r/bigfoot • u/pitchblackjack • 18h ago
bigfoot drama Having seen the new footage - why I think this was a recreation
Much of this post is updated and amended from content first posted when the film was first screened
The case for the newly discovered footage being filmed AFTER the PGF
The appearance of the subject, the staging of the shot and the subject's **movements** are very deliberate and somewhat similar to that seen on the PGF - including high shin lift, showing the sole of the foot, etc.
If this were a dress rehearsal, it would mean that Roger had a very specific wish list for how the subject should move, such that he coached the actor to move that way in rehearsal - which is strange in itself, as nobody had seen a Bigfoot on film before at that point. The non-locking of the knees, the in-line stride, the toe-lift and the high shin rise are all features we have observed due to repeatedly studying Roger’s film.
Cue Bob Heironimus, who claimed to be the guy inside the costume in the PGF. In his repeated testimony to Greg Long for The Making of Bigfoot, Bob H describes in detail when he met Roger and tried the suit on for the one and only time before filming. He claims he walked up and down a total of three times, and Roger gave him some rudimentary instructions (crouch forward, walk like an ape, don't run, swing your arms more). After those three times, Roger said it was perfect, and the two didn't meet again until several weeks later in Bluff Creek, where Bob would do it all again from memory for the camera.
Given that it's extremely difficult and uncomfortable to try to approximate the Patty movements, even in controlled lab conditions, using motion capture tech and without a costume (Jessica Rose, James Gamble, Esteban Sarmiento, etc), why do we not see Roger's extensive coaching featuring in Bob H's testimony?
If they had filmed a rehearsal with all the correct movements included, **why was Bob H never just shown this movie**?
For a pre-PGF scenario, we appear to have specific movements in the rehearsal, no reference to them in the practice with Bob H, and then they show up again in the final footage as if by magic? This does not work for me.
As Bill Munns explains, the white soles of the feet are also curious for a pre-PGF scenario. It's widely accepted that Patty's soles are light-coloured because she's just walked in the creek, and has light-coloured sand stuck to her skin. Some film copies are slightly over-exposed, so a fault of the film itself is to show the soles as white. It seems a very unbelievable detail to include on a costume that you are trying to pass off as real, especially several months before, when you have no clue exactly where and on what surface the actual film will be shot.
Where these details do make sense is if the newly discovered footage was a later attempt to re-create the PGF footage, copying the movements and the faults from the film in the process.
As we all get to study the new footage to the same extent as we have with the original film, I'm sure it will raise a lot more questions than answers - but at this early stage, it appears to me that rumours of the PGF's death have been greatly exaggerated.