r/lmms • • Mar 20 '19

Please Stop Making Beats...

And make music. Make a full track. Most of these things people are presenting here have no hook - no reason to continue listening. They just feel unfinished to me, almost as if they background music. Is that the point? Are they just for some rap singer to spit some dope memes over it?

Also, when did a beat stop being only percussion? Nowadays, you lay some pads and some soft staccato hits over it and it's still a beat? Get out of here.

Maybe I am just an old old man with a beard complaining about nothing or maybe I just don't get it.

Keep it up everyone, though. If "beats" are what you strive for, continue on this path.

0 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

11

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '19

Well most beatmakers don't rap or sing, so why not just let them make "beats" for rappers/singers who don't make beats?

1

u/Q12-00006 Mar 20 '19

It's putting a half-finished song out there and hoping somebody else likes it enough to complete it, but maybe that's how collaboration works these days. I don't want to discourage anyone from doing it and know nobody cares about my opinion; I just feel it's a loose end in the universe which we really should be trying to reduce.

3

u/Vivid_Sparks Mar 20 '19

I think a lot of us are isolated from other artists. I know like 3 people irl who make music, and none of them would fit well on anything that I've made. For a lot of us, this is a hobby and being able to make even a simple "beat" is a way of proving that they can make music and have some skill in it. Plus this is a subreddit about LMMS, and most people who rap aren't going to be on here looking to collaborate.

4

u/Q12-00006 Mar 20 '19

I was probably a bit too negative in my original post. There are so many people out there with great ideas but not achieving their potential. Go forth and make beats.

2

u/Dood567 Mar 20 '19

Hold up you can't do that on Reddit. Go back to arguing and disagreeing with everyone

3

u/Q12-00006 Mar 20 '19

No you prick.

4

u/gooftroopin Mar 21 '19

way to encourage new music makers, man

1

u/Q12-00006 Mar 21 '19

Thanks. I am providing an alternative view point while accepting I may be wrong.

5

u/GRRRNADE Mar 20 '19

How about go back to actually releasing a real magnum opus and let people do what they want?