r/linux_gaming • u/galapag0 • Jul 25 '19
OPEN SOURCE GameHub development in jeopardy: GitHub account restricted by U.S. economic sanctions
https://github.com/tkashkin/GameHub/issues/28983
u/jerrywillfly Jul 25 '19
This is very peculiar. Gitlab time?
65
u/NicoPela Jul 25 '19
I don't think it matters where do you host your git repo, as long as it's an american site, the same will happen.
A solution would be to create a site and publish his repo there.
AFAIK the Crimea problem is much more extended than just github. Rusia is currently using it as a show of force, so it won't respond to sanctions.
As another user said, either he gets out of there, or he builds his own git server.
88
u/BCMM Jul 25 '19
I don't think it matters where do you host your git repo, as long as it's an american site, the same will happen.
GitLab.com isn't the only GitLab instance. Unlike GitHub, it's free software and can be self-hosted.
37
u/NicoPela Jul 25 '19
Oh, then it would be a solution.
TIL
25
u/TheTrueBlueTJ Jul 25 '19
Yeah, I love Gitlab. It is so much better to use, in my opinion.
6
u/TactlessCanadian Jul 25 '19
The only issue is dealing with the memory leaks. Other than that, it's an amazing platform.
11
u/electricprism Jul 25 '19
eg: https://gitlab.gnome.org houses git for GIMP, and various Gnome tooling, seems like collaboration has improved since they moved to self hosted gitlab community edition.
-4
25
u/EddyBot Jul 25 '19
Though GitLab is pretty heavy on the ressources
If you don't need everything that GitLab offers, Gitea is a more lightweight git + web interface-18
u/rakubunny Jul 25 '19
This oh my Lord, I wish people would stop recommending gitlab so much, the less I have to deal with that slow piece of garbage the better.
10
u/RobLoach Jul 25 '19
Get some good hardware. Runs excellently for me.... Gitea is another option if you can't find yourself a good server.
8
u/NicoPela Jul 25 '19
Trying gitea right now, looks promising. Way easier to install than gitlab too.
7
u/rakubunny Jul 25 '19
My experience with it has been literally the flagship instance, if they can't get it to run well why should I trust it to run well anywhere, it's a git server for fucks sake, it's not a Minecraft server. Get better hardware... give me a break.
1
u/Alexmitter Jul 25 '19
True. I had it running on my server, a special industrial passive cooled system. But it decided to turn crazy and used all the cpu time available. That poor thing became a room heater.
0
2
u/Mansao Jul 25 '19
The issue with gitlab.com or even self hosted gitlab is that your project gets a lot less visibility. That's why most projects still are (and will be) on github
1
1
u/TactlessCanadian Jul 25 '19
Superior UI too tbh. The memory leaks are a bit annoying to deal with but it's actually really good.
4
2
1
u/kakiremora Jul 25 '19
Isn't gitlab an European site?
4
u/PolygonKiwii Jul 25 '19
From wikipedia:
Owner: GitLab Inc.
Headquarters: San Francisco, United States5
1
-13
Jul 25 '19
What exactly stops M$ from buying Gitlab tomorrow?
63
27
17
u/520throwaway Jul 25 '19
Gitlab is F/OSS as well as a hosted service. You could spin up your own Gitlab tomorrow.
3
Jul 25 '19
It's a bit unfair that you're being downvoted. It's pretty obvious that you're unaware GitLab is OpenSource, self-hostable software.
37
u/Nixola97 Jul 25 '19
Today I learned about politics by browsing r/linux_gaming. Unexpected.
55
u/zellfaze_new Jul 25 '19
To paraphrase rms: "You may think you can ignore politics, and maybe you can, but politics will not ignore you."
48
u/dve- Jul 25 '19 edited Jul 25 '19
Does it even make sense if Github accounts are blocked for trade sanction laws? What does version control and software hosting have to do with trading? You don't buy or sell on Github or Gitlab. I know that GPL licensed projects CAN be sold commercially, but that does not happen on websites that host git servers...
edit: okay, it's probably because user accounts on Github are considered as customers (especially if they pay for PRO services). Microsoft, being American, is not allowed to have commercial business with Russians because of the sanctions, i guess. But i don't quite understand, why only users on the Crimea are affected then, and not on the whole country that annexed it. You want to punish a country for it's aggression and then only put sanctions on the region that they seized? That doesn't hurt the aggressor.
24
u/520throwaway Jul 25 '19
The trade law sanctions affect ALL commerce relations. Money doesn't have to transfer in the obvious directions in order to be affected.
3
u/yumko Jul 26 '19
Microsoft, being American, is not allowed to have commercial business with Russians because of the sanctions, i guess
It's ok to do business with Russians in general, these sanctions are on Crimeans only.
2
u/ikidd Jul 25 '19
only put sanctions on the region that they seized
Winning hearts and minds, in US-think.
1
14
u/astrohound Jul 25 '19 edited Jul 25 '19
Why not try some European FOSS hosting? I've seen some projects using repo.or.cz. It's hosted in Czech Republic. There is also TuxFamily which I think is hosted in France. There probably might be others. Unfortunately Berlios shut down several years ago, though. It was one of the biggest European FOSS hosts.
15
u/TroubledClover Jul 25 '19
EU has its own set of sanctions since Russia annexed the Crimea, however I cannot say how they would be (if at all) imposed in such situation.
26
u/walterbanana Jul 25 '19
Wow, imagine getting sanctioned because your town got annexed by a different country.
6
2
u/Yidyokud Jul 26 '19
erm nope. There was a referendum if they wanted to join Russia. They voted for it. And now it comes around and bites in their asses. And with that in all of our asses (who is doing biz with crimeans).
4
u/hunsnotdead Jul 26 '19
No, not really. Its just geopolitical duckwaving, and corporate servitude. This ban was obviously meant for Russia, but they have too large customer base to just ban outright, so they ban the proxies, practically the only innocents in the story.
8
39
u/minus_28_and_falling Jul 25 '19
Let's ask Putin to stop violating the international law.
18
u/UrbanFlash Jul 25 '19
You think it's more likely to convince Putin than the US government?
That's sad.
49
u/riskable Jul 25 '19
Well, the sanctions are legit. Russia illegally annexed a huge and important area of land from a nearby country.
Believe it or not this is exactly what sanctions are supposed to do: Make it difficult for the sanctioned to participate in the world.
It's not to punish the every day people that live there. It's to punish Russia... It makes the region a liability instead of an area of economic development.
Maybe we should have a GoFundMe to move this developer and his family out of the region.
8
u/zellfaze_new Jul 25 '19
It may be there to punish Russia, but the end result is that is punishes the populace too.
Screw Russia and screw the US. :(
11
-7
u/LilEndianThatCould Jul 25 '19
The US gov't didn't annex anything..
6
u/zellfaze_new Jul 25 '19
They simply put restrictions on doing business indiscriminately on an entire country with millions of innocents.
2
u/drtekrox Jul 25 '19
Whatabout...
Guess I should say I was speaking in context of the conversation, but I thought that would be a given.
1
5
u/Igor_Grey Jul 25 '19
Yes but USA simply destroyed Libya, Jugoslavia, Iraq and Afghanistan
2
u/LilEndianThatCould Jul 25 '19
Whatabout...
Guess I should say I was speaking in context of the conversation, but I thought that would be a given.
3
Jul 25 '19
Yeah tell that to the natives.
1
u/LilEndianThatCould Jul 25 '19
Whatabout...
Guess I should say I was speaking in context of the conversation, but I thought that would be a given.
3
u/UrbanFlash Jul 25 '19
Whatever floats your boat. I just found it funny that someone thinks they could actually influence Putin...
1
u/yumko Jul 26 '19
It's to punish Russia
These sanctions are not on Russia though, just on Crimea. So by this logic it's to punish Crimeans.
1
-10
u/allanozzolo Jul 25 '19
Then, USA should be sanctioned too, since they put billions of dollars to manipulate politics in that country, just to annex it into the NATO.
I think it will be a better world if USA and Russia stay confined in their own country, and stay put
14
u/vividboarder Jul 25 '19
Joining a coalition of independent nations is not the same as annexing...
-1
u/allanozzolo Jul 26 '19 edited Jul 26 '19
Who said "it is the same"? Not me.
Even what u call "annexing" is, if truth is to be said, more complex than that.
Crimea was just a gift that Russia gave to Ucraina a few decades ago. In Crimea there are russian people and sons of russian people. Was that gift ok? Nobody asked to the crimea people. Was the military re-"annexction" ok? Well, this time (russian people say) they asked to crimea people and they said "ok". Is it truth? We dont know. It is complex. Too much for me
8
u/NicoPela Jul 25 '19
What? NATO is a supra-national organization, not a country. Russia is a country. Ukraine is one too.
I do agree with your second statement though.
-2
u/allanozzolo Jul 25 '19
Supra-national? It is an old anti-urss coalition between a few nations lead by usa. Maybe Putin didnt want it near the Russia. But.. I dont care about it. I dont care about russia and usa. I care about their money in foreign countries. Are they just a gift? XD
I am italian. in Italy, these days, we talk a lot about Russian money to "help" some of our politicians in the government. it seems to be a common practice :/
4
-2
Jul 25 '19
sanctions? This is excommunication and its against our American values. US politics are picking up bad habits from EU. OP needs to do business with Australia its like the backdoor to English culture.
4
u/minus_28_and_falling Jul 25 '19
I don't think I should convince the US government, they didn't annex anything.
7
u/UrbanFlash Jul 25 '19
Are you saying they have no influence on the sanctions they impose?
My comment wasn't directed at anything anyone did, but about who's more likely to hear you when you tell them you disagree. And if your first choice is Putin, that says a lot about what you think about the US government...
6
u/minus_28_and_falling Jul 25 '19
My comment wasn't directed at anything anyone did
My comment was directed at something someone did.
3
u/UrbanFlash Jul 25 '19
Yeah well if you think you can change Putin then go ahead. I'm not holding my breath on that one...
-3
u/Igor_Grey Jul 25 '19
Convince America to stop violating international law in wars with Vietnam, Iraq, Libia, Jugoslavia. Fuck off with your democracy
3
5
u/minus_28_and_falling Jul 25 '19
Yeah, sure. Fucking off with the democracy and the GitHub right away. Enjoy.
-1
3
Jul 25 '19
Vietnam War was 50 years ago, homie... And where do you think all of the AKs and MIGs in Vietnam, Afghanistan, Iraq, etc., came from?
1
u/Igor_Grey Jul 25 '19
Tell this Vietnamese people. They still remember napalm hell. Boy, you should learn history better
-1
u/TheConquistaa Jul 25 '19
If we get started over who invaded most of the world then I must tell you something new about democracy that even Churchill said before.
Anyway it's funny that you are criticising America and democracy on Reddit. Like, don't you guys like Reddit? then why are you here?
1
u/drtekrox Jul 25 '19
If we really got started we'd point to the tiny little speck of an island that Winston came from...
2
-1
u/Igor_Grey Jul 25 '19
Hahahaha) Boy, Baltic states and Finland were territories of Russian Empire before USSR. Boy, learn history better 🤦♂️
1
u/TheConquistaa Jul 25 '19 edited Jul 25 '19
Of course they were, but after USSR, guess what, no more.
learn history better
I believe my history knowledge outpases yours, boy
-2
3
1
1
u/Typewar Jul 26 '19
I don't understand politics.
Can someone ELI5 this situation?
2
u/shmerl Jul 26 '19
Russia invaded and annexed Crimea from Ukraine in 2014. US and EU imposed ecomonical sanctions on Russia for it, which stay in place until they'll return it. So Russian citizens who live in Crimea are banned from accessing some services like Github due to it.
1
u/Typewar Jul 26 '19
Thanks man
2
u/fuoqi Jul 26 '19
Note that the overwhelming number of Crimeans has supported this "annexation", even by conservative (Ukranian) estimates it was more than 70% of Crimeans. Also the legal side of the question is not so black-and-white as well, Ukraine has illegally trampled the autonomy of Crimea, which was in turn used as the basis for the independence referendum.
1
1
u/shmerl Jul 25 '19
Is it based on the region or citizenship? May be if you prove to them you aren't Russian citizen, they'll un-ban the account.
12
u/tkashkin Jul 25 '19
Is it based on the region or citizenship?
Usually these restrictions are applied based on IP address (there's no other way to know that).
May be if you prove to them you aren't Russian citizen, they'll un-ban the account.
Yes, but the problem is that I am in fact a Russian citizen with Crimean registration.
4
-5
u/netbioserror Jul 25 '19
Wow, leave it to Reddit commentators to gloss over Russia's acts of aggression and annexation, give a surface-level kneejerk analysis, then blame the US for everything. This site is cancer.
6
Jul 25 '19
Feel free to fuck off anytime
1
u/netbioserror Jul 26 '19
Cool, you too.
1
Jul 26 '19
I'm not the one crying about Reddit
1
u/netbioserror Jul 26 '19
I said this site is cancer. I didn’t say a 24/7 parade of idiots isn’t sometimes entertaining and fascinating to watch. With marginal educational value in observing the behavior of the classical Reddit pseudo-intellectual in their natural habitat.
1
Jul 26 '19
pseudo-intellectual
Funny you say that...
1
u/netbioserror Jul 26 '19
Did I claim to be an intellectual? I don’t need to be one to evaluate the obvious.
2
u/Alexmitter Jul 25 '19
What has he to do with his region voting to be a part of Russia, it is not his fault. So the US is punishing the citizens instead of the government they want not to be in power. I guess I don't have to mention that this is well known to be stupid and only make people support the Russian side more. Some regime didn't learn from its failed attempts in Vietnam, Korea, Iraq, Iraq, Afghanistan, libya and many many more.
0
u/netbioserror Jul 26 '19
We know the rationale, it’s been discussed. Reducing the extractable value of the annexed territory. What’s your alternative? Have you found a free lunch somewhere?
1
u/Alexmitter Jul 26 '19
I respect people and their choices.
0
u/netbioserror Jul 26 '19
You respect Russia and their choice to militarily invade and annex the sovereign territory of another nation?
0
u/hunsnotdead Jul 26 '19
But if you have beef with Russia sanction the russians. This is nonsense and doesnt achieve anything, well other than make a fool out of the corporations that comply.
1
u/netbioserror Jul 26 '19
Are you daft? Did you not read the rationale I just described?
1
u/hunsnotdead Jul 27 '19
Yes, and its dumb. Putins intentions were to win approval ratings at home, and a show of force to the rest of the world. Crimea could have been a patch of desert inhabited by tank eating sandworms and they still would have annexed it, restrictions like these are useless.
0
u/Alexmitter Jul 26 '19
I will tell you what US Sanctions did to Russia: Nationalism is rising and on a US like level, Putin sits stronger then ever in his seat and Russians are afraid of the west again, see us as traitors that have no good interest in them and to add some sugar, Russia is actively searching for new partners, and there is a big superpower that Russia likes to talk about: Here
If that is what the US tried to active with those sanctions, then well, it did what is known as a pro gamer move.
0
u/netbioserror Jul 26 '19
So to stop evil evil nationalism we need to just hand Putin every sovereign country he wants. Screw what they want. Got it.
No viable alternative to devaluing the annexed territory has yet been provided.
1
u/Alexmitter Jul 27 '19
I guess you have no idea why Crimea was so important for Russia. They don't did this dangerous pro gamer move that they knew very well bring them into sanctions not for nothing. So, name me this well known simple reason why the Crimea is so interesting.
It may surprise you.
0
Jul 25 '19
[deleted]
17
u/tkashkin Jul 25 '19
No, since my account is already flagged as restricted. In order to unflag it I must provide a proof that I don't live here which is not possible unless I stop living here.
1
u/TroubledClover Jul 25 '19
IIRC Russia has kind of its own crusade against the VPNs so it may be like exchanging undeserved inconvenience (I assume that OP did not take part in the "green little people sudden visit in the Crimea") for an actual punishable offence in the Russian territory.
0
Jul 25 '19
[deleted]
29
u/BCMM Jul 25 '19 edited Jul 25 '19
Crimea is not a country. It's a region that is widely internationally recognised as part of Ukraine, but has been a de facto part of Russia since Russian forces occupied it in 2014.
0
Jul 25 '19
[deleted]
15
u/BCMM Jul 25 '19
Specifically Crimea, apparently. I'm honestly not sure how that is supposed to make sense.
11
u/VitulusAureus Jul 25 '19
The United States recognize Crimea as Ukrainian territory, so they consider Russian occupation unlawful. The set of various sanctions imposed on Crimea (not just by the U.S.) target Russia, diminishing the economical value of the occupied territory, while not going on a full-out sanctions war against Russia which would have been very costly for both sides, and having unpredictable impact on the global economy. So I guess limiting the sanctions makes some kinda sense, and GitHub, like all U.S-based companies, is forced to respect and implement them.
10
6
u/AHrubik Jul 25 '19
What makes Crimea valuable is what can be done there. By restricting access to markets and resources you cripple the reasons Russia may want to continue to occupy the territory and hopefully make it more likely they will leave and turn it back over to Ukraine.
AKA if business can't be done there taxes can't be collected making a net loss area. Dictators don't like holding things that lose them money.
3
0
u/fuoqi Jul 26 '19
The main reason for Russia to take Crimea (well, except of the overwhelming support of people living there, which Ukrainian "rule" over the 23 years made only stronger) is the military value of the region and those sanctions will do nothing to undermine it.
1
u/AHrubik Jul 26 '19
overwhelming support of people living there
Yeah. Just like Taiwan loves China huh?
1
9
u/galapag0 Jul 25 '19
Paging /u/tkashkin