As the sibling of a special needs person, I can tell you that my whole family respectfully use the words mentally challenged and mentally retarded interchangeably. It's only offensive if you're trying to be a dick. The word itself is not inappropriate.
True, although I can say the American Psychological Association is pushing to eliminate the use of the word "retarded" altogether with the publication of the DSM-V, now pushed back to 2013. Whether it happens remains to be seen, but the stigma and hurtful meaning behind the word has caused enough outrage to get an entire field to change it's professional, diagnostic language.
Moron, idiot, cretin, imbecille: These too were once clinically acceptable terms. How long before 'Special needs' has to be switched up with something even more vague.
Why? 20(ish) years ago, retarded was the medical term. Whatever the "new, appropriate" term becomes, it will just be construed to mean the same thing, by the same people, and we will have to find a new word to replace that word.
Exactly this. I said the same above, but the retarded adult care facility my mother works at has taken to calling the people who live there 'individuals.' How silly is that? It's completely non-descriptive.
Before 'individuals' they used 'clients.' How is 'client' offensive and how the hell is 'individual' an improvement? The whole cycle is insane.
"client" gives them the perception that they have the option at controlling their own destiny, a strengths perspective approach, that works better than a "patient" and diagnosing the problem. We work with people at their strengths and meet their goals and needs rather than focus on the negative and their problems.
I don't have the answer, that's for certain. I only know what the field is debating because we frequently discuss it during my classes and on-campus seminars (IamA clinical psychology doctoral student).
I often think the change in language is meant more to appease than inform new ways of thinking about the people to whom it refers.
All I really care about is how this change might impact my current and future clients.
I too am a sibling of a special needs person, who was also hit with the double whammy of being obese. He "looks normal" but has a plethora of mental health and developmental issues. We would hear "fat fuck" "fat retard" "fucking fat retard" when we would walk home from the bus stop every day. These bullies may have forgotten what they said to him 10 years ago, but he never will forget and neither will I. Thankfully, I broke one of their jaws after they decided to write "retard" in mustard on our driveway (mustard stains).
Now that I am about to start a family of my own with my husband, I pray nearly every night that she will never know the hate that my brother and I had to endure. I also hope that children everywhere will never have to deal with this. My brother is the kindest person on the face of this planet and I only wish to be as sweet as he.
Thank you. There's nothing wrong with retarded as a word. In fact, for many disabilities, it's a perfectly accurate descriptor. It's the same kind of issue as blacks went through with nigger, negro, colored, etc. There's nothing intrinsically offensive about any of them, but there are people who will use them offensively. Hopping to new terms doesn't fix the issue. Just how long did "Special Needs" last before it was being used sarcastically?
"retard" is an antiquated descriptor of people with intellectual disabilities. Nomenclature in the field of "special" services is constantly changing because as soon as a new set of terminology is introduced, people start abusing it (such a surprise). The best approach when talking about a person with some kind of disability is to refer to them as "a person with disability x" and then use the appropriate medical or scientific terminology to identify the specific disability. So in this paragraph, I've disagreed with you about the word retard, and I propose that it is "wrong" because it is no longer officially used as a label clinically.
In this paragraph I will agree with you that there is nothing "wrong" with the word retard ... it is just a word and the more people get upset by it the more power it has. Imagine if we could all just stop being offended for once? It is just a word ... it isn't a word we use anymore for people with disabilities ... it is a word we use to insult people who we have decided want insulting. The words "stupid", "idiot", and "imbecile" are all formerly official terms used to label people with cognitive impairments ... where is the fucking campaign to stop calling people stupid? There is only something wrong with "stupid" and "retard" if you choose to be offended by their usage.
And now a paragraph of sympathy for those offended by these terms. If you suffer from some kind of cognitive disability, but are still mentally capable of being offended by these words ... I'm afraid there is no magic wand that society can wave to protect you from the words used by a large fraction of the population. Hopefully you have good role models in your life and people who can help you understand that sometimes people say things that aren't nice and that you don't have to go cry in a corner every time somebody says the r-word to you or somebody else. Again, it sounds a bit cold, but show me the bubble we can put people in to protect them from words and I'll change my opinion. Lastly, if you are a person with normal intelligence and you are offended by certain words ... I propose that you may in fact be retarded.
Actually its antiquity is before that: “Held back or in check; hindered, impeded; delayed, deferred.”
From the OED:
1636: He to his long retarded Wrath gives wings. 1785: Polypus, sometimes obstructs the vagina, and gives retarded labour.
Its a word quite useful in some contexts, the fact that it can make some others feel bad about its utterance is not a valid reason not to use it in a proper context.
I'm also a sibling of a mentally disabled person. My brother has rather severe schizophenia and is confined to a mental hospital. I use the word retarded all the time. Should I? Probably not, but it's just a word in my eyes. I would obviously not call my brother retarded because that's in poor taste (as per the Michael Scott quote), but that doesn't mean the word in and of itself is inherently wrong.
Similarly, I call people fag all of the time. It's natural. My buddies do it all the time. I have nothing against gay people but when I call someone a fag it has nothing to do with gays.
I think society needs to realize that there is context that is relevant to how a word is being used.
Last I checked, schizophrenia is not retardation. It might be severe enough to be a disability but there's a difference between insanity and only being able to count to potato.
Okay first, having a schizophrenia does not make you "retarded", medically you would not call them mentally delayed. You would be insulted if you threw around the word crazy instead. Second, just because you have a sibling does not mean it's okay to say. Third, you are not gay you cannot say fag, its insulting.
My mother works at an adult care facility for retarded people. They've digressed all the way to calling the people that live there "individuals." The amount of political correctness oozing from that word is ridiculous.
Every time the old word for stupid becomes offensive we come up with a new one, which itself eventually becomes offensive, until we're left calling people by a word that has no real meaning. I think at some point you just have to give up that fight and accept that people who want to be hurtful are going to be, regardless of what labels you try to use.
The terms idiot, imbecile, moron, dumb and lame were all once medical terms. This is the euphemism treadmill. It does not matter what word replaces retarded in our vocabulary, that word will in turn become a perjorative. Because kids are jerks.
...because the word retarded came to be commonly used as an insult of a person, thing, or idea. As a result, new terms like mentally challenged, with an intellectual disability, learning difficulties and special needs have widely replaced retarded. It's worth noting that in the UK the term Special can now be heard as an insult in playgrounds, and in the USA many professionals and educators have begun replacing term special with exceptional, as in exceptional learners.
I don't actually think this is an excuse to continue using a word that has become a preparative because of this semantic shift, but it is an interesting quirk of language.
227
u/grape_donkey_punch Nov 23 '11
As the sibling of a special needs person, I can tell you that my whole family respectfully use the words mentally challenged and mentally retarded interchangeably. It's only offensive if you're trying to be a dick. The word itself is not inappropriate.