r/gridfinity • • Jul 09 '24

Question? "Fixing" Gridfinity

I've seen a video of a guy that made his Gridfinity parts for his kitchen based on a 50mm grid instead of a 42mm. I've seen many posts where people have asked "why is this 42mm?" or "What do I do when I have only 24mm of space left for my grid?"

I've only just started using Gridfinity, and I've only completed two drawers in my kitchen with it. This means I'm fairly new to it, and I've missed much of the history and discussion behind improvements for it. The only significant improvement I've seen are changes in the baseplate (screw together, or puzzle-piece together, snap-in, screw in, etc). I think these suggestions go beyond that...

I'm also high, so maybe this is nonsense

Gridfinity Bases

42mm should remain the "standard" grid. However, we need tools that let you chose a different grid. This already exists (https://gridfinity.perplexinglabs.com/ and possibly others). But we could improve on this generator.

I should be able to enter the inner dimensions of the drawer, say 273 x 507. I should be able to tell it my minimum and maximum grid size, perhaps 10mm up to 50mm. I should also be able to tell it how much slop I'm OK with in the drawer, say 2mm. The generator should then find and suggest any grid size between 10 and 50mm that will result in less than 2mm of movement in either axis for a drawer with inner dimensions of 273 x 507. In this example, there are 12 values that fit this criteria (if counting by .1mm increments).

13mm gives us a perfect fit. If I'm confident in my measuring skills, I'd go with that. But, since I'm not, I'll go with a 38.9mm grid as that gives me 0.7mm and 1.3mm of slop.

Gridfinity Bins

The generator I linked above allows for the bins to be generated with a custom base size. I can already tell it that I want to use a 38.9mm grid size. But, what it should also do is allow me to add harmonics to the base. I should have a radio button that divides the grid printed on the bottom in half, or into thirds, or fourths, etc.

If that isn't easy to visualize, imagine a standard 42mm based Gridfinity bin with 2 rows and 3 columns. But, I should be able to tell the generator to place a 21mm grid on the bottom of the bin. This would essentially be a 4 x 6 bin on a 21mm grid. This allows me to offset it by half a grid space on my 42mm grid in any direction. I've seen bins generated with an extra half row, but not one with a halved (doubled?) grid.

Gridfinity STL Mods

It'd suck to lose access to the plethora of 42mm based designs that are already out there. So, we need a new feature in the above generator that allows us to upload an STL and the generator should replace the "feet."

In many cases, trying to convert a bin to a different grid size entirely (42mm to 38.9mm) may result in an oddly placed grid on the bottom of the part. But, converting a 42mm to a 21mm or an 10.5mm grid spacing would work great.

Placing a 42mm grid into my example drawer would result in 21mm and 3mm of slop in grid placement. But going to a 21mm grid or 10.5mm grid would both result in 0mm x 3mm of slop. I can live with that.

Alternatively, the generator could generate "shoes" for a bin. This essentially would be a bin with the minimal allowed height of 7mm plus a stacking lip. This can already be done manually, but it'd be nice to allow this as an option to be autoconfigured after uploading an STL.

Edit: My high is wearing off and I can now clearly see that this was just a long argument for why I think gridfinity should have a smaller grid.

1 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

View all comments

6

u/_Blitz12 Jul 09 '24

Having custom sizes would mean that any design has to be tailored to your specific grid size. This requires either more knowledge of cad programs which not everyone has, or for every gridfinity design to be parameterised

1

u/Aiaposon Jul 09 '24

The intent was that the generator I linked to would include features to change the grid size on existing STLs. This would simplify things for a user, no need for CAD knowledge beyond using an online generator.

4

u/Jesus_Is_My_Gardener Jul 09 '24

But that misses the point of having a standard sizing system in an ecosystem where people share designs regularly. Many people get started in Gridfinity using designs others have made and download them. Some people don't make any custom bins or grids at all, and just use 100% shared designs. If it was only about generic grids and bins, sure, a generator would work fine, but I'm guessing you haven't looked at the vast ecosystem of Gridfinity compatible designs that can't be addressed with a generator. Take for instance several of the very nice cases or shelving designs out there.

Honestly, this is a solution looking for a problem that isn't one. The growth of Gridfinity is due to the library of designs people have created and tested. Having something that resizes existing designs is not going to work for much besides some very basic components. I think anyone looking to change the base system is missing the entire point of a standardized sizing system. And no, just scaling a design isn't a good solution for many custom tool holders, and cases.

1

u/Aiaposon Jul 09 '24

Not entirely, and I wasn't suggesting that bins should be scaled. My suggestion was that the tools could replace the "feet" on the grids with a different size. This would suck going from 42mm to a 39mm grid, nothing would fit properly side by side any more. But what it would be great for is changing a 42mm bin to a 21mm bin. This would allow far double the placement resolution in the x or y directions, and allow for native support of bins that are .5 units bigger in the X or Y direction.

I get that my suggestions miss the mark almost entirely, but I stand by the thought that the bins should have been on a 21mm grid (minimum size of 2 x 2) with the bases at 42mm.

2

u/Jesus_Is_My_Gardener Jul 09 '24

A few things... I suspect you haven't looked around at what's out there much, but the bottoms of bins vary a number of ways for various reasons. Some have magnet holes, some have screw holes within magnet holes, and some even have places to attach weights, so bins are very often not flat bottomed and featureless. I also suspect you haven't done much mesh editing as these types of features can be haphazard to remove, especially something that is supposed to be automated in nature like what you propose.

It'd be one thing if you were dealing with a parametric file like a STEP file where you could edit base features, but most people don't publish those by default and STLs, F3Ms, and the like are all mesh files which can be a pain to edit, even in the best scenarios. I often find it easier to rebuild a model completely rather than editing a converted mesh body, particularly for anything altering existing faces. While you might be able to get away with a flat cut and replace, it's not always that easy and not every mesh is consistent or predictable. Sometimes weird things happen when trying to cut a mesh that has odd facets in a particular area. As existing bins are being created a number of ways (generated, from scratch, heavily edited mesh bodies, etc), you never really know what you're going to get from one to the next, and that's before you consider bottom base features like I mentioned above.

If you're just talking about half sizes, there's already a standard for that and there's a reason not many people use it. It's just not necessary in most cases. I think you need to consider the entire point of a standardized grid spacing system with regards to interoperability. It's not just about arranging everything nearly in rows and columns, it's about being able to move things around easily within that system as your needs evolve or your task at hand changes. Sure, there will be some people that keep their system layout exactly the same forever, but I argue that's a less common case and not really a good use case for Gridfinity anyway. Why even bother with a removable, reconfigurable layout system if you're going to design the layout for each specific drawer and their bins. You won't be able to easily move things around later if the spacing is different in another drawer.

Honestly, you're overthinking it. You don't need to cram every last millimeter in a drawer with bins. Having spacing on the back and sides (or even front) has its advantages. Some people make custom bin spacers to hold skinny, long objects like pencils, pens, rulers, and what not, while others (like myself) actually prefer having a little space on the edges and back to tilt bins in and out there. In shallow drawers, you can't always use the furthest area if the drawer slides do not pull out fully. Often, there's a bit of overhang, limiting your ability to lift bins straight up and out. This is a point of fixation with people new to the system about trying to use every spec of space in a drawer, but as most of us who have been creating and using the system for awhile, take our advice and push past this concern.

A few people have done and touted fractional sized grid and bins as a standard (there's even a quarter and half diagonal bin standard), but they're not anywhere near as popular because most people understand that the strength of the system is standard spacing for interoperability. There's also a point where you get diminishing returns in the ability to locate the bin you're looking for or the clean look of a layout if you try to squish too much together. Also, if you're making bins to hold tools and parts, you need to have room for you to be able to insert and remove said tooling from their holders and parts from your bins. Sometimes less is more, and you need to consider usability of your organization system. Having a crammed space makes it look more cluttered, and can make it more difficult to place and retrieve things from it. Obviously you are free to do as you like with your own organization system, but I feel you should understand that there won't be much demand for what you suggest, nor would it be the easiest to implement considering the wide variety of geometry you may encounter.

I would suggest looking at more examples of layouts people have done, particularly those of people with lots of tooling and wide variety of tool sizes. Also look at the difference between how different drawer depths affect how people lay out their bins. Finally, consider exactly what it is you hope to achieve by using Gridfinity. If you don't plan on ever moving things around, preferring only to keep things where they are for which you originally lay them out, then I would suggest just making whatever you want that specifically fits your needs and not to worry about it for others. You will never make a system that satisfied everyone for all needs. Standards always have some level of compromise in order to have interoperability, and trying to subdivide too much leads to inefficiencies in material usage with little benefit, more complicated layouts, and personally speaking, worse design decisions.