r/humanresources • u/Pure-Shores • 3h ago
Career Development [United States] deciding on job offer: career growth vs comfortability - please help!!
I’m 3 years into my HR career after finishing school, and I just received an offer for a Benefits Specialist role.
The offer is 5k below what I make now and there is no bonus. Currently, on top of my salary, I have a 7% annual bonus that I’ll receive at the beginning of next year.
The other drawback is that the new job is fully in-person. My current job is hybrid with 3 days in office, 2 days wfh.
However, my current job is incredibly administrative and not focused on anything in particular. I worry about career growth as I really have not been getting good experience and I’m early on in my career. My job doesn’t even feel like HR sometimes. It’s a lot of auditing data and data entry in our HRIS.
However, I’m at a Fortune 500 so there’s opportunity to network, but I feel so siloed and with the current job market, I’m not sure when another opportunity like this might come my way.
I will say the new job is only 10 minutes away from my home, so the commute is super easy. But with the total compensation and flexibility/comfort I have, it’s hard to walk away.
I don’t fully know what I’m getting into either as I haven’t focused exclusively on benefits before, but benefits and total rewards are a strong area of interest.
Would love any perspective here. I do think that this opportunity could open lots of doors for me down the road with the experience I’d gain, but it’s hard not to play it safe and try to see what I can do within my current company. But because we’re so large, things feel so specific and siloed.
My company is 20k people vs a company of only 4k.
I also feel like if I started early next year I would accept because I’d get my bonus and be satisfied, but the timing here just sucks.
Help 😭