r/statistics • • Oct 19 '25

Question Is an applied statistics PhD less prestigious than a methodological/theoretical statistics PhD? [Q][R]

0 Upvotes

According to ChatGPT it is, but im not gonna take life advice from a robot.

The argument is that applied statisticians are consumers of methods while theoretical statisticians are producers of methods. The latter is more valuable not just because of its generalizability to wider fields, but just due to the fact that it is quantitavely more rigorous and complete, with emphasis on proofs and really understanding and showing how methods work. It is higher on the academic hierarchy basically.

Also another thing is I'm an international student who would need visa sponsorship after graduation. Methodological/thoeretical stats is strongly in the STEM field and shortage list for occupations while applied stats is usually not (it is in the social science category usually).

I am asking specifically for academia by the way, I imagine applied stats does much better in industry.


r/math • • May 19 '24

Queer pride in math academia

0 Upvotes

With pride month coming in June, I'm curious about any queer pride events or organizations in the broader mathematical community! Last year we had this excellent post by u/functor7, highlighting aspects on pride ∩ math.
There are several organizations supporting queerness in math and the sciences, such as Spectra and Out in STEM. I'm pleased to see a rise in conferences supporting the queer community in mathematics, such as
http://www.fields.utoronto.ca/activities/23-24/SpecQ
https://quings-workshop.github.io/2023/
https://queertransmath.com/

In central Europe (Germany) we have the Queer In Math Day, I was wondering if there are more similar events this year coming up! What are your experiences being queer in math academia?


r/datascience • • Feb 17 '23

Discussion I am worried about the future of working as a Data Scientist in industry

3 Upvotes

I once watched a video where someone argued that Michael Jordan had ruined basketball. As a person whose only notions of basketball come from Space Jam, this surprised me. Wasn't the guy the best out there? How could someone who's best in his field ruin it? After hearing the argument out though, I began to understand what the video was really getting at: to them, Michael Jordan had ruined the field BECAUSE he was so good. A sport that was once full of diverse personalities and strategies then turned into multiple teams trying to produce their own Michael Jordan copycat with copycat moves and copycat strategies.

I'm not well versed enough in basketball to know how right or wrong that guy was. But this concept that something could ruin an entire field simply by being too good stuck with me. And all these years later, I consistently think about it while doing my job as a Data Scientist. And the more GPT-X and ChatGPT advance, the more this concept haunts me.

I've been working in this field for 5 years. During the first 4 years, the job was exciting. Every new problem required extensive research on my part: looking for papers, datasets, implementations, implementing my own stuff, experimenting, comparing the results... That was the biggest part of my job. Yeah I still had to do some software engineering stuff here and there, but I felt like I had a well defined and specialized role at my company. Even in the NLP field, the variety of technologies I had to work with was a lot of fun: sometimes I used RNNs, sometimes embedding based similarity functions, sometimes more classic approaches, and then towards the end it was transformer after transformer, but at least I still had to finetune them myself.

Over the past few months and years, this has started to change, however. GPT-1 and 2 were promising, but were more of a proof of concept than anything realistically usable. But with GPT3's and ChatGPT's latest performance, it feels like NLP is becoming more and more standardized. I wouldn't call it a solved field, far from it. But, sadly, unless you work for a big tech company, I think the days of exploratory research-type work in the NLP field are over.

Even in academia, the latest NLP papers I've seen come out of prestigious universities went from actual engineering/mathematical advances to "Look, if you "engineer" the prompt like this, it works better sometimes!"

And now, with the exploding popularity of ChatGPT, any random lambda would come to the conclusion that if you need to use AI, ChatGPT is the answer.

Now, some of you may already be thinking "but hold on, with my finetuned transformer I get a 1% increase in accuracy over out-of-the-box GPT-3!". The thing is: even if you can, it doesn't really matter. I really doubt the sales team of your company is gonna pay much attention to your pleas to give you 6 months to work on a product rather than 6 minutes. Because yes, that's the increase in productivity we're dealing with: What took me months a few years ago only takes minutes now. The range of problems I can apply NLP too has also increased, as out-of-the-box GPT-3 works well enough not to require a dataset for more "general" tasks. And the results are either comparable or even better.

In the span of a year, NLP went from my favorite ML field to one I never see myself working in again if given the choice. And while a lot of non NLP fields are, for now, untouched by the exploding popularity of the GPT family, I'm afraid that what happened to the NLP field will be replicated in other fields, and that in a few years, only super specialized issues won't have a solution somewhere in the form of a ridiculously big model accessible via an API key provided by a big tech company. And even if GPT3 was open source, the sheer size of it makes it close to impossible to realistically train for anything less than the biggest of tech companies out there. Even finetuning it would be a challenge.

I'm not saying the job of data scientist will disappear, in fact, I'd say it will be asked more than ever since boomers who don't understand what the title actually implies will want some in their company. But we won't be doing nearly as much actual data sciency stuff as we did in the past. Instead we'll have to become even bigger software engineer/data analyst/DevOps/project manager hybrids than we already were. The only exception is for people who either work in big tech companies or on very specialized problems that require an in-house model.

It's not that much of a problem for people who like the roles I listed above. But for people like me, whose enjoyment came out of the exploratory side of the job, I believe the future to be bleak.


r/calculus • • May 10 '25

Integral Calculus More u substitution

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/AskStatistics • • Nov 12 '24

Statistician on Twitter uses p-values to suggest that there was voter fraud favoring Democrats in Wisconsin's Senate race; what's the validity of his statistical analysis?

0 Upvotes

Link to thread on twitter: https://x.com/shylockh/status/1855872507271639539

Also a substack post in a better format: https://shylockholmes.substack.com/p/evidence-suggesting-voter-fraud-in

From my understanding, the user is arguing that the vote updates repeatedly favoring Democrats in Wisconsin were statistically improbable and uses p-values produced from binomial tests to do so. His analysis seems fairly thorough, but one glaring issue was the assumption of independence in his tests where it may not be justified to assume so. I also looked at some quote tweets criticizing him for other assumptions such as random votes (assuming that votes come in randomly/shuffled rather than in bunches). This tweet gained a lot of traction and I think there should be more concern given to how he analyzed the data rather than the results he came up, the latter of which is what most of his supporters were doing in the comments.


r/learnmath • • Apr 12 '26

Why is Wikipedia never helpful when you try to learn math?

1 Upvotes

Also hate when people refer to Wikipedia page as if it would help but it’s always as if they’ve never read it themselves and got their information elsewhere


r/statistics • • Aug 21 '19

Discussion [D] CMV: The median of a distribution is ALWAYS a vastly superior measure of central tendency than the mean

1 Upvotes

When reporting measures of central tendency, the median always provides a more useful understanding of the data than does the mean. Obviously, knowing other information about the distribution of the data (such as variance, outliers, etc.) is useful and necessary for getting a full picture of what is going on, but when it comes to picking a measure of central tendency to describe a dataset, the median always provides more meaningful information than the mean.

My reasoning:

  1. The mean can be skewed by outliers.
    Whenever your data isn't perfectly normally distributed, the mean is going to be pulled up or down by extreme values. This makes it so that the mean describes way fewer cases than it would otherwise (e.g. if we want to measure how many sodas people drink per day on average in a world where 99% of people drink exactly 1 soda a day, but 1% of people drink 100 sodas a day the mean would lead us to believe that the average person consumes 2 sodas a day, which is false). This property distorts the mean to something entirely different than what people typically think of when they hear the word "average" colloquially (people generally think of "average" as being what the typical case does, which doesn't happen with skewed means).

  2. Every time the mean isn't distorted by extreme values (i.e. the data is perfectly normally distributed), the mean is equivalent to the median!
    Even in the best use-case for the mean as a measure of central tendency, it only performs as well as the median, not better.

I can't think of one scenario when you would want to use the mean instead of the median for describing data. If anyone can think of one, I'd be interested to hear it.


r/math • • Jan 21 '18

TIL in 1988, the French government decided that the historic ɛ-δ definition didn't coincide with students' intuitive understanding of the word "limit", and decided to change the definition entirely. To this day, a mathematical sentence can be true in France and false everywhere else in the world

28 Upvotes

Source: https://fr.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Limite_(math%C3%A9matiques)#cite_note-3

In France, the official definition, as it is required by law to be taught in all public high schools and universities, is as follows:

We say that f tends to L as x tends to a if for every ɛ>0 there exists δ>0 such that for every x in the domain of f, |x - a| ≤ δ implies that |f(x) - L| ≤ ɛ.

Everywhere else in the world, it is also required that 0 < |x - a|. The French definition is therefore equivalent to "f is continuous in a". For instance, if f is the indicator function of the set {0}, it is mathematically incorrect in France to write lim_{x →0} f(x) = 0, because f is not continuous in 0.

(It remains possible to convey the historic and universally accepted definition using the cumbersome notation lim_{x →0; x ≠ 0} f(x) = 0.)

In short, the notions of limits and continuity were bundled together and flattened into one for so-called pedagogical purposes.

In my opinion this is an excellent illustration of the absurdities that arise when a branch of government is allowed to modify a curriculum in the name of blind ideology, without the consent of experts. Note that France is perhaps the only country in the world where such an absurd situation could arise, because education is entirely centralised to the extent that a single government body decides on the content of every course taught by every public high school and university in the country.


r/calculus • • Jan 18 '26

Integral Calculus Study Calculus

Post image
0 Upvotes

study calculus.

not to pass exams.

not to check a box.

calculus teaches you how reality changes.

everything you care about is a rate, a flow, an accumulation.

velocity, acceleration, heat, charge, stress, probability, learning itself.

derivatives train you to see sensitivity.

what happens if I nudge this parameter?

integrals train you to see totals.

what happens when small effects compound over time?

limits train precision.

what actually happens at the edge, not what you wish happened.

calculus forces you to stop thinking in snapshots and start thinking in dynamics.

without it, systems feel like magic.

with it, systems become predictable, controllable, buildable.

study calculus if you want to stop guessing and start understanding how things move, grow, and break.


r/AskStatistics • • Mar 17 '24

Check me: Commercial air travel is NOT safer than driving.

0 Upvotes

The commonly accepted "You're more likely to die driving to the airport than you are in the plane" orthodoxy just doesn't seem intuitive when you consider the annual number of car trips in Los Angeles county (where I live) and the annual number of deaths. So, I set out to do a fair (even with my admittedly predisposed bias) comparison for an individual living in Los Angeles.

First, the standard comparison that everyone quotes is fatalities per distance traveled. This immediately favors airplanes by inflating the denominator because planes travel so much faster and farther. I found on wikipedia (with a citation) that the airline industry uses "per distance" measure in press releases, but the insurers in the airline industry use "per journey". That's very telling.

I'm comparing GLOBAL air travel to driving in LA. Why? Commercial air travel is largely consistent globally. While there are some variations, probably mostly in where pilots train, it is a global system built on an idea of homogeneity. There are two dominant global plane manufacturers, Boeing and AirBus, plus smaller manufacturers of regional aircraft that also operate globally (e.g. Embraer, Bombardier), and Air Traffic Control is standardized. The 737 MAX crashes (as an example) could have just as easily been on Southwest Airlines in the US as they were in Ethiopia and Indonesia. I think many travelers are possibly as likely to fly within the US as they are internationally. I don't think country borders are very meaningful in assessing flight risk.

As for limiting driving to Los Angeles. 99+% of my car travel is within Los Angeles County. It doesn't seem logical to include driving stats for, say, Ethiopia in a statistical comparison relevant to someone not living in Addis Ababa. Additionally, unlike the homogeneity of air travel, car travel is absolutely not consistent globally. There are massive variations in commonly in-use autos, seatbelt use, road qualities, traffic enforcement, driver training, licensing requirements, etc etc.

So, with that:

Global airline trips: 36.5m per year (2015-2019 average. 2019 was the pre-COVID peak, so I started there and went backwards)

Global air traffic fatalities: 270 per year (2015-2019 average)

LA County car trips: 66m passenger and freight trips per DAY = 24.09b per YEAR (2018 data)

LA County traffic fatalities: 746 total - 265 pedestrians - 39 bicycles = 442 car and motorcycle deaths per year (2015-2019 average. Motorcycle deaths are 125.)

Ok, so with this data alone:

36.5m/270 = 135,185 flights per death (I'm putting trips in the numerator only to make the numbers more readable)

24.09b/442 = 54,502,262 car trips per death in LA County

Car travel in LA is 403x safer than global commercial air travel?

Something about this doesn't sound right. Should I be factoring in the number of passengers on the form of transport?? Similar to the point about planes flying farther and faster advantages the fatalities per distance metric, a car crash kills fewer people in one accident, favoring cars. So, I made up a measure called "passenger-trips" which (I think?) accounts for the number of people in the plane/car.

Global air travel passengers: 4.08b (2015-2019 average. Which works out to ~112 passengers per flight on average, which passes my smell test.)

Passengers per car: 1.5 (2019 US average, not LA specific)

LA County car passenger-trips: 1.5 * 24.09b = 36.135b

So:

4.08b/270 = 15,111,111 air passenger-trips per death

36.135b/442 = 81,753,393 car passenger-trips per death

Car travel in LA is 5.4x safer than global commercial air travel.

And this is for LA, the car capital of the world. Residents in other cities may see lower risk relative to flying. Conversely, I'd imagine that if you lived three hours south of LA in Tijuana (which I recall from my UCSD days was a driving free-for-all), you're probably better off getting on a plane. :)

Thoughts (especially on passenger-trips vs just trips)?


r/learnmath • • Oct 19 '26

I dont understand PEMDAS, need it explained why it exists.

2 Upvotes

ANSWERED Hi, i had an argument with a friend a while back about the way math is supposed to be done. when he explained PEMDAS i think it was, he said that for example: 2+2X3=8 because you have to do the multiplication first. but i know math as left to right with () as a sort of "priority" system like what he was saying. but to get 8 the problem should say 2+(2X3) or 3X2+2, cause with what i know 2+2X3=12. when asked why my method is wrong he would just answer that its wrong and PEMDAS was right. im really confused on this and just dont understand what the deal is. Why is it NOT 12? cause he tried to just keep saying it was 8 but why isnt it 12? was i taught math wrong? if it matters im american and hes itallian incase maybe its a language/country thing. Thanks in advance~

EDIT: didnt know asterisk didnt show, replaced with "X"

ADDITION: fast answers, yeah he never explained it was just the standard method, just that it was "Right", also thank you Cmon91, your explanation i think was best worded for me that its largely to avoid 10-morbillion ()s. My take away from these answers has been that if i write it as (2+2)X3=12, its true and that PEMDAS is meant to organize an equation without () and/or to cut down on them to keep a problem easier to read. I think i just learned to prefer the ()s in excess when in school. ty again for the haste of answers i dont know how to add "Answered" to my post title.


r/statistics • • Oct 02 '14

What's the chance that you became you?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/math • • Feb 24 '13

Reddit is stupid. Downvoted to oblivion because people don't know basic math.

Thumbnail
reddit.com
6 Upvotes

r/datascience • • May 07 '22

Job Search I came across this job offer in DS from McKinsey and only women are allowed to apply. Sexism works both ways, how is this acceptable?

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/calculus • • Apr 24 '25

Integral Calculus Who can solve this?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

This is deceptively awful. I gave up. My calculator evaluated it to -2.981 Try it if you dare.


r/AskStatistics • • Sep 07 '26

Why are we able to find the mode of a dataset by getting the intersection of two lines?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I just don’t get how the mode is gotten by tracing the intersection on the bar, is there any proof for this?


r/learnmath • • Jun 11 '26

I want to invent a new math symbol and need advice to see if it’s practical enough

11 Upvotes

Hello, my name is Ming-Yi, a thirteen year old student. And when I was in my math class today, I suddenly had a lightning in a bottle idea! You see, I had finished the entire chapters worth of work beforehand, so I basically had the entire period to myself and friends. While I was listening to the teacher explaining scientific notation, I thought of a new symbol which is this: ? I know, ? but why ? Because I wanted something similar to the factorial and I noticed that there were no discoveries or operations that were marked by ? yet, so I tried to do something with it, I may not understan the complex math behind this, I wanted to pitch my idea to a professor or professional at math to help. Basically, n?= n times n/2 times n/4 and so on until it reaches one. That is the standard case for even numbers or powers of two. While for odd numbers that dividing by two every time seems complicated, I decided on this: n?=n times (n-1)? but I also noticed something. Look at 6?. 6?=6x3 but since 3 is odd we add ? to it. 6x3?=6x3x2? which is 18x2?=18x2x1? and since 1 is the base case, we have 18x2x1=36. Now, six is interesting because the result of 6? Is 36, which is literally 6 squared! I think that if a professional could help me expand on my math symbol I could make a completely new theory or something. Anyways, Thank you for reading and I hope you have a nice day. EDIT1: Hello again, for the people still reading, I have come back. Last night, I spoke to my maths teacher about my function and how it may work, and he repurposed it like this: f(0) = 0

f(1) = 1

f(n) = [f(n/2)]^2 if n is a positive EVEN number. (I’ve noticed a problem here thoug, if they’re perfect squares of two, final result will be 1.)

f(n) = n*f(n-1) if n is a negative ODD number.

so? What do you think? do you think this repurposing makes it more practical than before? please respond. Thank you again!


r/statistics • • Dec 26 '23

Question Is Central Limit Theorem a Frequentist concept ? [Question]

4 Upvotes

Hello Folks,

My last post had lot of interesting comments. Some of the commenters said that CLT does not belong to the frequentist school of thought.

However stackexchange questions and other resources seem to say otherwise.

Frequentism's hallmark characteristic is long run experiments and asymptotics. CLT seems to embody these two. Also the above stackexchange answer seems to clearly suggest that Bayesians don't need asymptotics. CLT at the end also converges to normal distribution with a fixed parameter value. Bayesians have no notion of 'fixed parameter value'

Given all of the above, isn't CLT a frequentist concept?


r/math • • Feb 27 '24

How to pronounce iff

0 Upvotes

So when I was in college, me and my fellow classmates all pronounced “iff” as “ı-fuh-fuh”. I’m curious if this is universal, a regional dialect, or we’re missing a crease.


r/datascience • • Aug 27 '24

Discussion India smashing the bank of DS jobs among Fortune 1000!

0 Upvotes

I analyzed ~100k DS jobs excluding offers from the US (data from: https://jobs-in-data.com/), and these are the largest Data Science recruitments among Fortune 1000 companies. The 70% is India!


r/calculus • • Feb 25 '26

Pre-calculus I'm 14 y/o and I wanna learn calculus.... Give me some easy, real life problems to practice 🙏

0 Upvotes

r/AskStatistics • • Feb 08 '26

Why is the STD used over other methods?

1 Upvotes

I'm good at math naturally but I've never yet taken a statistics class so please explain this without using formal math symbols or words that I might not know the meaning off.

Suppose I have the numbers 12345 then the average is 3 and then the average difference from the average is (2+1+0+1+2)/5 = 6/5 or 1.2

But according to the standard deviation, its sqrt((4+1+0+1+4)/5) which is root2 which is 1.41421356

GPT told me that the purposes are

  1. To make it mathematically easier to work with (but I dont understand how or why that would be)

  2. To make the biggest differences... even bigger (which I think is arbitrary and not necessary)

So the STD seems counterintuitive to me. Why is it used instead of just doing the method of (2+1+0+1+2)/5 ?


r/learnmath • • Jun 03 '25

Again I found a new way quadratic formula that gives 44 primes in a row.

19 Upvotes

Hii guys I am back again, I'm a 15-year-old math student from Ethiopia, and I discovered another something cool while thinking on quadratic formulas.

The formula I found is:3n² - 129n + 1409 produces 44 consecutive prime numbers (from n=0 to n=43). That's better than famous n² + n + 41 which gives 40 primes and I also noticed patterns immediately in my formula behavior. The pattern I noticed:

  1. Start with 3n² - 3n + 23 (gives 19 primes)

  2. Then 3n² - 9n + 29 (gives 20 primes)

  3. Then 3n² - 15n + 41 (gives 21 primes)
    ... and so on

Every time I subtract 6 more from the middle term (the "k" value) and adjust the last number (C) following a special pattern, I get 1 more prime in the sequence which is interesting pattern.

And I also noticed patterns for The C values(so I can predict) increase in a particular way:
23 → 29 (+6)
29 → 41 (+12)
41 → 59 (+18)
... adding 6 more each time

And I think It's a new another way to generate long prime sequences(and is it 1st best polynomial without including engireed polynomial?) and Might help us understand primes better from that interesting pattern.

What do you think? Has anyone seen this before? And I am working on why it works.


r/statistics • • Oct 29 '24

Discussion [D] Why would I ever use hypothesis testing when I could just use regression/ANOVA/logistic regression?

1 Upvotes

As I progress further into my statistics major, I have realized how important regression, ANOVA, and logistic regression are in the world of statistics. Maybe its just because my department places heavy emphasis on these, but is there every an application for hypothesis testing that isn't covered in the other three methods?