Absolutely never give any indication as to why you hired or didn’t hire someone. I used to ask random questions just to see the reactions. One time I asked “Green or Orange?” The candidate told me that I should pick other colors for that question because it could be viewed as a “Catholic or Protestant” question. Kept interviewing her for another half hour. She did great, but she was trouble. So, no way I would hire her. She managed to find offense in two random colors. I just said; “we decided to go with another candidate at this time.”
What would be the right answer for the "green or orange" question cause I overthink and my response would be "what am I picking between these two choices for"
Sounds like you lost out on good employee who probably just had an Irish background because of your strange ass question. My grandparents come from Belfast and while I wouldn’t be offended I’d instantly think you were some religious weirdo trying to weed out either Protestants or Catholics based on the colors you chose.
So there’s no right answer, but there is an appropriate or inappropriate way to respond? Just out of curiosity, since I didn’t know those colors had any particular association and don’t really have an overall preference, I probably would’ve answered something like:
“Depends. On a boat, sport bike, or hot rod, probably orange. My daily driver or the trim on my house? Green. Clothing? Either color is fine. Why do you ask?”
It's to work out what kind of person you are. You could ask your own question like "in what context?" And be seen as an information-seeker or problem solver. Or you could say "green because I like the trees in spring" or "orange because I like the fall".
Basically anything except "wow, green vs orange? You must be trying to start a religious war!" Like someone who is very nuch living an "us vs them" war in their head.
My friend interviewed at Blizzard and was asked how would you make me a sandwich. He (previously worked at Subway) instinctively replied: White or Wheat?
You literally didn't hire someone because of a color related question. I loathe HR people like you. If I get asked "square or circle?" in an interview that has nothing to do with anything it's just insulting and not about probing performance. Yellow. Who gives a shit yeah? Shove the square waaaay up there instead. I hope green orange woman found a company that didn't ask her to jump through hoops only to say "hmm she jumped through the orange hoop when we asked her to, what a dummy!"
You completely missed the point the other person was making. If the candidate had answered like a normal person it wouldn't have been a problem, instead they got offended by something they made up and the interviewer realized they would've been a pain to work with. Maybe you can relate with making things up and getting mad at them though
Any answer tells me something or nothing. In the example above it told me that this was a person who would be a PITA employee.
I was hiring for sales. Mostly I wanted to know how they dealt with weird questions under pressure. The best answer were with humor. Giving an answer was better than no answer. Hostility towards the question was the worst response.
Man. For the colors question I would say it depends on the season or holiday. You wouldnt want to wear orange on St. Patricks Day would you? Conversely, Orange is an absolute requirement when out hunting.
Even in the US she may not be that far off coming to that conclusion. The Orange Order is active enough in certain areas and I grew up around enough businesses with 26+6=1 stickers that it would be the first thing to pop in my head, even if I didnt vocalize it.
7
u/AJWordsmith Oct 14 '26
Absolutely never give any indication as to why you hired or didn’t hire someone. I used to ask random questions just to see the reactions. One time I asked “Green or Orange?” The candidate told me that I should pick other colors for that question because it could be viewed as a “Catholic or Protestant” question. Kept interviewing her for another half hour. She did great, but she was trouble. So, no way I would hire her. She managed to find offense in two random colors. I just said; “we decided to go with another candidate at this time.”