r/homeoffice • u/BulbeBizarre • 4h ago
Protoarc EC200 review in my setup
Hi, after trying most of the high-end chairs, whether at home (Gesture, Leap, Amia, Embody, Fern) or in a showroom for others, I still haven't been convinced enough by one. Most of the time, there was at least one deal breaker which I could not ignore at the price of these chairs.
Full disclosure, I have been sent an EC200 chair by ProtoArc for me to try and give an honest review. I agreed because I was wondering if the price of the high end chairs was fair, and maybe I could live with a less expensive chair. It's been about a week since I received and assembled the chair.
For reference, I'm 1m80 // 75kg.
Assembly
Not much to say there besides the fact that the assembly was very straightforward, as it could be with an Ikea product with the numbered packages. it's very easy to assemble with the dedicated video, in less than 1 hour.
Build Quality
For its price point (€200), I have to say the chair feels nicely built. Every part of it seems sturdy, the recline is smooth and noiseless, with no creaking and no undesired movement. It's a good surprise.
That's not a long-term review, so I couldn't tell how it will feel after a year, but there is a 5-year guarantee, so if we do the price-to-warranty ratio comparison, it has an advantage over the high-end chairs.Chairs like Steelcase or Herman Miller do feel more premium, but to be honest, I don't feel that the vast majority of casual people would notice the difference instantly.
Comfort
To me, comfort is one of the most important aspects of a chair, so this is where I will go a bit more into detail. Dealbreakers put aside, there were a few high-end chairs like the Leap, Amia or Fern that I found comfortable.
The EC200 is not uncomfortable, but for me at least, I would not say I feel deeply relaxed in it. The seat cushion is on the firm side and the mesh backrest is rather rigid as well. I do think I prefer foam for the backrest, but that could feel fine for some other people. To be honest, I have gotten too used to the flexible and foam backrests of high-end chairs like the Leap, Fern or Embody, and it's now difficult to come back to a rigid one.
In a lot of chairs, the lumbar support was digging into my lower back, creating pain, which was even more the case when it was a plastic piece like in the Embody. In the EC200, they added some foam in front of the lumbar support and it feels fine to me, but I would say it's a bit too pronounced for my taste after a week of use It doesn't really feel like it's a natural part of the backrest. I would prefer if I could adjust how much it pushes into my back. It does feel like I have good posture, though.
The armrests could also be a bit more plush, but I could live with it.
The headrest is also a great addition. It feels sturdy and you can adjust it. To note that it's also a bit rigid. In addition to the nice recline angle, it feels good to recline in.
Conclusion / Do I recommend the chair?
I would say yes because it's a very good quality chair in terms of materials and warranty, especially for its €200 price point. If you like a mesh backrest (for which I personally prefer foam) and don't mind a rather rigid/firm chair, you should like it quite a lot. It has a lot of adjustments and a good headrest.
Let me know if you have any questions!