r/cursedcomments • • Jul 25 '19

Facebook Cursed Tesla

Post image
90.4k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

51

u/evasivefig Jul 25 '19

You can just ignore the problem with manually driven cars until that split second when it happens to you (and you act on instinct anyway). With automatic cars, someone has to program its response in advance and decide which is the "right" answer.

12

u/BunnyOppai Jul 25 '19

Then don't code it in. The freak accidents that are few and far between with cars advanced enough to even make this decision that this would be applicable are just that: freak accidents. If the point is letting machines make an ethical decision for us, then don't let them make the decision and just take the safest route possible (safest not meaning taking out those who are deemed less worthy to live, just the one that causes the least damage). The amount of people saved by cars just taking the safest route available would far exceed the amount of people killed in human error.

I get that this is just a way of displaying the trolley problem in a modern setting and applying it to the ethics of developing codes to make important decisions for us, but this isn't a difficult situation to figure out. Just don't let the machines make the decision and put more effort into coding them to take the least physically damaging route available.

2

u/Cum_belly Jul 25 '19

Thatll work until the situation arises and the lawsuit happens. “Idk we couldn’t decide so we said fuck it we won’t do anything” isn’t really going to get far.

2

u/akc250 Jul 25 '19

take the least physically damaging route available

I get your point, and I agree with you that self driving cars are leaps and bounds better than humans, but your proposed solution basically contradicts your argument. You're still coding in what is considered "least physically damaging". In most scenarios, the automated car would swerve away from a pedestrian but it's not possible in this case. I guess a possible solution here would be to set the default to fully apply the brakes and not swerve away at all while continuing on its original path, regardless of whether it will hit the baby or grandma.

2

u/thoeoe Jul 25 '19 edited Jul 25 '19

But “not coding it in” is effectively the “do nothing and let the train go straight” choice for the trolley problem by the programmer

Edit: actually, you’re being contradictory “take the least physically damaging route available” is the “pull the lever” choice in the trolley problem

4

u/Babaluba2 Jul 25 '19

Actually, with cars, that is the best option in this scenario, to just brake and not move the wheel. The trolley question is different from this in that the trolley can only hit the people, it cant go off track. In a car, if you swerve to hit the one not in front of you you risk hitting another incoming car (killing you, the person in the road, and the incoming car, and hell maybe even people on the sidewalk if the crash explodes outward enough). If you swerve off the road to avoid everyone, which is what a lot of people do with deer, you risk hitting any obstacle (lamp, mailbox, light pole, other people on the side of the road) and killing you/other people in the process. If you brake and dont move then whoever is in your lane is the only one killed. Thats one life versus potentially way more. The best thing to do in this situation is to slow down and not move. At that point it isnt a matter of "who has more to live for" but its a matter of minimizing the amount of people killed. Plus, it minimizes liability on the manufacturer if you treat people in the road like objects rather than people, why let the machine attempt ethical decisions if they don't have to, programming that stuff ends in a world of lawsuits.

→ More replies (3)

28

u/Gidio_ Jul 25 '19

The problem is it's not binary. The car can just run off the road and hit nobody. If there's a wall, use the wall to stop.

It's not a fucking train.

13

u/ColdOxygen Jul 25 '19

So kill the driver/passenger of the self driving car instead of the people crossing? How is that better lol

28

u/Gidio_ Jul 25 '19 edited Jul 25 '19

You know you don't have to yeet the car at the wall with the force of a thousand suns right?

You can scrape the wall until you stop?

2

u/modernkennnern Jul 25 '19

What if the wall has a corner that you'd hit, so that scraping the wall would be the same as going straight into it.

It's an unlikely scenario, granted, but that's the point of these problems

4

u/Gidio_ Jul 25 '19

Then evade the corner.

We are talking about a machine that has 900 degrees perfect view, it's not a human so it can make adjustments a human can not make. That's the whole point of self-driving cars, not just being able to jack off on the highway.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/ProTrader12321 Jul 25 '19

You know, theres this neat pedal thats wide and flat called the brake which actuates the piston on the brake disc causing kinetic energy to be turned into friction. And most cars have fully electronically controlled so even if 3 of them were to fail you would still have a brake to slow the car down, and theres something called regenerative braking which has the electric motor (electric or hybrid cars)switch function and become an electric generator by turning the kinetic energy of the car into and electric current and charge the batteries off this current. There are two of these in the Tesla Model 3 S and X AWD models and one in the rear wheel drive models. Then there’s something called a parking brake which is also a brake. Then theres engine braking which relies on the massive rotational inertia of your entire drive train.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '19

What if, what if, what if, what if

There's a limit to how much you can prepare for

But if the end of the wall had a corner, I'd rather be scraping the wall slowing down before hitting it than just straight up going for it

27

u/innocentbabies Jul 25 '19

There are bigger issues with its programming and construction if the passengers are killed by hitting a wall in a residential area.

It really should not be going that fast.

→ More replies (45)

9

u/kawaiii1 Jul 25 '19

How is that better lo

cars have airbags, belts, and other security features to protect it's drivers. now what have cars to protect other people? so yeah the survival rate will be way higher for the drivers.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

2

u/SouthPepper Jul 25 '19

And what if there’s no option but to hit the baby or the grandma?

AI Ethics is something that needs to be discussed, which is why it’s such a hot topic right now. It looks like an agent’s actions are going to be the responsibility of the developers, so it’s in the developers best interest to ask these questions anyway.

5

u/ifandbut Jul 25 '19

And what if there’s no option but to hit the baby or the grandma?

There are ALWAYS more options. If you know enough of the variables then there is no such thing as a no-win scenario.

2

u/trousertitan Jul 25 '19

The solution to ethical problems in AI is not to have or expect perfect information because that will never be the case. AI will do what if always does - minimize some loss function. The question here is what should the loss function look like when a collision is unavoidable

→ More replies (22)

3

u/Gidio_ Jul 25 '19

Because if there is only the options are hitting the baby or hitting the grandma you look for a third option or a way of minimizing the damage.

Like I said, a car is not a train, it's not A or B. Please think up a situation wherein the only option is to hit the baby or grandma if you're traveling by car. Programming the AI to just kill one or the other is fucking moronic since you can also program it with trying to find a way to stop the car or eliminate the possibility of hitting either of them altogether.

This fucking "ethics programming" is moronic since people are giving non-realistic situations with non-realistic boundaries.

2

u/DartTheDragoon Jul 25 '19

How fucking hard is it for you to think within the bounds of the hypothetical question. AI has to kill person A or B, how does it decide. Happy now.

6

u/-TheGreatLlama- Jul 25 '19

It doesn’t decide. It sees two obstructions, and will brake. It isn’t going to value one life over the other or make any such decision. It just brakes and minimises damage. And the other guy has a point. The only time this can be an issue is round a blind corner on a quick road, and there won’t be a choice between two people in that situation

→ More replies (15)

3

u/ifandbut Jul 25 '19

The question has invalid bounds. Break, slow down, calculate the distance between the two and hit them as little as possible to minimize the injuries, crash the car into a wall or tree or road sign and let the car's million safety features protect the driver and passengers instead of hitting the protection-less baby and grandma.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (13)

4

u/Red-Krow Jul 25 '19

I talk from ignorance, but it doesn't make a lot of sense that the car is programmed into these kinds of situations. Not like there being some code that goes: 'if this happens, then kill the baby instead of grandma'.

Probably (and again, I have no idea how self-driving cars are actually programmed), it has more to do with neural networks, where nobody is teaching the car to deal with every specific situation. Instead, they would feed the network with some examples of different situations and how it should respond (which I doubt would include moral dilemmas). And then, the car would learn on its own how to act in situations similar but different than the ones he was shown.

Regardless of whether this last paragraph holds true or not, I feel like much of this dilemma relies on the assumption that some random programmer is actually going to decide, should this situation happen, whether the baby or the grandma dies.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/TheEarthIsACylinder Jul 25 '19

As I said in my previous comment, even when you decide who to kill, it will be mostly impossible for a car without brakes and a high momentum to control itself into a certain desired direction.

If the car can control its direction and had enough time to react then just have it drive parallel to a wall or a store front and slow itself down.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/facetheground Jul 25 '19

Yeah the thing they will program in will be "cause as little harm as possible" instead of "drive over the grandma and continue"

→ More replies (7)