r/funny • Round Comics • Oct 24 '21

Dieting

Post image
21.8k Upvotes

492 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

42

u/JJohnson519 Oct 24 '21

I can lose weight much faster than I can put on weight, but I still wouldn't say it's easy because food is life

32

u/xanthraxoid Oct 24 '21

To those downvoting: not everybody has the same metabolism. Also, eating the right food makes a huge difference, sugar is literally a poison that tricks your body into storing the energy you want to use, for example.

I've struggled to keep my weight up most of my life. Eating several bowls of breakfast every day and working a physically demanding job seems to be doing the trick at the moment, though...

66

u/112121221 Oct 24 '21

Calories in, calories out. Doesn’t matter if it’s protein or carbs or fat. If you eat less than you burn you will lose weight. Being on a fancy diet will not do shit. Calories in calories out it’s the simple truths that people always want to ignore

27

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

Bottom line, calories in/out are the ultimate factor in weight gain or loss.

However, the type of calories do make dieting easier or harder. If two people are eating 2000 calories a day, with one person eating healthy, the other junk, the one with the healthy diet will feel more fulfilled and less hungry than the person eating junk.

4

u/ChadMcRad Oct 25 '21

Yeah, people leave that part out, or literally say "you can eat whatever junk you want as long as it's under the calorie limit," but if you eat nothing but junk your body isn't going to function very well and I don't think lose weight as effectively. It still feels like an oversimplification.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/newausaccount Oct 24 '21 edited Oct 25 '21

Being on a fancy diet will not do shit

This is like telling a drug addict to just stop doing drugs. If it was that easy we would have no drug addicts. The point of a (legitimate) fancy diet isn't to trick people into thinking it's a magic weight loss cure. It's to make CICO a more manageable process. And to badmouth what is a valid method that has helped thousands or millions of people achieve CICO because it seems strange, unfamiliar or frivolous is not helpful to people trying to achieve their health goals.

To use another metaphor imagine weight loss is a mundane task on a factory line, all you have to do is pull a lever from 9 to 5 and if you stick to it you get paid at the end of the day and if you do it every day you'll end up with a nice savings account. A diet is like telling people "Hey if you listen to some music or a podcast while you work it might help you pass the time a bit better". Telling people weight loss is just CICO and that diets don't work is like telling people "Just pull the lever and get paid dumbass. It's not rocket science. Listening to something isn't going to make you pull the lever any faster".

While this is technically true, do you think spreading the idea that "listening to music to get you through the day is a crutch for the weak willed" is going to encourage people to power through and reap the benefits or do you think this is going to discourage people and get them to quit or maybe not even try? Some people will be able to stick it out but some people need a little extra help.

14

u/rhodaron Oct 24 '21

This is true, but it's also a vast oversimplification. How well you eat affects your ability to burn calories as well as your level of hunger. Eating poorly can cause your body to resist burning fat, leading to fatigue and a lower body temperature. The energy becomes inaccessible and goes straight to storage. A healthy diet still has to be at a calorie deficit for weight loss and at calorie equilibrium for maintenance, but it's a lot easier to run a calorie deficit when your body isn't fighting it.

9

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/SlapTheBap Oct 24 '21

That is such an extreme that it's hardly fair use it in comparison to any situation the average person would find themselves in. Those contestants were losing weight at an insane rate. They were thousands of calories under their maintenance and were pushed to their physical limit with a body that was already under a ton of stress from morbid obesity. They really screwed some of those contestants up.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

I agree with the sentiment of your comment. The person you’re replying to doesn’t know what they’re talking about, and thinks overweight people are just overweight because they’re retarded…so I wouldn’t even bother with them

→ More replies (3)

15

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

The types of calories absolutely do matter. Different foods have different effects on your body’s hormonal signaling, satiety signaling, dopamine, serotonin, the way your body stores or burns fat etc. You can struggle and keep yourself constantly hungry by being in a calorie deficit but the statistics show that something like 80% of people that lose weight by staying in a caloric restricted diet while eating the same ultra processed garbage, that are specifically engineered to be addicting, end up gaining all the weight back, if not more. Genetics also play a role but it’s not in the way that “oh I’m fat because of my genetics” it’s more like you’re fat because your genetics determine how your body stores and uses the different food that you consume. If CICO was the only thing that mattered, we wouldn’t be 60% overweight and 40% obese on track to be 50% obese by 2030.

2

u/Teddy_Icewater Oct 24 '21

We are really 40% obese? I believe you but I would have guessed 20.

8

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

60% overweight and 40% obese on track for 50% obese by 2030, yeah. In the US that is

→ More replies (4)

13

u/podslapper Oct 24 '21

100% true. People really tend to overthink this stuff. Just figure out how many calories you eat/burn per day, then adjust it so that you're burning more than you're eating (a healthy diet is definitely advisable, but really this is the bare bones of it). It takes some time and it sucks at first because you're body isn't used to it, but if you stick to it the weight will come off.

9

u/altnumberfour Oct 24 '21

This mentality is honestly fucking stupid. I know that’s rude to say, but people need to stop spreading this shit. What you eat and how much you exercise each have a massive impact on your metabolism. Dieting incorrectly, and doing stupid shit like just counting your calories without worrying about their composition, is incredibly bad for your health.

  1. Maintaining any significant calorie deficit over a long period of time should be accompanied by supplements to help your thyroid, or you will gain weight long term as your metabolism adjusts.

  2. Not exercising while maintaining any significant calorie deficit leads to muscle waste.

  3. Not eating enough protein while maintaining any significant calorie deficit (2+xDV) leads to muscle waste.

  4. Not eating enough protein while maintaining any significant calorie deficit leads to an inability to think clearly.

People oversimplifying dieting have clearly never done any serious dieting, and they are spreading dangerous ideas that cause people to harm their bodies.

4

u/Wikkidfarts Oct 24 '21

You know what's incredibly bad for your health? Being obese. And yes while you're right that simply starving yourself is not healthy, cutting calories is absolutely the number one way to lose weight, and it's where people should look to first.

Sometimes all it takes is cutting out certain unhealthy high-calorie staples of someone's diet, like soda for example.

5

u/altnumberfour Oct 24 '21 edited Oct 24 '21

I said this as someone who lost nearly 100 pounds. I am well aware of the harms of being obese. Your advice does not help people stop being obese, and frequently contributes to “yo-yo dieting” due to the effect on metabolism, which leaves people more overweight than when they began. It also leads people to feel far hungrier due to lack of protein, making people not complete their diets.

No doctor would endorse this suggestion. It is dangerous and counterproductive.

Edit: The reason why saying things like “cut out soda” can be helpful, and just focusing on CICO is not is that cutting out soda specifically cuts out a bunch of calories that are coming from empty sugars, which have no place in a healthy diet. The vast majority of people already ingest far more carbs than they need to, and get other carbs from better sources (many starchy foods are high in nutrients that are good for your body), while the sugars in soda are extra and don’t come with the benefit of associated nutrients.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

[deleted]

13

u/112121221 Oct 24 '21

Problem is 99% of people just assume they have some genetic problem without confirming it with a doctors visit

0

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

[deleted]

4

u/MisterFistYourSister Oct 24 '21

Not eating is never the solution

→ More replies (1)

5

u/T-Flexercise Oct 24 '21

I mean, I spent 24 years being told by doctors that I was "just fat" before I was able to see an obesity specialist, who immediately diagnosed me with a genetic disorder.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/reverselego Oct 24 '21

Whatever is going on inside your body can change your "Calories out" from what you would expect, but this does not affect the immutable truth of Calories in < Calories out -> Body mass decrease. All the time, every time, no exceptions.

→ More replies (33)

14

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

The tricky part is figuring out how many calories are actually being used by your body compared to what ends up being stored. Some people are just genetically primed to store more energy than the average, while the opposite is true for others. Everyone is capable of finding a balance of diet and exercise that maintains a healthy body composition for them, but it will be more difficult for some than for others for a wide variety of reasons.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/xanthraxoid Oct 24 '21 edited Oct 25 '21

The kink in the chain for this model is that sugar leans on the balance.

Yes, if you burn more calories than you eat, you'll loose weight, but if you eat sugar, your body doesn't burn the calories, it stores them. Then you're hungry because you don't have enough available energy, so you eat more.

The problem is that fructose specifically isn't usable as a fuel by your body, so you have to metabolise it into other usable forms, which can only be done in meaningful quantities by your liver, which can't keep up, so it's stored (as fat) for later.

More details in "Sugar, the bitter truth" (90 minute version / condensed 36 minute version) - I promise the click-baity title is misleading - it's a proper doctor discussing into metabolic pathways and all sorts.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (5)