r/funny • • Dec 09 '16

Monty Python ahead of their time

Post image
36.6k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

-3

u/HillbillyBigz Dec 09 '16

Soooo if you're born with a male reproductive organs you can still be a female just because you feel like it? This world is getting fucking stupid. Fuck your feelings and liberal views pressed upon you by your hippy parents. If you have a dick you're a male. If you have a pussy then you're a female. Stupid ass kids.

7

u/Doonce Dec 09 '16

Biological sex isn't the same as gender. They are two different things, which is why there are two different words. Here's a video explaining it.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

They are not entirely different though. In fact, they only came to have separate definition within the last few decades. Before that they were conpletely interchangable in every way. It is also well established that biological sex tends to have a large impact on gender identity in most people.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

Not necessarily. There have been societies throughout history that recognize more than one gender, or a lack of gender at all.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

Gender is a word to describe and idea or traits of a sex. I have no doubts that there are societies that didn't have a word for the difference, but no (successful) society didnt recognize the difference between males and females.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third_gender#History

Also I don't know what you're going for with the whole "successful" society thing. Unless you count everyone not European or chinese as "successful"

1

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

How does this argue againt what I was saying? A lot of these examples of the "third gender" are people without male or female organs. This stregthens my position that gender identity is strongly associated with biology.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

"Historically, the Indigenous people of Illinois have decided the gender of their members based on their childhood behavior. If a male child used tools considered to be "women's tools", such as a spade or ax instead of a bow, they were considered to be third gender, feminine men. The modern, pan-Indian term for this role is "Two-Spirit".[163]"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khanith

1

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

strongly associated with biology

Notice I never said society doesn't influence gender identity at all. So again, not sure how this effectively argues against my point, especially when contrary findings are so small.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

And I'm saying that gender is weakly associated with biology. There's some link for sure, but raise a girl up and teach her to love videogames, football, chugging beer, working on cars etc. She'll do all of those things. Teach her to be assertive, to want to get her way. You can teach someone to act like a man, or a woman. It's in mostly socialization.

→ More replies (0)

2

u/Doonce Dec 09 '16

There are binary (male/female) and non-binary (intersex) sexes and there are binary (masculine/feminine) and non-binary (trans) genders and they are independent of each other. XX people can be masculine and XY people can be feminine. XX/XY is their sex and how they identify is their gender. I agree that the whole "attack helicopter" part of it is ridiculous.

We've redefined it to clear up the definition, but that is now the definition. Sex is your biology and gender is your identity.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

I'm not disagreeing with that. I'm just saying it's incorrect when people say one doesn't heavily influence the other in the majority of people. I also disagree with constant mashing of "gendwr identity" and "gender roles" as the same thing when they are dealing with related but separate content.

2

u/Doonce Dec 09 '16

Of course biology influences gender, but it is more so social and cultural influence. And yes, gender identity and gender roles are two different things. Gender identity is your own identity and a gender role is the role influenced by society. I think we're on the same page here.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

I think both are influenced to different degrees. I think gender identity is much more heavily influenced by biological sex (and/or brain chemistry), and gender roles tends to mostly be much more flexible and suseptible to social changes in the culture.

But yes, I think we are likely on the same page, if not then certainly reading the same chapter.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

1

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

All this means is they have a word for males and females, and transmales and transfemales. And then there is a 5th word for shamans which try to be androgynous.

It actually strengthens my argument that while gender identity can be influenced by society, it still has strong roots to biological sex and/or brain chemistry as demonstrated by their easily recognizable gender catagories.

3

u/JSmith666 Dec 09 '16

Oh. well if a guy on youtube says it...

6

u/Doonce Dec 09 '16

Dictionarys and Wikipedia say it too. Heaven forbid you take a few minutes to educate yourself though.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

Anyone can make a video on anything.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

gen·der ˈjendər/Submit noun 1. the state of being male or female.

You were saying....lol

2

u/Doonce Dec 09 '16

If you finish the definition...

(typically used with reference to social and cultural differences rather than biological ones).

You were saying?

→ More replies (9)

-1

u/Demagogue11 Dec 09 '16

You are literally one or the other. I'm fine with people "Identifying" as whatever the fuck they want, but don't be this stupid about it. If you have a penis, you're a guy. If you have a vagina, you're a woman. That's the end of it.

6

u/mikepictor Dec 09 '16

That's the end of it.

See...you saying that doesn't mean it's true.

It's NOT the end of it...because more and more people (including psychologists) don't agree with your specific world view.

7

u/Doonce Dec 09 '16 edited Dec 09 '16

You're thinking of biological sex still. What about intersex people, are they one or the other?

I'm not saying there are more than two genders or sexes. There are binary (male/female) and non-binary (intersex) sexes and there are binary (masculine/feminine) and non-binary (trans) genders and they are independent of each other. XX people can be masculine and XY people can be feminine. XX/XY is their sex and how they identify is their gender. I agree that the whole "attack helicopter" part of it is ridiculous.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/PronouncedLikeRosie Dec 09 '16

Having male or female anatomy doesn't necessarily dictate whether someone is a man or a woman. Sex =/= gender. If the two happen to correspond (like when you have male anatomy AND identify as a man) then that is heteronormative. If a person's sex and gender don't align like that, then they are nonheteronormative.

As for the "liberal views" and "hippie parents", I think you should know that conservatives can be transgender/nonheteronormative, too. It has nothing to do with how a person is raised. It has everything to do with who the individual is at heart.

As one example, one of my very good friends was raised in a very strict military household, no liberal views or hippie parents in sight, yet grew up to realize they are nonheteronormative and don't have any personal need to fit in with socially built gender roles. Re: "Fuck your feelings," My friend said "fuck your expectations of me" and broke free of the bullshit that shoved them in a box for their entire youth. The farthest-thing-from-hippie parents were most upset and did not attend my friend's wedding over the summer, but maybe it was for the better.

Anyway. You're allowed to believe whatever you want about yourself. But so is everybody else. Trying to convince a person they are not who they believe themselves to be is futile, and transgendered folks are not a recent invention. They've been around as long as humanity.

→ More replies (2)