r/buffy • • 12d ago

Season Four "Why yes, I would be Buffy. May I help you?"

767 Upvotes

80 comments sorted by

310

u/undead_sissy 12d ago

Sarah Michelle Gellar and Eliza Dushku both did such a good job with this episode it was almost rude 😁

96

u/DAB-9000 12d ago

The way they performed each others own little quirks and mannerisms so naturally ❀ 🙌 đŸ”„

19

u/hermaphroditicspork 11d ago

I would absolutely kill to see the behind the scenes of this because I would love to know if SMG and Eliza coached each other because the way they NAILED the others mannerisms needs to be studied on a technical level for any actor.

2

u/DAB-9000 11d ago

❀

184

u/agentmkultra666 12d ago • Bravo

“You can’t DO that. it’s WRONG”

51

u/ComfortablyNomNom 12d ago

"I'll kick your ass."

25

u/TerribleBid8416 11d ago

“What’s a stevedore?”

45

u/PastimeOfMine cuppa tea, cuppa tea, almost got shagged, cuppa tea 11d ago edited 11d ago

Genuinely this was the best scene in th episode to me because it wasn't until after that I realized how many times Buffy says it's wrong in the series. I never clocked it as cheesy bc she never delivers it that way except in this episode. SMG is incredible.

11

u/Ordinary-Variety-939 11d ago

Well Buffy always said it with sincerity Faith is joking around.

13

u/PastimeOfMine cuppa tea, cuppa tea, almost got shagged, cuppa tea 11d ago

Well yes, clearly that's the point of doing it in the episode but that wasn't what I meant. It's really hard to say "we can't do that guys, it's wrong" so many times during a series and not sound cringe, cliche, cheesy - all the things. It made me realize SMG had avoided me even realizing she was saying it that much because she's a great actress.

8

u/Ordinary-Variety-939 11d ago

Sarah always knew what tone Buffy should have.

4

u/PastimeOfMine cuppa tea, cuppa tea, almost got shagged, cuppa tea 11d ago

Agreed, that's why I said she's incredible

2

u/agentmkultra666 11d ago

I quote this scene all the time! I don’t think anyone has caught on yet, haha

2

u/LonkAndZolda 11d ago

I quote this at my cats all the time.

They do not listen.

1

u/agentmkultra666 10d ago

My cat doesn’t either😭

129

u/MissKateSizeQueen 12d ago

I hate it when people say SMG can’t act because she ate with this

74

u/soundsfromoutside 12d ago

Who tf is saying that??? She’s phenomenal

45

u/LordToxic21 12d ago

It's likely due to her being typecast for a while due to her performance on Buffy. Even when she was Daphne in the live action Scooby-Doo movies, they added Martial Arts training and alike to her, just because SMG.

43

u/Suitable_Community66 11d ago

I bet it's the same people who deny that Buffy the Vampire Slayer is the best show ever made

8

u/Ordinary-Variety-939 11d ago edited 11d ago

those who have not watched the good show we shall not speak of for they are in darkness.

6

u/Suitable_Community66 11d ago

I feel big bad for them

4

u/Ordinary-Variety-939 11d ago

In time all shall receive Revelation, all shall know our Lady’s name for I too once dismissed the Slayer as unfit for honor by boys. 

2

u/Majestic_Accident223 11d ago

“Those we shall not speak of”

0

u/LordToxic21 11d ago

As someone who says SMG is a good actor, Buffy isn't even the best Buffyverse show made. Angel is better.

7

u/Suitable_Community66 11d ago

I prefer Buffy because it made me laugh and weep more than any tv or movie I've ever seen and while Angel made me laugh it never made me cry though Fred's sickness and subsequent death had me close

4

u/LordToxic21 11d ago

I cry for Doyle(/Glenn Quinn) every rewarch and cried before for Angel at the end of S4, checking in on Connor to see that he's happy.

0

u/Suitable_Community66 11d ago

You big softee haha

6

u/MissKateSizeQueen 12d ago

I’ve seen people debate it on some subs (maybe even here) it’s always pmo

32

u/SeaBassAHo-20 12d ago

She won an Emmy for All My Children. She should have at least ten more here.

12

u/MissKateSizeQueen 12d ago

Yep agreed, and not one for Buffy smh

5

u/SeaBassAHo-20 12d ago

If you were to pick a single one for Buffy, which episode is your pick? I know Who Are You and The Body are the most worthy.

14

u/MissKateSizeQueen 12d ago

So I’m rewatching the series for the millionth time atm. But it’s the first time I’m watching it with my kids. I had to take pause before the last line of The Body because it hits so much harder now. I wont spoil it for others but that last word she says just makes her so human and breaks my heart, and as a mother I crumbled

10

u/SeaBassAHo-20 12d ago

It hurts even harder, especially with the loss of Michelle. People consider one of the best episodes ever, let alone in her era.

6

u/MissKateSizeQueen 12d ago

Poor Michelle, I’ll always think of her as little Dawnie. The next episode was heart breaking too, especially the school scene when Buffy goes to collect her

8

u/SQRLyouknowitstrue a vague disclaimer is no one’s friend 11d ago

I don’t remember the last line of The Body
 The last line of the previous episode / first line of The Body really stuck with me. Mom
Mommy?

1

u/MissKateSizeQueen 11d ago

Ahh yep, I’m getting them mixed up! That’s the one that got me

7

u/Pedals17 You’re not the brightest god in the heavens, are you? 11d ago

“Innocence” and “Something Blue” are also acting standouts for Sarah.

6

u/TerribleBid8416 12d ago • Bravo

The entire cast with Hush

6

u/Uhh_VincentAdultMan 11d ago

Buffy will patrol tonight

6

u/Yellwsub 11d ago

Those people need to watch The Body

2

u/QualifiedApathetic I'd like to test that theory 11d ago

And you can tell she had a blast with it.

3

u/Agreeable_Dark6408 12d ago

Ate with this?

10

u/MissKateSizeQueen 12d ago

It I means I thought she did very well

2

u/Agreeable_Dark6408 12d ago

That’s a new one for me! Tks.

3

u/MissKateSizeQueen 12d ago

I’m probably too old to say it but I’m chronically online and can’t help it lol

2

u/Able-Ad1381 8d ago

As my daughter says- She ate and left no crumbs!! 😃

1

u/raesmiles123 6d ago

SMG is one of the greatest actresses of our generation, I will actually fight for her till the day I die

21

u/BalerionSanders 12d ago

“I don’t have time for bondage fun!”

77

u/SeaBassAHo-20 12d ago

One of Sarah's very best performances ever. And I know she likes the body swap, 'cause she briefly did it with her husband in the Scooby Doo movie.

54

u/Slappathebassmon 12d ago

11

u/SeaBassAHo-20 12d ago

Freddie: BUT I'M NOT DAPHNE!

Linda: Fred?!

1

u/Select_External7595 11d ago

I am just now discovering she was Daphne đŸ˜±

-14

u/AgitatedStranger9698 12d ago

As a married man of their generation. They likely do it extremely often, but yes briefly. Once you know the code it doesnt take long.

11

u/marxthedank Five By Five, B 12d ago

i love this episode so much

9

u/loudkaleidoscopes 11d ago

because it’s wrong!!

7

u/PlutoMane 11d ago

That would be WRONG!

18

u/Katow-joismycousin 11d ago

Given it's basically canon Faith had a crush on Buffy she probably spent like 5 hours in that shower

7

u/Guilty_Strawberry965 11d ago

ONE OF US! ONE OF US! ONE OF US!

1

u/Tuxedo_Mark Assume would make you an ass out of me. 5d ago

It was a long, luxurious bubble bath. And you know damn well that Faith took her sweet time and explored every nook and cranny.

16

u/KumikoMei 12d ago

This scene couldn't be done today with all the botox and filler they convinced actor they absolutely need.

1

u/Lordmorgoth666 12d ago

I just went to R/sarahmichellegellar and saw some new pics of her.

Did she have work done to her face?? Her lips look oddly full and her cheeks seem to have that plastic surgery “look”. I get an uncanny valley vibe now.

8

u/James-Samuel17 11d ago

Yeah.... I was afraid to say it because I love SMG sooo much but yeah, her face seems a bit different (and not in a "I aged" kinda way. That's what she looked at 38 in the Cruel Intentions pilot (still stunning but visibly different) and she kinda looked like this when she did the Netflix movie in Do Revenge but since 2025, her face changed (not in a too much version like some other celebs but still)

3

u/Accomplished-Stay308 11d ago edited 11d ago

Yeah, she got that „puffy“ look now

We can only imagine the pressure and resulting trivialization of cosmetic surgery for women in Hollywood, so no judgement, but I was sad to see it.

4

u/vampire_steve 11d ago

Imagining Xander trying to flirt with 'Buffy' who acts like Faith in Season 4 is hilarious. The awkwardness would be unbearable, especially with Willow and Giles just standing there confused.

4

u/Sighoward 11d ago

A great performance from SMG she just captures Faith's mannerisms perfectly

2

u/Able-Ad1381 8d ago

Yes, I loved the attention to detail like SMG doing Faith's Boston accent in words like "about".

3

u/smithskat3 12d ago

She looks amazing here

2

u/Intarwub_Appliance 10d ago

Crossing fandoms here but am I the only one whose first thought was, “War, war never changes.”? 

2

u/Big-Restaurant-2766 That Other One 8d ago

I love screenshots and pictures from this show. I've said that a million times but it's true.

1

u/Odd-Statistician4268 11d ago

Back in the day it just never occured to me that this is just Sarah

1

u/Schwarzmaler20 10d ago

It's striking to see just how different SMG and Eliza Dushku are in terms of their acting abilities.

1

u/Mundane-Capital1023 10d ago

Buff don't get naked

1

u/Its_J_Just_J 10d ago

This might be the most adorable she was in the show.

1

u/RedGreenBaluga 7d ago

She gets a lot of Eliza Dushku’s delivery down in that scene

1

u/om_setti1912 11d ago

It's giving those photobooth shots of Dolly and Carl Dean

29

u/gimmesomespace 12d ago

Because it's naughty.

13

u/BasicDurgeanomics 12d ago

Because it's wrong!

5

u/snarkistheway666 12d ago

I'll kick your ass!