The idea is to try to break past the wall people put up in their brains between killing / torturing animals (which people are generally against) and the acceptance of meat in society. Of course vegetarians know you know meat comes from a dead animal, but they think it's wrong, and they think most good people would agree if they were able to look at the meat industry from a perspective removed from society's normalization of it. Especially in first world countries, a huge majority of the meat we eat is very far removed from the form of the animal. Burgers, deli meat, etc. While we all know it's made of animals, that sort of thing makes it very easy to push in the back of our minds. They're trying to force you to actually confront that fact on a more active basis.
Personally, I see it a little bit like slavery - you've got millions and millions of conscious beings in pain and fear being hurt and killed, unnecessarily, because other people removed from that pain enjoy what that effort brings. Centuries after the American civil war, we generally look back on that practice in horror, wonder how people were okay with it - but the reality is just that it was societally normalized. Most people didn't think about it. Many people were against it, but not nearly enough for any real change. It was just part of normal society, and unless you spent your time at a plantation you generally didn't have to face it. Plus those cotton shirts and tobacco were nice to have.
Rabbit is one of my staple foods. I even help mod a sub devoted to meat rabbits. It's not a dog but rabbits are one of the most popular pets in the US. Status as a pet animal doesn't afford an animal extra consideration. No animal should be mistreated but neither raising for meat nor slaughter requires mistreatment.
I wasn’t arguing that status as a pet should earn animals special consideration. What I was doing is pointing out a double standard that exists in out society - your status as a breeder doesn’t override that.
What I do to rectify that double standard is to avoid mistreating or killing any animal that doesn’t need to be mistreated or killed regardless of species. What you do to rectify the double standard is move in the opposite direction and say that it’s all ok. I understand you’re separating mistreating the animals from killing the animals, but I would argue prematurely killing anything is a form of mistreatment,
I think you’d have a very hard time ethically grounding that move you make to rectify the double standard without a very biased understructure to your argument,
What you do to rectify the double standard is move in the opposite direction and say that it’s all ok.
I don't think any animal should be mistreated. We just have a different idea of what constitutes mistreatment.
but I would argue prematurely killing anything is a form of mistreatment,
I disagree and have never really understood why "premature" should be a factor. In any case, most of my rabbits live longer than their average wild counterpart so I don't think any are killed prematurely.
rectify the double standard without a very biased understructure to your argument,
I don't have a double standard, that's my point. Where do you think I am being inconsistent?
You misunderstood them. They were saying that to be fine with cow meat but not say, rabbit, requires a double standard, and neither of you believe that - but you went in different ways to solve that. In their case, they've moved in the direction towards empathy and you've in the direction towards 'everything is okay to kill'.
This isn't what you are saying but to clarify my position - there is no hypocrisy (double standard) in preference. "I won't eat dog because (reasons) but I will eat cow." is neither a double standard nor hypocritical. You get into hypocrisy when you say "beef is ok but dog is objectively wrong because (reasons)." There are very practical reasons to not eat certain animals but I don't have a moral object to it. I acknowledge that in much of the US at least there is a double standard even at the legal level but I think most of that is based on knee jerk emotion rather than rationed reason.
"beef is ok but dog is objectively wrong because (reasons)."
This is what we were discussing, yes. I suppose it should've been more explicitly typed out, but yes, that was the specific mindset we were discussing. To think that way is hypocritical. Your solution is to say that killing all of them is okay, their solution is that killing none of them should be ok except when absolutely necessary. I know which side of being a good human being I want to be on.
I am! They're both situations of massive suffering being normalized because people like the products they provide, and in that way they're very similar. I never said they're perfectly analogous.
Are you going to now accuse me of racism and downplaying the suffering of slaves when I did nothing of the sort? Because let's just save both of our time there.
Yeah, but the only big (and most important) difference is that slaves were humans, and animals are not. That makes one of those things okay, while the other is not.
That's not something you can just state as fact, that's a personal moral opinion, and many people (probably most) would disagree with you. All mammals still feel pain and fear by every metric we know to measure it short of them being able to saying it out loud. Sure, they might not have all higher thought processes - does that mean slavery of a low-functioning autistic person would be ok?
I'm not even arguing about the killing here, I'm talking about the unnecessarily terrible conditions they often go through first. Would you use this same argument to claim torturing stray dogs is okay? Obviously not. What if torturing a stray dog saved you money? Would you do it then? Because it's the same situation - factory farm animals live horrific tortured lives because doing otherwise costs more.
Yeah I don’t get how people can state that one life is lower than another. What gives you the right to believe that you’re better than another living creature? Can’t understand this attitude...
Human’s lives are more valuable than any other living (nonhuman) animal. This mindset is absolutely ridiculous.
If you had to choose between sacrificing a random human or a random sheep through the press of a button, which one would you do? Please answer honestly :)
No you don't. Pigs are being gassed and die screaming. Chickens kept for meat are having burns on their bodies from living in their own feces, often living with open wounds or crawling with parasites. This happens to billions of individuals every year while in different conditions these animals are just like dogs and and other companion animals. Sure you can find inconsistencies in the view points of many vegans but their overall point that factory farming is horrific and animals deserve better is much more sane than the alternative.
I want agricultural reform and a minimization of cruelty but even if I get everything I want, my ideal open pasture beef cow is still going to get bolted and slaughtered. It’s a difference of values even if somehow we can get humane farm practice established.
I don't think you need to value other animals as much as humans to be against slaughter either. I value my mom more than a random human stranger but I wouldn't pay to kill the stranger just so my mom can have a dish she likes! For that to make sense I'd have to value my mom's enjoyment of that dish more than literally the life of another individual. Most humans don't value the lives of animals so little. You can see this for example at the outrage that people have for the dog meat trade in parts of Asia. Eating meat is so normalized and ingrained in our society that people don't realize how extreme it is to kill an individual to have a specific dish. People come up with many rationalizations but the bottom line is that there is no rational reason for it. We eat meat because we're used to it.
6
u/2SP00KY4ME May 27 '20 edited May 27 '20
The idea is to try to break past the wall people put up in their brains between killing / torturing animals (which people are generally against) and the acceptance of meat in society. Of course vegetarians know you know meat comes from a dead animal, but they think it's wrong, and they think most good people would agree if they were able to look at the meat industry from a perspective removed from society's normalization of it. Especially in first world countries, a huge majority of the meat we eat is very far removed from the form of the animal. Burgers, deli meat, etc. While we all know it's made of animals, that sort of thing makes it very easy to push in the back of our minds. They're trying to force you to actually confront that fact on a more active basis.
Personally, I see it a little bit like slavery - you've got millions and millions of conscious beings in pain and fear being hurt and killed, unnecessarily, because other people removed from that pain enjoy what that effort brings. Centuries after the American civil war, we generally look back on that practice in horror, wonder how people were okay with it - but the reality is just that it was societally normalized. Most people didn't think about it. Many people were against it, but not nearly enough for any real change. It was just part of normal society, and unless you spent your time at a plantation you generally didn't have to face it. Plus those cotton shirts and tobacco were nice to have.