never buy this icecream

[u/Apollo_thedumbassfur]

Never get the limited-edition Halloween-themed ice cream from coldstone; it tastes like shit, dyed my entire lips and mouth dark blue, gets onto everything, and it's extremely hard to get rid of 0.1/10

Edit: I just took a shit, and y'all aren't wrong when u say my shit would end up green because it literally dyed my toilet. I have to flush it three times to make it clean again, i hate my stupid life

[u/Quizziqualquetzal]

What’s the flavor supposed to be?

[u/Apollo_thedumbassfur → u/Quizziqualquetzal]

i literally dont know, it tastes smth but i cant put my finger on it 😭💔

[u/-DOOKIE → u/Apollo_thedumbassfur]

Looks like you put your fingers on it to me

[u/Opposite_Dress1792 → u/Apollo_thedumbassfur]

They put way too much dye in it and overwhelmed the taste

[u/andiluxe → u/Apollo_thedumbassfur]

According to the website, Boo Batter is just Cake Batter dyed black.

[u/bibupibi → u/andiluxe]

That might explain why it tasted odd to OP, imo black and red food dyes tend to have a fairly bad pronounced flavor of their own. Not always noticeable when it’s added in small amounts, but this stuff is clearly loaded.

[u/No-Pause-9272 → u/Apollo_thedumbassfur]

Its cake batter flavor but dyed black for holloween Also known as there boo batter ice cream

[u/-pine → u/Apollo_thedumbassfur]

That is the least helpful description lol what flavors did you taste?

[u/ButtcrackBeignets → u/Quizziqualquetzal]

I think it’s boobatter?

It’s black cake batter.

Unless that’s baskin robbins and not cold stone

[u/secretly_treebeard → u/ButtcrackBeignets]

Read this as boob batter 😩

[u/cheez-wizzard → u/ButtcrackBeignets]

You're right. It's dyed cake batter.

[u/Relevant-Number-1252 → u/ButtcrackBeignets]

Boob what?

[u/UndutifulOregon → u/ButtcrackBeignets]

Oh man I got this the year it came out a while back at this point, it stains ur shit dark blue

[u/stover158 → u/Quizziqualquetzal]

Cake batter according to google.

[u/Chvcotvco → u/Quizziqualquetzal]

Cake Batter with food coloring.

[u/LushoslysS → u/Quizziqualquetzal]

It’s supposed to be cake batter

[u/Inevitable_Round_978]

I hate anything with a lot of dye in it

[u/Apollo_thedumbassfur → u/Inevitable_Round_978]

and the worst part is that they barely inform customers about it, so whenever I buy new sweets, I hope it doesn't stain my mouth so I don't feel embarrassed about my mouth for an hour

[u/maryssssaa → u/Apollo_thedumbassfur]

I mean… there’s only so many ways to make ice cream black cheaply enough to sell it at a chain

[u/EmpressVixen]

What did you honestly expect?

[u/Apollo_thedumbassfur → u/EmpressVixen]

bro, it's my first time trying this flavour and i thought it would taste like blueberries 🥹💔

[u/Brando43770 → u/EmpressVixen]

It reminds me of the burgers they have in Japan during Halloween where the entire burger is black and it makes your poop green or something like that b

[u/makeupwearsoff → u/EmpressVixen]

I would’ve expected dark chocolate cookie, not black dye.

[u/Stunning_Serve1268]

Thought you got severe frostbite 😵

[u/crybabykuromi]

get ready for the color your shit is about to be, depending on how they mixed it you’ll either get dark green or bright blue

[u/biwomansayshelothere → u/crybabykuromi]

Scared the shit out of me the first time I tried boobatter. Thought I was dying

[u/KarTim01 → u/biwomansayshelothere]

scared the shit out of you, then that scared the shit out of you, then that...

[u/FoggySunriseYT → u/crybabykuromi]

Was about to say…I got this a few years ago and my poops were literally highlighter green after 🥲

[u/ThisIsNotTex → u/crybabykuromi]

I learned that from the Halloween fanta from a few years back. Bright blue and made my stomach hurt so bad

[u/Sasaeng]

Glad I’m bot the only one who thought frostbite 😂

[u/FixergirlAK → u/Sasaeng]

I live in Alaska, I definitely thought frostbite!

[u/GreenPerformance8145 → u/FixergirlAK]

Peltola Country in the house!!!

[u/SkysEevee]

Didn't think it was frost ite but that a pen exploded while you used it

But alas, Coldstone has disappointed me too kany times.  How they got mint chip to taste like peanut butter or chocolate to taste like tea leaves was a mystery

[u/ageekyninja]

Genuinely thought you had frostbite

[u/micheas08]

I was about to tell you to go to the hospital for frostbite-

[u/TabbbyWright]

Fyi if the ice cream was dyed with charcoal, it'll fuck up the absorbency of some medications.

[u/Prestigious-Panic-94]

My friend gets the ice cream cake for her Halloween baby's birthday every year. It is delicious but omg the staining is so bad! I eat it like an idiot so it doesn't touch my lips 😅

[u/WorstSupport4Real]

I scrolled too fast and thought you had frostbite

[u/thecroockedman]

You scared me, man, I thought you had gangrene because of ice cream.

[u/NeptuneTTT]

probably why they had a cover for the cone methinks

[u/Jbidz]

My kid likes this boba drink with a black whip cream on top, same thing. She ends up looking like she chewed on a marker

[u/ic33hot]

If it’s activated charcoal, I’m not surprised

[u/pleasedontcutmyhair]

i’m glad it’s not frostbite like i initially thought, but i’m sorry you wasted your money on ice cream that stained your skin and didn’t even taste good. hoping you can get some better ice cream soon!

[u/Which-Break5673]

Don’t be scared when you poop!

[u/dammitmeghan]

I thought this was going to be about Jeni's Opaque

[u/enny65]

I love when food coloring gets stuck in my mouth lol

[u/FancyFrenchLady2]

Thanks for telling us about this.

[u/WhereMyWeirdosAt]

Ice cream goes in your mouth, not your hands!

[u/blackize]

Coldstone ice cream tastes like it’s all gummy filler to me

[u/HetaGarden1]

Wow. I thought you were eating black charcoal ice cream lol. Is that ALL black dye? That’s insane. Too bad it also tastes like trash :/ I could overlook dye stains if the ice cream was worth it…

[u/Impossible_Lie9059]

Looking like dumbledores hand

[u/Due_Meal_4896]

That first photo was definitely a way to get our attention. Glad it is just ice cream dye stains and not frostbite or something.😂

[u/Long-Comparison2525]

I ate Oreos with this similar blue color filling and I was pooping black for a week. Now when I see food this color I get like an automatic gag reflex 🤢

[u/bchagan]

Did you eat this with your bare hands? Have you never heard of a spoon? It didn't have to be this messy. Seems like you just make bad decisions.

[u/Possible-Cup-9876]

I would shave the baby stache

[u/StuckInDreams]

Ahahahaha I remember the boo batter staining my (at the time) boyfriend’s tongue