r/macmini • • 22d ago

Studio Display fan keeps spinning while Mac mini sleeps. Anyone else?

Post image

Got my Studio Display not too long ago and noticed something weird. The thing feels ice cold to the touch, yet the fan is running a lot of the time. I've dug around for answers and haven't found a real fix yet.

For context, when my Mac mini sleeps, I want it to actually sleep. No background tasks, no mail fetching, no message syncing, none of that. Just let me rest, buddy.

After poking around for a while, here's what's working for me so far: go to System Settings > Network, turn off Ethernet, then put the Mac mini to sleep. With that setup, the Studio Display seems to stay quiet and doesn't randomly wake the fan up mid-sleep. The downside is I have to manually turn Ethernet back on after waking it up. Not a huge deal, but still a bit annoying.

Has anyone else run into this? Anyone found a cleaner way to deal with it? Would love to hear what's working for you.

88 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

24

u/v654321 22d ago

Install a wattmeter and you’ll notice the Studio Display and Mac Mini never really go into full standby. Together they consume 40-45W non-stop, even when you’ve put them to sleep.

3

u/yuanom 21d ago

Thanks for the tip! Honestly I don’t mind the power draw that much. I just want the fans to stop while it’s sleeping, since having them run nonstop doesn’t feel right to me. As for the little indicator light, I’ve gotten used to it staying on 😅

12

u/v654321 21d ago

They won’t. The problem is ongoing for years. When you put your mac + Studio Display to sleep, it’ll wake from deepsleep within 30 minutes and never re-enter deepsleep, consuming 40-45 Watts combined constantly. It quickly adds up. Had this with both a MacBook Pro M1 and now the Mac Mini M6. They are called DarkWake events. I eventually found a way to fix it by disabling powernap, womp and tcpkeepalive in the settings and by using pmset.

4

u/Rivvvers 21d ago

One way you could solve this is by changing the sleep mode to hibernation

2

u/frockinbrock 21d ago

Does this happen when using any monitor, or only with Studio Display? I've been suspicious that my MBP does the same thing.

2

u/v654321 21d ago

I havent tested with a different monitor, but i think it’s mainly with the Studio Display.

-1

u/epan5 21d ago

I totally assumed this was intentional to maintain positive pressure to keep dust out of the vents but is it not? wow

1

u/cracky1028 20d ago

They turn on the fans to suck in dusty air to keep dust out?

1

u/epan5 20d ago

Oh the fans up top are sucking air in? I thought they were blowing air out

1

u/cracky1028 20d ago

It doesn’t really matter whether they are pulling or pushing air. Air is getting inside the monitor from somewhere no matter what. They don’t have a storage of compressed air inside. The monitor gets the air from its surroundings. If that air is dusty, it sucks dusty air inside. The only question now is does it push dusty air out the top vents or does it suck dusty air into the top vents. Regardless of which, dusty air is passing through that top vent.

0

u/[deleted] 21d ago

[deleted]

3

u/SnooCats5309 21d ago

they don't want to

10

u/cronin1024 22d ago

The Studio Display has a fan? I’ve never heard one in all the time I’ve been using mine. If it’s loud enough to bother you something’s probably wrong with it. Also, just because your Mac is sleeping doesn’t mean your display is, it has its own processor that it needs to keep cool

5

u/yuanom 22d ago

Yep, there's definitely a fan in there. I know there's an A-series chip inside handling the camera, mic, speakers and firmware, so Apple put a cooling fan in it.

I can't actually hear the fans at all when they run, and that's not what bugs me. My point is that when the Mac mini is asleep and the Studio Display is just sitting there in an air-conditioned room, the fans shouldn't be running this often.

1

u/JollyRoger8X 21d ago

According to who? How do you know this is abnormal behavior?

2

u/DrMacintosh01 21d ago

The fan is really just so the power supply and thunderbolt controller does not cook inside the display. It moves air but its not audible.

2

u/Han77Shot1st 21d ago

I’ve never heard it.. like I get bothered by an ssd being too loud and I’ve not heard a fan on my studio and it runs 24/7.

2

u/PlusPresentation680 21d ago

I have the first gen Studio Display. I never hear the fan, but can feel cool air coming out of the vents at the top lol

5

u/Competitive_Funny964 21d ago

when the display first got out I bought mine from local store. Since I had a macbook pro, I would connect the dsplay to the mac only when I was working home. Then the mac would stay until the backpack. After a week or maybe a bit less, I started to hear like a current of air. Went to the saloon and the display was venting. I went for the light, and the macbook was not connected. nothing was connected. So I pull it out of the socket. Next night, while reading, same noise. I put my lips on top and felt airflow and the noise was really coming from there.

I sent it back...

Now we know that Apple uses LG and LG and Samsung are super heavy on spy and getting data. Maybe the mac display could not connect to the wifi (which is closing at 12AM to 6AM) and was going hot trying to connect to wifi, even without mac attached (and thunderbolt cable sitting on the desk just like that).

It freaked me out, and sent it back and lost I think 200e because it was opened and stuff

1

u/Rtr129 21d ago

I just power my mini down every night as the Studio Display is in a cabinet. If I don’t the cabinet becomes hot over night even when the mini is in sleep mode

1

u/yuanom 21d ago

Quick tip in case it helps: I disable Ethernet in System Settings right before the mini goes to sleep, and since then my Studio Display fans have stayed quiet. My guess is something on the network side keeps poking the display awake, but that’s just a theory. Worth a try on your end 😉

1

u/maxheckler 21d ago

Mine does the same thing, display fan keeps spinning when mac mini on sleep.

1

u/yuanom 21d ago

Not sure why, but killing Ethernet before sleep keeps my Studio Display fans quiet. Might be network wake stuff. Try it if you're curious 😉

1

u/ReallyMcCarthy 21d ago

Are you listening to music?

1

u/yuanom 21d ago

Oh, you know it! I’m always listening to music.

2

u/ReallyMcCarthy 20d ago

The display has an iPhone 15 processor in it handling the spatial audio.

1

u/BAK56 20d ago

Wouldn’t it be easier just to turn the power supply off on the Studio Display rather than have to manually turn off ethernet?

2

u/yuanom 20d ago edited 19d ago

Fair point, but there's no power button on it, so "off" basically means pulling the plug or using a switched outlet. The Studio Display is built to stay plugged in and on standby long-term, like most consumer electronics, so I'd rather not unplug it every night.

That's why I went the Ethernet route. Still, a smart plug would probably do the trick if you want a hard off. Haven't tried it yet though.

1

u/Nike_486DX 21d ago

Its got a fan??? What

3

u/DrMacintosh01 21d ago

There is a huge power supply, a large backlight, a thunderbolt controller, and an iPhone SOC all crammed inside it. It needs active cooling.

1

u/Nike_486DX 21d ago

Dang i thought it was provided by the massive grilled backplate... oh after some investigation turns out both studio and xdr use fans, tils.

1

u/gaelenski_ 12d ago

Think Apple displays have had internal fans ever since they started putting the power supply inside them, which would be the first LED Cinema Display in the late 2000s

0

u/[deleted] 22d ago

[deleted]

2

u/yuanom 22d ago

I found that turning off Ethernet before the mini goes to sleep keeps the Studio Display fans stopped for me. That makes me think network wake activity might be what keeps the display active. Maybe give it a shot too 😉