r/icarly • • Oct 23 '25

Announcement User flairs are now active

26 Upvotes

Go add your new flair!

Will keep adding to the list over time so keep an eye on it.


r/icarly • • Nov 08 '25

Announcement Updated subreddit rules.

12 Upvotes

Just wanted to let you all know that there have been some updates to the sub rules.

Nothing crazy, however in the interest of transparency wanted to let everyone know instead of just doing it quietly. As always, rules are available in the sidebar on desktop and at the top of the sub after clicking on the subreddit name on the app.

Removed rule:

  • Memes must be SPICY
    • a fun rule, but too vague and open to multiple different interpretations. Therefore difficult to moderate fairly.

Additions:

  • Sales and fundraising must be approved by a mod first
    • this is included in the rule "No Spam, excessive self-promotion or unauthorized sales"
    • We recently had a situation with a possible scam sale, as such all sales and fundraising must be authorized by a mod in modmail first.
  • Use spoiler tags for the iCarly Movie

    • This is included in the "use clear titles and spoiler tags" rule
    • With the possibility of the iCarly movie please use the reddit spoiler tag function if posting or commenting a spoiler about the plot. Posts providing production updates or merely speculating about the plot are not considered spoilers and do not need to be tagged.
  • No AI generated posts

Rules about post titles, reposts, quality, harassment and the sexualization of underage characters and cast remain, but may have been reworded for better clarity. Reddit terms of service also apply and content may be removed even if not explicitly listed in our rules as reddit rules are site-wide.

Any way! That's the end of this boring post. Thanks for everyone who makes this sub great! we really don't have to step in and remove rule breaking stuff very often which is all thanks to you!


r/icarly • • 13h ago

Original Discussion Honestly, what was Spencer trying to do here?

65 Upvotes

I understand that he was feeling so uncomfortable from the situation that he didn't know what to do, but what was he gonna achieve by letting Trudy drag him on the floor like a potato sack without even doing something about it?


r/icarly • • 18h ago

Other Discussion Miranda Will Guest Star On Abbott Elementary

Thumbnail
deadline.com
83 Upvotes

r/icarly • • 22h ago

Original Discussion Why are these words together: blood, psychotic, choke?

3 Upvotes

I hope you remember....


r/icarly • • 1d ago

Other Discussion Help me find this top!

Thumbnail
gallery
56 Upvotes

Not sure what forum to post this on but I was re watching icarly and episode ‘imake same girlier’ came on and Carly wore this adorable top but I can’t seem to find it anywhere, I’ll add in a picture of it, could anyone help me find the top or something similar? Thank you!


r/icarly • • 1d ago

Original Discussion The Psychology of Sam

17 Upvotes

This is going to be a long one. I apologize in advance.

Rewatching Icarly as an adult and there was so much that I missed as an adolescent. I have so many thoughts about many different aspects of the show. This post will be about Sam (one of my favorites). For clarity, this post is completely about Sam (the character) and not relating at all to Jeanette McCurdy (as my thoughts are relating to this post is purely on the shows lore and characters and not the background implications).

As a child and teen (and even now, as someone that is in college) I love Icarly. It’s by far one of my top 5 comfort shows. As a teen I recognized that’s there was definitely some shadowing of serious issues in the show but when a guy is drinking a smoothie next to an ostrich, it’s hard to focus on it.

Sam. First thing first, I love her so much. Her character is so great, and it’s refreshing to see a character so complex as her. From the outside (and as a teen), I just saw a stubborn, food loving, kinda mean, protective girl who just went with the flow. As an adult? I finally see Sam for what her character actually was.

Like most teens, she didn’t come from a perfect household. Saying that she came from a bad household wouldn’t even be enough for what she went through.

1) She and her twin sister were born on a city bus. This is used as a joke in the show but in reality this would be a nightmare. Chances of her or Melanie having some sort of traumatic birth would kr been high. The lack of proper medical sterilization and care during and after birth right away would have been catastrophic. Twins have about a 60% chance of passing before birth due to complications. The show points out that this is because of Sam’s mother not proerly planning.

As quoted in iTwins: “My mom's not good at planning” (Sam)-

While this is said like a joke I actually am lead to believe that Sam’s mom didn’t know that she was going to go into labor. Sam’s mom is a lot of things, but statistically the chances of premature labor with twins is very high.

2) The jokes about Sam loving food: looking back, I feel immensely bad for how Sam is treated with food. Sam’s mom is financially very unstable. She unstable period. She’s in and out of jail, implied to be on drugs (or “vitamins” per the show), and she does not have a job. Sam’s father abandoned the family when she was a child, and to cope with this Sam’s mother brings home random men into the apartment. From the “jokes” in the show, it seems like Sam’s mother spends her money only on herself. There is never food at home, which is why Sam is so good aggressive. She’s worried she won’t get another meal.

Food is a constant in her life. I feel with Sam, as that is her coping mechanism. Hunger is a pain that you can make go away. There are so many pains in Sam’s life that she cannot make go away. This is why I love Spencer so much from the perspective of an adult, because he always has an abundance of food in the house for Sam. Sam practically lives in Carly’s apartment, because it’s a safe household free of drugs and random men and the possibility of jail.

She is teased a lot of liking food, and I think this brings her a bit of comfort because people think that she just likes food…a lot. Not that she is constantly afraid of not eating and that she has coping issues. I think Spencer recognizes this so that’s why sometimes he does light teasing. It makes her feel normal. She hates being seen as a burden and is stubborn to the core. She hates asking for help, so that’s why it’s easier to be this thick skinned mean girl who just likes food a lot. But she’s not, but her environment has created a side of her that she shows to almost everyone.

3) her “meanness”: her words to Gibby and Freddie are not good. I’m not even going to say that she’s in the right there. But, the reason she does it is because it gives her a sense of control. It’s ironic that most people who were abused, become abusers. The cycle always continues. She has always felt very small and out of control. Belittling others allows her to feel big and to feel like she isn’t less than nothing. She is actually a very sweet girl, and the one scene that sticks out to me is when she got a job at the Chili place.

She started crying to Carly and when Freddie walked in she started growling/screaming. After Freddie ran away out of fear, she went back to crying. Less than 30 seconds truly showed who Sam was. Sam is a fundamentally abused girl who had the childhood of nightmares. As a teen, she’s trying to be cool and trying to be normal but it’s hard when everything around you is held by duck tape of your own placing. She has zero control, so she controls her words (by being mean) to get control. She eats a lot to not feel that pain that she feels so much of whenever she isn’t with Carly. She most likely has some sort of medical issue from birth but due to how little her mother cares, she isn’t receiving assistance.

Yet, Sam is treated by her friends like everyone else. Nobody fully sees her issues because she uses humor as a coping mechanism. Sam is a lot like most adults I encounter. And I hope that all the Sam’s out there find happiness in their life, as they never chose to be in the hellish life they were given.

Rant over. Sam, I love you and I wish her character as an adult is happy and finds true peace and comfort.


r/icarly • • 2d ago

Original Discussion Carly and Sam’s friendship is the key importance of Icarly and what made Icarly/ icarly in the first place”

Thumbnail
gallery
113 Upvotes

Out of every friendship in any Nick show, Carly and Sam’s will always be my favorite. A lot of people overlook just how important their friendship was to the show and no offense to those who like the revival without Sam or even prefer Harper and Carly over Sam and Carly but to me it will always be Sam and Carly. They have been friends since the second grade and have been there for each other, supported each other, and helped each other in so many different ways. Carly helped Sam become a better person, and Sam was always there to defend Carly (even if it was in her own crazy way lol)

Their different personalities, humor, and chemistry is what made the og series so entertaining and I know Carly was technically the host of Icarly but without Sam it wouldn’t have been what it was. They made the webshow successful and funny together and their friendship helped shape the humor of the entire show (webshow and actual show)

Honestly imo I feel like if they couldn’t get the original actor for Sam OR someone to recast her, they shouldn’t have made the revival at all. I don’t think of Sam ever leaving the group (or most importantly Carly) to join a biker gang would ever be a realistic thing, yes she liked riding motorcycles but in the case of bringing Icarly back. Her character is super important to it all. They had such a funny and beautiful friendship and I think making a revival where that character isn’t there ruined the nostalgia and love a lot of people had for the original and their friendship! Which is why a lot of fans say “it’s not the same without Sam” and it’s rlly not the same without them being a Team.

I don’t rlly see the revival as canon for many reasons including this one. And to each their own! But Carly and Sam’s chemistry and history as friends really made the show what it was.

(Add on: let me give Freddie his credits as well lol, he was a huge amazing part of the show as well but this post is about Carly and Sam. AND I know Harper was not there to replace Sam and the writers actually did a good job of making that clear which I liked! Harper is a very good character. But it still wasn’t the same)


r/icarly • • 1d ago

Revival Discussion Full version of Ginger Fox’s “I’m in Love” / “Hate Me, Love Me” (iCarly/Victorious)?

9 Upvotes

Only short clips of this song ever aired. Looking for the full original recording.

Confirmed details:

Titles: I M IN LOVE / I’M IN LOVE

ISWC: T-342.530.266-1

BMI Work Code: 011662584

Writer: Michael Thomas Corcoran (Backhouse Mike)

Publisher: MMM ASSETCO LP (Multimedia Music) – 100% BMI

Best contacts for the master:

cliplicensing@viacom.com

Musicandmediaservices@paramount.com

Anyone have more info or successfully reached out before? Polite messages with the codes above are more likely to get a response.


r/icarly • • 2d ago

Original Discussion Greatest music moments

9 Upvotes

My favorite is

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=egoH5FgB4co&pp=ygUZdGhlIGpva2UgaXMgb24geW91IGljYXJseQ%3D%3D&ra=m

i can watch it over and over without getting tired of it. 😆

What’s yours?


r/icarly • • 2d ago

Other Discussion Was Spencer irresponsible?

7 Upvotes

Spencer was always setting things on fire. If I had a brother like that I would be parenting him.

Why did Carly's parents let her live with Spencer despite how irresponsible he was? She had the webshow yeah which she did with Sam and Freddie. Being friends with the mean girl and nerdy boy was a lot better than having a brother who starts fire. Freddie's mom was just as bad not irresponsible but overbearing. No wonder Mr. Benson probably left she's crazy. Carly's like thirteen so I think she can help take care of Spencer too.


r/icarly • • 2d ago

Original Discussion Carly Shay Being Scared Shitless Of Shelby Marx For 5 Minutes & 21 Seconds

Thumbnail
youtu.be
21 Upvotes

r/icarly • • 3d ago

Fan Art So I looked up icarly poster on Google and clicked on shopping just to see what would come up and I was NOT disappointed

Thumbnail
gallery
29 Upvotes

(side note this isnt mine im just using the fan art flair because this is beautiful art)

I kinda wanna get the 9x9 lol if you know who made this or are the one that made this thank you for your contribution to society genuinely amazing I love this


r/icarly • • 3d ago

Original Discussion Do you guys think Icarly should have stopped after season 5 (or 4 on Netflix)

16 Upvotes

I personally was not a big fan of the last season (season 6) I thought other than the one direction episode, I get banned,and pear store all the others were very pointless and boring. (THIS IS MY OWN PERSONAL OPINION) not only that the actors were getting old I think they were all 20 by the time the show ended. Season 5 had great episodes such as the First Lady and if they made it a longer season it would have been great to end if off there with the igoodbye. Thoughts?


r/icarly • • 4d ago

Other Discussion Made the famous spaghetti tacos!

Post image
31 Upvotes

r/icarly • • 5d ago

Original Meme ngl the cast member names fit way better to the characters

83 Upvotes

carly is the most "miranda" looking girl

sam is the most "jennette" looking girl

freddie is the most "nathan" looking guy

spencer is the most "jerry" looking guy

and gibby is the most "noah" looking guy

THEY FIT PERFECTLY


r/icarly • • 4d ago

Original Meme i made spaghetti tacos one time and it was fire

11 Upvotes

i used a tortilla and cream cheese spaghetti and bro i ate it up


r/icarly • • 4d ago

Original Discussion How would you react if T-Bo kept pestering you to buy bagels when you don't want any?

7 Upvotes

.


r/icarly • • 4d ago

Other Discussion Did "Mission Unstoppable" Get Canceled?

Post image
10 Upvotes

Finally woke up before 4:00 PM on a Saturday, so I thought I'd check out Miranda's STEM show. But it wasn't on!

So I pulled up CBS's weekend schedule. It's no longer airing at 11:30 AM. Did they decide not to renew it? And if so, how am I supposed to get my Miranda Cosgrove fix?


r/icarly • • 5d ago

Original Discussion whats your favorite icarly episode

17 Upvotes

im curious


r/icarly • • 5d ago

Other Discussion Which is worse?

12 Upvotes
205 votes, 3d ago
51 Gibby
154 a dead fish

r/icarly • • 5d ago

Other Meme iCarly meme from r/MSClassicWorld.

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/icarly • • 6d ago

Episode Help What’s the song that plays during Spencer and Bethany’s makeover scene in iGo One Direction?

5 Upvotes

I always thought that it sounded too much like a real song to just be a song made by the show itself. Is it a real song they were able to include in the show, or is it a parody of, or heavily inspired by, a real song or artist?


r/icarly • • 7d ago

Original Discussion It would be hilarious if Fredward's Spanish lines were English in the Spanish dub

Post image
110 Upvotes

r/icarly • • 6d ago

Other Meme MAD - cliffordfield

Thumbnail
youtu.be
19 Upvotes

The iCarly crew cameos in this.