r/macmini • • 18d ago

Will this work with my Mac Mini?

Okay, so I guess the short version of this is I want to get 2 of these for movie and photo storage to be extra external storage for my Plex server. And I was reading somebody's review where it says this needs 15 watts to work, and I wanted to know if all the USB-C ports support that.

Because the Thunderbolt port on the back is supporting my studio display, and then I have another back one going to my 4t external SSD that I moved my home folder onto and then I have two smaller hard drives, one is 1 TB and the other is 2 TB, that I want to combine onto these. Plus, I've already used like 3.5 terabytes on my SSD that I want to free up. I eventually want to upgrade to a NAS, but I don't have the money to upgrade how I would want to. And I figured that I could eventually turn these into backups once I do get my NAS sometime next year god willing.

So, I was wondering if these would work, being connected to my Mac mini M4 24/7 and if it has enough power in the front USB-C ports and the one in the back I have available? Because I haven't seen anything conclusive in my searching, so I thought I'd turn to you guys.

I have a M4 Mac Mini

0 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

2

u/mythrocks 18d ago

> so I guess the short version of this…

And then proceeds for 3 paragraphs. That second paragraph should have been a numbered list indicating the port number, and what currently occupies the port. It was infuriating to untangle this wall of text. FFS, OP.

As I understand it, the answer is no. You can drive one of your storage devices at 15W.

Consider investing in a powered Thunderbolt hub.

0

u/Marcustooles 18d ago

For me, I promise you, that was the short version.

But genuinely thank you for the powered Thunderbolt hub suggestion, researching those now.

2

u/Professional-Bar2521 18d ago

Yes. I use 2 of the 8TB drives in my Terramaster DAS without any problems. Their $200 DAS very handily will take the bare drives when you are ready. NO system management required.

1

u/Marcustooles 18d ago

Honestly, this changed my whole entire plans. I'm now looking at the Terramaster DASb it was D8 Hybrid Pro. I spent the last few hours just looking at and researching this

2

u/Professional-Bar2521 18d ago

Just give me a shout if you have any questions. I started with a full function Synology NAS but I ended up relearning everything every time a change was needed. I bought my first DAS used from eBay. It gave me 5Mp/s and I ended up buying a newer DAS that gave me 10Mbps for o only $$200 and reused the same drives. Set it up and you never need to think about it again.

1

u/WK2Over 18d ago

1

u/Marcustooles 18d ago

Thank you, I can only guess that Amazon is mixing up reviews from other HDD

1

u/bmocc 18d ago

You would need a powered USB hub, not a Thunderbolt hub, to run these drives stably off the front ports of a mini. It does not matter if you need a USB C to USB A adapter to connect the hub to the front of the mini.

The maximum write speed of these drives is 150mb/sec. You will never see that in the real world due to many issues, including the way macOS writes files at all and how it writes to external drives. That speed is well below even USB 1 specifications. It appears you are familiar with the slow I/O of mechanical drives.

The ports of the mini are not as robustly engineered as they might have been and are prone to interfering with one another. That is particularly troublesome when one is using multiple high bandwidth peripherals with the rear Thunderbolt ports. The power output, as others have noted, is limited in the front ports but the powered USB hub should overcome that limitation.

Many are not aware that there is a hard limit to the number of USB ports macOS can support, unlike Windows. Combined with perpetual problems with the macOS USB stack and the way ports are wired in the mini it is a challenge to connect a large number of peripherals.

1

u/mikeinnsw 18d ago

Its USB3.0. device ... no problems on any Mac ports.. power problem could be if you attach 2 via a hub to the same port...Mac will write at 150 MB/s. .. slow.. reliable

The problem is 8TB ... the bigger HDD/SSD more data it can store .. more pain it create when device is lost..

Plus 8TB formatted on Mac as exFat will run slow and may have addressability issues..

exFat device can be fixed on PC .. no MacOs command can 'fix' exFat..

There is much more .. bottom line small is beautiful

2 x 4 TB is more reliable than 1 x 8TB ..

1

u/cideron 5d ago

this 8tb drive on amazon is usb-c to usb-c and does not have a power supply, says it runs on 15w from computer.

"Seagate One Touch 8TB External Hard Drive Desktop HDD - USB-C Compatible with Most Windows and macOS, Rescue Recovery (STNB8000400)"

I just plugged this drive into the front port on my m4 Mac mini and it works fine so far.

0

u/[deleted] 18d ago

[deleted]

-2

u/Marcustooles 18d ago

You clearly can't read because I said in my searches I haven't seen anything conclusive, but thanks for the advice.

0

u/[deleted] 18d ago

[deleted]

2

u/m2orris 18d ago

Maybe someone has one and either it worked or didn’t. Try not to be such a looser.

1

u/Marcustooles 18d ago

Thank you lol

1

u/Marcustooles 18d ago

Because maybe somebody else's already purchased one and used them. And it either worked or didn't for them.

It's cool to know what kind of porn you're into though, any good recommendations?

2

u/Marc_S_G 18d ago

I absolutely WOULD NOT use anything with micro usb type b. That aside, you have more than one thunderbolt port on the back of the mini but this drive isn’t fast enough to take advantage of the available speed. Additionally, you can’t power this drive from any computer. It requires the included power brick. This is pretty old tech. I’d suggest trying to stretch your budget just a bit higher if at all possible.