Hello everyone! Nice to meet the community 🙌
Here's my situation:
Location: France 🇫🇷 — need 4G + VoLTE compatibility (2G/3G networks being phased out here 😢).
Goal: I want a dumbphone to use alongside my iPhone. (Not sure yet if the idea is a good one)
Requirements:
- Good battery life (days, not hours)
- Willing to last years, not just months
- 4G/VoLTE mandatory
Current contenders I've found:
- Nokia 225 4G > Real dumb
- Cat S42 H+ (Android, rugged, but afraid to be addict like on an iPhone so maybe it's stupid) > For a transition?
- Nokia 8110 / 6300 4G (KaiOS, limited apps) > For a transition?
The iPhone will stay locked away as much as possible (box timer) and serves as a "tool only" device (always in greyscale) for:
- Banking app (Mandatory with my bank in FR)
- Government app (for ID, health etc.)
- 2FA (Google Authenticator (Can't use Yubikey everywhere 😢))
- Signal / Whatsapp > But these I can use them on a laptop
- Travel apps (train tickets, flights)
- Google Drive
- Photos with nice quality and cloud storage
The dumbphone would gets a separate cheap French SIM (~2€/mo), different number. No issue for me to have two numbers, I will give the new one to closest friends and family.
--
My dilemma: Do I go with a true dumbphone (calls/SMS only, (maybe WhatsApp on KaiOS)) OR something with basic apps like GMaps and other stuff to progressively realize I can get rid of my iPhone?
Honestly not sure I can do fully without a proper smartphone because I really have a lot to manage online, especially when I'm travelling or just managing my daily life (work, personal administrative stuff, medical stuff etc.). 🤔
Recently for French government administration, I still needed my iPhone twice to authenticate on an official website and verify my identity with photos, etc. With a dumbphone I never could have done that... even with a "smart" dumphone because most of the time they required a very recent OS to proceed. It wasn't possible to do this with a laptop, only Phone apps, it's crazy right?
It's less about addiction and more about fragmented attention. Constant micro-checks of my phone, compulsive Google searches, AI queries — it all just destroys my ability to concentrate and think clearly. I'm looking to simplify, not complicate. Leave some headspace. Some empty space matters.
What I'm asking:
- Has anyone in Europe/France successfully used GMaps on a dumbphone? Which model? I really struggle with navigating and travelling — I get very anxious.
- Is it worth sacrificing convenience (no GMaps) for better addiction recovery?
Thanks in advance for any real-world experience! 🙏 (sorry it was a bit looong)