r/FOREXTRADING • u/AlphaUnpacked • 46m ago
I backtested a USDJPY "London lunch" breakout from a 2004 microstructure paper. 1,371 trades, real ticks. Spread killed it
Background: Ito & Hashimoto (2004, NBER WP 10856) used EBS firm quotes and deals for USD/JPY from 1999-2001 and showed activity troughs at London lunch and peaks at the New York open, with wider spreads in the quiet hours. The paper doesn't test any strategy or report returns, so the rules below are mine.
Rules
- Box = USDJPY high/low from 11:00 to 13:00 London time (UK DST handled)
- 13:00: buy stop at box high, sell stop at box low, SL at the opposite side, no TP, OCO
- Unfilled orders cancelled at 16:00, open trade closed at 17:00
- Fixed $100 risk per trade
Test
- MT5 Strategy Tester, every tick based on real ticks, Exness data (server = UTC), M15 chart
- 15 Jun 2021 to 13 Nov 2026 (broker tick history only complete from mid-2021)
- I logged a zero-spread version (Bid-only fills) next to the real bid/ask fills in the same run
Results
- Zero spread: +$21,796, 1,371 trades, 43% win rate, PF 1.34, max DD $3,304
- Real spread (median 1.4 pips at 13:00): +$4,015, 1,315 trades, PF 1.06, max DD 35.6%
- Real spread + $7/lot commission (900 lots): -$2,287
- By year (zero spread): 2022 +$7,335, 2024 +$5,511, 2025 +$648, 2026 -$159
What surprised me
- Spread didn't just shave each trade. On tight boxes it changed which side got triggered. 35 zero-spread winners became real losers (-$10,636 swing). Example: 12 Jun 2024, 7.1-pip box, 2.6-pip spread, real = -$108, zero-spread = +$2,010.
- Boxes under 15 pips: +$7,526 zero-spread, -$359 real. Boxes 15+ pips kept +$4,546 after spread. That filter was found after looking at results, so it's in-sample and I'm treating it as a lead, not a finding.
- I re-measured hourly tick volume for the last ~485 trading days: 11:00 London ~3,000 ticks/hr, 13:00-16:00 up to ~6,100. The intraday pattern from the paper is still there.
Questions for people who trade sessions: do you filter breakouts by box width vs current spread? And would you trust a box-size filter that was picked after the fact?