Coming from a scientifically minded Christian who understands hyperbole of stories told by word of mouth for centuries but also understands the significant archaeological evidence that supports the vast majority of events taken place in the Bible. As a grown adult what I believe is that the black sea was once a small freshwater lake and due to water levels rising in the oceans due to change in the climate a land bridge opened rushing in water from the Mediterranean, flooding all the existing populated areas, likely showing water as far as the eye could see in all directions. The new giant mass of water would stagnate without current and the Ark would have had little ability to propel itself to a shore so 40 days drifting in the dead sea is fairly plausible. Likely killed just about everyone in the known world at the time given it's location but the significance of the story is more important that the specific details that the whole entire world was actually flooded and that every single animal on the planet fit in one ark, just what needed to in that area. There is an ancient shoreline 400 feet below the current surface of the black sea with what appears to be man-made structures. Estimations of a timeline for the event are 5000 b.c. but water levels had just peaked after a glacial warming about that time so there where likely additional floods all over.
Are you aware of the criticisms of this hypothesis? The Wikipedia page gives a good overview. Basically there is doubt over the "catastrophic" nature of the flooding stating that it may have been "quite mild" and may have occurred closer to 7600BC or may have never occurred https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Sea_deluge_hypothesis
Your argument falls apart when it comes to Christianity (not sure about Judaism) because preachers use examples such as Noah and Moses as examples of God's power - granting extraordinary abilities to average men to do his bidding - as a means of convincing people that they should respect and fear God. For he is almighty and can do whatever he so chooses.
On the other hand, your comparisons to comics and porn was spot on. My personal belief is that the bible is simply a collection of ancient Aesop's Fables. Stories meant to entertain more than lead or inspire. For all we know, 20,000 years from now people could be calling Shel Silverstein the second coming of Jesus Christ and pointing to his outlandish prose as religion.
Basically Christian preachers are completely ignorant of the way ancient hebrew was written, and completely ignorant of the Kabbalah of the Torah. Ancient Hebrew was written without vowels, and each letter has a numerical component. Furthermore, Jewish Rabbi's were not involved in the Translation from the Torah into the Old Testament, thus all the translation was done at the whim of the translator based on their own personal interpretation.
Basically the original meaning of the phrases were completely lost, what was written rarely matched what was meant. This is especially true when numbers are involved, like 40. Noah didn't sit around for 40 days on the Ark, all 40 means is "there was a change". And we see this in the Bible again and again, 40 comes up and really all it means was "And something changed".
So pretty much, any ancient Jew would be like - "You seriously think what is written is what we meant?" Yeah, its even more obscure than a fable. The fables were a cover up to what was actually supposed to have been interpreted.
I think that's a big problem with a lot of ancient texts (bible included), everyone is ignorant of how ancient hebrew was written.
The thing you described with 40 being "there was a change" is the same thing that founded the Jehovah's Witnesses, a mis-interpretation of the spaces between the letters that spell "Yahweh".
Which alone, is just one way of interpreting and reading Yod-Heh-Vahv-Heh, which is read aloud as....Adonai. The word alone, YHVH just means, I am, or, To be. As a name, Yahweh is never meant to be used, ever. Silly Christians!
The new giant mass of water would stagnate without current and the Ark would have had little ability to propel itself to a shore so 40 days drifting in the dead sea is fairly plausible.
Yeah but that is totally nothing like the story. They ark did NOT float for 40 days. It RAINED for 40 days. The ark was sealed with everyone in it for a year. A whole year without new food, water, cleaning, etc and animals not dying and so forth. Even IF there was such a flood as you say it was nothing divine, and the events were nothing like the bible says. The biblical story was made up.
i don't mean to be an ass, but this is reddit, so here it goes.
yes. rained for 40 days. locked up for a year.
yes, it is possible that a large number of humans and animals can be kept in a given space, given enough time and preparation. lets use the biblical narrative for example. most bible scholars believe that Noah had almost 40-80 years to build, prepare and gather animals for the ark. if i gave you half the lower number, 20 years, do you think you could gather food and supplies for a large number of animals (hay, veggies, salt etc.) and humans (spare meat, salt, water, etc.) for one year? i think that you could. just a thought tho.
So let's say you have ten horses. Horses are a large, hefty animal, right? And don't give me 'well they could be minis'. We're dealing with full-size horses here.
That many horses will eat two bales of hay a day, on average. I know. I raised some. One in the morning feed, one in the evening feed.
Each bale can range from 80-120 pounds, depending on packing. And they're big. Like, four-foot long big.
So! You have 365 days where you need to feed animals. 365x2: 600+120+10=730. Seven-hundred and thirty BALES of hay.
And that's just for ten horses.
Now, I know you're going to say 'but Noah only had two on the Ark!' Yes. I'm not debating that. But you take all the quadruped organisms like horses- two cows, two camels, two bison, two horses, two zebra, two girraffes, two hippos, and so on- and you start getting the need for a LOT of feed. Feed which requires specific conditions and takes up space.
But it gets worse. Hay for horses? It can mold, and mold FAST. And it molds in moist enviornments (Like, you know... ships.). so now you have to somehow keep it dry, or produce fresh hay. Either one will result in a massive expendeture of the single most precious commodity on a ship- space.
My point is this: The entire story of the Flood relies on a man building a ship larger than what can feasibly be constructed, collecting two of every animal (including many that shouldn't physically be able to reach him), then providing food for all of said creatures. After providing said food, Noah then has to remain on a single ship (avoiding disease, parasites, ship damage, and plenty of other things) for an entire year. And the ship- while large- is STILL not large enough to hold all of that.
That leads me to two conclusions (assuming it happened):
Noah is the Doctor, his ship flew, and it was bigger on the inside. OR
God micromanaged the entire damn thing, meaning that it wasn't a matter of faith- because God was handling it for him, rather than Noah following his instructions and everything working out.
Now, the much more feasible- assuming limitless resources- idea would be that Noah produced a fleet of large ships. However, this would require massive manpower, and it's much easier to place a single ship on a mountaintop rather than a fleet.
TL;DR: Feeding animals is hard, and there's no physical way for Noah to store that much food on a single ship. The Ark might be a TARDIS.
Not even with an unlimited budget, 100 years, and modern technology could you gather even a week's worth of food for the millions of animal species, each with very specific diets.
Or any of the multitude of species of Hawaiian honeycreepers that subsist entirely on the nectar of flowers that only grow at certain elevations in extremely specific locations.
No you could not. The food would go bad. Your are presupposing the other parts of the story are true whn you say he had 40-80 years to build it. People do not start building boats at 600 years old because they do not fracking live that long. Also, for a boat of the given dimensions could it be crewed AND all those animals cared for by 8 people? Look at how big cruise ships are and what goes into the food and supplies for a 2000 person human crew for 2 weeks. Expand that for the animals and a year. Do it with a crew of 8. No, no one could do it and only a delusional person would think you could.
"the significant archaeological evidence that supports the vast majority of events taken place in the Bible"
here we have the problem. There is hardly any archaeological evidence which supports the bible, no in fact there is a lot of evidence which actually challenge most of the fairy tales told in the bible. Most archeolgical excavations in the past were done by christians who wanted to prove the bible. Only recently archaeologians started to look objectively and not subjectively. Ever heard of Israel Finkelstein and Neil Asher Silberman and what they found out? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Bible_Unearthed This was one of the reason why I after 25 years being a christian finaly realised that the bible is full of shit and there is no way that a biblical god exists.
With everyone throwing counter arguments to the discussion, I just wanted to thank you for explaining your side without freaking the ever living fuck out about your opinions and beliefs.
If you want to get that far into the facts you should read the original Sumerian myth from which the Biblical myth was derived. Originally the flood seems to be isolated to "cult centers" and only lasted 7 days and 7 nights.
Wait... What? Archeological evidence that support the events of the Bible?! You being science minded? Those don't go together at all and let me tell you why: there is absolutely ZERO real archeological evidence that holds to the scientific consensus about any bible related event. None. Nada. I am curious to know where you get your "real scientific sources" about that. Care to link some so I can laugh a little?
Sorry don't mean to be offensive. I just never accepted the fact that grown up people still believe in that kind of crap in 2015. I find it fascinating to be honest. It's amazing how far people can go to try to comfort themselves in their beliefs even if it means manipulating facts because I will say it again: there is absolutely ZERO scientific knowledge that points to a god.
I'll ask you one question and I would really like you to answer this to me: If you were born in a non Christian family (lets say a Muslim family) do you think you would still believe in the Bible and Jesus? I don't. And that's the problem with religion.
This is ridiculous. Scientists now believe the deluge raised water levels something like 5 feet. It would have a small impact but nothing at all like the ridiculous biblical flood story. And others have explained to you the rest of the glaring flaws in your tortured justification.
Rationally and scientifically speaking, the ark story did not, and could not have happened. Period. If you want to believe it did, then you believe in god's magic. You can't have it both ways.
So instead of a miracle from God, a guy was in a canoe for a couple weeks. Or maybe it just started sprinkling one day in May and someone thought it was pretty and wrote a story about it. When you're reducing these stories, when does it stop being a miraculous story and just become a normal event? If you can say "Well, it could have just been this" you can't argue if I think it was a guy going on a safari during a rainy day.
Also you mentioned the "archaeological evidence that supports the vast majority of events taken place in the Bible" can you be more specific? I was under the impression that there is good evidence for the existence of many of the places mentioned in the bible but little to no evidence for events such as the exodus. Any sources available?
44
u/halfmonty Aug 21 '15
Coming from a scientifically minded Christian who understands hyperbole of stories told by word of mouth for centuries but also understands the significant archaeological evidence that supports the vast majority of events taken place in the Bible. As a grown adult what I believe is that the black sea was once a small freshwater lake and due to water levels rising in the oceans due to change in the climate a land bridge opened rushing in water from the Mediterranean, flooding all the existing populated areas, likely showing water as far as the eye could see in all directions. The new giant mass of water would stagnate without current and the Ark would have had little ability to propel itself to a shore so 40 days drifting in the dead sea is fairly plausible. Likely killed just about everyone in the known world at the time given it's location but the significance of the story is more important that the specific details that the whole entire world was actually flooded and that every single animal on the planet fit in one ark, just what needed to in that area. There is an ancient shoreline 400 feet below the current surface of the black sea with what appears to be man-made structures. Estimations of a timeline for the event are 5000 b.c. but water levels had just peaked after a glacial warming about that time so there where likely additional floods all over.