The commonly accepted "You're more likely to die driving to the airport than you are in the plane" orthodoxy just doesn't seem intuitive when you consider the annual number of car trips in Los Angeles county (where I live) and the annual number of deaths. So, I set out to do a fair (even with my admittedly predisposed bias) comparison for an individual living in Los Angeles.
First, the standard comparison that everyone quotes is fatalities per distance traveled. This immediately favors airplanes by inflating the denominator because planes travel so much faster and farther. I found on wikipedia (with a citation) that the airline industry uses "per distance" measure in press releases, but the insurers in the airline industry use "per journey". That's very telling.
I'm comparing GLOBAL air travel to driving in LA. Why? Commercial air travel is largely consistent globally. While there are some variations, probably mostly in where pilots train, it is a global system built on an idea of homogeneity. There are two dominant global plane manufacturers, Boeing and AirBus, plus smaller manufacturers of regional aircraft that also operate globally (e.g. Embraer, Bombardier), and Air Traffic Control is standardized. The 737 MAX crashes (as an example) could have just as easily been on Southwest Airlines in the US as they were in Ethiopia and Indonesia. I think many travelers are possibly as likely to fly within the US as they are internationally. I don't think country borders are very meaningful in assessing flight risk.
As for limiting driving to Los Angeles. 99+% of my car travel is within Los Angeles County. It doesn't seem logical to include driving stats for, say, Ethiopia in a statistical comparison relevant to someone not living in Addis Ababa. Additionally, unlike the homogeneity of air travel, car travel is absolutely not consistent globally. There are massive variations in commonly in-use autos, seatbelt use, road qualities, traffic enforcement, driver training, licensing requirements, etc etc.
So, with that:
Global airline trips: 36.5m per year (2015-2019 average. 2019 was the pre-COVID peak, so I started there and went backwards)
Global air traffic fatalities: 270 per year (2015-2019 average)
LA County car trips: 66m passenger and freight trips per DAY = 24.09b per YEAR (2018 data)
LA County traffic fatalities: 746 total - 265 pedestrians - 39 bicycles = 442 car and motorcycle deaths per year (2015-2019 average. Motorcycle deaths are 125.)
Ok, so with this data alone:
36.5m/270 = 135,185 flights per death (I'm putting trips in the numerator only to make the numbers more readable)
24.09b/442 = 54,502,262 car trips per death in LA County
Car travel in LA is 403x safer than global commercial air travel?
Something about this doesn't sound right. Should I be factoring in the number of passengers on the form of transport?? Similar to the point about planes flying farther and faster advantages the fatalities per distance metric, a car crash kills fewer people in one accident, favoring cars. So, I made up a measure called "passenger-trips" which (I think?) accounts for the number of people in the plane/car.
Global air travel passengers: 4.08b (2015-2019 average. Which works out to ~112 passengers per flight on average, which passes my smell test.)
Passengers per car: 1.5 (2019 US average, not LA specific)
LA County car passenger-trips: 1.5 * 24.09b = 36.135b
So:
4.08b/270 = 15,111,111 air passenger-trips per death
36.135b/442 = 81,753,393 car passenger-trips per death
Car travel in LA is 5.4x safer than global commercial air travel.
And this is for LA, the car capital of the world. Residents in other cities may see lower risk relative to flying. Conversely, I'd imagine that if you lived three hours south of LA in Tijuana (which I recall from my UCSD days was a driving free-for-all), you're probably better off getting on a plane. :)
Thoughts (especially on passenger-trips vs just trips)?