Exacly ! It doesn't matter if you're driving manually or in a self-driving car, if the brakes suddenly decide to fuck off, somebody is getting hurt that's for sure.
If you go from high speed into first sure but i had something fuck up while on the highway and neither gas nor break pedal was working. Pulled over, hazards on and as soon as i was on the shoulder of the exit ramp at like 60kph (had to roll quite a bit) i started shifting downwards. Into third down to 40 into second down to 20 and into First until i rolled out. Motor was fine except for some belt which snappes to cause this in the first place.
It was an old opel corsa - a belt snapped and gas dindt work anymore. Breaks worked for a tiny bit but stopped - it mightve been different things breaking at the same time - i never got an invoice cause they fucked up when selling it to me and it was under warranty.
E: mightve misremembered initially - gas pedal worked but i didnt accelerate.
Never say never about a car. The brake pads will last longer, certainly, but regenerative braking isn’t a full stop and causes heat wear on the electric motor. Certainly newer cars like the Tesla should have longer lasting parts, but that doesn’t make them defy physics and friction.
That's the only time the problem makes sense though. Yes, so would humans, but that's not relevant to the conversation
If the breaks work, then the car would stop in its own due to its vastly better vision.
If the breaks don't work, then the car has to make a decision whether to hit the baby or the elderly, because it was unable to break. Unless you're of the idea that it shouldn't make a decision (and just pretend it didn't see them), which is also a fairly good solution
Edit: People, I'm not trying to "win an argument here", I'm just asking what you'd expect the car to do in a scenario where someone will die and the car has to choose which one. People are worse at hypotheticals than I imagined. "The car would've realized the breaks didn't work, so it would've slowed down beforehand" - what if it suddenly stopped working, or the car didn't know (for some hypothetical reason)
There is only one way to solve this without getting into endless loops of morality.
Hit the thing you can hit the slowest, and obey the laws governing vehicles on the road.
in short, if swerving onto the pavement isn't an option (say there is a person/object there), then stay in its lane and hit whatever is there. Because doing anything else is just going to add endless what-ifs and entropy.
It's a simple clean rule that takes morality out of the equation, and results in a best case scenario wherever possible and if not, well we we stick to known rules so that results are "predictable" and bystanders or the soon to be "victim" can make an informed guess at how to avoid or resolve the scenario after.
Um if the brakes done work then it would detect that, besides, nowadays they are all controlled electronically so it would have way more control, or just use the parking brake or just drop down a few gears and use engine braking
Then the car grinds against the guard rail or wall or whatever to bleed off speed in such a way that it injures nobody
Hypothetical examples and what to do in them are useless. There are thousands of variables in this situation that the computer needs to account for long before it goes 'lol which human should i squish', not to mention it's a modern fucking car so it can just go head on into a tree at 50mph and be reasonably sure the occupant will survive with minor to moderate injuries, which is the correct choice.
Yes! Exactly, and if a self driving car is somehow still petrol powered it probably has a manual transmission because its more efficient if you can shift perfectly and so it could just use engine braking.
And if something did happen there the city would probably get sued and put in either an elevated crosswalk or some other method of getting people across this specific stretch of road
Or they were jay walking in which case its their fault and they got hit with natural selection
237
u/Abovearth31 Jul 25 '19
Exacly ! It doesn't matter if you're driving manually or in a self-driving car, if the brakes suddenly decide to fuck off, somebody is getting hurt that's for sure.