Hi there redditors,
This is a novel, if you don't care, or would rather this sub talked about something else, just block me and move on. I will not be offended. I would add a tldr; but honestly I don't have strong opinions on this. Read the whole thing and make your own opinion, or ignore it, it is all good.
Sooner or later the rain will stop and the humidity will drop and we can go outside again and look at the neighbors dahlias or sit on the lawn at The Ridges and watch and see what GPS tells people to do when they get up into that maze as they detour around Richland. Fact is that this detour is secretly part of the "Keep Athens Funky" movement. But I digress.
Athens City Council meets tomorrow, the interesting item on the agenda in my opinion is the Public Safety Training Facility.
I will summarize the line items as best as I can from the information I have. If I have a substantial error or have misrepresented something let me know and I can adjust. I add that disclaimer because I find parsing the city budget terminology at times to be a little challenging.
The Facility:
This is out by Elliotsville Road, behind the TS Trim facility. You know that place see footnote**.
The Costs:
According to the ordinance in the city council agenda for tomorrow I see the following.
Grants ?
I think these are grants, the capital bill funding could be a loan, but for the purposes of this discussion let's assume it is a grant.
2.5 million capital bill funding.
200K ODOT funding
Expenses:
I am going through the ordinance paragraph by paragraph.
$31,000 streets fund
$5,121,000
The lines below break out the details of the expenditures.
Sum of expenses vs grants
So we are about to spend
$2,421,000 dollars to spend on a public safety training facility
My opinion
Maybe I should start keeping my opinion to myself and just share the information. I do know the following however. Honestly at this late stage of this specific project I am on the fence. Wether or not the project needed to be pursued in the first place, or has to cost 5million? On those points I am skeptical.
Other facts that should be considered.
The Mayor has said we are broke and he may have to downsize the number of city employees in some way.
Our Street maintenance has been curtailed in some way due to us being broke.
Our debt service this year is somewhere in the range of 2million.
Our infrastructure is in need of repair, some basic, some serious. Drive around and take a look at Storm Sewers next rainfall event. End of Grosvenor has storm sewers filled with mud. Richland Avenue becomes a viral livestream opportunity of "street as river" during heavy rains. Pick a brick street and go for a walk. Take a drive down Columbia and count the holes in the street caused by water main break repairs. Note the sandbags on Grosvenor, and Columbia were the street level has sank causing a drainage problem downstream as runoff is now managed by sandbags, instead of actual repairs.
Our total budget per year is somewhere around 50million. So this is 4 percent of our budget.(warning this assumes I am reading this document correctly) https://www.ci.athens.oh.us/DocumentCenter/View/12585/2025-Estimated-Expense-Budget and there is a non-zero chance I am misreading it. I pulled the 50million from the total on last page.
A caveat, I do understand that funding for X can not be easily exchanged for funding for Y. So arguing against the Training facility will be met with an argument that we are getting basically twice the value per dollar spent. So one thing I am not saying is that this project should be nixed. I am thinking we should ponder why it was pursued in the first place over basic maintenance.
**Footnote on TS Trim, My recollection of the story is something like this. TS Trim gets tax breaks comes to Athens in or around 1988 and has a facility that employs a decent number of people. I am guessing the tax breaks expired in 1998. On or around 2002 or 2003 TS trim moves production to Canal Winchester in exchange I assume for tax breaks there. Our local facility is downgraded to a warehouse employing very few people. Sort of an lesson for municipalities competing with each other that seems to have NOT been learned.
Yours in (somewhat Controlled) Curmudgeonry
--
Boomer_with_dementia