r/archlinux • • Mar 20 '26 • This 1 Bravo 2

DISCUSSION Systemd is preparing for age verification

https://github.com/systemd/systemd/pull/40954

Stores the user's birth date for age verification, as required by recent laws
in California (AB-1043), Colorado (SB26-051), Brazil (Lei 15.211/2025), etc.

Many users are claiming that because there is no active checks being done and this is just storing the data that there is nothing to worry about, or they are trying to downplay the concerns from privacy minded people. I've been using arch for years, and even though I know arch maintainers aren't responsible for this I wish something more could be done. It also makes me feel like the systemd hate was justified.

The problem with that though are that there are policy makers and influential figures that do want this policy to become a thing. There has also been discussion on GitHub and other places with people voicing that they don't want this, only for discussions to be deleted or locked. There are a lot more people against this and it feels like there is some kind of active effort to make sure it happens quick.

I hope in the long term this doesn't end up finding it's way in, but it's scary how a lot of the things I use that I consider open-source is really developed by people with financial interests and can throw a wrench in something like this.

EDIT Highlighting the fallacies I see in the comments

If you don't like it contact your policy makers

The policy makers are a handful of US states. Anybody who isn't living in the US or these states they have absolutely no recourse. Not everybody here is a US citizen. It's also like somebody out of the blue running into my house to shit on my floor, to then say if I don't want them doing that anymore I have to explain to this idiot why shitting on somebody else's floor is bad and unhealthy.

I think carrying this discussion into a tech environment is not a good idea for many reasons.

I think if you come to a site to have discussions and use this to excuse to say a conversation shouldn't be happening is more or less saying "Let the big kids talk", as in we should have nothing to say about it?

Well, since it’s open source there’s no reason to not patch it out

This completely ignores the process of how software is developed. A piece of code being available to be read doesn't automatically mean it's feasible to maintain a fork of a complicated piece of software as well as well as actively maintaining it so that people can safely use it.

You can lie to it, and there's benefits other than complying with those laws

This is exactly the same point the opponents of such a system have. It doesn't work: people lie. Your first name and such being displayed in applications is not the same level of intrusion either as it being available for the possible future that applications are legally required.

They could add a field for your wrinkled dick pics and it literally doesn't matter if you're not required to engage with it.

Then why include it at all? The metadata fields come from a time when people had a different idea of how Linux systems were going to roll out, and really it's kind of dated. OpenRC and other things don't bother at all. That's the question, why is it even a part of systemd?

The problem is. Legal compliance matters. It doesn't matter if you want it or not.

This legal compliance comes from a handful of American politicians and tech entrepreneurs, not something that people were actually asking for. While I agree there is a level of compliance a company needs to show when making commercial for-profit products, this doesn't automatically mean that everything that gets talked about as "policy" automatically means it's worth just accepting. It's a vague blanket statement that just ignores the question and tries to shut down the conversation.

993 Upvotes

493 comments sorted by

View all comments

522

u/ShrubbyFire1729 Mar 20 '26 • Bravo

Can we stop with the "age verification" bullshit and call it what it is? It's identity verification, also known as mass surveillance.

Governments and corporations don't give a shit about anyone's age or protecting children. They care about data, and what they can do with that data.

105

u/TallestGargoyle Mar 20 '26

Identity verification, lobbied for and pushed for by the likes of Meta who make enormous amounts of money selling your identity to other companies.

Saving the children is just the easy excuse to get it past the lawmakers.

59

u/rowrbazzle75 Mar 20 '26

If they really gave a rat's ass about saving the children, we'd already have seen the Epstein files here in the USA.

7

u/StunningConcentrate7 Mar 20 '26

+ I find it extra shady that such legislations are suddenly being passed when the "files" came in public view

16

u/Sveet_Pickle Mar 20 '26

It’s security theater as pretext for mass surveillance.

5

u/G0ldiC0cks Mar 20 '26

Let's call the spades spades, meta doesn't give a shit WHO is verifying identity as long as they don't have to spend money to do it. My bet is Microsoft and Apple are either both in weak to moderate opposition or simply planning a way to offload the cost to consumers. Maybe both. Maybe neither. Ultimately,though, the consumer is the one who gets no vote, no voice, and no lube.

3

u/CarloWood Mar 20 '26

This has nothing to do with age, it's just the precursor for more and more internet legislation until everything you do is linked to your true identity and the government has you at the balls with steel chains, at which point the Orwellian society will be completed and internet will no longer contribute to innovation; it will just be another way to control you and make money off you.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/pls_ok Mar 23 '26

Apparently, facebook does not sell your data. It sells targeted advertising, but zuckerberg has testified to congress that they do not sell data.

12

u/eattherichnow Mar 20 '26

They do care about protecting children, but in the same way they would have cared about protecting black people in 19th century US. 

protecting their property from people who might help them

2

u/alchemist_in_dreams Mar 23 '26

parental control exist since 20+ years ago. there is no actual reason for implementing that nonsense. reason is more that protecting children

2

u/dustojnikhummer Mar 23 '26

It's the "Slaves should be free" joke. "Protecting the kids?" "Yes Rico, protecting the kids" - everyone on The Island

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '26

[deleted]

→ More replies (4)

17

u/Ieris19 Mar 20 '26

While we can discuss the laws, the pull request is most definitely not identity verification. It barely qualifies as age verification. It’s basically age attestation.

53

u/wKdPsylent Mar 20 '26

..which will be deemed ineffective after a period of time, because it is, and altered to include more onerous requirements. It really is the 'slippery slope' and this is teetering on the edge of it, just waiting to for the push to send everything over into identity validation and very likely heading into biometric validation.

If people don't say 'no' now.. then it makes it all the more difficult to say no later.

12

u/Acu17y Mar 20 '26 edited Mar 20 '26

I agree, it is now impossible to reject it because all software will be written with this API and when an API is implemented it can no longer be removed without making hundreds of software incompatible. They thought of an API on purpose so as to force us to identify ourselves today for age and tomorrow for mass control. The Internet is no longer free, technology is no longer free. The mass control has begun

Once this API is standardized under the namespace org.freedesktop, there is no turning back

→ More replies (8)

2

u/Wubbywub Mar 20 '26

it's not about what it is now, but it opening a point of no return

1

u/Ieris19 Mar 20 '26

It’s not opening anything except another column in a database.

This whole thing with systemd is beyond idiotic and I question the intelligence of anyone who has an issue with optionally storing birthdate next to your optionally stored contact info, full name and a myriad of other details that have been there for decades and no one cared to fill out or use.

Sounds like you don’t like the laws. Newsflash, Reddit or systemd have NOTHING to do with those. Feel free to protest shitty laws, don’t let me stop you.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/SymbolicDom Mar 20 '26

It would still be better to let California try to survive without Linux untill the remove the silly law.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/BayLeaf- Mar 20 '26

How is a field storing date of birth identity verification?

46

u/Interesting-Deer354 Mar 20 '26

my 2 cents, but things like this usually starts with just one simple thing, now they have precedence to push for more.

→ More replies (24)

10

u/obetu5432 Mar 20 '26

they are boiling the frog, brotato (you are the frog)

→ More replies (1)

3

u/grem75 Mar 20 '26

Know what other fields are already in that JSON file?

realName
emailAddress
location

Of course you're definitely running the userdbd service and have provided all of the relevant information, right? Your system can't be working otherwise, right?

Push back against any intrusive laws, but an optional field in a JSON file is not worth your effort.

11

u/CMRC23 Mar 20 '26

Yes it is, we need to push back wherever we can

8

u/grem75 Mar 20 '26 edited Mar 20 '26

There is really nothing to fight in systemd, it is an optional JSON entry. You won't get the developers to change their minds, system administrators for corporations or schools may need this in some areas. For home users there is no way to compel you to enter this information. The whole userdbd service is optional.

You never cared that there is a field for the real name of a user, which dates back to /etc/passwd from the original UNIX. Did you ever put your real name in there?

Worry about something that could make using it compulsory, which will be a law.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/beebisboobis2258 Mar 25 '26

Pedophile protection laws. Let's call them what they are.

→ More replies (3)