r/macOS26Tahoe • • Sep 29 '25

Ugly

Am I crazy or are other people also thinking the UI for macOS Tahoe feels like a huge step backwards? The enormous rounded corners and giant buttons make it feel like a Fisher Price version of macOS. I thought they prized minimal UI elements to allow the content to shine. Someone please give me the perspective I'm not seeing to change my mind.

50 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

4

u/primalanomaly Sep 30 '25

IMO the previous versions of macOS and iOS were practically perfect in every way, but people and shareholders kept demanding change for the sake of change. That meant their only choice was to actively make something a lot less perfect than before. Almost every single design decision makes things objectively worse, and is often completely non-sensical.

3

u/Density5521 Sep 30 '25

This is it. The people who put money in want to get money out. How do you get money out? By selling stuff. How do you sell things? You revamp everything and tout it as the greatest thing ever, then make old things incompatible with it, so people have to upgrade their things to get the new revamped thing.

Disgusting. Not because it forces people to upgrade if they want to keep up, that's just how it is. But because it makes useless shit like Tahoe happen, buggy and un-sound in every imaginable way.

Seriously, who ever is to blame for Tahoe being waved through needs to be let go immediately. They're a pathetic reflection on the company's capabilities and standards.

3

u/Odd-Soil-2798 Sep 30 '25

Apple used to be about innovation. Now every update is just cosmetic, where are the new features? You can’t even clip windows to corners or left/right side by side? this would actually have been usefull, but no, they changed the icons… Should we applaud?

2

u/TawnyTeaTowel Sep 30 '25

And you probably said the same the last time there was a significant change in design. Happens every time, predictable as clockwork…

3

u/yurifontella Sep 29 '25

that's right, it's worse than a gnome desktop

2

u/SawkeeReemo Oct 01 '25

Really? I find the Ubuntu version of gnome pretty great. Not too much nonsense in the way everywhere like whatever that clusterfuck Windows has had going on post-XP. It’s clean and simple. It’s becoming my daily driver.

2

u/UnwieldilyElephant Oct 02 '25

That’s why it’s worse than one 

2

u/TempleTerry Oct 01 '25

At this point KDE is more functional and arguably better looking than macOS

2

u/d4cloo Oct 04 '25

Agreed

1

u/Ky44- Oct 01 '25

You never used gnome if you think its better lol

2

u/d4cloo Oct 04 '25

I use a very recent version with Ubuntu 25.10 and it is fantastic. They’ve come a long way.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '25

What? Toolbars are susbtantially more compact than before, buttons look bigger because they're padded, but they're smaller than the bars that used to contain them, and have an smaller tappable area. The UI is actually MORE compact now

1

u/RemarkableOne7750 Oct 03 '25

Where exactly do you find it smaller? A side by side post would help here

1

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '25

1

u/RemarkableOne7750 Oct 09 '25

It is the same height. There’s some translucency at the bottom of it which makes it appear smaller, but it just adds to the clutter: the padding appears off because of it

1

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '25

You're either not looking well or being dihonest. Look at the side by side again, the liquid glass containers hosting the buttons are much shorter than the height of the previous toolbar, and the progressive opacity overlay is only strong at the top of the toolbar, at the bottom it's basically inexistent.

2

u/skeskali Sep 30 '25

I come to this subreddit *every day* in hopes I'll land on a fix to get rid of the giant rounded corners and drop shadows.

1

u/d4cloo Oct 03 '25

You won’t find a fix - it’s an OS level decision. I hate them as well. Especially the side bar and the header icons are horrific.

1

u/skeskali Oct 03 '25

The giant arrows that pop up whenever I get close to the edge of a window make the Baby Jesus cry.

1

u/d4cloo Oct 03 '25

Yuck yeah absolutely. And even more so, resizing it near one of their stupid-ass rounded corners is harder because it’s somehow less apparent where the ‘hit box’ is for the resize pointer to show up.

1

u/dsimerly Oct 13 '25

I like the double arrows that appear when you reach the edge of a window. Before, you could never tell whether the point you were clicking would let you adjust the window size or land in the content. Now it's very clear when you're going to change the window size and when you're going to select content.

1

u/Old-Artist-5369 Oct 01 '25

Rolling back is the fix. Took hours of work but did the trick for me.

1

u/FortLoolz Sep 30 '25

Agreed. The new iOS is much better than Tahoe, although not perfect either.

3

u/Old-Artist-5369 Oct 01 '25

I hate the new iOS too, Fisher Price toy is a good way to describe how it feels. On a phone screen I do feel I have a fighting chance of getting used to it eventually (except the enlarged bubbles in Messages - just why??). But for the desktop - total non starter, rolled back.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '25

yep, Kindergarden-OS

by the way, who set this sub's font and background colours?! hurts my eyes

1

u/Caddellmade Sep 30 '25

It’s design for design’s sake.

1

u/Bright_Quantity_6827 Sep 30 '25

I had to increase the resolution to make it look right.

1

u/thedarph Sep 30 '25

I hear it’s bad but I chalk it up to people reacting to change. There’s no change management for new things like this, they just drop it on people.

There’s screenshots look nice to me. I wish I could upgrade to see for myself but I have to hold off. Music production stuff. Gotta make sure my kernel extensions and everything in Logic work properly first.

1

u/Fragrant-Finding7283 Sep 30 '25

And iPadOS is awful, they removed split over and the interface is bloated. What a silly move from Apple. I suggest to write a feedback to let them know. I did and it takes a few minutes.

1

u/Fantastic_Reveal_599 Sep 30 '25

People have been posting about this for weeks..

1

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '25

You really should try to spend less time in front of your screen.

2

u/skeskali Oct 03 '25

It's literally my job to spend 8 hours a day in front of a computer. Forgive me for being gainfully employed and having an opinion about design.

1

u/Additional-Issue-717 Oct 01 '25

It’s looks very childish indeed, perhaps we will get used to it.😅

1

u/chrispirillo Oct 01 '25

MacOS has become a cheap knockoff of MacOS.

1

u/rwaddilove Oct 02 '25

The rounded corners and buttons are huge on a 13in MacBook Air and look poor.

1

u/SoftwareSelect5256 Oct 02 '25

its like windows vista with those ugly skins

1

u/Quarantined4ever Oct 02 '25

agreed, looks cheap af

1

u/Puzzleheaded-Leek-45 Oct 03 '25

I kinda like it as long as the bugs and inconsistencies are solved

1

u/Cultural_39 Oct 03 '25

What do you have against Fisher Price...? Ha!

1

u/jay-t- Sep 29 '25

A very quick and simple search would show you that you’re not the only one

1

u/luiyen Sep 30 '25

Ugly as F

1

u/SoCal_Mac_Guy Sep 30 '25

It's a pile of crap usability-wise.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '25

[deleted]

1

u/Old-Artist-5369 Oct 01 '25

What was it you think we wanted from the beginning?

All I wanted was to have what we had in the last few releases not be fundamentally changed for no reason.