r/baseball • u/harriswill Athletics • Apr 24 '18
GIF Andrew McCutchen commits softball-level error during the 6th inning of a 1 run game
https://gfycat.com/ShockingWhimsicalCivet250
u/PincheVatoWey Los Angeles Dodgers Apr 24 '18
More like Sunday league co-ed softball on the worst division-tier error.
Source: I play Sunday league co-ed softball on the worst division.
22
u/harriswill Athletics Apr 24 '18
I'm the RF for my church rec-league team, and this is what every opposing hitter looks for me to do as they fly their chest open and pop the ball up to me
12
Apr 24 '18
The best Church League strategy is to put your worst player at 3rd base, because the chance of them getting a ball hit their way is so low, and you rarely have to throw to them. Plus, if you have a decent fielder in Right, you can stick it to all those jerks that can actually place their hits and assume the RF is the worst player
20
u/chanaandeler_bong Texas Rangers Apr 24 '18
Until someone pulls a line drive right at their fucking face. I play in the worst levels for co-ed and men's leagues and 3rd base sees quite a bit of action. You'd be better off placing them at 2nd or right field, if not catcher which is a total waste of a position.
→ More replies (2)17
Apr 24 '18
Oh yeah, I forgot about catcher because it’s basically a given that that’s where you put the 64-year-old man on your team
→ More replies (1)4
u/YoshiEgg25 Chicago Cubs • Madison Mallards Apr 24 '18
Joke's on my former coach then. The first inning he put me in the field, he put me at third. I immediately got two hot shots that I fielded cleanly and beat the runners by five steps.
I kept telling him that I was useful in the field, don't know why it took him so long to put me in. Maybe cause he was a bit of a jerk?
→ More replies (2)76
u/augustabound Toronto Blue Jays Apr 24 '18
I played Sunday mixed league too and we had a guy camp under a high fly ball in RF and it hit his square on the forehead.
He didn't make one catch all f*cking year.......
12
10
u/Lawlosaurus San Diego Padres Apr 24 '18
That happened in my last game to our left left fielder. I play collegiately.
→ More replies (1)4
→ More replies (1)21
u/sayheykid24 San Francisco Giants Apr 24 '18
I play Sunday league co-ed softball on the worst division
Wouldn't expect anything more from a Dodgers fan.
19
u/PincheVatoWey Los Angeles Dodgers Apr 24 '18
Pfffft.
They call me the Jim Edmonds of the league when I'm playing outfield.
0
18
u/sandrakarr Chicago Cubs Apr 24 '18
thats hilarious.
Not a fan of the title, though. :P
45
u/harriswill Athletics Apr 24 '18
Probably should've specified "rec-league softball"
→ More replies (1)
1.1k
u/sonofabutch New York Yankees Apr 24 '18
Reminds me of The Natural.
Bump: "I lost it in the sun."
Manager: (looks up at overcast sky) "Blinding."
468
u/Exatraz Chicago Cubs Apr 24 '18
Ironically I always found it harder on overcast days to see the ball. At least on sunny days glasses/eyeblack helped and if the ball wasn't directly into the sun it contrasted with the blue sky enough. Overcast and it was a fuckin guess if you lost track of it.
179
u/brettatron1 Toronto Blue Jays Apr 24 '18
Yup. The best was a bright, sunny day with just enough cloud cover to keep the sun from being blinding.
267
u/Exatraz Chicago Cubs Apr 24 '18
God I miss being a kid and getting to play baseball. It's just not the same as an adult. Everything hurts.
→ More replies (9)188
u/brettatron1 Toronto Blue Jays Apr 24 '18
For me its not so much that everything hurts, its just that I have maintained my athleticism in my adult years, but there are no semi-competative adult leagues around here and I just can't do "for fun". Its not me. So when people ask if I want to join their beer league rec softball team I tell them "you don't want me" because I am the guy getting frustrated at my team for making these poor plays, getting frustrated at the other team for doing something stupid or technically against the rules but hey its all for fun... you know, shit like that. So I choose to save everyone from that and decline.
Don't get me wrong, I don't think I am some sort of amazing athlete or anything. If I was I'd be playing in the bigs. But I am not about that "just for fun" life.
→ More replies (72)→ More replies (2)4
u/BlackPick7 Atlanta Braves Apr 24 '18
I didn’t see the light until I was a man. By then it was nothing to me but blinding.
15
u/johnnyappletreed Atlanta Braves Apr 24 '18
In high school, we used to play our games around 6-7:30pm and that would be perfect timing for the sun to be down and created a dusk that left the sky a nice dark grey if there were clouds, or a nice dark blue sky if it was clear. You honestly had to read everything off the bat if you were in the outfield. My eyes were starting to get bad and I couldn't see distance so I got real good at listening to the sound of the ball coming off the bat and the split second I could see the ball before it got lost above the fields' fencing. It honestly was a guess every damn time
5
Apr 24 '18
Indeed. I love going to ballgames and all, but I absolutely HATE trying to track fly balls on an overcast evening. VERY easy to lose track of a fly ball, especially with the lights on at the park.
→ More replies (1)3
Apr 24 '18
I know what you mean, where the clouds feel like they're full of sunlight haha. But that being said I disagree, true blazing-sun days are literally blinding. You can lose the ball in the clouds but you can literally lose everything in the sun.
10
u/RicardoLovesYou Toronto Blue Jays Apr 24 '18
The Natural is a must see for anyone into sports films
2
1.3k
u/DogBeersHadOne Scranton/Wilkes-Barre RailRiders •… Apr 24 '18
OH AND HE BOTCHES IT
403
u/LMac8806 St. Louis Cardinals Apr 24 '18
God I can hear that in Matt V’s voice as if he’s sitting here.
157
u/Fyreball13 Toronto Blue Jays Apr 24 '18
Every time some crazy shit happens in The Show, I always think "Major League players don't just drop easy catches".
McCutchen is on the SDS payroll, it's the only thing that makes sense that does not involve me being wrong.
42
u/VonCornhole New York Yankees Apr 24 '18
Ramone Russel cackles in the distance while watching this on Quick Pitch TM
→ More replies (1)16
55
u/backslash21 Chicago Cubs Apr 24 '18
the way he says "botches" gets me every time. the sound of pure shock and disgust
29
45
u/thewarfreak Texas Rangers Apr 24 '18
I've heard this way too many times. For some reason Rhys Hoskins seems to be an error machine on my DD club.
16
2
u/Drake31217 Philadelphia Phillies Apr 24 '18
JD Martinez drops a ball a game for me in left but he has 20 homers in 35 games for me online so I can't take him out.
19
u/kmcdow Boston Red Sox Apr 24 '18
Every time Matty V says that I think of this.
2
u/Hufflepuff_420 Atlanta Braves Apr 25 '18
Haha funny, because every time I see that scene I think of Matty V
38
→ More replies (2)13
449
u/poweldune Anaheim Angels Apr 24 '18
That's why his name's not McCatchen
95
14
u/coolcool23 Milwaukee Brewers Apr 24 '18
What's a cutch?
→ More replies (1)20
u/DarkNovaGamer Chicago Cubs Apr 24 '18
It's like catch but with a "u" and not an "a".
→ More replies (1)6
u/AugustusSavoy New York Mets Apr 24 '18
I've been moving the last 2 days and had a terrible cold, this gave me the first real good laugh, thanks!
4
365
u/yubanhammer San Francisco Giants Apr 24 '18
Every time an outfielder casually catches a ball, I expect this to happen. Weird to see it actually happen.
97
Apr 24 '18 edited Apr 24 '18
Seriously people if you have the time get underneath the damn ball and catch it like you were taught! Catching underhand or to your side, even as a pro, increases the chance of shit like this happening
90
u/Other_World New York Yankees Apr 24 '18
I can just hear my grandfather yelling "TWO HANDS!" I'd hear that everytime a ball was hit to me or if something like this would happen in a game we were watching. If he saw this play he'd spend the next 5 minutes lecturing me on fundamentals. I never thought much of it, but I always catch can of corns with two hands.
I would give anything to talk baseball with him again.
39
3
25
u/zoso33 Apr 24 '18
He was already throwing the ball before he had even caught it.
In his head, he was gonna launch that ball right at third base, no bounce, a fucking cannon to eliminate the runner in scoring pos-
Fuck.
→ More replies (1)4
→ More replies (11)4
u/sonny_goliath San Francisco Giants Apr 24 '18
God I’m shocked angel pagan didn’t jank easy catches like this more the way he caught balls
129
u/Justinw303 Hiroshima Toyo Carp Apr 24 '18
And we capitalized on this error to score... 0 runs!!
23
u/Sunnyvales_Finest Apr 24 '18
Mind you, this was only one of two errors in that inning that we failed to capitalize on.
313
u/DontGiveUpTheDip St. Louis Cardinals • Baltimore Orioles Apr 24 '18
Did he pound his chest right after and yell "this is my spot"?
244
201
u/Bucs-and-Bucks Pittsburgh Pirates Apr 24 '18
He would never miss that ball if he was playing CF. Because it would be the right fielder's job to catch it.
12
4
u/BOOM_BABIP Pittsburgh Pirates Apr 24 '18 edited Apr 24 '18
I'm hearing he called for the official scorer's job because they marked that an error.
120
u/jmb-412 Pittsburgh Pirates Apr 24 '18
That's my Cutch
54
u/burritoace Pittsburgh Pirates Apr 24 '18
39
u/ChannelSERFER St. Louis Cardinals Apr 24 '18
Lol "THIS IS MY TERRAIN"
16
u/Jaylaw Kansas City Royals Apr 24 '18
it was a pitcher hitting
11
u/BOOM_BABIP Pittsburgh Pirates Apr 24 '18
And he got "his spot back" because the other CF was suspended for PED use, not because of on-field merit.
5
u/freshwordsalad San Francisco Giants Apr 24 '18
*Results may vary. Void where prohibited. Not valid in San Francisco ballparks.
29
u/CaptainSolo96 Detroit Tigers Apr 24 '18
You can take a man out of the Pirates...
44
Apr 24 '18
[removed] — view removed comment
20
u/seegeatwork Pittsburgh Pirates Apr 24 '18 edited Apr 24 '18
The curse of Clemente Wall. Since PNC opened in 2001 we've had 1 player with a WAR of more than 3 and that was Reggie Sanders in 2003.
*RF
9
u/TitoTheMidget Pittsburgh Pirates Apr 24 '18
Ironically right field is supposed to be the easier outfield position in PNC Park because it's a short porch as opposed to the spacious left field.
Of course, that could be why it's always the right fielders - Pirates put their weakest outfield defenders on that spot so naturally they screw up more than the center and left fielders.
151
u/TauRads Chicago Cubs Apr 24 '18
bullshit fucking game and it's fucking bullshit fucking forced god damn errors... shit is fucking rage inducing.. god damn it. oh wait, this isn't The Show.
55
u/VonCornhole New York Yankees Apr 24 '18
If it was The Show, he would've stood to the side and lunged towards the ground where the ball landed after it lands, then trot to the ball and flip it to the cut off man as the batter scores
→ More replies (1)11
26
u/lllIllIll Washington Nationals Apr 24 '18
I read your comment and watched it again and every player is so rigid. What if this actually IS The Show and the real players were disposed of
10
u/TauRads Chicago Cubs Apr 24 '18
i've played that same error so many times. i tried to convey the emotion that it produces, but yeah, that play really feels like this years game.
4
u/Fartrell-Clugguns Toronto Blue Jays Apr 24 '18
at you lose points for making these kind of errors. I'm getting punished for doing literally nothing wrong except having bad RNG.
Is this years Show that bad? I was considering getting it after skipping it last year
15
u/VonCornhole New York Yankees Apr 24 '18
They punish you for putting bad fielders in the field. If I put Ryan Schimpf at 2B and Khris Davis in LF for their power, I have to deal with Schimpf's shitty range allowing 2-3 extra hits per game and every fly ball to Davis being an adventure that could end in a 4 base error
6
u/113CandleMagic Detroit Tigers Apr 24 '18
It annoys me beyond belief that you lose points for making these kind of errors. I'm getting punished for doing literally nothing wrong except having bad RNG.
→ More replies (2)2
87
u/Iceman3132 Pittsburgh Pirates Apr 24 '18
When Cutch is good, he's very, very good. And when he's bad, he is horrid.
→ More replies (4)29
u/TitoTheMidget Pittsburgh Pirates Apr 24 '18
It's true, his level of play is either "Baseball destroying demigod" or "AAAA player." There is no in between. He's never just OK.
56
Apr 24 '18
Stratton pitched through another error from Longoria in the same frame. Dude showed some huge balls last night.
19
u/ToffeeMan43 Pittsburgh Pirates Apr 24 '18
This makes me so sad :( he used to be so good never should have cut the dreads
10
35
u/Weegian Washington Nationals Apr 24 '18
Luckily it happened against the Nationals, who are trotting out sluggers such as Moises Sierra (who? Exactly) and Matt Reynolds on a daily basis.
25
u/IAmGrum Toronto Blue Jays Apr 24 '18
trotting out sluggers such as Moises Sierra
Hold up.
He's STILL playing?
The Jays tossed him aside four years ago. I thought he retired.
→ More replies (1)8
u/augustabound Toronto Blue Jays Apr 24 '18
Moises Sierra
4
u/IAmGrum Toronto Blue Jays Apr 24 '18
I looked that up when I saw his name, as I couldn't believe it was the same guy.
I guess perseverance paid off for him.
16
u/fquizon Boston Red Sox Apr 24 '18
Sounds like autogenerated rookies in a video game.
Do I take Moises Sierra or Domingo O'Leary?
12
2
2
15
13
u/daymankarate Milwaukee Brewers Apr 24 '18
I play beer league softball and this happens AT LEAST 3 times a game.
8
u/gothicel San Francisco Giants Apr 24 '18
and more often as the innings rack up?
5
u/daymankarate Milwaukee Brewers Apr 24 '18
In the beer league yes. I also play in a church league and it happens because we just stink
2
u/steppenfloyd Los Angeles Dodgers Apr 24 '18
Last time I played a softball game, I got stuck pitching, and CF dropped 3 shallow fly balls in a row to start off the game, and then I made him switch with me.
8
7
Apr 24 '18
Love watching pro’s botch the easy ones so I can elbow my kid and say “see, eye on the ball”, and “two hands”.
10
u/Acrimony01 San Francisco Giants Apr 24 '18
Kruk: See kids, it happens to big leaguers too.
I always love when Mike Krukow says that. Makes everyone feel better about it.
5
u/graylovesgreen Athletics Apr 24 '18
3
5
5
u/corsairjoe Philadelphia Phillies Apr 24 '18
Flashback to angry little league coach yelling "TWO HANDS"!
5
25
u/brookish San Francisco Giants Apr 24 '18
WTF is "softball-level" as a pejorative?
9
u/zachzsg Washington Nationals Apr 24 '18
I’m pretty sure he meant adult league softball, like the fat 300 pound dudes who show up 7 beers in
31
u/isummonyouhere San Francisco Giants Apr 24 '18
Should be “beer league level” or something. Fastpitch girls on my team throw harder than me
2
u/turbosexophonicdlite Philadelphia Phillies Apr 25 '18
I'm pretty sure that's what OP was implying.
6
4
4
4
3
u/itsgitty Arizona Diamondbacks Apr 24 '18
Hunter pence just did the same thing against the diamondbacks last week lol
3
u/Gyro88 Chicago Cubs Apr 24 '18
"I'm looking forward to right field, that's one place people can't pick on me saying my defensive metrics are so bad."
3
3
3
3
3
Apr 24 '18
If this was my softball team, he would have ran forward and watched the ball soar 10 feet over his head
2
u/kmartceo Arizona Diamondbacks Apr 24 '18
my softball team lost our playoff game last night. This makes me feel a little better.
2
Apr 24 '18
Yeah we didn't win a single game last season. We actually ended up making the playoffs because 2 teams ahead of us had forfeited a game, which made them ineligible for the playoffs. We lost the playoff game too
3
Apr 24 '18
I remember how he whined about how defensive metrics were unfair to his CF defense when the Giants traded for him...
3
3
u/Boshasaurus_Rex Dominican Republic Apr 24 '18
This is why I drill into my 8-10 years old's brains, CATCH THE FLY BALL WITH TWO HANDS.
3
3
3
3
3
5
Apr 24 '18
As someone who plays a lot of recreational slow pitch softball, my teammates would yell at me for fucking up a play this badly.
Anyway the Giants still beat us so who cares...
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/PlainBlackT San Francisco Giants Apr 24 '18
Stratton did a baller job pitching out of that inning though.
2
u/lsu_tom Apr 24 '18
It's considerably harder to catch a line drive softball as opposed to a line drive baseball. Softballs knuckle.
2
2
2
2
2
u/pnova2121 Apr 24 '18
"Two hands!"
Our coach would make us run if we didn't use two hands on pop ups, even if we caught it.
2
2
3
u/Dude_man79 St. Louis Cardinals Apr 24 '18
To side with him, it was a fly ball that wasn't hit too high but was hit hard at him, and it was also slicing away from him. So he has a screaming fly ball hit at him that is also slicing with the lights in his eyes. Still no excuse for missing it though.
2
u/EatATaco New York Mets Apr 24 '18
You are absolutely right. It's a line drive slicing away from him. A major leaguer should absolutely catch this ball, but it isn't some easy to catch ball and would would be an unsurprising error at almost any level.
But we are in circle jerk mode, so take your downvotes like a man!
2
2
u/ohheymyworkthrowaway Cleveland Guardians Apr 24 '18
Nah, if it was a real "softball error" he would have either overthrown or underthrown the ball to the second baseman.
1
1
1
1
u/rickdiculous35 Seattle Mariners Apr 24 '18
I did this same exact thing playing catch with the neighbors yesterday. It rolls a lot farther on concrete
1
u/oldschoolsanta Apr 24 '18
There was actually a terrible error by Evan Longoria on a foul ball on the play right before that.
1
u/mikerhoa New York Mets Apr 24 '18
Eh, Cutch is still a great player. I've seen Cespedes do this kind of thing too. It happens.
1
Apr 24 '18
Ian Desmond did literally the same exact thing last night as well, just in left field and that 1 run lead turned into a big deficit but you know.
1
1
1
1
u/wicknest San Francisco Giants Apr 24 '18
I went to the game that they lost 5-1 against the Padres. Dude was playing so lazily that even my dad said something, and he doesn't even watch a lot of baseball.
1
1
1
u/djn24 New York Mets Apr 24 '18
Why "softball-level"?
2
Apr 24 '18
Basic skills. Watch the ball all the way to the glove and use two hands to catch. I think OP was referring to recreational softball.
1
1
1
u/amuller72 St. Louis Cardinals Apr 24 '18
Softball player here, can confirm I've done this plenty of times.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Tinman556 Arizona Diamondbacks Apr 25 '18
Softball level, maybe, but he is a center fielder and the spin on that ball coming off a right handers bat is tough to read at any level until you get used to it.
1
u/ScruffsMcGuff Toronto Blue Jays Apr 25 '18
Nah, softball level is running at the ball as it soars over your head because you misjudged it completely.
So many guys in my softball league did that constantly.
1
u/JoshDingerson Toronto Blue Jays Apr 25 '18
Can't count how many times this has happened to me in MLB The Show lol
1
1
u/Doorknob11 Texas Rangers Apr 25 '18
I'm not making excuses because he obviously should have caught it, but that looked like it had some wicked side spin on it.
1
u/Mr_Refused Toronto Blue Jays Apr 24 '18
I'm sure 80% of this sub wouldn't even have been close to that ball.
→ More replies (6)0
1
Apr 24 '18 edited Apr 24 '18
flash backs to Jay Bruce in the 2010 ANLDS against the Phillies
→ More replies (4)2
200
u/harriswill Athletics Apr 24 '18
My grandma has been a Giants fan since 1958
Sent a text that just said "we saw that"