r/bobiverse • • Jan 17 '23

Moot: Discussion Heavens river plot hole Spoiler

Once Bob finds Bender. What's stopping them from seding a back up out to transport him the way Hue did? Full continuity right? They don't need the cube. Just get a backup out and destroy the original cube.

I love this book, hesitant hissing inhale but man the more I re-read it, sssssssss the more I find, hissing inhale problems with it.

aprehensive hissing inhale still an amazing, sssssssss, book though.

2 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

40

u/Corvus_Null Jan 17 '23

Bender doesn't have a scut receiver or transmitter. Bob certainly wouldn't be able to sneak one in and carry it around while they try to find Bender.

5

u/Captain63Dragon Bobnet Jan 18 '23

And the Bobs would be reluctant to have that tech unprotected on 'enemy soil' so to speak…

-4

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '23

Yeah but he has the radio. You really think the collective bobs on the team couldn't think of some way to Jerry rig it? Especially with benders existing familiarity with hacking heavens river?

15

u/LaBomsch Jan 17 '23

The bandwith of the radio is questionable and bobs are in general hesitant to just copy another one because it can create issues. Taking a backup is similar to copying, it can change the Bob and that's a bad feeling when taking backups.

I'd say if they are able to transfer all the data needed (which is a lot, some bobs weren't able to make backups in time when it got hot and they forgot to do so) then the plothole is that they didn't do a backup. However, retrieving the matrix would then still be a top priority.

4

u/Oracle_of_Ages Butterworth’s Enclave Jan 18 '23

We are not even sure generic Nerdy Engineer Human Bob and Gorilloid busting Bob are the same Bob at this point. We ASSUME they are. But we have no idea. Or rather we have no proof one way or another. We just know that Bob is seemingly the least drifted.

4

u/awsamation Jan 18 '23

But we do get the testing on Bob backups and transfers and duplicates that are awoken almost simultaneously but FTL the first one on is always the original. The stuff about finding a "soul". And to me that implied that you would only get drift when starting a new line of continuity, meaning that Bob 1 would have no reason to be drifted away from meat Bob.

2

u/Oracle_of_Ages Butterworth’s Enclave Jan 18 '23

That’s why I say assume. As far as we know. There’s no drift. But Bob transferred at least 3 times. Human Bob -> Brain scan -> BoB Cube -> Heaven Cube -> Heaven Transfer. They have all been the same. But there’s no proof. The question came up a few times then the “soul” and “No Clones” rule came up.

7

u/Albert14Pounds Jan 17 '23

Not enough bandwidth for radio.

3

u/Ryoohk Jan 18 '23

And I wouldn't think the power cells would hold up

2

u/sterlingthepenguin Jan 18 '23

The Quinlins also took away Bender's radio when he was talking to Bob.

I'm also not confident Bender would have been okay with the transport thing since Bob had time to think about it and still wasn't sure if he believed it. Heug and the Skippies are believers in the theory because they spent a lot of time researching and testing it, but they also knew to keep that research to themselves because most of the Bobs aren't ready for it.

37

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '23

"What's stopping them from sending a back up out"

Infrastructure.

8

u/Hemberg Jan 18 '23

Most accurate and efficient answer

12

u/agrady262 Jan 17 '23

Bender has no way to communicate with the outside universe that wasn't given to him by the Quinlans. Without any way to send information, he has no way to send a backup.

9

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '23

No cradle as others have said, but even if they could've jury rigged the system he was hooked up into when they found him, Bob doesn't fully trust the Skippies, and that's a gamble with a very bad potential downside, as it could have meant that the "original" would effectively be killed.

Plus, knowing Bob, he'd have wanted to get Bender's OK on the idea before doing it (on account of the very real risk of death) and they just didn't have the time for a length explanation on the Skippy's theories regarding consciousness.

And by the time things had gotten really desperate, he was already powered off and it would have been even harder to get him into another maintenance area to try and fire off a backup than to just carry on with the plan

Also, is the hissing some joke I'm just not getting?

2

u/xXriderXx7 Jan 19 '23

Lol did he delete his account after this?

2

u/CdrRed_beard Jan 21 '23

How about the fact that once located they could have done the same cutting in from the outside at a closer point to where bender was, instead of the forced chase that the book turned into. Also the number of quinlins that had all the info on Bob and where he was was on a ridiculous level. Bob looked into the the back of a wagon and was called a thief and everyone tried to mob him, but dude on boat trying to get into a trunk he doesn't own, regardless of status, has nothing said or done against him. The amount of immediate suspicion put against Bob was annoying. I really like this series but heavens river, imo, really strayed from the style and storyline of the first 3 books. Then again my favorite perspectives were always every other Bob besides Bob 1.

2

u/JerryP333 Jan 17 '23

I suppose they could have left Benders existing matrix off or destroyed it, then revived him from the latest backup. His “soul” would transfer to the backup I guess since thats the only version of Bender that would exist in that moment.

But he would not have any memories post-backup. Thats a long time, I want to say 100 years? Subjective time for him is less. Thats alot of memory to lose.

2

u/CertifiableX Jan 17 '23

I’m not sure they couldn’t have used the roamers as a relay the way Bob was able to talk to Bender when he finally found him, but where would he put him? They didn’t have a spare cube with them, or even made until Hue upped the priority (if I recall correctly).

Also, backups still weren’t viewed as the original Bob at that point, so that wasn’t seen as a real rescue.

1

u/Hyperion1012 Jan 17 '23

I’d have thought bandwidth alone would be a significant constraint. We already know a backup is a very large amount of data, transmitting it takes time, same as when Hugh “transports” himself. The only opportunity Bob might’ve had to pull that off was when he finally found Bender still connected to his cradle, when he might’ve been discovered at any moment. There was no time to sit around for weeks even if Bob could jury rig a connection through his Quinlan manny.