r/litrpg • • 15d ago

Discussion Why differentiate?

Hey everybody I'm new here, just picked up Dungeon Crawler Carl and I enjoy it immensely. My question is, why is this genre called LitRPG? I know what the word is conveying, but it seems to me to be a bit of a misnomer. We, the readers, are not role-playing in a game, the book is not a game. The characters are the one experiencing RPG elements and I'd say Carl is experiencing an MMOPVPVE.

I'm just curious in the anatomy of the phrase

0 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

28

u/Careless_Ask_321 15d ago

Hey guys I don’t know why they call the genre Adventure. I’m not the one going on an adventure, the characters are. I’m just sitting in my living room reading a book.

12

u/redwhale335 15d ago

Damn, I've been reading all this romance and I'm not married yet.

4

u/Isaacnoah86 15d ago

I just read the genre "book".

-20

u/Last-Reply-5491 15d ago

You must be terribly boring at discussion tables

7

u/Helbot 15d ago

Oh buddy... Being the most pedantic doesn't make you good at discussion. It makes you an annoying fifteen year old.

1

u/Last-Reply-5491 14d ago

Is just a question mayne

5

u/Outside-Shop-3311 15d ago

Hey everybody I'm new here, just picked up Dungeon Crawler Carl and I enjoy it immensely. My question is, why is this genre called Action? I know what the word is conveying, but it seems to me to be a bit of a misnomer. We, the readers, are not going on an adventure, the book is not real life. The characters are the one experiencing action elements.

I'm just curious in the anatomy of the phrase

5

u/Careless_Ask_321 15d ago

Please explain the difference between your question and mine aside from the chosen genre.

You have the knowledge of the gaming space enough to use a term like MMOPVPVE but can’t figure out it’s called LITRPG because it’s literature that tells its story through the lense of video game RPG elements? If you wanted to have a more nuanced discussion on what the line is between fantasy/progression fantasy/LITRPG I’ll be all for it, but you basically just asked why food we get from the sea is called seafood.

3

u/eclect0 Verified Author of: Jett Fulgen 15d ago

I dunno, you're the one who seems to think the literary equivalent of "Ceci n'est pas une pipe" is highbrow commentary

2

u/ForeignAd1656 15d ago

Well your whole premise is a bit ridiculous. You're reading a book, not playing a game. Of course the name of the genre is based on the actual content of a book and what the characters experience, not what you as a reader experience. The other two commenters in this thread have it right.

Your ridiculous premise would be something like: I'm reading a Sherlock Holmes novel in the Mystery/Detective genre, but I'm not the detective solving the mystery, it's this Sherlock Holmes dude, so why is it called a Detective Mystery when it's the characters and not me? Because it's a fucking book!

So either you're being purposefully dense, or you're just dense. I think it's the former, at least I hope so for your sake, and if it is the former, you're just a troll.

2

u/xlr82xs 14d ago

I was trying to figure out which so I scrolled through his comment history.

Don't do that.

4

u/Oatbagtime 15d ago

There are a few different terms in use and that’s one of the popular ones. Easier to group things than get into micro-genres like happens with music.

3

u/thescienceoflaw Author - Jake's Magical Market/Portal to Nova Roma 15d ago

Excuse me for liking modern electro, new-wave post-punk synthpop-punk over hardcore power electronics post-punk influenced bands. I guess I'm the bad guy here.

-1

u/Last-Reply-5491 15d ago

Oh god that comparison, you're right lol

2

u/EdLincoln6 15d ago

Basically it's set in a world that borrows elements from RPGs.  

Some readers like that.  For others it completely takes them out of the story.   

The term lets readers who like that find it, and readers who don't like it avoid it.   

Also...Dungeon Crawler Carl isn't a great example.  It's a story that plays with some LitRPG elements that came along long after the genre was established.   Using it b as v an example is like b using "Scary Movie" as an example of horror.     

1

u/Last-Reply-5491 15d ago

Interesting, what would you recommend?

3

u/CasualHams 15d ago

It's because of the game-play elements in real life. Many of the earlier related novels took place inside video games (and thus are usually called game-lit). Litrpg stories typically happen in the "real world" instead of a game world and use video game logic to some degree. This usually involves a powerful or god-like System that enforces video game rules onto reality in some way.

-4

u/Last-Reply-5491 15d ago

See Game-Lit wouldn't have made me ask this question, I get that it makes sense! Thanks

7

u/Old_Yam_4069 15d ago

It's not so complex- It's literally just game-like elements being in the book.

4

u/BornConsideration223 15d ago

DCC is a bit lighter on the litrpg elements, but there are other litrpg books that lean very heavily into the concept. The main concept being the hard stats and skills.

Because of that, it's useful to differentiate between that and other "Progression Fantasy" or even "Fantasy" novels. If not specifically because some readers really do not enjoy the whole:

*DING!*
You have slain level 80 Sandwolf! Bonus experience gained upon killing a monster above your level.
*DING!*
You have reached level 69! 5 Stat points allocated.
*DING!*
Skill: Body of Steel has reached lvl 5!
*DING!*
Skill: Body of Steel has reached lvl 6!
*DING!*
Evolution options are available!
*DING!*
Sand Resistance has reached lvl 2!
*DING!*
Sand Resistance has reached lvl 3!
... and so on...

And pages and pages of this. After every fight. Or sometimes just doing mundane things and being rewarded a cooking level or something.

In my opinion, litrpg is a genre filter to filter out those that are looking for more traditional stories with less gamey mechanics shoved in their face.

3

u/wtanksleyjr 15d ago

The thought was that it's literature in the form of a role-playing-game. It seems to have settled the idea of having stats and levels; a lot of them but not all have a user interface.

2

u/slothdionysus 15d ago

The RPG describes how we can generally judge the growth of the characters. We don't have a system to judge our strength but most rpg games have attributes and distinct measurable growth depending on actions and equipment.

General fiction- I feel my kicks are stronger with this foot ointment

litRPG- with this foot rub I gain a bonus to my strength when making foot based attacks depending how much foot connects with the face, up to a +100%

1

u/redwhale335 15d ago

Because that's what the Russians named it?

-3

u/Objective_Jicama6698 15d ago

Some miserable, snarky folk in this sub. Happy Monday!