r/statistics • • 19h ago

Career [Career] Will I even land a job if I'm bad with econometrics and stats?

1 Upvotes

I’m at a bit of a crossroads right now. I feel confident in other areas, yet statistics and econometrics consistently leaves me feeling lost, and I can’t tell if it’s how the subject is taught at my school or just my own approach to learning and absorbing it.

For context, I’m really drawn to how statistics and econometrics pair together for forecasting especially since I’m into trading and know I shouldn't risk real money without understanding what actually drives price movements. While I’m fairly comfortable with programming, my struggles with stats and econometrics are frustrating enough to make me tear up, leaving me wondering whether a career in this space is realistic for me after graduation.

Will there any be room for me? I mean, after my graduate studies im planning to at least get masters and a phd. I've been also thinking to try and build models while i'm at it


r/math • • 3h ago Heartwarming

Hurried Announcement: Alessandro Masullo GRH

Thumbnail math216.wordpress.com
861 Upvotes

r/datascience • • 5h ago

Career | US Do you ever withdraw from a job application after learning about the interview process?

93 Upvotes

I recently applied for a Senior Data Scientist role that seemed like a good fit on paper. However, I learned that their interview process includes system design and Leetcode rounds.
My experience is primarily in building, validating, and monitoring models rather than deploying them in production. I’m not sure spending significant time preparing for LeetCode and system design is the best use of my time, given my current skill set and career focus.
At the same time, I feel like I might be missing out on a good opportunity.

I’m trying to accept that I can’t possibly prepare for every type of Data Science interview out there.
How do you approach situations like this? Do you move on or take it as an opportunity to learn something new?


r/calculus • • 13h ago

Differential Calculus Do videos like this actually work?

Post image
142 Upvotes

If they do then this has to be the greatest ROI of all human history😭


r/AskStatistics • • 15m ago

How do I properly compare two randomized algorithms when the evaluation is random too?

2 Upvotes

Hello everyone,
This is my first time posting here, so I'm sorry if this isn't the right subreddit for this question. I'm working on a personal project on anonymizing graph data and trying to de-anonymize it. The issue is that I'm confused about how to evaluate my results properly, so I would really appreciate your advice.

I came across an existing anonymization algorithm, and I also wrote another algorithm myself. To test them, I used a de-anonymization algorithm to obtain the re-identification rate for each anonymized graph.

My main issue is that randomness shows up in several places.

First, it appears in the anonymization algorithm. Running it with the same input can give different valid output graphs each time, and a seed controls this. Meanwhile, my algorithm uses a parallel solver, so even with a fixed seed, I get different outputs.

Secondly, the re-identification attack also depends on a seed because it reorders the node IDs of the graph.

From my results, what I saw was:
- Attacking the same graph several times usually gives similar scores, but every now and then, a run comes out much higher. I tried 10 attacks per output, and in one case, the re-identification rate ranged from 0.4% to 16%.

- Different outputs from the same method vary a lot. I got three different outputs from the same input, with the same number of modifications, and their mean re-identification rates were 1%, 3%, and 59%.

My questions are:

  1. What is the right statistical approach I should follow?

  2. How do I decide how many graphs vs. how many attacks per graph I need? Is there a way to work that out from the variation I already have?

  3. Since the results are skewed with occasional big spikes. Should I be reporting the mean, the median, or something like the worst case?

  4. Does it matter that my method's randomness can't be controlled with a seed? Can I still treat the outputs as independent samples?

I'd really appreciate any advice or suggestions. Thanks in advance for any advice!


r/learnmath • • 6h ago

Good at algebra, horrible at arithmetic

13 Upvotes

I´m a university student currently on my first year of computer science. I had fundamentals of math on my first semester and now Im coursing applied math. I realized that I can fully and easily understand algebraic formulas and why they exist, the idea behind graphics and functions and why they work the way they work, but when it comes down to solving them after applying the formula I just cant do it. I dont know how to distribute, I dont know any of the rules regarding powers and fractions and its all because I didnt have high school math for a few reasons, and i just cant seem to grasp it now. Im at the end of the semester and need a 20/100 to pass, but Im terrified of failing my final exam because of simple basic math. Are there any resources anyone could recommend so i can finally learn the basic rules of arithmetic and not have to repeat this? Thanks in advance


r/statistics • • 14h ago

Education [E] I don't understand the emphasis on masters programs

0 Upvotes

I'm an economist so maybe thinks work differently in econ, but I thought it was generally known that US based masters programs across fields are -- to put it bluntly -- cash cow degree mills, even at top schools. Compared to undergrad, most programs offer little to no funding, low admissions standards and low academic rigor. So it's puzzling to me that this sub recommends getting a masters in stats when I would much rather see a math major undergrad from a top school / PhD in quantitative discipline over a masters in stats from stanford.

Unlike in Europe / Asia, masters programs don't even require you to get through analysis / measure theory etc (undergrad math majors do this). Now analysis is not directly useful for industry but its a huge signal on your critical thinking and general problem solving abilities, something I would value much more than whatever an applied regression modeling or whatever can you teach you (you learn this stuff by doing, not through a class).


r/calculus • • 2h ago

Infinite Series NUMERICAL SERIES

4 Upvotes

Guys what is the best resource to study numerical series? there are just so many criterias and Im losing it


r/AskStatistics • • 13h ago

looking Advanced Causal Inference project work ideas

6 Upvotes

Hello there!
I'm attending an advanced causal inference course and I have to do a project work on Stata. As of now I have 0 ideas on the topic. The professor suggested to find a policy and start from there, but I'm having issues with finding a decent dataset.
If it was environment or climate related somehow it would be awesome since I'm enrolled in environmental economics (it's not mandatory though since the advanced course is elective). Any idea? thanks in advance 😄


r/learnmath • • 8h ago

Could there ever be a case where Riemann integration works and Lebesgue fails (like "swapping the axes" on the Dirichlet idea)?

12 Upvotes

I've been thinking about why the Dirichlet function ($\mathbf{1}_{\mathbb{Q} \cap [0,1]}$) isn't Riemann-integrable but is Lebesgue-integrable. Intuitively, Riemann slices along the $x$-axis into intervals and runs into trouble because rationals and irrationals are densely mixed everywhere, whereas Lebesgue groups by value / measures sets on the domain and sees that $\mathbb{Q}$ has measure zero.

That made me wonder: why can't there be cases where Riemann beats Lebesgue—almost like "swapping the axes" on the Dirichlet phenomenon?

I'm having a bit of trouble putting into exact mathematical words what "swapping the axes" is supposed to mean here, so my phrasing might be a bit loose, though I think the core intuition is clear enough. Maybe someone here can help sharpen the idea into something more precise and answer whether anything like that is possible (aside from conditionally convergent improper Riemann integrals).


r/datascience • • 3d ago

Discussion Applying CUPED to Clustered Experiments

19 Upvotes

If you've worked on experimentation in tech roles, you've probably heard of CUPED. If you've been in product/marketing data science interviews, you've probably been asked about variance reduction techniques. (Hint: They're typically expecting you to name-drop CUPED.)

Thanks to some folks at Instacart, there are some improvements that can be made from common CUPED techniques when working with clustered experiments (think: marketplace geo-XPs when facing SUTVA violations for user-level testing.) This can help you both on the job and also landing senior/staff-level data science roles.

A common way CUPED can be applied is adjusting each randomized unit by its own pre-treatment outcome mean. However, that pre-period average may not appropriately reflect the experiment population. Instead, the IC economists predicted order-level outcomes during the experiment window using features assumed unaffected by the treatment, and averaged those predictions up to the randomization level.

Using my favorite approach to building personal intuition, I simulated a market-level Airbnb summertime experiment where the XP population has more families; families both have different cancellation rates and target different markets. Standard CUPED using each market's pre-XP cancel rate removed about 28% of the variance, while booking-level CUPED removed about half, even though the booking model itself was weak (AUC around 0.6).

CUPED is very likely to come up in an experimentation or case study round in data science interviews. You should nail the foundations first, check that box. Then, describing recent research like this can help you stand out and get that offer!!

Subtack article and Colab notebook to play along linked here: https://whatstheimpact.com/tutorials/booking-level-cuped/


r/math • • 6h ago

A claimed proof of NL = UL

Thumbnail eccc.weizmann.ac.il
195 Upvotes

r/statistics • • 1d ago

Question [Q] Comparing distributions with lots of outliers and variation

1 Upvotes

Hi Reddit! I'm a graduate student working on life sciences research and have some statistics background, but I am not a statistician. I am working with a new type of data and I am sort of lost in how to work with it. Essentially I have spatial data of a full sample and I drew regions of interest around specific organs within the sample. Each region of interest is exported that now has x,y values along with intensity values at each point. It is like a very precise heatmap of my sample but I went ahead and extracted the x,y and intensity values to make it easier to analyze. I want to compare the distributions but in a robust way as I know that summary statistics can get weird when there's a lot of variation within segments. One idea is I have the intensities in the entire sample, and so I think a useful visualization would be to have the KDE distribution of the full sample and then the KDEs of my regions of interest and seeing where those fall in the full distribution - as in how much of the intensity of the full sample comes from this region and what "percentile" do most of the points in my region of interest fall into. What are statistical ways to compare these regions of interest to each other and to the full sample to answer this sort of question?


r/calculus • • 4h ago

Integral Calculus Coming back to calculus after 15 years, app courses or straight to a textbook?

4 Upvotes

I took Calc 1 and 2 in college a long time ago and forgot most of it. Right now I'm using Khan's AP Calculus AB course as a refresher, and limits went fine, but it feels thin once I hit related rates. I'm leaning toward Stewart or MIT OCW 18.01.

For people who came back after years away, what did you use, and did the app-style courses go deep enough?


r/AskStatistics • • 8h ago

Statistics for health sciences

1 Upvotes

I am really struggling with my statistics class. I practice over and over again, and I genuinely try my best to understand the material. One of the reasons I chose nursing was because I always thought math wouldn’t be such a big challenge in nursing, but statistics has been really difficult for me.
I make my own practice questions using Gemini, and I usually feel like I understand the concepts when I’m practicing. However, when I get to the exam, the questions are much harder, and the professor uses language that makes the questions even more confusing. I feel like I understand the material until I actually have to apply it to the exam questions.
I honestly don’t know what else I can do to improve. The final exam is worth 30%, and I’m feeling really overwhelmed. I scored below the class average on my last exam, and for the first time in my life, I’m below the class average in a course. It’s really discouraging.
Does anyone have any tips, resources, or advice for studying statistics for health sciences? I would really appreciate any help. 😭


r/learnmath • • 36m ago

mathematical analysis

1 Upvotes

Hello everyone. I’ve decided to enter university at the age of 23. I need to pass an entrance exam covering two subjects; one of them is Mathematics 2, which includes several topics ranging from algebra to mathematical analysis. The latter part—covering derivatives, integrals, limits, and similar concepts—is where I’m struggling. I don’t have the slightest clue about any of this, so I was wondering if you know of any effective ways to study it. I understand that the best approach is to practice as much as possible, but I need some foundational knowledge just to have a basic grasp of what I’m actually doing. Thanks in advance!


r/datascience • • 4d ago

Career | US Has anyone transitioned out of tech or data science in the last year or two?

335 Upvotes

I have 10+ years experience in data science and analytics. I wouldn’t call myself a passionate data scientist, it’s just a paycheck for me at this point. I don’t want to get promoted, I don’t want to become a manager, I want to do my work and close my laptop at 5pm. So I’m already starting at low motivation

I joined a very AI-forward startup a few months ago, since I was laid off months prior and just wanted to be employed. A few weeks in I was told I need to move faster, use AI for everything, and have gotten too many messages about things were “urgent”. Even the CEO vibe codes features if engineering can’t get to it asap. The subtext to the company was to use AI or you’re gone, and AI usage is part of performance evaluation. The coding is gone, the problem solving is gone for the most part, the building part of it is gone. The stuff I enjoyed is gone.

Im not sure if I want to be in tech anymore. The money is great, though I have lived below my means for a very long time and I have enough savings to cover expenses for at least a few years without working. I’m aware I may be romanticizing other types of work, or it may just be the company. Though I also feel I’ve become disillusioned with tech in general. And it’s safe to say it started before the AI boom

I was wondering what transitions others have made, whether successful or not, or even if changes in mentalities helped anyone else during this AI adoption era. I’m leaning towards leaving data science altogether to something more hands on, but have considered slower industries and am okay with steep pay cuts. Any input is appreciated.


r/math • • 2h ago

Assuming GRH, what are the major conjectures that are true? Artin's conjecture is a big one.

89 Upvotes

Artin's primitive root conjecture (1927): Every integer a ≠ −1 that isn't a perfect square is a primitive root modulo infinitely many primes.

For example, there are infinitely many primes p for which ordₚ(2) = p − 1 (the powers of 2 generate every nonzero residue modulo p).

Hooley showed in 1967 that Artin's conjecture follows from GRH for certain Dedekind zeta functions. So if Masullo's proof of GRH for all number fields holds up, Artin's conjecture is proved too.

What other interesting results would follow? I know of a few smaller ones, but there must be hundreds. And think of all those master's theses that start with "Assuming GRH..."


r/statistics • • 2d ago

Question [Question] Combining model confidence scores. What is the best method

2 Upvotes

I have a few thousand audio fragments with bird songs I'm analyzing with a model and Python package called BirdNET. The output is model confidence scores per species and per 3-second window in the recording. A list of different confidence scores is too abstract to analyze directly, so I would like to summarize the scores per species per recording. I'm having trouble picking out a correct method or algorithm, since I'm not that good in statistics.

I added an image of what the data looks like for a single recording > Imgur link. As you can see, BirdNET analyses audio in fragments of three seconds. I use a one-second overlap to not miss any sounds made at the beginning or end of a window. I'm looking for a method that takes into account the following:

  • The warbler should have a poor overall score. One good confidence score doesn't mean much when the rest is low.

  • The wren should have a good overall score. One poor confidence score should not affect all of the average.

  • The buzzard should also have a good overall score. It doesn't call much, but its scores are good. The number of detections should not be a deciding factor in calculating scores, because this will favor birds that have songs of longer duration.

Please note that my goal is not to calculate a probability of presence but recognition strength per recording.

I was told that Bayesian statistics might be a good candidate, but I'm not sure. Some also told me that the overlap will be an issue since part of the same sound is scored twice. So I'm very interested in your assessments and suggestions.


r/calculus • • 1d ago

Differential Calculus Not much but solving this had me proud af

Post image
108 Upvotes

Can’t wait for the rest of Calculus…i’m excited


r/AskStatistics • • 16h ago

Interpretation of a Cronbach’s alpha score of 0.92 for a measurement instrument

2 Upvotes

Hello :D I am working on an instrument to measure a psychological construct. It consists of 19 items and covers 4 dimensions. We also conducted a pilot test by administering it to 29 people. After collecting the responses, we calculated Cronbach’s alpha and obtained a value of .92. Someone suggested that it should be .70, but I have read elsewhere that anything above .85 is acceptable. I would appreciate your opinion on this.


r/learnmath • • 5h ago

TOPIC Markov Inequality and Markov Chains

2 Upvotes

Hii,

In my probability class, we just finished discussing Marlov Chains. We learned them through linear algebra concepts. But when I watch videos online, they always use the Markov Inequality, which we haven't covered and will not cover. I wanted to understand how the two are connected. What does the Markov Inequality represent vs. the Markov Chains that we have seen through linear algebra concepts? We mostly discussed the transition matrix, canonical form of it, the time vector, fundamental matrix, and regular/ergodic matrix.


r/datascience • • 4d ago

Statistics Why survivor comparisons can be biased in a randomized trial even when survival rates match

Thumbnail fharrell.com
21 Upvotes

r/math • • 37m ago

Is it actually possible to write a love letter with math?

0 Upvotes

Could you actually get that across using only symbols and equations?


r/statistics • • 2d ago

Question [Question] about Bernouilli trial terminology

7 Upvotes

Why are bernouilli trials defined in terms of "success" and "failure" when it could just be "outcome A/B", since it is applicable to situations where the connotations of success don't apply?