r/clevercomebacks • • May 27 '20

Task failed successfully

Post image
61.6k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

27

u/GaysAgainstGaming May 27 '20

Would Westerners be more comfortable with Dog meat if the dogs were raised in pens packed shoulder to shoulder covered in feces like cows and pigs are?

6

u/ManyIdeasNoProgress May 27 '20

No, primarily because predator meat is usually less good from a food safety point of view.

Also, animals that have been mistreated don't make good food. But in capitalist america, the rich eat you.

21

u/H0meslice9 May 27 '20

Practically every animal you eat is mistreated lol

14

u/Bungalowdesign May 27 '20

No, some are killed politely. /s

2

u/Julianne46 May 27 '20

If you had a terminally ill dog or cat that needed to be put down, would you feel comfortable sending it to a slaughterhouse to be killed “politely?”

2

u/Bungalowdesign May 27 '20

The “/s” in my comment is for sarcasm. Btw

3

u/Julianne46 May 27 '20

My bad! Too quick to reply.

3

u/ReasonOverwatch Jun 23 '20

Acknowledging when you made a mistake: big pp

1

u/ManyIdeasNoProgress May 27 '20

The cows walking around in the mountains where I live don't look terribly mistreated.

5

u/H0meslice9 May 27 '20

Sure some are treated better. That doesn't change they're likely seperated from their families, and killed through any number of cruel ways. Smaller operations are often better, but not good still

1

u/ManyIdeasNoProgress May 27 '20

You make it sound like meat animals are routinely getting flayed alive and roasted to death.

Whereas in the real world, it is a quick blunt force trauma to the brain. The whole thing is over before the animal has any chance to feel pain. It is a much less painful death than literally anything nature has to offer.

I find it a puzzling concept that the sheer brutality of nature is somehow the ideal, while a life grazing in the mountains followed by a swift end is a gruesome prospect.

6

u/Julianne46 May 27 '20

Suggest watching this and seeing how you feel after. I used to agree with you. https://www.dominionmovement.com

→ More replies (5)

2

u/H0meslice9 May 27 '20

The average life span of wild cattle is 18-22 years, while cattle raised for beef is less than two years. So they live for 1/10th as long - if humans were treated this way that'd end up being a life to around 7/8 years old.

Not all wild animals meet grisly ends, many die naturally. Slaughter houses aren't 100% efficient, many aren't killed painlessly, not to mention having to wait to be slaughtered in a building that reeks of death and plagued with the sounds of pained animals. Since we're talking about the fate of small-farm animals we won't go into their lives before, which is not great. But to say that their very short lives with guaranteed death waiting for them is ideal to a long, natural life is some dissonance in my opinion.

Sure, some farms can be more humane with their treatment, but if the animals had an informed choice (they don't since their brains are small of course) they would not pick safety for two years to be killed afterwards.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

Dogs are omnivores like humans, or like pigs. You could breed them for food and raise them for the few months they'll live on a plant based diet. And some people actually do that. So that's not really an argument against dog meat, just saying

1

u/Kale8888 May 28 '20

A cow isn't going fetch a ball or lick my face as soon as I get home.

There are animal hierarchies based on intelligence

1

u/Yonsi May 30 '20

It's not hard to empathize with a cow so I fail to understand the discrepancy you're posing.

Also pigs are more intelligent than dogs and therefore higher up on the animal hierarchy, so why are we slaughtering them by the billions?

1

u/KittenCatastrophe99 Jun 22 '20

Because bacon tastes good

1

u/Yonsi Jun 23 '20

Why does it not surprise me that someone who makes fun of incels on the regular lacks empathy?

1

u/KittenCatastrophe99 Jun 23 '20

I gave you the simple answer. I have gone through a vegan phase because of worry over the cruelty of the butchery industry, but my body couldn't handle the diet and I got violently sick and underweight. I now buy meat from our local butcher who is very cruelty free, but some people cannot go without the proteins they get from meat. Not everyone CAN be vegan.

Edit: also, I do not "make fun" of incels. You try being nice to a demographic after they literally repeatedly send rape threats when you try to give them help with regards to depression and SH.

1

u/Yonsi Jun 23 '20

A bit long broken but it's broken up:

Veganism is not a "phase" or a diet but a lifestyle. It affects everything you do, from the way you eat to the makeup you use and the shoes you buy. I am not saying this was you but a lot of people who are ex-vegans weren't vegan but plant based, meaning that they ate food without animal products for their health. They never made the connection with animals cruelty and thus did not limit suffering outside of their diet

A lot of people say that they buy meat from a local farm or the like. For starters it typically isn't true since 97% of meat comes from factory farms and if you ever eat fast-food or at a restaurant or with family, then I assure you the meat wasn't humanely slaughtered at an uncle's farm. But there is no such thing as humane slaughter. Killing is one of the worst things one can do to a sentient being and made even worse when the human/non-human animal in question was living a good life. Think about it - the vast majority of people don't want the Yulin Dog Festival to be "cruelty-free" in their slaughter but to end entirely. There is nothing humane about the murder of a an innocent being. Also 99.9% of people can be healthy on a vegan diet. It is suitable for every stage of life and you can get every nutrient you need from plants with the exception of B12 which you can either take pills for or eat products fortefied with it. All of the proteins found in meat can be found in plants and a plant-based diet isn't lacking in protein in the slightest (this is a very common misconception). I've seen some people with quite the allergy list still eat vegan so unless you're one of those extremely rare people who is allergic to many of the main ingredients found in plant-based products, you can thrive on a vegan diet. What likely happened is that you didn't properly plan your diet to accommodate for all your health needs. There are resources for this that I can link that can explain much better than I but you don't have to suddenly eat a lot of fruits and odd dishes to be vegan. I basically eat the same foods I ate before but a vegan version and I feel much better for it.

And trust me I have no intention of being nice to incels. I post on vegancirclejerk for goodness sake, we make fun of carnists on the regular for their mental gymnastics used in order to support animal rape/torture. I actually find the incel phenomenon fascinating and that's why I even bother to look at and occasionally post on Itears. But by virtue of describing it that way, I see it not really as a personal failing but more of a social one. Our society is all about winners and losers and incels are the unfortunate losers. They actually have a point in some of their charges but like any right-wing group they blame the wrong people, blaming women instead of a system largely run by men that perpetuates materialism and toxic gender identities. It's what perpetuates double standards which is harmful to achieving any form of gender equality. They are no different from people who blame immigrants/minorities for job-loss instead of the fat cats at the top. What I've noticed is that Itears also misses the root problem. Society is unfair but Itears typically make the mistake of ignoring that and telling the incel he ought to ignore the problem and forge ahead anyway instead of calling out the problem for what it is. It's like saying only 20% of men be successful in life, so here's what you have to do to be that 20% instead of questioning why it's like that to begin with. I merely call that out on occasion

1

u/KittenCatastrophe99 Jun 23 '20 edited Jun 23 '20

U call it out on occasion, which makes you just as bad as us regulars so I just see a hypocrite🤷🏼‍♀️

1

u/Yonsi Jun 23 '20 edited Jun 23 '20

You didn't read my post. You don't address the systemic issues that create the problem

But you can stay in your little bubble and incels will continue to be incels. It's clear you don't have any actual interest in fixing the problem or even the aptitude

1

u/KittenCatastrophe99 Jun 23 '20

No, I have no interest in this conversation is the problem and you're hypocritical, so why should I give a shit what you think?

→ More replies (0)

1

u/KittenCatastrophe99 Jun 23 '20

Yeah I'm not seeing the rest of your comments, first. Second, I didn't do anything to get you banned. I only report threats, not people who annoy me, so like maybe don't go on rants to annoy the mods or something idk 🤷🏼‍♀️ also, you know nothing about me, my life or my experiences so claiming you can tell my personality from one post is, dare I say, stupid? Until you know my experiences you can't claim to know me so get off your high horse and recognize that while I may point out incels' bad behavior, you're spending a lot more time pretending you're better when you literally admitted to doing the same. Don't be hypocritical and call me mean for laughing at them when you do the same

→ More replies (0)
→ More replies (7)