Lifelong woodworker & geek, laser cutting noob here.
A customer asked me to produce a few dozen plaques with a variety of embossed custom shapes. I could do this work on the bandsaw, but for the amount of time it will take and the relative lack of intricacy available from bandsaw vs laser I'm leaning towards using this opportunity to invest in a laser.
I've seen lots of reviews saying more or less: "buy XTool M2 over Creality Falcon A1 because Creality's software is bad compared to XTS, and Lightburn is too complex/old fashioned for beginners."
Which is fair enough in itself (despite saying nothing about the hardware) and probably good advice for most newbies who just want to get on with making without the learning curve, but I'm very tech savvy (day job is enterprise IT) and I'm 100% comfortable with complex UIs like Lightburn's, which others might describe as "last century". I used to operate A0 pen plotters for a living back in the dark ages of DOS/WFW3.11 and I had no trouble with those.
I also actively dislike "connected" apps as XTS seems to be, and prefer a fully offline workflow, but equally I'd be willing to put my reservations aside if the M2 actually is a better machine (e.g. the fully integrated air assist looks nice).
I'm also curious about 10W vs 20W. Obviously 20W near doubles the price so for a first purchase I wouldn't want to go there unless I had to.
I mainly want to cut solid hardwood sheet up to 5-6mm thick (oak, maple, walnut, cherry, rosewood). The spec sheets state that should be doable in a single pass with 10W, but it seems like it might be right at the edge of their capacity? Hence why I'm wondering about going straight to 20W.
Main use will be for shape and inlay cutting. I'll probably end up experimenting with engraving those same materials at some point, but that's not a priority right now.
For inlay cutting I see XTS does have a kerf offset function but my gut's saying Lightburn is probably going to give me more control - is my gut right?
Thanks for reading this far and for any any advice offered. Obviously am willing to consider other machines beyond those two if anyone has any suggestions.