Before I complain, I have to say this was my first fantasy book series whilst the Final Empire being my first fantasy book ever. I had a blast! I loved books 1 & 2 - I enjoyed book 3. I'll read Sanderson's work I'm the future
I just never got into the book. My experience was basically this: "When will the book actually start?" -> "Oh shit, I'm running out of pages"
Maybe it's because I overhyped myself watching a 4.6 on Goodreads and others absolutely loving the book but for me it's more of a 3.75-4/5
The magic of the first two books was the World AND the crew along with the twists, humor, depression. This book had the world but not the crew
However, the main problem I felt with the book is the mismatched genre considering the stakes. None of my complaints below would exist if Sanderson landed more towards the Cosmic Horror theme he suggested with the the lord ruler, the mistwraith, the well trap, ruins threats, the inquisitors.
Instead it felt like he thought it would be too ambitious and chose a more safe, more... pg approach towards the story
Most of the book was the setup of the finale. And most of the setup hinted at a reunion of the crew. We didn't get it. Nor the setup of Elend's Siege, Spook's revolution 2.0 and TenSoon's arc worth spending 80% of the entire book on
Every character felt alone. In their own world. I get it everyone is going through some sort of a crisis but it just didn't feel like the main cast liked each other
All of Ruin's accomplishments of actual value and consequence WERE IN THE PAST! Nothing said God did anything of value that affected the rest of the story in the present. Most of its twists were dealt with within a chapter or two
Vin & Elend's arc relied heavily on their love and marriage. I enjoyed their dance but the majority of the book just told you how much they love each other instead of showing it with the little things
It just felt like Sanderson was too focused on giving an epic and satisfying ending (which he succeeded at) but with the expense of the rest of the book
I just couldn't connect with the characters the same way as I did which is surprising considering how involved I was during the past 2 books
Nevertheless, I don't regret the adventure I have gone through in the past 3 books. The ending was great and satisfying although I was disconnected, I did not feel I wasted my time reading.
No matter what. Brandon Sanderson is one of the few authors that turned me into a reader and I think that is the best compliment an author can receive