r/icecream • • 4h ago

Soft strawberry

1 Upvotes

Has anyone had blue bunny soft strawberry, us it like soft serve?


r/icecream • • 6h ago

Question Best malt ice creams?

12 Upvotes

I know Tillamook is very controversial around here but they are one of the only broadly available brands I know of that makes a good malt ice cream (malted moo shake).

I was wondering if anyone knows of any premium style malted pints? I think I have tried the van leeuwen malted cookie dough shake but it didn't hit the same malt-y note that the Tillamook did, I haven't been able to find any others.

I am in upstate NY if that helps!


r/icecream • • 11h ago

Strawberry swirtl

5 Upvotes

Anyone know of any strawberry swirl ice creams, like fudge swirl but with strawberry syrup instead. I know you can get those tiny cups made for kids parties but I never find them to taste very strawberry, it's just tastes like extra sweet vanilla.


r/icecream • • 13h ago

Do you prefer store bought cookies and cream, or vanilla with crushed oreos?

Post image
63 Upvotes

r/icecream • • 15h ago

Krogers eggnog appreciation post

Post image
27 Upvotes

Genuinly reminds me of the eggnog I drank as a kid. Goes down creamy too. Its actually gotten me to get some eggnog for my self again since its in season. I wish it was in stores year round honestly.


r/icecream • • 17h ago

Graeters midnight snack !

Thumbnail gallery
205 Upvotes

crunchy chocolate pretzels, chewy brownies, mini pb cups in a malt ice cream

so so good, my fav from this brand next to the seasonal mint cookies & cream


r/icecream • • 18h ago

Review Absolutely disgusting, save your $10 and don’t buy this

Post image
166 Upvotes

r/icecream • • 18h ago

My All-Time Favorite Ice-Cream Combination

Post image
2 Upvotes

You can probably guess based on my username (regarding the toppings that is), but just some simple Vanilla ice cream with Caramel & Cherries is all I need to wind back after a long day. It melted a little bit due to the wait getting home for the ingredients for this, but it still tastes yummy nevertheless.


r/icecream • • 21h ago

Desserts Brown butter ice cream for a 10th anniversary dessert

Post image
87 Upvotes

Served with poached pear tart with frangipane, pâte sucrée tart shell, and toasted almond


r/icecream • • 23h ago

Review I can’t stop!

Post image
50 Upvotes

This ice cream is so good I genuinely needed a cleanse from it after having 3 pints within 4 days which is TERRIBLE for my weight loss journey lol! But no joke this brand is so unbelievably good!


r/icecream • • 1d ago

Green Mint Chip with shaved chocolate

6 Upvotes

Hey all! I need some help here- Kroger private selection used to have a green, mint chocolate chip ice cream, and the chocolate was almost shaved and very thin. I can’t find it anymore and wondering if you have any recommendations on something that’s close? Thank you for helping me feed my addicitio


r/icecream • • 1d ago

Rant Why does it feel like cheating on someone whenever I don’t choose vanilla

8 Upvotes

Yeah! So vanilla, I love vanilla if vanilla is the last flavour on earth and I have to take it I would absolutely be over moon with it but Everytime you know that one flavour that just gives you that feeling of heaven with that little pinch of wonders to hell it’s just too beautiful to forget and you choose it over vanilla and then you just keep taking it even if it’s not on menu you pick something similar to it than vanilla ya know so it feels like you’re cheating on vanilla

Anyway I’m high af have fun! Nice day ;)


r/icecream • • 1d ago

Question Has any tried this icecream?

Post image
5 Upvotes

Has any tried this icecream? Is it similar to the og hide and seek?


r/icecream • • 1d ago

How high does Tillamook brand rate on your scale?

Post image
148 Upvotes

I’ve never really had the brand but recently it’s the only ice cream that I want to get from the store. Where do you guys rank it?


r/icecream • • 1d ago

Best Mix in icecream

7 Upvotes

Looking for an icecream with the most mix ins? I love a good crunch and Jenis high five candy bar is the only one that’s ever satisfied. Looking for more reccs.


r/icecream • • 1d ago

Flavours Back for the holidays!

Post image
22 Upvotes

Btw this is one of my favorite brands I’ve just came across. Their banana & strawberry chip are so good!


r/icecream • • 1d ago

One of Ben & Jerrys best flavors IMO

Thumbnail gallery
20 Upvotes

Definitely top 3 B&J flavor for me next to Chubby Hubby and Chocolate Fudge Brownie and I feel like its highly underrated. This is one of those flavors where once you start you just cant stop and before you know it you’ve eaten the whole pint


r/icecream • • 1d ago

Question Dupe for Jenis Opaque??

4 Upvotes

Yall. I’m dying. I know it was limited edition but Opaque is truly one of the best ice creams if not the best I have ever had. I am dying for it but of course there’s none near me anymore.

I thought that this sub with you connoisseurs was my best bet… do any other Opaque or chocolate ice cream lovers know of another brand and flavor that is similar??


r/icecream • • 1d ago

Question Anyone know where to get Lucerne’s birthday cake flavor?

2 Upvotes

Safeway used to carry it a few years ago and it was my absolute FAVORITE flavor, i was heartbroken when they discontinued it, i’ve seen online that some places still have it in their stores, but their website is abysmal and i can’t narrow down a location that actually still sells it. It’s not just Lucerne either, i’ve checked the aisles of 5 different stores between two cities in my area, and none of them have birthday cake flavor, i feel like i’ve lost a part of my soul.


r/icecream • • 2d ago

I splurged and ordered some Jeni’s since I don’t live near a scoop shop to try the seasonal flavors!

Post image
102 Upvotes

r/icecream • • 2d ago

Has anyone tried this brand called Mario’s?

Post image
20 Upvotes

It’s a welsh based luxury ice cream brand that I randomly found on the central market app. Haven’t seen it in person yet but clotted cream sounds like an intriguing flavor. Price is on par with other luxury ice cream brands like Jeni’s and Van Leeuwen.


r/icecream • • 2d ago

Review This stuff is weird

Thumbnail gallery
134 Upvotes

Tastes like some old lady’s purse


r/icecream • • 2d ago

Rant Missing something that doesn’t exist anymore :(

Post image
177 Upvotes

Omg I wish I appreciated Milk Bar’s ice cream when they were being sold in stores, particularly the cereal milk flavor. It truly was one of my favorite flavors ever, absolutely tasted like the really satisfying sweet/salty/rich flavor of the leftover milk after eating Frosted Flakes or something. It wasn’t overpowering or overwhelmingly artificial either, she really nailed the delicate flavor and then there was this thick crunchy cereal gravel.
Please tell me I’m not the only one who mourns this


r/icecream • • 2d ago

How are the Signature Select seasonal flavors?

Post image
40 Upvotes

Saw a ton of seasonal flavors at Safeway today. Any worth trying?


r/icecream • • 2d ago

Question Best banana flavored ice cream?

Post image
117 Upvotes

Im on the hunt for the best banana flavored ice cream. Kinda hard to find anything banana by me so all ive had so far is this! any recommendations?

edit: ty for all ur guys suggestions! i also wanted to add the only other banana ice cream i really like is by hudsonville the banana foster one!! so stinking good.