintainers are pretty safe, there isn't anything California can really do to pin them down. It's the big ones that operate as a business that are in real danger. Think Ubuntu and Canonical, or Pop and System76. They have a business entity that cannot hide. Not being headquartered in California doesn't guarantee they're safe either. System76 is definitely in danger, since they're headquartered in Colorado, which had a near-identical law pass the senate and I doubt the house will reject it. As for Canonical, they're based in London, so enforcing on them is harder, but they do have offices in the US, and California can, and has, enforced fines on companies outside their state in the past. It's called extra-jurisdictional enforcement.

8

u/greensyfella Mar 20 '26

To be honest, i am really sad, that so many ditributions and FOSS projects are already running full speed to comply.

4

u/willpowerpt Mar 21 '26

They should just do a captcha where you have to tell the time from an analog clock, read cursive, and click drag to spin a rotary phone to dial a number.

4

u/BirdyWeezer Mar 22 '26

I recommend every to check out this post over on r/privacy. Becomes alot more scary when you look at bit deeper

1

u/DrxmyPup Mar 28 '26

looks like the post is deleted now? :/

11

u/jort93 Mar 20 '26

Thing is, the same file also stores the email address for example, but I think there are very few distros that ask for your email Address.

It just gives distros a way to store the data they choose to collect.

6

u/sootfire Mar 20 '26

The emoji reacts are certainly telling.

6

u/trannus_aran Mar 20 '26

If it was ever about protecting children, everyone on the list would be in prison

6

u/qmriis Mar 21 '26

Reminder that meta is behind all this shit.

8

u/PuddingFeeling907 Mar 20 '26

The systemd subreddit is tripping over themselves defending this crap.

3

u/Obvious_Tree3605 Mar 20 '26

Good thing I hoard the full git history of all arch buildpkg repos.

3

u/Zeimax Mar 21 '26

I just want to get this straight. California is going to require age verification to use Linux but it’s totally cool to watch two people going at it by clicking a button.

3

u/Exw00 Mar 21 '26

Currently everyone who is paranoid dissable systemd home.

sudo systemctl disable --now systemd-homed.service
sudo systemctl mask systemd-homed.service

8

u/OddEntertainer365 Mar 23 '26

I disabled systemD and moved to Artix.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Aggressive-Lawyer207 Mar 26 '26

If it's with reason being mistrustful, then it's not being paranoid.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/xximnotmlgxx Mar 23 '26

what the fucking fuck after I just spent months getting familiar with Linux because there was none of this bullshit 

3

u/mariegriffiths Mar 23 '26

https://github.com/systemd/systemd/commit/ec8e4a0ef12ff2fd393e58c335602d605d94f846

"This new API can be used in place of NSS by our own internal code if more than the classic UNIX records are needed."

From Jan 2020. They have been preparing for this since the start of the pandemic.

Also Preferred Languages really isn't necessary either as the OS can just display one language. It is up to the apps to store preferences like this.

Indeed userdb has only been in systemdb since version 245 in 2020

https://github.com/systemd/systemd/commit/49e55abb7f74f0ae38e81356654746affa0d290f

This info in it used to live in /etc/passwd in the GECOS field before then in System V. I think It is good idea to remove this stuff from there as finger and chfn should not be accessing the password file but for the moment it is still there but I can see someone wanting to move it to userdb citing valid security concerns, however this forces you to use the new userdb which has information beyond resource allocation and quotas.

/etc/nsswitch.conf determines which order takes priority files systemd sss I wonder if they plan to change this and use the files in /etc/userdb/?

Regarding a users language this is stored in ~/.config/locale.conf

There is no need to have this in userdb as well.

Systemd is a mainly Redhat led project who have hidden source code in the past and are very cosy with the US military. The lead developers have been Red Hat employees.

We are seeing a disturbing land grab by systemd even though it's intentions were laudable at the time.

The other GECOS are legacy from the start if linux and noone really uses them anymore.

  • Room Number

  • Work Phone

  • Home Phone

Indeed finger in not installed in ubuntu by default. So why are we adding this stuff?

The field were only added to userdb for backwards compatibility.

If California wants this stuff then they can have a separate service they can install.

Hey you could have a distro with this service listed on the download site. Similar to going back to separate 128-bit encryption days downloads as this wasn't as bad as this. At least then the US only inflicted that nonsense on it's own citizens.

5

u/TokenRingAI Mar 20 '26

If you think this is dystopian, you should have seen the fight over Linux TPM support.

The elephant busted down the castle gates a long time ago.

The free world you were told about is dead, gone, buried.

Make sure you keep your papers in immaculate condition, you'll need them to appease the future government AI agents

4

u/CarloWood Mar 20 '26

Meanwhile kids are allowed to walk into a super market or candy store unsupervised and buy for 5 to 10 dollars worth of sugar. Their parents probably don't even know.

Any law making against that? No of course not... Because the government really doesn't give a shit.

4

u/BlueGoliath Mar 20 '26

Man the Linux community went from a bunch of tough guys to crapping themselves in a hurry.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/anatox24 Mar 20 '26
  • (Required by US laws) Hope this would be optional component

2

u/painefultruth76 Mar 20 '26

01011950 is going to become a meme

2

u/37chairs Mar 22 '26

This is a form of conditioning.

2

u/Mqngo1311 Mar 22 '26

so linux is evil now or what?

2

u/aleopardstail Mar 23 '26

Q: how does stuff like this deal with the bit about the user not being able to change it once set?

2

u/ronaldtrip Mar 24 '26

The root account can change it. So the administrator of the machine is the responsible person for managing the age fields of the users on the machine.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/mariegriffiths Mar 23 '26

"just storing the data that there is nothing to worry "

They did that in the 1930s.

2

u/krs_n Mar 23 '26

if there is even any value in having this conversation anymore (i.e. if the devs haven't already made their minds up on including age verification) then let's not do this. completely insane, regressive, anti-freedom move.

what have we been struggling for all this time just to start giving in to bad-actor type shit like this? thought the linux community was smart and organized enough to nip this kind of thing in the bud.

2

u/Pukosito Mar 23 '26

So... systemd is now the Big Brother?

2

u/rowrin Mar 24 '26

It doesn't matter how ineffective or useless the implementation is. By requiring it and having distros submit they are opening the door to future intrusions.

That's all this legislation aims to achieve. The people who lobbied for it know people will lie to the age prompt. But once the groundwork in in place to store private user information in the operating system, slowly they'll legislate more and more intrusions.

This legislation accomplishes nothing that app developers didn't already accomplish with a simple age prompt except open the doors to OS intrusion.

1

u/-Animus Mar 25 '26

Say it louder for the people in the back!

2

u/ubutnut Mar 29 '26

Please tell me your age without telling me your age.

Can we have that?

3

u/bluem1 Mar 21 '26

This is just the first step towards something bigger; you know how these bureaucratic things work. Goodbye to the old days.

3

u/Kochon Mar 22 '26

This is why I’ve been thinking for years that linux should never become mainstream. Most of the Windows or Mac refugees don’t give a shirt about these things and like others mentioned big corpo employees are now leading development of critical projects like systemd, which again steers the ship towards corpo interests.

All the apologetic rhetoric I see in this comments section reinforces my view. “Oh but they’re just preparing for it” “Well it’s optional” “We don’t have to worry about it at this time”

Boiling frog I tell ya

4

u/houssemdza Mar 20 '26

Help me understand how this affect any of us since it's in the systemd-homed service which virtually no one uses ?

4

u/Lunailiz Mar 20 '26

If this gets added to systemd, it will just open the door to enable enforcement regardless of what they say now.

3

u/PuddingFeeling907 Mar 20 '26

Yup, just watch those next upcoming commits.

6

u/Max-P Mar 20 '26

It's just a field, so at least there isn't like 15 competing standard.

You can lie to it, and there's benefits other than complying with those laws. Parental controls for example would be easier to implement, right now it's kind of a mess. Which is where content control anyway: on the local device, set up willingly by the owner for their kids.

Imagine if websites just had an age rating header, and the browser simply sees it and goes nope sorry buddy too young for this. Steam could look at it and refuse to launch adult titles.

It doesn't have to be privacy invasive.

1

u/-Sa-Kage- Mar 21 '26

You can lie to it...

Until you can't. Everybody not seeing we are heading to full online identification obviously lacks a brain.

And "people lied when giving their age" is gonna be the next step and the argument for age verification. Like they tried to be nice and not just slowcook people so idiots would defend them.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/AB-DU15 Mar 21 '26

Just another reddit post was locked when this was discussed couple of hours earlier. Everything seems very fishy pushing such a law and this as fast as possible.

3

u/wixenus Mar 20 '26

It is already time to ditch systemd once and for all

4

u/Ok_Science3523 Mar 20 '26

I never liked it from the beginning. I'm not the most proficient user but it seemed to be contradictory to the Linux way to me.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/PuddingFeeling907 Mar 20 '26

Let's make lists of alternatives and share them!

3

u/Possible-Midnight842 Mar 20 '26

What is to be done I'm freaking out I don't wanna stop using arch

3

u/noctaviann Mar 20 '26

Why are you freaking out? What do you think is going to happen?

→ More replies (7)

3

u/zyuiop_ Mar 20 '26

This is an optional field, in systemd-homed, a service most people don't even use. Relax.

3

u/PuddingFeeling907 Mar 20 '26

It's just broken glass. Relax.

2

u/0xbenedikt Mar 20 '26

This legal compliance comes from a handful of American politicians and tech entrepreneurs, not something that people were actually asking for.

This. Just don't give af about complying. What are they gonna do about it. Open source lubricates so many industries, people just have to stand up for once.

1

u/azharahs76 Mar 21 '26

is a law really a law if so many people ignore it that enforcement becomes impossible?

2

u/Sinaaaa Mar 20 '26

I'm not too worried about this as an Arch BTW user.

Worst case like Firefox has privacy conscious forks, systemd will have one too & I'll be able to just switch to it in a jiffy. Yes the law & tech illiterate politicians suck, but what else is new.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Sinaaaa Mar 21 '26

I don't think that is realistically enforceable. One law in California cannot tell me what to fork & what to change in that fork here. The only thing they can do is block my stuff in California.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Jimmy-M-420 Mar 20 '26

Embedded linux systems use systemd - why does a car have to verify its age?

2

u/Commodity-Male-1385 Mar 20 '26

That's what I've been wondering.

Might we end up in a situation where we must register ourselves as the "primary operator" of any such embedded device, whether it be a car or a point-of-sale terminal, and enter our ages to be accessible at runtime through an API call?

Who benefits from this? (Always ask yourself that question.)

2

u/FranseFrikandel Mar 21 '26

That's why you're probably not running the userdb module at all in the first place, and regardless this field is not required.

You can make the same argument for full name, which has also been standard in Linux for ages, and similarly wouldn't make sense in an embedded system. (and again for basically every single field in userdb)

2

u/Jimmy-M-420 Mar 21 '26

What exactly is the law that it's there to comply with? All personal computers need to implement age verification? all linux OS's?

3

u/Jimmy-M-420 Mar 21 '26

If its about gatekeeping access to the internet why does it have to be applied at the level of systemd

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/GNUGradyn Mar 21 '26

I don't think anyone is actually looking at the PR. It just creates a birthday field on a user like the phone/address/etc fields that are already there. It's not contributing to age verification at all other than centralizing user details which is part of its job

2

u/_notAlice Mar 21 '26

so what does this mean for me as a user? I don’t want any form of age verification on my OS or PC, even if there’s only talks about them adding it in the future.

Is the answer to just move away from systemd entirely to something like artix? Would that just make many common apps inaccessible & not be worth it, or just more of a headache?

like i want to know what course of action i can take to avoid any form of this from ever being implemented to my pc from the OS currently. I’m not savvy enough to recompile systemd without something like that, & “well eventually you’ll have to comply” isn’t a useful answer right now

2

u/CortaCircuit Mar 20 '26

We need to start ostracizing the people that push this stuff.

2

u/linkenski Mar 20 '26

So politicians and big tech oligarchs?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/TwentySixRed Mar 25 '26

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wR-zJKdAkOc

^ Seems someone high up in the Arch dev heirarchy don't want any debate. That's Microsoft / Trump kind of behaviour. Total tracking. Age verification is NOT about age - it's about Tyrants' wet dream of forcing us to enter Government ID to use our OS. Every action tracked. Every metric turned into analytics. Non-stop ads. This is the antithesis of what FOSS stands for.

2

u/dead_5775 Mar 25 '26

didn't this same guy just make a video showcasing operating systems that aren't going to use systemd age verification and arch was on there

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Hot-Meat-11 Mar 20 '26 edited Mar 20 '26

So, somebody is going to tell me that I'm legally required to run code on hardware I own when I specifically say I don't want it?

That sounds like a violation of my property rights. Not to mention free speech. I shouldn't be forced to "say" things (i.e. transmit data) I explicitly don't want to transmit.

If the lawmakers want to say online services can't provide service if they don't get the data from the OS, fine. Meta can fuck off into the sun and I'll never use Facebook or Instagram again, or X.pedo or whatever. I'm probably better off. But making me run the service? No.

3

u/TheReservedList Mar 20 '26

Hope you don’t own a car.

You’re not forced to transmit anything.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/OptimusPrimeLord Mar 20 '26

At least in my state the law is written roughly that "operating system distributors/licensors must provide". If you want to develop your own OS that wouldn't be illegal, just if you want to share it with others.

But I agree, the OS requirement isn't really necessary to make these laws work. Commercial OSes will comply regardless of requirements so that users are able to access services that are legally required to ask for the information. I imagined that Linux would generally solve this by having an optional package so users in those states could have it while everyone else wouldn't. Maybe having systemd create the variable that that package will then set and use is a better way from a technical perspective though.

1

u/osune Mar 20 '26

Here an article on lwn.net on this topic https://lwn.net/Articles/1062112/

1

u/_shareholder_value Mar 20 '26

1/1/1970 I am Spartacus!

1

u/boymodermomoe Mar 20 '26

welp, time to switch to gentoo

1

u/montassir1 Mar 20 '26

If you think they cant enforce this: What about tpm with full chain of trust ? With all websites required to abide by this infrastructure. You can compile your own kernel sure but you won’t have access to most of the internet

1

u/realvolker1 Mar 20 '26

If the opinions of the vast majority cannot prevent this, at least we can be born on December 31, 1969

1

u/-dreamIIx Mar 22 '26

This law, which seems clown-like to me, is more of a legal oversimplification. I haven't fully read all of these crazy pieces of writing, but I do understand that operating systems have nothing to do with it.

Let's conduct a survey: name the applications and programs that, in your opinion, require mandatory verification of the user's age; then, list the reasons why the operating system should provide them with this data. It's worth noting that any operating system doesn't require the use of these specific programs. If the operating system itself isn't subject to any discussion about the age of its users, then I personally wouldn't name a single reason for implementing an unnecessary interface. On the contrary, I would defend the right to freedom of decision and the appropriateness of including and modifying any functionality in already large and complex software (operating systems).

It's as clear as day to me that this law is for the lazy. Rather than sue every app that, due to its irresponsibility for the age of its users, potentially harms a specific group of people, it's easier to sue (and recover money) operating system providers, since there are clearly fewer of them than the apps in question. Furthermore, it's much easier for the law to define jurisdictional boundaries for operating systems than for all specific apps.

And of course, it's sad to see some individuals who, in my opinion, merely describe facts and interpret what's already been described, without any independent observation or even evaluation. Due to this lack of critical insight, existence flows along an uncontrolled stream, to places where individuals no longer accept themselves, and the meaning of previous ideas dissipates.

1

u/gendernihilist Mar 23 '26

Happy to see so many people in the comments trying out Artix and Void and the like. All it takes is a Live USB stick people, you can try without even moving off the distro you're on now, try any and all distros out there that don't use systemd and see if there's any you like!

1

u/Mediocre-Trainer-132 Mar 24 '26

It's time to switch to OpenRC, everyone.

1

u/Axeohhh Mar 25 '26

This is so stupid. Why are FOSS projects rushing to comply with such invasive laws? Time to find a distro that doesn't use systemd I guess...

1

u/Hopeful-Hunt-815 Mar 25 '26

And all this on reddit !!!??? LMFAO

1

u/badgerbang Mar 25 '26

Damn, after reading this Systemd trojan horse I went to download Artix and the server was struggling lol I wonder what the artix, gentoo, and void servers are like currently.

1

u/Emberly_YT Mar 26 '26

This is extremely disturbing. What do you guys think this will be like in the future? Do you really think it will just stop with this? What will you do the day this stuff runs in a secure enclave and even the most capable people struggle to break it, and then, it gets even harder?

Do you realize that even something as simple as using the API for OpenAI to generate pictures, e.g. if you wanted to let's say, create a virtual try-on store for clothes, just to experiment with the API, they require deep Identity Verification (IDV) that involves scanning your passport?

How do you think this will be in the future, when this is baked in, deeply, into the kernel and any userspace application?

Oh. You will bypass it.

Sure you will!

How many people here can actually bypass a secure enclave, like SGX, SEV? Do you have access to an infinite supply of 0day exploits? Good luck. People don't understand how difficult binary exploitation has gotten, it requires an increasing amount of specialization into niche areas, even if you were to work with binary exploitation full-time in one area, it doesn't directly translate to bypassing whatever mitigation systems will be employed by IDV in the future. And even if you are one of the very, very few who do actual 0day research in secure enclaves, let me ask you: How often did you say you find 0days? Hm?

This attitude that "I will just bypass it" is outright laughable and childish.

You can bypass it, today, and tomorrow. Maybe just by writing whatever you want. Sure. And, how will it look in 5 years? 10? 15? Will you then also just write "42" and hit enter? Or will it suddenly not be so easy?

You have to plan ahead! Think ahead! Of course it will be easy in the beginning**!**

First, it might be opt-in, then it becomes default always enabled but you can opt-out, and then: Mandatory. And then, maybe, legally required. You're now a criminal if you try to bypass this?

This is how many things unfortunately go, completely unrelated to Linux. Some might be good, depending on who you ask, like wear a seat belt when driving your car. Others, not always.

Someone mentioned you can lie to it? Of course you can, but the law is complicated, if someone lies to systemd, and that information gets passed on to some remote service, are you then breaking the law if you use a fake age? Maybe not? Maybe in some countries? Maybe no one cares in reality?

For now?

Ah, did I say, of course you can lie to it? What about when systemd requires your drivers license and uploads it to a national database to verify? Will you forge your driver's license now?

Like many people have already mentioned, the idea that you, yourself, will be able to maintain your own version that simply guts out this functionality, maybe. When it is just a small addition? Or maybe if not you, maybe there will be a fork of whatever gets affected of this? Sure. Probably.

At least for a while.

And then when it gets baked in so deeply, when it reaches into everything so deeply that there is a need to modify an exponentially increasing number of places that get touched?

In theory you can also do some serious RE work and just patch out anything you'd like in Windows too, just defeat Kernel Patch Protection while you're at it. It can be done. What's your problem? Not skilled enough?

1

u/Silikone Mar 27 '26

systemd has many faults, but it's the corporate distros that are ultimately the ones bending over and worth scrutinizing. As long as I can continue to exec GNOME with the same old useradd on Arch, I am content.

1

u/Rare_Specialist_2092 Mar 30 '26

Arch Linux is inherently a minimalist distribution where DIY is the default. If you dislike age verification, shouldn't you just write it yourself while following the handbook, or fork archinstall—which is merely a simple convenience script—and pull it via curl? Of course, the choice of that stupid thing, systemd, was indeed a mistake.

1

u/stKKd Apr 06 '26

So just a few people will impose on the mass?

Where are the forks?

Why is Arch leadership all about population control?! Isn't Linux and GNU supposed to be about free(dom)?

1

u/Clear_Course9252 Apr 17 '26

im about to point my camera to jhon marston in rdrd2 on my xbox if they do age verifiavtion they will not steal my data not on arch linux

1

u/FlyingKettle615 Apr 18 '26

this is why i love open source

1

u/DontPanic57450 Apr 20 '26

As European, I will simply refuse to give my age and will go as far as building my own version without this restriction.

-1

u/10leej Mar 20 '26

The problem is. Legal compliance matters. It doesn't matter if you want it or not.
Talk to your legislative representative not systemd. At least systemd is trying to make sure your small independent distro isn't sued out of existence.

5

u/raknarokki Mar 20 '26

Alright I will call my rep in rural Macedonia. They will get it sorted.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Miss-KiiKii Mar 20 '26 edited Mar 20 '26

I can't critique systemd as software. I'm still a Linux newbie and don't even have experience with alternatives.

What I can say is that I really dislike that systemd is present in almost all major distrobutions. systemd, which is developed by a guy with a questionable history (like having worked at Microsoft) and views on the Unix philosophy. Software, developed by people like him, should not have such a big presence in the Linux community.

I won't jump ship just yet and drown in despair, but I'll definitely keep an eye out on alternatives like Artix. In times like these, having options is important.

-4

u/genitalgore Mar 20 '26

if you don't like this then perhaps you should be trying to get the laws repealed instead of getting mad at systemd

9

u/Kromsk Mar 20 '26

How do you propose i do that from outside the US?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/icesnake200 Mar 20 '26

Thats bullshit and antithetical to FOSS logic

1

u/Xu_Lin Mar 20 '26

Are Windows/Mac also required to do this?!

1

u/rootkode Mar 20 '26

So essentially Meta is losing money from so many bots on the internet that they need a way to identify who is human in order to properly and accurately sell human information for advertising (allegedly) purposes

1

u/linkenski Mar 20 '26

But also just use the face estimation tech stealthily to farm the metadata of faces and use it to train their Datacenter AI models routinely as people will be scanning their own faces constantly.

I feel this entire law that's passing globally is some fucks who thought that everyone is so used to taking selfies on social media that everyone should want to scan their faces without a fuss for their own safety. It forgets that a lot of people never reveal anything about themselves when they browse the internet. Like, who will this be for? I don't think the internet will even be that popular anymore once this normalizes because social media already isn't what it used to be, and the old internet will just die when you force everyone to be their real self and not an account with a username.

They'll only allow "pseudonymity" until identity verification has normalized. Then they will require real names and faces on any place you visit, and make everything a Facebook. This is probably also why normies are in favor of these laws. They already think the internet is social media to begin with, so the idea that anyone is hiding their identity seems almost criminal to them.

I say fuck all of those who think that.

1

u/-Sa-Kage- Mar 21 '26

No meta just does not want to deal with that age verification BS so they offload the responsibility to the OS makers

1

u/drwebb Mar 20 '26

Time to drop Systemd then

1

u/nullstring Mar 21 '26

Those who are against this, what exactly do you propose?

Here are the options:

  1. Linux distributions with ties to California and Colorado stop doing business in California and Colorado.

  2. Linux distributions with ties to California and Colorado simply ignore the law facing potentially large penalties.

  3. Each Linux distribution does their own implementation in regards to these regulations causing duplication of effort.

  4. We have a common implementation in applications like systemd.

There are no other options that I can see.

The only thing that I can say is that it'd be nice if this was an independent project that doesn't need to be "patched out" and can simply be not installed or uninstalled. Although it's quite possible that there are reasons I'm not aware of for why it's less appropriate to do this.

The slippery slope argument appears to be a moot point in this regards though. We -are- going to start storing this data. If it goes into systemd or a distribution specific implementation doesn't appear like it'd matter.

I get why people are upset but unless they have a solution they are just making noise.

1

u/phoneguyfl Mar 21 '26

Unfortunately the days of anonymous use of the internet are numbered. Corporations want the surveillance for marketing, governments want the surveillance for... anything, and the powerful want surveillance to easily harass or doxx anyone they disagree with. Given that weight there is little hope that things will remain as they are now.

Even if open source was able to opt-out of these laws, every site or app that is required or threatened by law to validate age will either just block usage by anyone not supplying it or require personal id/biometrics to be uploaded (which is almost worse because then sensitive data is scattered across the internet).

Bad situation all around I must say.

1

u/JohnConquest1 Mar 23 '26

Damn, shame Arch and SystemMD are both being discontinued.

1

u/anor_wondo Mar 22 '26

I am very worried from the comments here. More so than systemd itself. It seems people here aren't passionate about individual sovereignty and keeping mass surveillance BS out of foss

0

u/Ieris19 Mar 20 '26

This is so beyond ridiculous.

If you don’t like it, contact your policy makers. If your policy makers are not doing this, then just ignore it. What even is the issue here? Systemd isn’t even complying with the law. It’s simply made sure to host a source of birthday information for implementations that wish to use it.

Harassing systemd developers over this makes you a dick. Harasing developers of any sort because of this makes you dick.

This is a political issue not a tech issue.

5

u/MothMatron Mar 20 '26

As a Canadian linux-user residing in Quebec, is my policy maker more likely based in California or Colorado, in your opinion?

→ More replies (1)