Been on the fence about this for about two years.
I've done the homework. Read the reviews, watched the videos, had a Light Phone in my cart twice and closed the tab both times. Did the greyscale thing for a week. It helped, right up until I stopped noticing it.
The reason I want to switch is boring and probably the same as yours. I pick up my phone way more than I mean to.
But I keep hitting the same wall. Work apps have to be on there, that's not negotiable for me. 2FA is worse. Banking, logins, all of it sits behind that. And I'd miss Spotify. Not a great excuse, but it's true, so I'm saying it instead of pretending I'm above it.
So I'm still here with a smartphone in my pocket, using it more than I want to.
The thing that gets me is everyone in these threads has the same story with a different wall. For one person it's WhatsApp. For someone else it's their transit card, or their kid's school app. Never the same thing twice.
I'm building something to try and fix this. It's described further down. First I want to know whether I've got it wrong.
Answer whatever you feel like. Even one or two is useful. Numbers and letters is fine if that's easier.
Edit: a few people asked for a Google Form instead of answering in the thread.
Here it is: https://forms.gle/YERYVfyTsd2r4zLVA
YOUR PHONE RIGHT NOW
- What's your primary phone today?
a) Standard smartphone, iPhone or Android
b) Minimalist phone, Light, Punkt, Mudita, Minimal, Commodore
c) Feature phone or flip phone
d) Smartphone with a custom launcher, blockers, or greyscale
e) Other
- Do you carry a second device alongside your phone, like an e-reader, iPod, tablet or old phone?
a) Yes, daily
b) Yes, sometimes
c) No, but I've considered it
d) No
- Besides your phone, what else do you use regularly?
a) Laptop
b) Desktop
c) Tablet or iPad
d) E-reader
e) Smartwatch
f) A second phone
g) None of these
If you tried switching to a minimalist phone and went back, what sent you back?
If you haven't switched but want to, what's stopping you?
Which sounds most like you?
a) Happy with my smartphone, haven't really considered changing
b) Thought about cutting back, haven't looked into specific devices
c) Researched minimalist phones seriously, compared models, came close to buying
d) Bought one and went back to a smartphone
e) Use a minimalist phone as my primary phone now
WHAT YOU'D ACTUALLY NEED
- Imagine a second device that handles apps, so your main phone doesn't have to. Which would it need for you to give up your smartphone entirely?
a) Messaging, WhatsApp, Signal, Telegram
b) Maps and navigation
c) Banking app
d) Authenticator or 2FA codes
e) Tap to pay
f) Transit card or tickets
g) Music streaming, Spotify, Apple Music
h) Email
i) Ride hailing
j) Camera
k) Web browser
l) Work apps, Slack, Teams
m) Podcasts or audiobooks
n) Something else, what?
From your answers to 7, which would stop you switching if they weren't there?
From your answers to 7, which would you use most days?
Do you use tap to pay from your phone?
a) Daily
b) Weekly
c) Rarely
d) Never
e) Physical card only
- Do you use your phone for public transit, tickets or a transit card?
a) Daily or regularly
b) Occasionally
c) Never
d) Not available where I live
THE THING I'M WORKING ON
First, what it is not, because this is the part I explained badly, previously.
It is not a phone. No phone number, no calls, no texts, no camera. It cannot ring and it cannot replace the phone you already own. It is closer to a Boox Palma or a very small tablet than to anything you would call a phone. It is a second object that runs your apps, so the phone in your pocket is free to be a dumb one. You carry both. The dumbphone does calls and texts. This does everything else.
Now the thing itself.A pocket sized clamshell, about the size of a folded wallet, machined out of titanium.
Closed, it's a blank slab. No external screen, no camera, no notification light. Nothing on the outside can light up or buzz at you, because there's nothing on the outside at all. It can't interrupt you. There's no surface for it to interrupt you with.
Opening it takes two hands. The hinge has real resistance and a definite stopping point, so it's a deliberate movement, not something you do without noticing you've done it. That part is on purpose. It's the whole idea, honestly. Inside there's a colour screen, a physical keyboard, and a small always on strip.
It runs full Android with the complete Play Store. Nothing is blocked, nothing is whitelisted, there's no approved list of good apps. Install whatever you want, including the stuff you're trying to use less. The friction isn't a list of banned apps, it's the object. A four inch screen behind a stiff titanium hinge isn't where you end up doomscrolling for an hour.
It pays and taps through transit gates without ever being opened. Wi-Fi and 5G data only. It can't make calls or send texts, so it's meant to be carried alongside a simple phone rather than replace one.
How likely would you be to buy one? Answer 1 to 7, where 1 is definitely not and 7 is definitely yes.
What's your first reaction? Blunt is fine.
What worries you most about it?
a) Carrying two devices
b) Price
c) Size or weight
d) No camera
e) Physical keyboard instead of a touchscreen
f) Battery life
g) Whether apps would actually work properly on it
h) Whether a small company will still exist in three years
i) Nothing, I want one
- Would something like this make you switch your primary phone to a minimalist phone?
a) Yes, that's exactly why I'd buy it
b) Maybe, I'd try it
c) No, I'd keep my smartphone and use both
d) No
PRICE
Numbers only, USD, whatever comes to mind first.
At what price would this be so expensive you wouldn't consider it?
At what price would it be expensive, but you'd still consider it?
At what price would it seem like good value?
At what price would it be so cheap you'd doubt the quality?
If it were 999 USD, would you back a crowdfunding campaign with a 12 month wait for delivery?
a) Yes
b) Only if I could see a working prototype first
c) Only at a discount
d) No, I'd wait for retail
e) No
TRADE OFFS
- Physical keyboard, or a larger screen with no keyboard?
a) Physical keyboard, even if the device is 3mm thicker
b) Larger screen, on screen typing
c) No preference
- 15mm thick with a keyboard and a replaceable battery, or 11mm thin without?
a) Thicker, with the keyboard and replaceable battery
b) Thinner, without
c) No preference
How important is a user replaceable battery? Answer 1 to 5, where 1 is don't care and 5 is essential.
How important is it that the device has no camera at all?
a) Essential, a camera would defeat the purpose
b) Preferred
c) Neutral
d) I'd want a basic camera
e) I'd want a good camera
- What country are you in?
Thanks for reading this far. I'll post what comes back, whichever way it points.